Paragominas has halted deforestation to become a model of sustainable growth in a region charred by wildfires
a shaded boardwalk winds through the forest to a green-hued lake complete with lily pads and a sculpted serpent rising from the waters
Macaws squawk in the canopy near a soaring sumaúma tree
But Paragominas has escaped the worst of the rainforest’s climate-crisis events. Even as seasonal burnings ravaged its neighbours
this fast-growing town in Pará state remained comparatively unscathed by wildfires
The soot and ash darkening the city skyline late this year was mostly secondhand smoke blown in from blazes elsewhere
View image in fullscreenForest cleared for charcoal production in Paragominas 21 years ago
when Brazilian rainforests were being cut down at a record pace
Photograph: Cavan Images/AlamyIn a region battered by predatory logging and ranching
Paragominas is the story of a reversal of fortune
this was a boomtown with ruthless ambitions
Brazilian rainforests were being razed at a record pace
prompting international outcry and a federal crackdown
Miscreant municipalities were fined and collectively barred from taking farm loans
That was the view at the timeAdnan Demachki
ex-mayor of ParagominasWith its forest-gobbling ranchers
bootleg loggers and dodgy sawmill operators
this sprawling township the size of Israel was a big red flag
Environmentalists railed; investors kept their distance
but we were the best-known municipality on the blacklist,” says Demachki
shut down predatory logging and morphed into that rare thing in Amazonia: a frontier community that conserved as it grew
Paragominas was one of the Amazon’s epicentres of deforestation and timber extraction
which reduced deforestation by 80%,” says Beto Veríssimo
“Controlling deforestation turned the township into a magnet for investment and economic growth.”
religious leaders and farmers for an emergency summit
He concluded that Brazilian politics did not offer a solution
the pact pledged to end illegal deforestation by 2010
replant forests and put conservation on the school curriculum
Landowners were obliged to declare their holdings with digital coordinates on a geo-referenced property registry
giving inspectors a drone’s view of the countryside
By 2010, 80% of landholders had complied, two years before the registry became national law
with a third of rural properties verified by inspectors
compared with just 1.4% of validation nationwide
The municipality fined environmental violators
closed unofficial sawmills and banned smelters of pig-iron from stoking their charcoal kilns with wood from the rainforest
The campaign earned him national headlines
a landslide re-election victory – and a mutiny among ranchers
A week later a mob attacked the park grounds
torched Ibama’s offices and hijacked the trucks with the confiscated hardwood
an executive order was out of the question
so Demachki suggested the signatories to the deforestation pact reconvene
“Any decision had to be by community consensus,” he says
View image in fullscreenOne of about 60 sawmills in Paragominas
where decades of intensive logging left almost no virgin forest standing nearby
Photograph: Axel Bugge/ReutersHe arrived at the meeting hall with two letters
he apologised to the nation for the mayhem
then implored the people of the town to renew their commitment to keep Paragominas green; the other was his resignation
Free newsletterGet a different world view with a roundup of the best news
As it happened, Paragominas’s path to ignominy stretched back much further. Year zero was 1959, when the then president, Juscelino Kubitschek, climbed on to a bulldozer and toppled a great jatobá tree, symbolically clearing the way for a new Amazon highway. His declared mission was to “rip open” the rainforest”
had been crushed to death by a falling tree in a botched forest clearance
“The jungle was the enemy; that was the view at the time,” says Demachki
Amazon municipalities often pay the price for environmental decisions made higher upAmanda OliveiraFounded a few miles from the highway
the home states of most migrants to the area – quickly became home to pioneers
Land-grabbing and shootouts were so commonplace that the town was nicknamed “Paragobala” (Paragobullet)
Fraudulent property titles flooded the market
thanks to a class of con artists known as grileiros – after the popular ruse of “antiquing” deeds by sealing them in a box full of grilos (crickets in Portuguese)
View image in fullscreenOne of the mahogany trees cut for export near Paragominas
when the area’s loggers were known as among ‘the country’s worst forest predators’
Photograph: Dylan Garcia Travel/AlamyYet by the turn of the century
Demachki’s town hall brinkmanship paid off and the municipality doubled down on its green commitments
Demachki tore up his resignation letter and launched his second mayoral term
There have been setbacks: clear-cutting spiked in 2022, the last year under the far-right president, Jair Bolsonaro
which landed Paragominas back on Brazil’s environmental watchlist
The city later traced the surge in felling to permits issued by state and federal authorities
then quickly flagged and punished the transgressors
“Amazon municipalities often pay the price for environmental decisions made higher up,” says Amanda Oliveira
“Paragominas transformed from one of the country’s worst forest predators to one of the leaders of environmental governance in the Amazon,” says Tasso Azevedo
a forestry expert and former director general of the Brazilian Forest Service
In 2023, Paragominas earned the 80th-highest score on the environment index of 5,570 townships nationwide. Income by head has more than doubled since 2010, and primary school test scores are up 60% since 2007.
That does not seem to intimidate Demachki since he has discovered the path to change
“There’s no substitute for sitting down and thrashing out your differences.”
This story was produced with support from the Rainforest Journalism Fund in partnership with the Pulitzer Center
Your gateway to environmental health knowledge
Join the Environmental Health News community
has transformed into a beacon of sustainable development
reducing deforestation by 80% and earning recognition as a "green municipality."
Mac Margolis reports for The Guardian.
“Paragominas transformed from one of the country’s worst forest predators to one of the leaders of environmental governance in the Amazon.”
Paragominas demonstrates that local action and community consensus can reverse environmental destruction
offering a hopeful model for addressing the Amazon’s ecological and climate challenges
Paragominas shows that even in a place scarred by exploitation
regeneration isn’t just possible — it’s powerful
Read more: EU’s new climate change plan will cause biodiversity loss and deforestation.
hand-picked by our editors and researchers
We offer a host of daily and weekly options
Nonprofit organizations MADE SAFE and Plastic Pollution Coalition released the new Healthy Pregnancy Guideto help parents-to-be navigate the challenges of making healthier living choices for babies and the planet
a newsroom powered by Environmental Health Sciences
It all improves the health of our communities
IN SHORT: A video of a tanker truck exploding on the side of the road has been circulating on social media
Claims that the incident took place in South Africa’s Limpopo province are false
“That Limpopo explosion that took place today is crazy,” reads a common caption for a video that has been circulating on social media in South Africa since 4 July 2024
“Hope everyone who was trying to help survived.”
The dramatic 12-second clip shows what seems to be a burning tanker truck on the side of a road. Almost immediately it explodes and flames cover the screen
The rest of the video shows the camera tumbling to capture random images as someone cries out
Others are highly critical
“Why are people of this calibre given responsibility that is clearly beyond them?” one caption reads
“If this is ‘equality’ or ‘equity’ is it is also murder and destruction
but we can't change the nature of the beast or its privileges.”
But does the video really show a “crazy” explosion in South Africa’s Limpopo province
Get a weekly dose of facts delivered straight to your inbox
The viral claim most likely began with a post from a verified X account (formerly Twitter) on 4 July
But in the comments, other X users were quick to slam the post: “You can see Those road markings are not for South African roads.”
Wanya. You can see Those road markings are not for South African roads pic.twitter.com/utJ2HwdD0D
Another commented: “This is a Propane explosion that happened on the BR-010 near the Paragominas Palace Hotel in Brazil.”
This is a Propane explosion that happened on the BR-010 near the Paragominas Palace Hotel in Brazil. https://t.co/WZsBDMzkGf
The comment includes a link to a Portuguese-language news article that includes the video. Brazil is a country in South America
A machine translation of the headline reads: “Tanker truck explodes after accident on highway in Pará; videos show moment.”
the day before the viral claim appeared online
A Google search using the keywords “tanker explosion Pará Brazil” led to several other news reports on the incident
all of which placed it in the South American country
There have been no news reports of a recent tanker explosion in South Africa’s Limpopo
One of the comments on the original X post suggested that the false claim was simply to garner views: “Atleast you'll get the views
There have been concerns that monetisation is feeding sensationalist disinformation on the platform
In October 2023, Musk threatened to demonetise X creators who posted false information
“Any posts that are corrected by Community Notes become ineligible for revenue share,” he posted
This came after the European Union challenged Musk to clamp down on the site’s false content, which is illegal under the EU’s Digital Services Act
The act aims to ensure a “safe
predictable and trusted online environment
addressing the dissemination of illegal content online and the societal risks that the dissemination of disinformation or other content may generate”
You can republish the text of this article free of charge, both online and in print. However, we ask that you pay attention to these simple guidelines
as in most cases we do not own the copyright
3. Make sure you credit "Africa Check" in the byline and don't forget to mention that the article was originally published on africacheck.org
A fact-checker has rated your Facebook or Instagram post as “false”
Click on our guide for the steps you should follow
The content we rate as “false” will be downgraded on Facebook and Instagram
public figures need to be held to account for what they say
non-partisan organisation which assesses claims made in the public arena using journalistic skills and evidence drawn from the latest online tools
sorting fact from fiction and publishing the results
Help us keep it that way by supporting our work
Africa Check values your trust and is committed to the responsible management, use and protection of personal information. See our privacy policy.
Support independent fact-checking in Africa
The Paragominas bauxite mine is located in the east of the state of Pará in Northern Brazil
Late Tertiary and early Quaternary sediments
The Paragominas bauxite mine is located in the east of the state of Pará in Northern Brazil
one of the world’s richest sources of bauxite
Fully owned by Brazil’;s Vale (CVRD) the mine commenced operations in 2007 and currently boasts annual capacity of 5.4 million tons a year
Around $196m will be invested in stage one of the mine’s expansion with a view to push production up to 9.9 million tons a year
This was to have been completed by April 2008
in line with the third expansion undertaken by majority-Vale-owned alumina manufacturer Alunorte
To date Vale has invested $352m in the plant
In August 2008 Vale kicked off its $1.1bn expansion of the Paragominas refinery which is supposed to increase the plant’s output by almost 50% to 6.3 million tons a year
making it the second biggest refinery in the world
Paragominas lies within the eastern Amazon region and the Maranhão Basin where it would seem to have been developed in late Tertiary and early Quaternary sediments
The bauxitic zone extends over at least 1,000km² with an average thickness 2.2 ±1m and estimated resources of more than 1Gt of bauxite
Reserves in 2004 were estimated at 878Mt (USGS)
The Palaeozoic tectonic regime in the continental interior of Brazil produced a series of large sedimentary basins
Reactivation in the Mesozoic and Cenozoic caused further uplift
resulting in substantial erosion of the Brazilian platform
The concomitant build-up of sediments in the low-lying area was extensive and continued into Quaternary time
Bauxite from the Paragominas Mine has average content of 50% applicable alumina
and a granulometry level below 65in with 12%-13% humidity
Paragominas lies three degrees south of the equator with annual average rainfall of 1,700mm with a pronounced dry season from July to November
The ore will be flushed with water along 244km pipe
which started operations in 2007 and is the only one of its kind in the alumina industry
The Paragominas mine utilises the strip mining technique
The mine also has an improvement plant with grinding facilities and a mineral ducts with a 244km extension to transport the bauxite in pulp form to Alunorte
The Paragominas bauxite mine currently has an annual capacity of 5.4 million tons
This is expected to increase to almost ten million tons after completion of the first mine expansion currently underway
Give your business an edge with our leading industry insights
View all newsletters from across the GlobalData Media network
ResearchBack to the forestBrazil's rainforest rebounds as a long-view investment in research and local talent pays off.A city park in Paragominas
the city was the epicenter of rainforest destruction in Brazil's Amazon basin
The research institute founded by Penn State ecologist Chris Uhl has been instrumental in halting deforestation and turning Paragominas into a thriving and healthy community
That was the brusque advice I got as I boarded the bus for Paragominas. The year was 1996, and Penn State ecologist Chris Uhl had invited me to Brazil to visit Imazon
the small research institute he had founded near the mouth of the Amazon
The prospects for the rainforest seemed bleak, and Uhl wanted me to witness the epicenter of that bleakness. In an article for this magazine
I described arriving in Paragominas late at night:
The sharp smell of woodsmoke began to seep through the bus’ sealed windows
in the hills on either side of the highway
there began to appear a strange orange glow
Paragominas boasted well over 200 operating sawmills
It was the largest raw-lumber producer in Brazil
it would sit atop the federal government’s “black list” of counties with the highest rates of deforestation
the smoke has cleared and the sawmills are gone
replaced by clean industry and manicured parks
Paragominas is officially a Municipio Verde
or “Green Municipality,” a model for sustainable development
Deforestation there has essentially stopped
there has been an 80 percent drop in deforestation across the whole of the Brazilian Amazon
a figure touted as the single greatest reduction of carbon emissions ever achieved by humankind
This remarkable transformation is due to a convergence of factors, both political and economic. But Imazon
the innovative organization that Uhl willed into life 25 years ago
has played a critical role in bringing it about
Understanding the ProblemIt started in the mid-1980s
found themselves working in the degraded pasturelands surrounding Paragominas
Uhl had considered becoming a medical doctor before getting his Ph.D.
and was fascinated by the emerging field of disturbance ecology
“I was drawn to the areas that had been wounded,” he says
Prevailing wisdom held that those wounds would never heal
that the slash-and-burn practices of the loggers and ranchers flooding into the area would soon turn the fragile rainforest into a desert
Uhl and Nepstad were surprised by the resiliency they saw
“It was way too early to write off the Amazon as a system that was irrevocably damaged,” Uhl says
Their findings acutely challenged the status quo—and an overheated political climate made things even stickier
“It was a difficult time in Brazil, especially in the Amazon region,” says Adalberto Verissimo
Verissimo was then an agronomy student from Brazil’s impoverished northeast
keen to do whatever he could to save the rainforest
The military dictatorship that had held power since before he was born had just ended
The country would soon have its first presidential election in a generation
The building of the Trans-Amazonia highway had opened the interior to unprecedented development
but by the late 1980s government investment in the region had dried up
and the newly profitable logging industry had devolved into a free-for-all
rising criticism from abroad stoked anger at foreign interference
A New Kind of NGOWhat was missing from that volatile mix
Very little careful work had been done on deforestation
and important facets of the problem had been misunderstood or ignored
Armed with a grant from the MacArthur Foundation
he and a colleague from the University of Wisconsin
conspired to start a new kind of non-governmental organization
it would focus on research—but research squarely aimed at solving a dire real-world problem
Its sole purpose would be to provide the kind of high-quality information that Uhl believed would enable policymakers and other stakeholders to make environmentally conscious decisions
The purity of his vision was regarded by many as naïve—even McGrath soon left the project
would be to draft young Brazilians fresh out of school
a dozen students whose idealism and passion might as yet be undimmed
But that choice presented huge challenges of its own
since Uhl’s charges were as green as they were eager
had to be convinced that impartial research
"It was way too early to write off the Amazon as a system that was irrevocably damaged."
the first few years were a period of intense struggle
“It was the hardest time of my life,” Uhl says
“My hair went from blond to gray in about three years.” Verissimo
just understanding the reality of the forest,” he says
they were getting a crash course in academic practice
and we had to learn how to write papers that would be publishable in quality journals
It was a very high standard we had to achieve in a short period of time.”
“We would do things 30 or 40 times before they were good enough,” Verissimo says
And while they were earning their academic chops
they also had to learn to see beyond good guys vs
“It was not a conscious ideological choice,” Uhl remembers
“Imazon was so field-based that if we wanted to learn about logging
just trying to carve a life out of this wilderness
based on this trust that was established face to face.”
by demonstrating that logging could be done sustainably
and without sacrificing profit or the well-being of the forest
The team produced training manuals and best-practices videos grounded in painstaking comparative research
They developed a comprehensive forest-management plan that became widely adopted
Tools of ChangeBy the time I visited Brazil, the training phase was pretty much complete. The young scientists and policy analysts I met at Imazon’s modest headquarters in the city of Belém were a formidable group. Several, including Verissimo and eventual co-director Carlos Souza Jr.
Their work had already started to transform logging practice
“The big card we had was that Imazon was respected,” Uhl remembers
their poise—they were just a class act.” In the ensuing years
these attributes would prove vital to the role the institute would play in shaping Brazil’s environmental policy
Imazon turned to a second major focus: identifying and prioritizing vast unclaimed areas of forest to protect them against haphazard development
“Nobody was talking about this at the time,” Verissimo says
“but we realized that if we wanted to stop deforestation we would have to close the frontier.”
the institute produced a series of maps and reports proposing a tiered system of conservation units
the federal government finally moved to create large-scale environmental reserves
Imazon’s information proved vitally important
nearly half a million square kilometers—an area well over the size of California—had been set aside for preservation
At the same time, Imazon was pushing ahead in the area of remote sensing, pioneering the use of satellite imagery for essentially real-time monitoring of forest destruction. The Deforestation Alert System (SAD)
provides government agencies and the media with monthly reports of deforestation activity
The availability of this data has been a game changer
for the first time putting teeth into government enforcement efforts and enabling crackdowns on illegal logging and ranching
Something for the WorldIn 2010, Imazon won the prestigious Skoll Award for Social Entrepreneurship, a major international honor. Its work has been celebrated in The Economist and the New York Times
and the latest iteration of the SAD is supported by a partnership with Google
Now 25 years old and with a staff of about 40
the institute recently expanded its monitoring efforts to include all South American countries that are part of the Amazon Basin
and Verissimo recently laid out an ambitious goal for the decade ahead: reducing deforestation to zero
“there were a thousand people in the audience,” Verissimo remembers
After the screening of a video describing their work
the researchers were treated to a standing ovation that went on for several minutes
“This told us we had done something important for the world
something that has resonance across the globe,” he says
Much of Imazon's impact can be traced to the foundation Uhl struggled to build
Having birthed Imazon and helped it gain its feet
when he realized that his next call was to devote himself to raising ecological consciousness back home
first by leading a three-year student-driven research project that wound up laying the groundwork for Penn State’s institutional commitment to sustainability
the basic environmental science course for non-majors
into something he likes to call “Awaken 101.”
He marvels quietly that the organization he launched has had such an impact on the life of the rainforest
can be traced to the foundation Uhl struggled to build
and the culture he worked so hard to create
“These are the things Chris taught us,” Verissimo says
This story first appeared in the Spring 2016 issue of Research/Penn State magazine
As a global specialist in sectors ranging from renewables and infrastructure to technology
Macquarie has deep expertise and capabilities in these areas
We are a global financial services organisation with Australian heritage
We offer our investors a track record of unbroken profitability
We believe in a workplace where every person is valued for their uniqueness and where different views and ideas are embraced
Follow the links to find the logins you’re looking for:
The Norwegian aluminium company has a target to reduce carbon emissions by 30 per cent by 20301 and has been building out its global renewable energy business
Macquarie initially partnered with Norsk Hydro to develop and structure power purchase agreements (PPAs) that have helped the heavy industry player reduce its carbon footprint. This partnership has enabled the development of 1.3 GW of renewable energy capacity.2
More recently, MAM has been working with Norsk Hydro’s renewables business, Hydro Rein, in Brazil. Norsk Hydro was seeking a source of long-term renewable energy, at a stable price in US dollars, to supply its industrial facilities, Alunorte and Paragominas, which mine and refine alumina for global export.
With Brazil’s abundance of renewable energy sources, including wind and solar, strong decarbonisation commitments and a maturing regulatory environment, the country is becoming an increasingly attractive market for renewable energy development.3
The Ventos de São Zacarias project combines MAM’s renewables development and financing expertise with Hydro Rein’s experience in the Brazilian energy market
Alongside co-development, MAM structured long-term inflation-linked US dollar PPAs between the Alunorte and Paragominas facilities and the project
One of the PPAs enables Alunorte to switch its boilers from coal-fired to electric. This includes the installation of three electrical boilers for steam generation, which together have the potential to reduce emissions at Alunorte by 400,000 tonnes by 2025.4 Additionally
the nature of the US dollar- and inflation-linked PPA reduces exposure to both Brazilian currency and inflation risks
which have historically been a key obstacle to international investment in the country
This helped Ventos de São Zacarias become the first US dollar-backed project in the country to raise financing without the aid of a development bank.5 Instead, a consortium of seven private sector banks – JPMorgan, HSBC, Citibank, BNP Paribas, SocGen, Natixis and Santander – will provide $US290 million of debt.
To support the efficiency of the grid capacity secured by Ventos de São Zacarias, MAM and Hydro Rein, also have the option to develop up to 130 MW of solar power production in phase two.
In early construction, the project has supported more than 800 jobs, facilitated by the local contractor, Elecnor Brasil.7 While the project’s innovative financing structure will provide a template to help drive subsequent investment into Brazil’s burgeoning renewable energy industry
of renewables developed between Norsk Hydro and Macquarie8
wind project to be developed in the northeast of Brazil
supported in the early construction of Ventos de São Zacarias9
option to develop solar project in phase two of the Ventos de São Zacarias project
we view sustainability as part of our fiduciary duty to protect and grow our clients’ assets
This focus also helps us generate positive outcomes for our investee companies and the communities they serve
Our latest Sustainability Report outlines the progress we have made over the past financial year
Supporting the build-out of green infrastructure
Accelerating the global deployment of energy storage solutions
Macquarie Asset Management’s Green Investment Group and Hydro Rein to develop hybrid wind and solar project in Brazil
This information is a general description of the Macquarie Group only
you should consider the appropriateness of it having regard to your particular objectives
financial situation and needs and seek advice
No information set out above constitutes advice
to buy or sell any security or other financial
credit or lending product or to engage in any investment activity
or an offer of any banking or financial service
Some products and/or services mentioned on this website may not be suitable for you and may not be available in all jurisdictions
All securities and financial products or instrument transactions involve risks
Past performance of any product described on this site is not a reliable indication of future performance
MenuThe world in briefCatch up on global daily news
var(--mb-colour-greyscale-london-5));font-family:var(--mb-typeface-serif);font-size:var(--mb-typestyle-body-2-size);font-style:normal;font-weight:var(--mb-font-weight-regular);line-height:var(--mb-typestyle-body-2-leading);font-variant:var(--mb-typestyle-body-2-figures);text-wrap:balance;}Biodiversity
once the preoccupation of scientists and greens
Liberal helpings of growth and technology are the best way of preserving it
1fr));}}@media (min-width: 52.125rem){.css-1uuz26i{grid-template:auto/repeat(9
1fr));}}@media (min-width: 89rem){.css-1uuz26i{grid-template:auto/repeat(12
Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents
43,000+ global companies doing business in the region
102,000+ key contacts related to companies and projects
news and interviews about your industry in English
We help Amazon farmers and ranchers comply with Brazil's Forest Code
Conversion to agriculture and cattle ranching is the greatest threat to the Amazon rainforest
scientists predict that more than half of the Amazon could be cleared or severely degraded within decades
The Conservancy believes that the key to reverse this trend and reconcile the demand for production with conservation is an extraordinarily prescient Brazilian law - the Forest Code
farmers and ranchers should retain 80% of their lands under native vegetation
Our work is founded on creating realistic incentives for compliance with the law
We work in several municipalities in the Brazilian Amazon
some of them with the highest deforestation rates in the region:
The Conservancy is rapidly becoming known as the organization in Brazil that can enable all levels of Brazilian government to enforce the country’s Forest Code
We will continue to collaborate with the local government to improve its environmental monitoring system for implementation of Brazil’s Forest Code
Connecting decision makers to a dynamic network of information
Bloomberg quickly and accurately delivers business and financial information
Norsk Hydro's Alumina do Norte do Brasil SA refinery in Barcarena
citing weak alumina and bauxite markets and uncertainty over power prices in Australia
The bulk of the writedownsBloomberg Terminal relate to its Alunorte alumina refinery and Paragominas bauxite mine in Brazil
hurt by shrinking margins and higher fixed costs
Bauxite mine in Paragominas is exploited by Hydro-owned company - João Ramid/Norsk Hydro
After several reports of spills and environmental violations
a local association of Indigenous and African-Brazilian communities (Associação de Caboclos
Indígenas e Quilombolas da Amazônia – CAINQUIAMA) filed a class action lawsuit with a federal court to order that Norsk Hydro-owned mining company Mineração Paragominas S/A stops its bauxite mining operations in the Barcarena area
The mine is located in the Miltônia Plateau in Paragominas
argued that the petition is based on a scientific research conducted by the Geoscience Institute of the Geochemistry Laboratory of the Federal University of Pará
which found “highly contaminating radioactive substances with the bauxite” in the area
The Norwegian state owns over 50% of Norsk Hydro
and Norsk Hydro owns Mineração Paragominas and Alunorte
two companies that operate in Pará
Both companies argue that the claims presented in the class action suit filed by CAIQUIAMA are “unfounded,” saying the study it mentions is actually “a geological description of how bauxite formed in the area” and does not include any links “between characterization of bauxite and its impacts on human health."
Moraes explains that the class action asks the court to order Brazil’s National Mining Agency and the Ministry of Mines and Energy to revoke Mineração Paragominas' mining license for the bauxite field
This is the third class action suit filed by the association against the same Hydro-owned company
the first suit was filed in 2017 and requested the suspension of its operations at a local dam
where there was a spill later in February 2018
After an untreated wastewater spill in Barcarena
a second class action suit was filed in March this year to ask Hydro to pay for the lab exams for residents who were impacted by the contamination
The court ordered that the company should pay for the tests for 300 people who live in the area
the Miltônia bauxite mine has a yearly output capacity of approximately 10 million metric tons
In 2016, Hydro bought Vale’s remaining shares in Mineração Paragominas S.A. and became its only owner. According to a Nexo article
in 2010 the company had already bought Vale's stake in Alunorte
the Norwegian company became the only owner of the entire aluminum production cycle in Brazil
residents reported a dam spill in Hydro Alunorte
city and state authorities found a secret pipe that was pouring red-colored water directly into the environment
a survey by Evandro Chagas Institute confirmed that the local environment was being contaminated with untreated wastewater
Authorities ordered the immediate suspension of the company's operations at the dam and recommended it should supply clean water to the communities that were directly impacted by the spill
A court ordered that Hydro Alunorte should reduce its industrial production by 50% and suspend operations at one of its dams
a task force found another secret pipe pouring untreated wastewater into the Pará River
All original content produced and editorially authored by Brasil de Fato may be reproduced
provided it is not altered and proper credit is given
All original content produced and editorially authored by Brasil de Fato may be reproduced
Whereas Brazil's Para state saw a 25% increase in deforestation in 2020
reported the lowest deforestation figures in its history
CIRAD and its partners are working there to reconcile productive agriculture and forest conservation policies © R
TerrAmaz: a new partnership to reconcile the fight against deforestation with development in the Amazon
Forland, for sustainable, integrated territorial management
Mediterranean and Tropical Livestock Systems Management of Renewable Resources and Environment Forests and Societies
presse@cirad.fr - Tel
ScientistsRené Poccard-ChapuisCIRAD, BrazilE-mail
Marie-Gabrielle PikettyCIRAD, MontpellierE-mail
CIRAD, MontpellierE-mail
the municipality of Paragominas in Brazil was hit by a series of devastating fires: 183 000 hectares of forest went up in smoke
was as devastating as the total deforestation over the previous 15 years
While such vast forest fires are now a rarity in Paragominas
the overall trend in the Amazon and worldwide is upward
Decades of deforestation and degradation have seriously affected ecosystems and made the forest increasingly vulnerable to drought
183 000 hectares of forest went up in smoke in 2015 in Paragominas (Brazil) © R
To fight this growing risk and preserve the forest without sacrificing economic and social development
CIRAD researchers are working to help local stakeholders manage their territory better
The aim is to rethink the spatial organization of local landscapes
depending on the specific capacities of the on-site environment
"The spatial distribution of land use types plays a critical role in productivity
a geographer with CIRAD who is coordinating the Paragominas pilot as part of the TerrAmaz project aimed at reconciling sustainable agricultural transition
A map of zones suitable (or not) for sustainable intensification of crop and livestock systems is being drawn up
with a series of indicators to assess the sustainability of territorial development methods
the challenge is not fighting deforestation
but "to organize landscapes in an efficient way
depending on the capacities of the local land : suitability for intensified agricultural production and capacity for forest cover to protect soils effectively
A land use act is currently being drafted for the municipality
terraces are being constructed to prevent soil erosion
while forests occupy any areas that are not flat © R
CIRAD is working with local stakeholders to help the municipality to identify zones
"In zones that have already been deforested
we suggest sustainable farming practices that boost crop yields"
"Instead of intensification by means of chemical inputs
we encourage a transition to ecologically intensive practices." The past few years have seen the development in Paragominas of new pasture management practices
Agroforestry practices boost soil fertility
They also reduce the risk of fires during the dry season
thanks to the moisture released into the atmosphere through evapotranspiration © R
"We also encourage people to leave zones not suitable for agriculture to lie fallow
and we are measuring the effects on water and carbon cycles and on biodiversity." In such zones
crop and livestock farming have thus been abandoned and the forest is growing back at a speed that depends on the history of the plot concerned (for instance the degree of soil compaction) and the landscape configuration (proximity to trees likely to spread)
is not just intended to increase the area of forest in the municipality
but should also help to boost certain ecosystem services
such as limiting soil erosion or linking forests"
areas not suitable for agriculture are being abandoned and forest cover is gradually being restored
This enables forest corridors to reconnect with the forest matrix © R
If this combination of agricultural intensification and forest restoration is working in Paragominas
it is because farmers are no longer trying to increase the utilized agricultural area of their farms
Paragominas is the first municipality in Brazil to have introduced an official land register for almost its entire territory
National satellite monitoring and coordination between the local authorities and value chains mean the police can now identify the people responsible for any new deforestation
and prevent them selling the resulting products
the authorities are indirectly forcing farmers to adapt and intensify production on the agricultural areas they already have"
This work - conducted in collaboration with EMBRAPA
Pará State University and the Federal Rural University of the Amazon - opens up new prospects for the territory
for instance the construction of a territorial sustainable development label or the establishment of a "zero deforestation" supply area for responsible value chains
the Brazilian agricultural research centre hosting CIRAD in Paragominas
is conducting agroforestry trials (foreground) that serve as demonstration plots for farmers
a fire-damaged forest block has been restored and acts as a sustainable forestry resource management "laboratory" © R
The municipality of Paragominas was chosen as one of five innovative models being studied by the TerrAmaz project
CIRAD and its partners will be studying and supporting the rollout of this type of approach aimed at reconciling sustainable agriculture and forest resource conservation in the Amazon
"A territorial certification approach is due to be developed in Paragominas to assess the progress made by committed territories
promote them and step up responsible investment"
says project leader Marie-Gabrielle Piketty
The figures for deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon: a very contrasting picture
The figures reported by the INPE show a loss of 11 088 square kilometres of forest across the Brazilian Legal Amazon between August 2019 and July 2020
This is the highest figure since 2008 and the third yearly increase in a row since 2017: 8% in 2018
According to CIRAD's René Poccard-Chapuis
"the increase in deforestation in the "legal" Amazon in fact hides substantial geographical variations
There is an Amazon in which deforestation is increasing much faster than elsewhere
and an Amazon that has put a stop to deforestation"
the rise of almost 10% observed in 2020 (corresponding to 959 km2 across the Brazilian Amazon) is concentrated in Pará state alone
The situation in other states is more or less stable
Mato Grosso) and others that are either slightly negative or stable
are responsible for a major share of deforestation"
The two municipalities of Altamira and São Félix do Xingú alone account for more than 30% of the deforestation in Pará
are sustaining very low levels of deforestation: 10.75 km2 in 2020
according to the initial figures from the INPE
'Municipios Verdes': from zero deforestation to the sustainable management of natural resources in the Brazilian Amazon
In: Living territories to transform the world
The French agricultural research and international cooperation organization working for the sustainable development of tropical and Mediterranean regions
rotational grazing is boosting productivity per hectare and encouraging livestock farmers to leave slopes fallow
since such areas are difficult to access and plough © R
Marie-Gabrielle PikettyMontpellier, FranceE-mail
René Poccard-ChapuisParagominas, BrésiltE-mail
farmers let their cattle graze wherever they wanted
and the use of fire ruled out any forest regrowth
With technical support from the TerrAmaz project
they are being helped to choose the best land for rotational grazing
This improves both the animals’ diet and soil fertility
René Poccard-Chapuis is a geographer with CIRAD and is coordinating the TerrAmaz project’s activities in Paragominas
Those activities combine rural development and forest management
and are backed by a simple principle: organizing landscapes according to soil properties
filtering rainwater and limiting erosion are all services whose absence very quickly makes itself noticed.”
Restoration map of priority forests for water resources in the prefecture of Paragominas (2020) © R
Several of TerrAmaz’s activities in Paragominas make use of mapping tools to steer and monitor land use changes precisely
the maps produced serve to pinpoint zones that should be reforested as a priority
“Forest cover in the areas where water runs off or collects acts as a filter”
“Treating water in Paragominas is currently very costly
since it contains a lot of suspended particles
ravines and floodplains are extremely difficult to plough and are of little use for agriculture
They are already beginning to be abandoned and forest is becoming established
To speed up and extend the restoration process
the Paragominas water board is keen to encourage farmers
The scheme would be funded by people in urban areas and supported by the town council
by means of a geographic information system.
Several areas where TerrAmaz works – not just Paragominas but also Cotriguaçu in Brazil and Guaviare in Colombia – have embarked on the same dynamic
35 livestock farmers have signed forest resource conservation agreements and received individual funding to improve their husbandry practices
Those agreements currently cover 930 hectares of forest
or 30% of the total area of farmland in the municipality
CIRAD agronomist Marie-Gabrielle Piketty is leading the TerrAmaz project
She is enthusiastic about the initial results: “TerrAmaz is helping to support and capitalize on these initiatives in several parts of the Amazon
Local government and development players are working together on this
TerrAmaz is funded by the Agence française de développement and is due to run from 2020 to 2024
scientists will be able to determine precisely the economic
ecological and social advantages of these innovative landscapes
Some say the trial is unethical. Others, that not doing it would be immoral
Childhood exposure to a common gut bacterium could be responsible
For now, the evidence for neuromodulation products is slim
Many will still be culled under false pretences
Initiatives test solutions for restoring the vegetation in degraded areas
The initial results from an ecological restoration project at Marupiara Farm in the municipality of Paragominas
four years after the degraded areas there were isolated and the first seedlings of native species such as açaí and andiroba were planted
The use of techniques such as artificial enrichment of forests
which adds new species to the growing vegetation
has led to the recovery of about 60% of the area partially destroyed by timber harvesting in recent decades
had 17 hectares that were not in compliance with the law in 2011
These lands were supposed to function as Permanent Preservation Areas (APPs) to protect the rivers
The recovery program has also helped diversify the farm’s output
as evidenced by the fact that açaí and wood will soon be brought to market
The number of cases of this type could potentially increase over the next few years
Brazil’s federal government enacted the implementing regulations for the Rural Environmental Cadastre (CAR)
an instrument created to regulate and monitor some 5.6 million rural properties
Completion of the cadastre in 2016 will initiate the Environmental Regulation Program
which will require rural landowners to restore areas that were illegally deforested in the past
“This will likely increase the demand for projects to restore natural formations in Brazil,” says biologist Ricardo Ribeiro Rodrigues
a professor at the Luiz de Queiroz College of Agriculture
one of the principal livestock centers in the Amazon Region
was at the top of the Ministry of the Environment’s deforestation blacklist from 2008 to 2010
With pressure from the Office of the Prosecutor for the Public Interest
the city was able to get off the list with support from The Nature Conservancy
which helped register 80% of the properties in the rural environmental cadastre of the state of Pará
the city faced a new dilemma: how to keep from getting back onto the list of worst deforesters
“There was only one answer: we should adopt modern techniques that can transform livestock-raising in the region,” says Mauro Lucio Costa
owner of Marupiara Farm and former president of the Rural Producers Union of Paragominas
The union requested help from researchers at ESALQ-USP
who have a wealth of experience in forest restoration studies
“Our research findings come from studies done under the Biota-FAPESP program,” says Ricardo Ribeiro Rodrigues
referring to the initiative begun in 1999 to map the biodiversity of the state of São Paulo
Rodrigues was coordinator of the program from 2004 to 2009
One result was a 2008 document that presents guidelines for conservation and restoration of the biodiversity in the state of São Paulo
based on the knowledge generated by Biota-FAPESP
that the remaining fragments of vegetation be taken into consideration in recovery projects
with an emphasis on riparian forests—the vegetation growing along the edges of headwaters
lakes and dams that protects the water from silting up
and also acts as a center for seed dispersal and creates ecological corridors
Reproduction from the book Restauração florestal/Editora Oficina de Textos Intensive livestock farming freed up more space for forest restoration in areas that had been degraded for decades in Paragominas
ParáReproduction from the book Restauração florestal/Editora Oficina de Textos
There was one more challenge: convincing the farmers in Paragominas who are averse to change
“Most of them only became engaged when they saw that the restoration projects were viable and could diversify production and generate a profit,” Costa says
12 native species were planted in legal reserve areas
where sustainable management is permitted for economic use
Work was also done to improve the pasture areas
more fertile land were improved and thickened
This made it possible to keep more cattle in a smaller space
the property had 0.9 head of cattle per hectare; in 2015 that number rose to 3 head per hectare
Ricardo Rodrigues how heads a project to restore riparian forests
native forests for economic production and degraded forest fragments
The goal is to simulate and understand the effects of implementing the new Forest Code
to identify the potential for using and marketing wood and non-wood products from native species and to develop low-cost methods of restoration
research groups such as the one at ESALQ are also endeavoring to test practical applications for a number of available techniques
Some of these efforts in Brazil are described in the book Restauração florestal (Forest Restoration)
which was authored by Rodrigues along with Sergius Gandolfi and Pedro Brancalion
The sixth edition of the book was introduced at the Ecological Restoration Symposium held November 9-13
The book updates the theoretical framework drawn up in 2010 to provide technical support for the Atlantic Forest Restoration Pact
an effort that brings together 350 public and private institutions
The goal is to restore 15 million hectares of Atlantic forest by 2050
“Many initiatives have had no guarantee of success
because the projects have been implemented incorrectly,” says Rodrigues
Forest recovery on farms in rural São Paulo State is one of the initiatives carried out under the Pact
three farms in Itu were chosen as sites for restoration activities intended to provide environmental compensation
The initiative works as follows: the owner of a sugarcane plantation that does not have areas suitable for forest recovery in a legal reserve can
invest in remaining natural areas located on another property
“We’re also putting 10,000-square-meter land parcels up for sale on some of the farms
Half the area is restored native vegetation
The objective is to form a forest corridor amidst the buildings,” says business owner and sociologist Neca Setubal
Reproduction from the book Restauração florestal/Editora Oficina de Textos Stream protected by riparian forest in Lucas do Rio Verde
state of Mato Grosso…Reproduction from the book Restauração florestal/Editora Oficina de Textos
The current Forest Code permits controlled exploitation of APPs on small properties
provided that species from the local region are used
In areas where sustainable management is permitted
the law authorizes the planting of up to 50% exotic species
the first resolution published by the state environmental department named 247 tree species to be used in restoration projects
recently announced a revised and expanded list of 2,315 species that includes not only trees
Successful restoration depends on the biodiversity involved and the genetic variability,” says Luiz Mauro Barbosa
most of the recovery areas used no more than 30 species
And nurseries concentrated on producing just a few types of trees
the state has 207 nurseries that produce about 40 million seedlings of 800 arboreal species each year
The expanded list of species will be a strategic cornerstone of the Headwaters Program
a river conservation initiative based on forest restoration launched by the São Paulo State government in 2015
The objective is to protect 6,000 kilometers of streams and restore some 20,000 hectares of riparian forest
a nongovernmental organization that will take part in projects under the state program
is one of the entities already at work in the area around the water system that supplies the city of São Paulo and other cities
The organization is participating through the Water Production Program run by the National Water Agency (ANA)
in response to a call for proposals under the BNDES Atlantic Forest Initiative
we were able to determine that planting seedlings improved the water quality,” says Pedro Barral de Sá
who heads forest projects for the Green Initiative
has been conducting a program to improve water quality and increase production by protecting headwaters
The initiative is devoted in part to associating the production of yerba mate with forests around the headwaters of rivers and streams
Several stakeholders are involved in the project
including the municipal government and the Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation’s forestry division (Embrapa Florestas)
We’ve now recovered a number of headwaters
and the case has become a model for headwaters protection and ecological restoration
It even includes training for technicians,” says Emiliano Santarosa
an analyst at Embrapa Florestas who is in charge of technology transfer operations in the region
Another recovery method implemented by Embrapa is the agrosilvopastoral system
and can increase productivity in the field without the need to expand the agricultural area into virgin forest
Embrapa is developing projects of this type primarily with dairy or beef cattle farmers
Partial shade offers comfort to the animals and
there are over 40 properties that serve as models for the use of this system in projects carried out by Embrapa in partnership with the Paraná Institute for Technical Assistance and Rural Extension
Reproduction from the book Restauração florestal/Editora Oficina de Textos … and an unprotected stream in Piracicaba
in rural São Paulo State: vegetation prevents streams from silting upReproduction from the book Restauração florestal/Editora Oficina de Textos
experiments that combine sugarcane planting with native forest preservation are revealing a way for bioenergy production and forests to coexist in the same space
A 2012 study by Brazilian and American researchers showed that native forest can store 18 times more carbon than can sugarcane
along with colleagues at the National Institute for Space Research (INPE)
showed that the state of São Paulo has a deficit of 800,000 hectares of forest that should be recovered
“One solution is to plant the sugarcane around forests
or vice-versa,” suggests Marcos Buckeridge
a co-author of that study and coordinator of the National Institute of Science and Technology of Bioethanol (INCT-Bio)
the difficulties lie in making the experiments work on a larger scale,” he notes
“The projects implemented in Brazil are so far rather localized,” he points out
depends on strategies to lower the cost of forest restoration projects and facilitate economic gains
the forest renewal on the three farms cost about R$20,000 per hectare
they had to plant a full complement of seeds or seedlings
and the costs need to be brought down through the use of scientific know-how,” Rodrigues says
© Revista Pesquisa FAPESP - All rights reserved
Get our news on your inbox! Suscribe x
MercoPress, en Español
Montevideo, May 6th 2025 - 10:12 UTC
Europe’s third largest aluminum maker
agreed to buy mining and smelting assets from Vale (NYSE: VALE) in a deal valued at 4.9 billion US dollars
boosting its control over raw materials used in production
the world’s largest iron ore producer
will receive 1.1 billion in cash and new shares equivalent to 22% of the Oslo-based company’s outstanding stock
Norsk Hydro ASA (OSL: NHY) said in a statement
Hydro will assume 700 million USD in net debt and plans to raise 10 billion kronor (1.69 billion USD) selling shares to help finance the transaction
Norsk Hydro ASA is adding raw-material assets to lower costs after prices for aluminum slumped last year on slowing economic growth and declining demand from builders and carmakers. The purchase gives the Norwegian company control of Brazil’s Paragominas
one of the world’s bauxite mines
The combination will “considerably” strengthen Hydro’s position in bauxite mining and alumina refining
The quality and efficiency of the new assets will also “significantly improve” the Norwegian company’s financial position
it said. Hydro also gets 51% of the Albras aluminum plant and 81% of the CAP alumina refinery project in the deal
It already owns 34% of Alunorte and 20% of CAP
“This is a historic day” and a “transforming transaction”
Hydro’s Chief Executive Officer Svein Richard Brandtzaeg said at a press conference in Oslo. Hydro has the right to take over the remaining 40% stake in Paragominas in two installments
in return for a cash payment of 200 million USD for each installment
the company said. The company decided on the rights offer
The transaction will reduce the Norwegian State’s ownership in the company to approximately 34.5% from 43.8%
Norway’s Minister of Trade and Industry Trond Giske said at the press conference
Norway’s “ambition in the longer term” is to bring the holding back up towards 40%
it said in a statement. The purchase is a “good strategic move” for Hydro and the value is fair
The government says “yes to the deal” and the share issue
Vale becomes the second-largest shareholder in Hydro
A representative of the Rio De Janiero-based miner will join the Norwegian company’s board of directors and the company has agreed to not increase its shareholding
Vale’s Executive Director Tito Martins said in an interview after the press conference in Oslo
Vale doesn’t foresee any job losses as a consequence of the deal
he added. Vale is committed to the business and will give its total support to Hydro,” Martins said
“I am confident it will bring us a lot of benefits.”
Commenting for this story is now closed.If you have a Facebook account, become a fan and comment on our Facebook Page
Terramaz project website
René Poccard ChapuisParagominas, BrazilE-mail
The Union with Municipalities programme is led by the Brazilian Ministry of Environment (MMA)
It sets out actions to support 70 priority municipalities
identified for their high levels of deforestation and forest degradation in the reference year 2022
Focusing on equipment and incentives for municipalities
the programme establishes new tools to achieve its objectives: ensuring zero illegal deforestation by 2030
and improving livelihoods for local people
To the municipalities that engage in this process
the programme will allocate a total of 740 million reais (133 million euros)
600 million of which are from the Amazon Fund
this funding will be used to implement various actions
including accelerating environmental and land regularisation
financing sustainable productive activities
and equipping and modernising “good governance offices” in city councils
which has so far been the poor relation in Amazon policies
is now considered essential for engaging Amazon populations and achieving real impacts on the ground
the consolidation of territorial institutions is seen as playing a structural role in reducing deforestation in the priority municipalities
also stressed the importance of a good relationship within the territories between the different types of actors
Organising this coexistence is the only way to effectively meet the expectations of the different groups”
“This is exactly what the Paragoclima project
seeks to do by giving all stakeholders a voice and trying to include everyone in governance instruments”
From left to right: René Poccard-Chapuis
the Environmental Secretary for Rondon do Pará
Since 2020, the municipality is one of the five pilot territories of the TerrAmaz project
with which it is developing a territorial intelligence plan to foster synergies between economic
Drawing on this progress and these outcomes
the municipality launched its ParagoClima project in April 2023
with the goal of achieving carbon neutrality by 2030
The objective is to build on the comparative advantages of the Amazon for low-carbon activities
especially in the fields of sustainable agriculture and forestry
more sustainable territorial development dynamics
forms the coordination group responsible for implementing this project
These actions have enabled Paragominas to be proactive in developing this new Union with Municipalities programme
A number of exchanges have taken place with the MMA’s Special Secretariat for Deforestation Control and Territorial Planning (SECD)
during which the municipality stressed the importance of promoting low-carbon development rather than focusing solely on forest protection
These different exchanges and events have already contributed to defining the criteria and outlines of this new programme to combat illegal deforestation in the Amazon
Paragominas will continue to discuss ways to improve the programme with the SECD
and with the Amazon city councils so that they are better able to develop projects in line with forest protection
Criteria for inclusion in or removal from the list need to be discussed in greater detail
especially where forest fires are concerned
and the municipality will tackle this issue
René Poccard-Chapuis has also coordinated a report that he submitted to the SECD
analysing deforestation across the whole Amazon biome
and making suggestions for adapting federal policies to specific situations in the major types of municipalities in the Amazon
Tackle climate change : Recommendations for agricultural adaptation policies of tomorrow
Climate change at CIRAD
Marie HrabanskiMontpellier, FranceE-mail
How can effective policy instruments to adapt agriculture to climate change be implemented
CIRAD has published a set of recommendations in a policy brief: "Tackle climate change: recommendations for agricultural adaptation policies of tomorrow"
Adapting the agricultural sector to climate change calls for five key measures: assessing the true performance of climate policy instruments; implementing sectoral policy instruments; promoting incentive
communicative and regulatory instruments; improving implementation of existing instruments; and promoting national "jurisdictional adaptation" as an assessment of climate adaptation at global level
Agriculture accounts for 25% of global greenhouse gas emissions
it has the potential to slash its emissions by 75%
The article contains five key messages for policymakers
two of which run counter to what is generally advocated on a global level
The performance of policy instruments must be measured on the ground
Governance issues or the dilution of policymakers' capacity to act may limit the efficacy of action plans
It is important to ensure the effective dissemination of objectives
and concrete implementation of instruments in territories and/or cultivable plots
it is generally accepted that climate issues must be managed by means of cross-sectoral governance
agricultural issues must be addressed in combination with other sectors such as water
"instruments for adapting agriculture to climate change are more effective if implemented by the agricultural sector
We think this is because the agricultural sector often has better territorial coverage and is more structured than other sectors".These factors facilitate more rapid innovation
to implement instruments for adapting agriculture to climate change
three quarters of current instruments are being implemented by players in the agricultural sector
such as the Climate Smart Agriculture platform in Senegal
The platform coordinates national and local players
to ensure the integration of climate policy in agricultural policies and projects
notably by means of departmental platforms."But this does not mean that non-agricultural players should not be involved in public policy building"
The authors stress the importance of rehabilitating command-and-control regulatory instruments
but they feel that such regulatory instruments
combined with incentives and communicative instruments
guarantee effective implementation of climate adaptation policies.Hybrid instruments already exist
such as EU agri-environment-climate measures
which provide financial support to farmers provided they adopt more environmentally friendly practices
There is no point developing a range of climate plans: in Colombia
climate policies have blossomed in recent years
we would recommend institutional and instrumental restraint", Marie Hrabanski stresses
The priority is to improve implementation of the sectoral instruments judged to be the most effective
The authors pinpoint the need to promote national "jurisdictional adaptation" as an efficient assessment of climate adaptation policies on a global scale
local climate litigation serves to improve international climate law
innovate in terms of transnational disputes
and develop a preventive approach in terms of liability
respecting these priority messages will ensure the successful implementation of public policy in favour of climate adaptation within farming systems worldwide
Please enable JS and disable any ad blocker