which is celebrating its centenary this year
and you’ve considered settling in Tibet or Beijing
we’d find you in the Šluknov Hook [northern Czech Republic] instead
The Šluknov region is more a matter of chance
My family and I were looking for a place to live between Berlin and Prague and I wanted my son to attend a Czech school
So the Czech-German border region was a possible choice
When I first saw the vast meadows and pastures there
they greatly reminded me of the Tibetan plains
I could immediately picture a herd of yaks there
And there is indeed a herd of yaks grazing behind your house
But you took your imagination even further
I’ve spent several years in the Tibetan regions
Mostly among pastoral nomads and their herds
so I guess I wanted to bring home at least a piece of Tibet and share it with others
A stupa is a Buddhist structure that is meant to symbolise peace and tranquillity
I knew exactly what it’s supposed to look like and contain
What if the bricks don’t align due to their size and what should the interior look like
I’ve consulted with builders and read through instructions
I even consulted the issue with the monk who accompanied the Dalai Lama on his 2006 visit to the Czech Republic
He ended up drawing me a diagram and explaining what was important for the construction of the stupa
officially called the Centre for Exploring Asian Regions
Bringing a piece of Asia into my own home was an idea I had even before I started working at the Oriental Institute
The Culture and Information Center for Asia allows us to bring our work closer to people
to share our research and findings with them
We host lectures for schools and the general public
So you’ve managed to transplant a bit of Asia to your homeland
The COVID-19 pandemic has made travelling quite difficult
When was the last time you were in the region
With the outbreak of the covid crisis in 2020
I came to realise that the only Asia in my reach at that moment was in my backyard
The last time I visited China and Tibet was in 2019
I managed to go to Nepal for a while in 2021
but travelling to China is complicated at the moment
Are these difficulties with travel caused by the COVID-19 pandemic or the increasingly more restrictive regime of the People’s Republic of China
It’s interconnected; the covid crisis has come in handy for the regime
The pandemic can be used as an excuse for many things
China completely isolated itself for a while
and it’s practically impossible for researchers of my kind to get into the country right now
How do you get information directly from Tibet if you can’t go there
We all now have to find new ways of accessing information
it’s hard to follow and understand exactly what’s going on
I visited Tibet every year for a few weeks or months at a time
and even then you could see how the situation in the peripheral regions of China was changing dynamically
Just an absence of half a year was enough for the situation to change completely
How was life changing in the areas inhabited by Tibetans at that time
and many places lacked electricity and network coverage
Tibetans have woken up to a whole new era and are struggling to find their place in it
We can read about what’s happened the past two years from official sources like the Xinhua News Agency
but what they present is a very distorted view
A visit in person to verify the facts is therefore absolutely essential
you refer to your “informants” on the ground
That’s also why I avoid getting information via email
because any outgoing communication abroad can bring with it sanctions from the government
China is significantly ahead of the curve when it comes to technology and its usefulness in controlling its own people
Let’s clarify which areas we’re talking about
The ethno-cultural region of Tibet covers a much larger area than just the Tibet Autonomous Region
It is vast and represents about half the total expanse of historic Tibet
Tibetans also make up the majority of the population in the Chinese province of Qinghai
which lies to the north-east of the autonomous region and is called Ambo
It is the region I specialise in and visit most often
The third cultural and linguistic Tibetan area is the Kham eastern province of Tibet
which has for the most part been administratively incorporated into the Chinese Sichuan province
we see him as the exiled representative of Tibet
But which part of Tibet does he actually represent
The current Dalai Lama and the Tibetan government-in-exile represent all Tibetans
the Dalai Lama still embodies the ultimate authority
what springs to mind is typically the image of a monk
a person who draws their wisdom from their spirituality
But what does it really mean to be a Tibetan in the present day
The Czechs have a certain awareness of Tibet
especially thanks to Václav Havel and his contacts with the Dalai Lama
He was the world’s first head of state to officially welcome the Dalai Lama as a state representative
Us Czechs know roughly where Tibet is located
our notion of ordinary Tibetans is quite distorted
We tend to think that people there live in harmony; in touch with nature and spirituality
the ordinary Tibetan is not so different from me and you
and the opportunity to send their children to a good school
How important is religion to Tibetans today
In the modern world that the Chinese government has developed in the Tibetan areas over the past twenty years
People can now earn money and buy whatever they want
More and more people are employed or are trying to run businesses
Life has sped up and there is less and less time to practice religion
it is undergoing a process of modernisation instead
young entrepreneurs don’t have time to frequent temples or spin a prayer mill at home
they purchase a solar-powered prayer mill and put it in their car or office
Here we should explain how such a prayer mill works to better understand.
Picture a cylindrical hand-held prayer mill that is attached to a metal or wooden handle
Inside is a rolled-up piece of paper inscribed with prayers
Even Tibetans are adapting their religious practices to today’s needs
which actively discouraged people from practicing their faith
Religious freedom is a problem throughout China
As part of the fight against anything foreign
the Chinese government is restricting especially Christianity and Islam
the question is whether you can consider it domestic or foreign influence
There is a great deal of room for interpretation
Tibetan Buddhism has become the target of a campaign to ethnicize the religion in recent years
Red Chinese flags flutter outside monasteries
slogans and portraits of Xi Jinping hang on the walls
The government is calling on Tibetans to stop making financial donations to monasteries – this
What power does the current regime have over Tibetan monasteries
The government has tried to seize control of the monasteries from the very beginning
it had to retain a certain amount of freedom to express religion to maintain peace
the Chinese government has definitively incorporated the peripheral areas into a functioning infrastructure that allows the regime virtually unlimited oversight and ability to intervene
the influence of monasteries and other religious institutions
as parallel sources of authority to the centralized government and the Chinese Communist Party
and monastery abbots are required to undergo patriotic education
Tibetan is quite different from Standard Chinese (Mandarin)
Are Tibetans “allowed” to use their own language
These are two completely different language families
Lhasa Tibetan falls under the Tibeto-Burman languages
Tibetans do not use Chinese characters for writing
the use of Tibetans’ own language should be guaranteed when it comes to official affairs and education
the government is now trying to universally impose classes in schools taught only in Chinese
and even official documents are not always made available in translation
nomads – who had to relocate from the grasslands to newly built housing developments – being given a contract to sign that was only in Chinese
They had to sign something they didn’t understand at all
But many of them wouldn’t have been able to read the one in Tibetan either; a large part of the older generation cannot read or write
it’s not easy to just say “I am Tibetan”; it’s the identity of “Chinese citizen” that is promoted
The Chinese citizen comes first; cultural and ethnic traditions are secondary
Chinese citizens should be equal regardless of origin
The regime requires everyone to declare themselves as Chinese citizens
We’ve mentioned the relocating of Tibetan nomads from the grasslands to housing developments and the construction of infrastructure
Let us add that these changes are in line with the ‘Open Up the West’ strategy that the government announced at the start of the new millennium
about seventy percent of China’s territory
is the coast with metropolises such as Shanghai
Money has been pumped into the East since the 1980s when China began to open up to the world and was in need of foreign investments
and the region soon became the centre of the economy and contact with the world
you could find modern cities booming there
That was the first time I visited the area
Almost nothing had changed in Tibet from the 1950s to the end of the millennium
a journey from a nomadic area to the nearest centre
So the government decided to open up to the world and modernise Western China as well
The East of China was becoming rapidly wealthier and the economic and social disparities between East and West were starting to become unsustainable
Many people migrated from Central and Western China to find work in the East to earn money
where they lived without legal status and as a result
The government therefore launched a programme to develop the Western part of the country and started heavily subsidising it
the streets in towns and deserted roads in the middle of the plains were flooded with slogans about the great opening up of the West
about how everything was going to be great
The Chinese government is relocating traditional herders into cities to better exert control over them and extract mineral resources found in the areas
The proclaimed goal was to catch up with the East
But I’m assuming the intent was not as altruistic as presented by official press sources
What are the other dimensions of the strategy
To catch up with the standard of living in the East was one thing
everything was presented as an intention to lift the population in the West out of its so-called backward way of life
To turn the pastoral herders into urbanites
It was a less publicly mentioned fact that the region was very rich in mineral resources which hadn’t yet been exploited
along with the fact that the West is a sparsely populated
while the East is overcrowded with tens of millions of people
So the aim was definitely not only to support the population in the West
the aim was to build infrastructure – roads
airports – and to connect the western peripheral regions to Central China
and exerting more control and influence over the lives of the local inhabitants
One of the phases was the abolishment of pastures and housing development
The Communist Chinese government claimed to be helping the locals
Is it possible to say how voluntary these relocations were
The reasons most often given by the government for sedentarisation
are about improving the living conditions of the herders and protecting the environment
which is supposedly under long-term threat from livestock grazing
the government is subjecting the cleared land to construction and mining
relocating people into newly built housing greatly improved population control
which became a priority after the 2008 riots
that they had a great opportunity to move into a house for free or for a very low fee
and they would have access to education and health care
But they had to make a decision within the week or lose the opportunity
Those who refused to move were sometimes threatened with sanctions
Tibetan nomads relocated in rather massive numbers
Two decades have passed since this strategy was launched
Do we even know how the former pastoral nomads are faring in the cities today?
The housing developments are mostly located on the outskirts of district cities or towns
But some of them are completely out of the way
Even several years after the construction being finished
many housing developments have no electricity or water supply
Those who relinquished their right to the government to use the pastures or sold their herds haven’t been able to do so
Many of these people feel great frustration
They have no means to make a living and are just waiting for welfare
They’ve become a plaything in the hands of a government on which they are now totally dependent
Alcoholism and other problems are on the rise
the People’s Republic of China had set itself the goal of eliminating poverty
China announced with fanfare that it had completely eliminated poverty
It all boils down to how you define poverty
the government includes social welfare in the income of the population
the poverty line isn’t necessarily crossed
But this says nothing about the stability and sustainability of living standards
a large Turkic minority living in China’s western province of Xinjiang
information has leaked out about internment re-education camps
Do similar detention camps exist for Tibetans
There are no re-education camps on such a massive scale as those in Xinjiang
but we would certainly find parallels in Tibet
It was Tibet which used to be considered problematic
it was common for inconvenient people to suddenly disappear and the population to be under permanent control
in the wake of the Summer Olympics in Beijing
Tibetans wanted to take advantage of the whole world watching China and decided to draw attention to their situation
The reaction of the Chinese government was drastic
The protests started in March 2008 in Lhasa to mark the anniversary of the Dalai Lama’s departure into exile
and unrest broke out in other Tibetan areas
The Chinese authorities responded with a brutal crackdown
with reports of hundreds of casualties (deaths) and thousands of arrests
there were fewer Chinese military bases in Tibetan areas than there are today
the infrastructure that the Chinese government ‘gifted’ to the Tibetan people
which enabled the rapid relocation of troops to the problematic areas
Between March (when the riots broke out) and August (when the Olympics began)
trucks with soldiers armed to the teeth would patrol the streets every day
Many people ended up in jail during that time
some for being found with a picture of the Tibetan flag or for singing Tibetan songs
The situation didn’t ease up even after the Olympics
The soldiers remained in Tibet and security checks intensified
Population monitoring is ubiquitous across the whole of China
So governmental control over the population is similar both in Tibet and Xinjiang
and there is little to speak of in terms of freedom of movement
who imposed strict measures on Tibetans after the Olympics
such as thoroughly monitoring people’s movement through ubiquitous camera surveillance and checkpoints
Any sort of mobility in China is unwelcome and suspect
China uses a system of classifying the population; you fall into different categories according to the number of social points you gain
Some citizens earn the right to hold a passport
The last Olympics sparked a wave of solidarity with the Tibetans around the world
with calls for a boycott of the sports event
we found ourselves in the same situation again
as the Winter Olympics were held in Beijing in 2022
Does this mean that the world is quietly tolerating the violation of human rights in China
It is a surprise that China was able to qualify again
Beijing is the first city in the world to ever have hosted two Olympic Games
Why the International Olympic Committee chose China in 2008 is understandable
the country seemed to be changing and opening up; the world probably assumed that the Olympics would encourage development in that direction
China more or less perceives being chosen as the host of the Olympics again as an endorsement of its policies
She completed her studies in Sinology and Tibetology at the Humboldt University in Berlin
She has been working at the Oriental Institute of the CAS since 2014 as a researcher at the Department of East Asia
She is co-investigator of a project (supported by the Lumina quaeruntur fellowship of the CAS) on the context of national and foreign policy in present-day China
Along with Ondřej Klimeš and in collaboration with universities in Warsaw
Ptáčková has applied for an ERC (European Research Council) Synergy grant concerning a follow-up research focus
CAO of the CASTranslated by: Tereza Novická
Texts and photographs labelled (CC) are released for use under the Creative Commons license
The primary mission of the CAS is to conduct research in a broad spectrum of natural, technical and social sciences as well as humanities
This research aims to advance progress of scientific knowledge at the international level
the specific needs of the Czech society and the national culture
Prof. Eva Zažímalová has started her second term of office in May 2021
and a Professor of Plant Anatomy and Physiology
She is also a part of GCSA of the EU.