Culture
By Emmie Willis
The people felt betrayed by their leaders following the signing of the Treaty of Versailles after WWI
which devastated the once-thriving country
German leadership had maintained that they were the superior power and would defeat their enemies
even when it became clear they were losing the war
when the war ended and the Germans signed the treaty
Vast tracts of land were taken away and the Rhineland (Germany’s industrial heart) was occupied by Allied troops
The German army was reduced to a maximum of 100,000 men
All Germany’s colonies were seized and most damaging of all
reparations were imposed upon Germany to compensate the Allies for damages incurred during the war
It’s understandable that everyday Germans felt bitterness and resentment
They felt they were cheated of their rightful victory
Into this political climate came the National Socialist German Workers Party (also known as the Nazis) with promises that they make a better Germany—that they would make Germany great once more
Sophie Scholl was raised in a Christian household
Her parents believed in speaking up for truth
The Scholl household hosted many political discussions
A few months before Sophie’s 13th birthday
not least of which was a rush of youth groups popping up with the aim of supporting Nazi values
In addition to the official youth groups were some not officially affiliated with the Nazi party
whether because they existed before youth groups became a political platform or because they wanted to explore their own way through Nazi values without having to follow the official rules and their emphasis on military training
The Nazis did not like unofficial youth groups
and soon a law was implemented banning any such groups
who supported the Nazis against their parents’ wishes
along with other members of the illegal youth group
Werner and the others were soon released with a warning
This prolonged time in prison made him start to think hard about what the Nazis were doing
comparing them with the values he knew to be true
Those questions stayed in the back of Sophie’s mind as she tried to fulfil her dream of studying at university
a law was implemented that only those who had served time in National Labour Service would be given leave to seek higher education
Sophie quit school to take on an apprenticeship as a kindergarten teacher in the hopes that this would satisfy the requirement
she joined the National Labour Service and found it to be arduous
The strict discipline with no room for personal expression did not suit her and she chafed at it
she was able to enrol in the University of Munich where she studied biology and philosophy while also studying religion as much as she could
also attended the University of Munich after having completed his conscription services as a medic on the eastern front.When Sophie heard some of the stories he brought home of the cruelties of the Nazis in their treatment of captured enemies
she felt the injustice of it and wanted to do something
It wasn’t until she came across a pamphlet one day that she had any idea what she could do
This pamphlet contained information about the ugly truth the Nazis were trying to contain as well as a call to action for the citizens of Germany
It was highly illegal and if the Nazis found out who wrote it
the perpetrators would be killed for treason
Sophie recognised the writing and knew immediately that Hans was involved
he tried to keep her out of it because of the danger—but she was adamant that she be included
she became a member of the resistance group known as the White Rose
It was a small group of mostly students and one professor bent on fighting back with the power of truth
unable to turn a blind eye to the cruelty happening in their country
They still had faith in the German people and formed the White Rose to tell the truth about what was happening and spark a fire of resistance that they hoped would defeat the Nazis and end their reign of injustice
They wrote pamphlets and mailed them to people encouraging them in whatever resistance efforts they could manage
from sabotaging ammunitions factories to publicly speaking out against the Nazis
At the time of the release of their sixth pamphlet
it was increasingly clear that the Germans would lose this war also
hand delivering the pamphlets around their university
Sophie was in the corridor between classes when she realised that there was a stack of these pamphlets that would go to waste if she didn’t act so she grabbed them and threw them down the stairwell
a janitor who was loyal to the Nazis saw her and reported her
Hans was carrying the draft for their seventh pamphlet
The three were executed for treason on February 22
This wasn’t the end of the impact of the White Rose however
as the Allies heard of the executions and ran stories in their newspapers
about German students protesting the Nazis
This helped boost morale near the end of a very long war
They also managed to get a copy of the sixth pamphlet
which they copied and dumped over Germany from planes
Sophie never resorted to violence; she held true to the belief that truth would set them free
ensuring her voice and those of her fellow conspirators would be heard far and wide
holding her head high in the face of injustice
movies and plays have been written to tell her story
ensuring that her courage in speaking the truth will not be in vain and that Sophie Scholl will never be forgotten
Sign up to get our monthly newsletter
Signs of the Times has been published by the Seventh-day Adventist Church since 1886
Subscribe
The year was 1942. While the Battle of Stalingrad would begin later that summer, the horrors of the Holocaust were far from over with the mass, systematic murder of Jews at Auschwitz-Birkenau just beginning
20-year-old University of Munich student Sophie Scholl was coming to the conclusion that she could no longer sit idly by and watch the expanding crimes against humanity that Hitler and the Nazi party were commintting
Scholl made a commitment to what activists of today might call active allyship
joining the White Rose resistance group and in turn stirring thousands of German students and civilians into action
even serving time in a Nazi prison later in his life for calling Hitler “God’s scourge on mankind.”
It wasn’t until her brother, Hans, was arrested in 1937 for participating in an illegal non-Nazi group that Sophie would begin her awakening, fully turning against the Nazi Party and making her way into the resistance. In 1939, both of Sophie’s brothers were drafted into the war, with Hans being stationed at the Eastern Front. It was here that he witnessed some of the atrocities being committed against the Jews first hand
and what would inevitably inspire the founding of the White Rose
After serving her required six months of auxiliary war service as a nursery teacher, Sophie enrolled at the University of Munich alongside Hans in 1942
began printing and distributing anti-Nazi Party leaflets around the city of Munich under the name of the White Rose
The group was inspired by the examples of passive resistance they had heard about in the United States
where groups of students were beginning to fight in the name of civil rights and racial justice
The White Rose would eventually write and distribute six pamphlets in total
and even cultivating a network of supporters that would help them distribute the leaflets throughout all of Germany
The leaflets asked many questions of their readers
they asked the same question Sophie asked of herself as she began to grow suspicious of the National Socialist Party and their values: If you know what is happening
Along with educating German students and calling for “freedom of speech
and protection of the individual citizen from the arbitrary action of criminal dictator-states,” the White Rose’s activist materials implored civilians to engage in forms of non-violent resistance by sabotaging weapon plants and war industries
and attempting to obstruct the overall actions of the Nazi Party
Leaving a number of copies of the sixth pamphlet throughout the empty hallways of the University of Munich
Sophie made the decision to fling the remaining leaflets off the staircase and into the main hall
It was then that a janitor and supporter of the Nazi regime saw Sophie and her brother and called the Gestapo immediately
and I have to go… What does my death matter
thousands of people are awakened and stirred to action?” She was 21
The efforts of the White Rose did not die with Sophie
their sixth leaflet was smuggled into the United Kingdom where it was reprinted and later dropped all over Germany by Allied planes
because they die too… Life is always on the edge of death; narrow streets lead to the same place as wide avenues
and a little candle burns itself out just like a flaming torch does
As we bear witness to perhaps one of the largest civil rights uprisings in modern history with the Black Lives Matter movement
non-Black allies must ask themselves the same question Sophie and the White Rose asked of the German people: If you see what is happening
Sophie’s courageous actions remind us of how important it is to speak out against injustice and to engage in passive resistance not only when our own rights are being threatened
but as an ally when the lives of others are at stake
and her story is something we would all do well to remember
Header image of Sophie via National World War II Museum; flowers via CSA Images/Getty Images
Find more of her musings on feminst pop-culture and history on BUST.com and on Twitter @alizapelto
By submitting I agree to the privacy policy
Does a video shared on Facebook genuinely show "Texas tractors"
Customs and Border Patrol confirmed to Lead Stories that there is no evidence that such an event occurred
The clip in question was taken from a longer video posted on YouTube by German broadcaster Schöntal TV and was described as a farmer protest that took place on January 14
A version of the claim originated in a video shared on Facebook on January 23, 2024 (archived here)
Below is how the post appeared at the time of writing:
(Source: Facebook screenshot taken Fri Feb 2 21:40:07 UTC 2024)
In response to a query from Lead Stories, Rick Pauza (archived here)
Customs and Border Protection (CBP) in Laredo
emailed that the agency has "no evidence" that the event shown in the video ever occurred along the Texas portion of the U.S.-Mexico border
"The equipment depicted in the reel is not CBP equipment
is not indicative of anything used by the agency in our day-to-day operations and does not appear to be the U.S.-Mexico border area," Pauza wrote in an email received on January 31
A description that accompanied the video read:
500 Bauern in den Weinbergen von Forchtenberg im Hohenlohekreis gegen die aktuelle Sparpolitik der Bundesregierung
around 500 farmers protested in the wine mountains of Forchtenberg in the Hohenkreis district against the current austerity policy of the Federal Government
A comparison of screenshots taken from the clip shared on Facebook (below right) and from the video posted by Schöntal TV (below left) show similar elements, including the white street sign alongside a roadside shoulder seen at the 9:53 mark and a white house located on a hillside shown at the 10:18 mark of the video on YouTube:
(Source: Lead Stories screenshot taken Fri Feb 2 22:56:49 UTC 2024)
Lead Stories emailed Schöntal TV for further confirmation but did not receive a response
the location was also identified as Forchtenberg
Madison grew up a perpetually curious tidepooler and has used that love of science and innovation in her now full-time role as a science reporter for the fact-checking publication Lead Stories
Chat with our friendly robots on WhatsApp
Add our number +1 (404) 655-4223, follow this link or scan the image below with your phone:
Please select all the ways you would like to hear from Lead Stories LLC:
You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking the link in the footer of our emails
For information about our privacy practices
We use Mailchimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to Mailchimp for processing. Learn more about Mailchimp's privacy practices here.