Background: For people who have experienced mental health crises or psychosocial disabilities, it is considerably more difficult to receive support to participate in work on an equal basis with others. In the town of Geesthacht, in Northern Germany, an integrative care network was implemented that allows for acute psychiatric treatment as well as participation in work and activities. This paper aims to explore the principles, advantages, and challenges of this innovative project.
Methodology: Within the context of a participatory and collaborative process evaluation of a prospective controlled cohort study (PsychCare), researchers with and without experiential expertise conducted expert interviews and focus groups to evaluate the experiences of 37 employees, with and without lived experience, from various institutions associated with this care network. The data was analyzed using qualitative content analysis.
Conclusion: This innovative project in Geesthacht demonstrates the multifaceted potential of a global treatment budget system in the field of mental health care. To address certain downsides of the Geesthacht model, further development is necessary.
Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Rehabilitation
Volume 12 - 2021 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyt.2021.634080
Background: For people who have experienced mental health crises or psychosocial disabilities
it is considerably more difficult to receive support to participate in work on an equal basis with others
an integrative care network was implemented that allows for acute psychiatric treatment as well as participation in work and activities
Methodology: Within the context of a participatory and collaborative process evaluation of a prospective controlled cohort study (PsychCare)
researchers with and without experiential expertise conducted expert interviews and focus groups to evaluate the experiences of 37 employees
from various institutions associated with this care network
The data was analyzed using qualitative content analysis
Results: It was the change from financial compensation paid on a daily basis to a global treatment budget that allowed for a significant reduction of hospital beds in Geesthacht and freed up resources to implement a complex care network
These developments now allow for a less bureaucratic and often smooth transition from being a service user to involvement in participatory activities in the role of a peer
which is frequently perceived to be empowering and beneficial by participants with lived experience
this care model has led to multiple role conflicts and different challenges for all parties involved
Conclusion: This innovative project in Geesthacht demonstrates the multifaceted potential of a global treatment budget system in the field of mental health care
To address certain downsides of the Geesthacht model
the CRPD aims at ensuring equal rights and participation in education
A self-determined and autonomous life is intended for everyone
in accordance with their own will and preferences
In the field of mental health, many of these principles resonate well with long-debated concepts that originated within the social movement of survivors of psychiatric services, who are largely critical of the psychiatric care system. The notion of “recovery” has now been implemented in various health policy programs, implying self-determination, personal growth, participation, and control of one's own living conditions (2)
The concept of “empowerment” has equally been coopted by various psychiatric institutions or stakeholders
yet its original meaning designated self-determination and choice of those people who should be the focus of care
both of which are indispensable conditions for effective participation
the majority of people with psychosocial or intellectual disabilities in Germany are still employed in segregated workplaces
The increasing number of beds in nursing homes and hospitals almost everywhere in Germany
among other structural mechanisms of exclusion
leads to a situation in which these people struggle to establish their existence independently from institutions and find inclusion in society
This paper presents part of the results from a participatory process evaluation that took place within the context of a larger prospective controlled cohort study (PsychCare) (5)
Various opportunities for people with lived experience of mental health crises and disabilities in a psychiatric care network in the town of Geesthacht in Northern Germany to participate in work and activities were explored
These opportunities have evolved from a longer process of reorganizing psychiatric care in Geesthacht with the aim to better assist people with lived experience in leading a more autonomous and self-determined life rather than assuming the identity of a help-seeking
This paper focuses on only one segment of that transformative process - the gradual development of more prospects for participation in the fields of work and activities
as it reflects the main focus of the work carried out in Geesthacht over the past years and demonstrates how these changes are presently perceived and evaluated by the people involved
the participation model in Geesthacht is considered critically
especially in relation to the question as to whether or not it meets CRPD-compliant criteria
To evaluate the Geesthacht model on its own terms
we have deliberately avoided comparing it with other models or insight of the international literature
instead focusing our discussion on its inherent tensions and ambivalences
This text was jointly developed by people with and without lived experience with the psychiatric care system
why it is important to us to handle language carefully
We purposely omitted terms such as “illness” or “disorder,” instead using the language of the CRPD
such as the term “mental health crises” and “psychosocial disabilities.”
Considering the variety of possibilities for work
it was difficult for us to find a single term to describe all the areas of involvement and roles connected to them
activities and/or formal employment are dealt with
such as paid employment on the basis of various forms of financial compensation and contracts (the wages ranging from usual market levels until small
volunteer work (by people with and without lived experience)
or therapeutic activities (in the sense of occupational therapy
supported employment or more traditional forms of work therapy)
To demarcate these different forms from each other at least to some extent
we refer in the following to paid work as “employment” and to unpaid work as “activities.” The gray area of supported employment [covering both place and train (individual placement and support) and train and place (in the sense of vocational training) versions] or more traditional forms of work therapy
in which therapeutic support may transition into employment will be indicated accordingly
All opportunities that are mentioned are offered by the same or different institutions
meaning that one and the same institution may offer one or more types of work and/ or activities
or another form that has been developed and offered by peers
the employees with lived experience offer support without any previous peer training
which is due to the historical development of the project
The Psychiatric Department at the Johanniter Hospital in Geesthacht was founded in 1997 and is in charge of providing care for the Duchy of Lauenburg county
a catchment area of 195,000 inhabitants to the east of Hamburg and south of Lübeck
The Duchy of Lauenburg is a rural area with 156 inhabitants per km2
Resources were released through this reorganization that were reinvested in various forms of home treatment
housing therapy (“Housing First”) and supported employment
as well as to support cross-sectoral cooperation
occupational therapy taking place in outpatient practices was included in the budgets
as it had been traditionally used heavily in this catchment area prior to the years of reorganization in Geesthacht
A more detailed description of these reorganization processes cannot be given in this paper due to limited space (9)
a complex and comprehensive network of institutions inside and outside of the hospital was established
spanning across different treatment sectors
and including various non-profit organizations
and forms of peer-organized crisis centers and respites
Developing this network enabled more continuous
and empowering treatment and support across the sectors and within the service users' home environment
Even more noteworthy is the fact that this network was created and built up at a time when neither the CRPD
recovery or peer support had been applied on a larger scale
Table 1 lists the actors and institutions cooperating with the Geesthacht model
Some of the participating partners receive payment for their services
either through health care funding (according to the German Social Code
Books V and XI) or via funds from rehabilitation programs (according to the German Social Code
Some collaborating institutions generate their own income or finance work based on donations
the global treatment budget was somewhat flexible
making transfers of funding between the institutions and sectors involved possible
fewer of these options exist due to structural reasons (see discussion)
the cooperation between the actors and institutions involved has become more limited
thus hampering the continuity and flexibility of the related services
Overview of the main institutions (and provided services) that cooperate with the Geesthacht model
together with the concepts of recovery and empowerment that over time developed into some of the guiding principles of the care network as it is practiced now
This origin of the Geesthacht model in the 1970's and its evolution over time has led to certain conceptual tensions
for instance understanding work as therapy or as a right
tension that will be discussed to be productive further below
this region showed several structural idiosyncrasies that were not sufficiently captured through this multicenter study
This was taken as an opportunity to study in further detail the range of services available in Geesthacht
One of these discussions involved clinical staff of the hospital in Geesthacht (n = 5; employees without lived experience)
while the second group was constituted exclusively of employees with lived experience (n = 8)
individual interviews were conducted with employees with lived experience (n = 7)
with non-professional employees without lived experience and no formal training in psychosocial care (n = 2)
as well as with employees without lived experience (n = 5)
The latter included the current and former heads of the Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy in Geesthacht
Additional questions focused on the home treatment system in Geesthacht and on the Housing First program but are not listed in the supplement due to the focus of this paper
All participants who were interviewed gave their informed written consent
The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of the Brandenburg Medical Association (Landesärztekammer Brandenburg) [2017
S7(a)] and by the Ethics Committees of the Federal States the participating hospitals were located in
Only results related to the areas of work and activities are listed and discussed with the objective of making this paper easier to understand and accessible
we have omitted a discussion of other innovations in the fields of treatment and housing that have nevertheless also occurred in Geesthacht
Roughly half of them (n = 19; 51.1%) called themselves employees with lived experience
81.1% had several years of experience as users of the mental health care system in the study region
64.8% (n = 24) of all study participants were female
The majority of the participants without lived experience worked in executive positions
To guarantee the anonymity of the participants
a more detailed presentation of the sociodemographic characteristics was omitted in this paper
the results are presented in two parts: Part I explains how participation in the fields of work and activities is ensured in Geesthacht
Part II provides the participants' experiences and evaluations
This division into two parts does not represent the multiple
recursive and circular connections of our analytical codes that made this evaluation very elaborate and interesting
It also reduces the lived complexity in Geesthacht
where different forms of participation are interlaced with each other
citations are marked either by E (employee without lived experience) or ELE (employee with lived experience)
Opportunities for work and activities in Geesthacht are described in this section using both citations and figures
whereas the evaluations of the participants are reserved for part 2
The form of activity or work varies depending on both clinical requirements and the person's needs and capabilities
employees without lived experience are the ones who start looking for activities or work for persons with lived experience:
“It's a bit like placing a volunteer or something like that
Together with the people that are interested
you simply see [what's possible].” (E)
opportunities for activities or work evolve from a definite situation
or people find out from others that it is possible to work in the mental health care system as a (former) service user:
service users sometimes said: ‘Come on
let me continue to help out.’” (ELE)
it has to do with how people progressively recover
[…] how people hear about it somehow by word of mouth…” (E)
there is a networking group that acts as a hub for work placements and organizes various forms of participation:
“[The group on Tuesday] is kind of a group meeting […] if someone says
the first step would be to join us in one of these meetings
now we have to make a contract’ […] at some point you notice if it works out or not
you don't have to report or send an application to participate
but first you have to […] get to know each other a little
Different opportunities for work and activities may exist and alternate for former service users
These opportunities involve different roles and kinds of work that may lead to increasing autonomy in accomplishing tasks and also be financially rewarding
“For example it may have started [with cooking]: ‘Back then
it was good but it's not really my thing anymore
they may go on to do other tasks: ‘I have become pretty stable
[…] I want to be part of the peer advisory group
The transitions between first the use of therapeutic services (in the role of a user/patient)
“This lady […] made coffee in the shelter for many years [as part of outpatient occupational therapy]
she worked as the supervisor for the Saturday occupational therapy sessions
she has been engaged in peer support.” (E)
The conditions of expenditure of the regional psychiatric budget allowed for greater flexibility in terms of use and transiting between these stages of the program
how resources from the regional budget were used to establish an outpatient care service under the supervision of an employee with lived experience:
“There is this nurse manager who was suffering from depression […] who says: ‘I want to do something useful again […]’ ‘and the others said: ‘Okay
we need a new nursing service.’ And she got the financial support to build up a nursing service.” (E)
The gradual opportunities for work and activities are displayed in Figure 1
The opportunities to participate in the fields of work and activities are shown as a gradient in relation to the implementation of work-related participation and the different roles (i.e.
The ABC team makes a flexible change possible between workplaces and tasks
occupational support facilities are regulated by the underlying financial structure in each case
The opportunities for participation and related financial rewards, if available, can only be addressed descriptively due to limited space. A more detailed description can be found in the Supplementary Table 1
a plethora of different activities for employees with lived experience exist that are continuously evolving
Many of these activities do not fall within the definition of peer support and involve areas where experiential expertise is not directly necessary or applied
the total share of employees with lived experience has increased through the availability of these different types of work and activities
The activities that are offered require and encourage different levels of autonomy and self-determination and can therefore be helpful at different stages of the recovery process
through psychiatric nursing or everyday support) or through personal budgets allocated
many of these resources were administered by the relevant institutions and could be managed jointly
making it possible to hire a number of employees with lived experience
The transition from a regional budget to the global treatment budget in 2013 resulted in lesser financial flexibility
The system described in this paper requires a certain way of thinking and acting on behalf of the institutions involved
The following section consists primarily of thoughts and citations from executive staff (all of them without lived experience)
therefore presenting a potentially idealized (and idealistic) image of the Geesthacht model
the initiative to make these changes in Geesthacht was based on genuine values of traditional forms of work therapy
work has a therapeutic benefit and therefore plays an important role in every person's life:
“The idea has always been: everyone wants to be needed
Especially people with no opportunities on the regular job market.” (E)
I get to go out and get to do something useful.” (ELE)
A second principle in Geesthacht is orientation based on the person's needs
All processes are geared to the perspective of what the person explains they need and want
participation is implemented in daily routines allowing for “organic growth,” which leaves sufficient space for spontaneity
“I cannot say that that he is or is not able to do that
the people [employees with lived experience] have to know that for themselves.” (E)
“You must allow room for chance opportunities.” (E)
in many interviews the phrase “let them do it themselves” was articulated
This includes encouraging others and oneself to relinquish control and to rely on autonomy and self-responsibility:
for me that was the beginning of it all […]” (E)
“It is important that you believe in people
And that you do not leave them alone.” (E)
This “let them do it themselves” attitude is common in Gesthaacht
This attitude is important for pragmatic reasons
when some of the services in Geesthacht could not have been run without the support of peers involved
either due to a shortage of employees or because only employees with lived experience have the necessary expertise:
“We had no choice but to ask our patients to support us and take over tasks.” (E)
“This used to be some kind of a self-help ward
There were some employees but sometimes not enough
so service users sometimes had to organize themselves somehow.” (ELE)
we used them purposefully to enter into contact with particular patients when we thought we were not able to reach the person.” (E)
employees with lived experience often take over unpopular jobs like bureaucracy
the jobs that [they] are happy to hand over [to the peers].” (ELE)
“There is no additional pay for working on Saturdays
That means employees are happy when other people can take over this shift
it is give and take and has advantages for everyone.” (ELE)
This section reviews the evaluations and experiences of the persons that used the opportunity to participate in the fields of work and activities
We primarily present citations by operative employees (vs
executive staff reported on in section Philosophy and Mindset above)
Although the experiences and evaluations of both groups coincide to some extent
fundamental discrepancies became apparent as well which merit description
questions related to their role and the changes to their role were central
The following citations illustrate how they felt about the position they have within the team
the forms of knowledge they were expected to have or were able to apply
and the significance of their experience within the teams or the institution:
“What is the position of peers within the team
This all remains part of an ongoing discussion and debatable.” (ELE)
no clear description of the role or expectations of employees with lived experience has been established
no well-defined concept of experiential knowledge or expertise has been formalized:
a clear role description for peer support is lacking.” (E)
what is the unique characteristic of the activities and contributions of people with lived experience
And what is the impact when these practices become institutionalized?” (ELE)
Given the high level of ambivalence and many role changes
the lack of distinct role descriptions was problematic for some of the interviewees:
it was really difficult for me to distinguish - am I the patient now or do I work as part of the staff
[…] It was too much.” (ELE)
“It went so far that my boss was simultaneously my therapist […] we framed this with the famous hat trick: ‘Well
now I'm wearing the hat of the therapist
or of the employee.’” (ELE)
“…being both at the same time
I lived but also worked in this housing project
[…] But that's the way it is in real life - I can feel deathly ill and at the same time I can still help you
if people with lived experience gain power
this naturalness of giving and taking will be restored.” (ELE)
As described in section Forms of Employment and Compensation
flexible and person-centered funding system is lacking in Germany that would allow for participation of service users in the life of the community
The Geesthacht model tries to bridge this gap through creative ways of providing compensation
we are aware of the risk that the Geesthacht model could lead to exploitation of employees with lived experience
They do important work but are paid only partially or not at all for it:
“By now I think that it should be paid […]
you'll get [money] at some point when you are really a part of it’.” (ELE)
a number of employees with lived experience complained that the financial compensation for their work was insufficient
payments varied significantly from person to person
“You have to know that peers are far from being able to make a living [with that activity].” (ELE)
“Everyone at this table receives a different amount or no payment at all for the same amount of work
[…] People have totally different arrangements.” (ELE)
Connected to the issue of a lack of financial compensation
the issue of a lack of respect for their work was brought up by some of the employees with lived experience
Some interviewees mentioned that the contributions of people with lived experience were not taken seriously by the other employees
the lack of appreciation was shown by the insufficient provision of infrastructures necessary:
“We are probably seen as patients who play around a bit and do their own thing without any real value.” (ELE)
That is why I sometimes continue to work at home and write there […] You cannot work properly in this office.” (ELE)
Some interviewees saw a correlation between the lack of respect and institutional hierarchies
others felt a lack of respect on the side of service users:
I do not think that we have a good reputation.” (ELE)
“Because some people look at me as if I were still a patient
the way they talk to me is different than the way they speak with their therapist
for example […] less on the same eye-level.” (ELE)
The opinions of employees with lived experience varied in terms of their perception of the level and quality of collaboration between employees with and without lived experience
Some employees with lived experience described the collaboration as smooth
as they were allowed to make choices by themselves
giving them space to work independently and autonomously:
“Everyone was very much on eye level
I never had the feeling that she was the boss or that she ordered me to do anything.” (ELE)
there are some situations when you are being told to do something […].” (ELE)
Other issues were voiced as well: power struggles
controversies regarding competencies required or responsibilities between employees with and without lived experience were reported
The fear of being replaced or giving up responsibilities was mentioned as a reason for this phenomenon:
Is he allowed to have a key?” (ELE)
“Only 10% of the working hours may be done by peers […]
This shows that the [employees] are simply afraid of losing their jobs
And that could be prevented with new rules.” (ELE)
employees with lived experience repeatedly felt that they were obliged to assert their own perspectives forcefully:
“I often face the problem that when I get a certain impression of a patient and I mention this to the team […]
And then I have to find a way […] to still assert myself.” (ELE)
many employees with lived experience reported that they did benefit from the opportunity to work:
I could not imagine sitting at home all the time.” (ELE)
“My self-image became more positive
And I am not that sad any more about the fact that I'm not employable or cannot be placed on the regular job market.” (ELE)
employees with lived experience felt they were perceived more positively by the other employees than if they had simply remained a patient
This is seen as a helpful development in the process to break down the rigid boundaries between employees without lived experience on the one hand and employees with lived experience on the other hand:
“I am really happy that I am not just perceived in my role as a patient
but also as someone who is engaged as a peer
Now I don't feel like I'm walking around being stigmatized as a patient.” (ELE)
work was experienced as a burden and as demanding:
“You hear a lot about the problems [with peer support]
[…] you will still be confronted with this.” (ELE)
Patients in occupational therapy usually have drug issues
We even asked for help from the ward sometimes
difficulties setting boundaries were mentioned:
“Setting boundaries is a big topic for me because I am very sensitive
I learned to turn my sensitivity into a strength
it is difficult for me to set boundaries.” (ELE)
There is not a systematic network among the employees with lived experience
Some of the interviewees mentioned that the other employees without lived experience did not want this kind of exchange to occur:
“The institutions do not want this
they don't want peers to sit together across the entire institution they are working in
Because they think that this automatically means that the institutions would be discredited.” (ELE)
some networks have been established independently or at a limited scale:
The whole system will collapse.” (ELE)
some employees with lived experience perceive support among themselves as good:
“It is a nice way of being together
Connected to this lack of networking is the criticism that the participation model in Geesthacht has not been planned systematically enough and needs further development
Defined structures with a clear and sufficient place for employees with lived experience have not been established yet:
“That is the biggest mistake we have made
[…] We did not structure the program
there are too many loose ends.” (E)
I do see peers as set parts of the teams who can participate in supervision or in the planning of processes of change just as everyone else can.” (E)
this lack of systematization requires a systematic evaluation of what has (and has not) been achieved:
“That we look at it: what was good
“Organic growth” t in Geesthacht over the last 13 years has led to the development of a care model that enables and promotes the participation of people with lived experience of crises and disabilities in the fields of work and activities
This care model aims at supporting people by fostering an active and autonomous life in their primary care setting right from the start
with the objective of making them less and less dependent on institutional support and in a sustainable way
These goals and principles regard the activities in Geesthacht in the field of work and employment
but also the different forms of assisted housing that have been established over years
combining aid from community services and volunteers with forms of home treatment
thereby enabling support in the services user's own environment and social interaction of people who are isolated
The labor market still holds enormous barriers and access restrictions for people with psychosocial disabilities
the unemployment rate of this group of people is disproportionately high
as are their possibilities for societal participation
allowing for gradual and often peer-based support for people with mental health crises and psychosocial disabilities
this paper focusing on the gradual development of the Geesthacht model over years as a response to the German-specific historical or contemporary health service and political developments
a detailed comparison will be deliberately omitted in favor of a comprehensive discussion of its conditions of development as well as its inherent tensions and ambivalences
The model of participation in Geesthacht was developed through a stepwise process
leading to changes in institutional culture and its characteristics which thus vary depending on the institutions involved and the time
The fact that there was no central management of this process led to many instances of chaos and temporary (or long-lasting) solutions that are both satisfying as an achievement
the chaos involved can also be interpreted as a driving force and a necessary condition to enable a flexible
daily-life and person-centered model of support in Geesthacht
we believe that the model can be seen as a constructive attempt to further de-institutionalize mental health care
with the focus on adapting psychiatric care to the lives of the people in care
instead of subordinating them to a rigid set of institutional rules
The stated aim is to strengthen the autonomy and self-determination of the people who need support when experiencing mental crises and disabilities
which is certainly not always the case in Geesthacht
The development of the Geesthacht model started at a time when the principles enshrined in the CRPD
as well as the various critical approaches to the existing psychiatric care system were neither formulated nor well-known
it inheres conceptual tensions that will be further elaborated upon in the next subchapter of this discussion
The change of paradigmatic embedding of the psychiatric care system over the past 40 years has led to a progressive enrichment of concepts
initially drawing on ideas of the era of de-institutionalization
and gradually turning into more human rights-oriented models over the years
This evolution has resulted into a variety of co-existing work and support models that consequently draw on a wide spectrum of rationales
is of contemporary importance as most people who experience mental crises and disabilities are still employed in sheltered workplaces (rather than supported employment)
continue to live in asylums or residential care homes (instead receiving supported housing)
or remain hospitalized (instead of receiving home treatment)
Fundamental to the changes in Geesthacht were adjustments to the budget allocation system for public hospitals. Care budgets previously based on either the number of days of care or the intensity of care were first supplemented with a regional mental health care budget in 2007, which was then encompassed in a global treatment budget from 2013 to 2019 (9)
Thanks to flexibility allowed in terms of how the global budget was applied
it has been possible to establish a complex network of opportunities for participation and activities for people with lived experience
a certain mindset and certain principles of the people involved were equally important: leaving room for spontaneity and serendipity and for processes to develop
as well as the deep-seated conviction that participation
and activities are important existentially to all people
are only a few examples of an overall strongly ideological and value-based approach in Geesthacht
the project would not have evolved in this way
some of the benefits of the Geesthacht model of participation can be explained by the variety of tensions
we found ourselves in varying emotional states that were subject to rapid change on several occasions
and sometimes discontent occurred in rapid succession
the divergence of perspectives of the different actors interviewed became apparent
While the statements made by those who were operational employees (with and without lived experience) were mainly related to their work tasks and the project which they evaluated critically
the executive staff (all without lived experience) tended to focus on the values and principles of this project
This difference represents one part of the enormous complexity and the contradictions that are characteristic of the Geesthacht model
Geesthacht is characterized by a high willingness to take risks
to dare to try new things and to see that they are done
Employees with lived experience are trusted and given space to find their own way and shape their own lives
Instead of pre-planning or over-regulating participation and involvement in detail
opportunities for activities and work can grow organically between the parties involved
from concrete situations as well as from relationships that have grown over time
this approach has led to a lack of clear structures and responsibilities to date
Responsibilities often remain vague and there are no fixed formats for networking or supervision
leaving employees with lived experience sometimes alone with the question whom to approach
Another area of conflict concerns the lack of a clear separation between therapy and work
It is possible for the service users in Geesthacht to participate early on during their hospital care by taking over tasks
The same or other activities may be continued after discharge and at times
Many problematic situations are possible along the way
it remains a fact that for some of the employees with lived experience
no other avenue of participation or work would have been possible
the employees with lived experience are involved as much as possible during these transitions between therapy and work: in each case they make decisions themselves or at least say they are ready to go along with them
A third example of the many forms of ambivalence felt toward the Geesthacht model is the way in which the different roles change into another
which can be very challenging for all participants
The citation above from one of the employees with lived experience who continued her paid employment even at a time when she was experiencing a crisis illustrates these tensions
often it is impossible for persons to differentiate between their identity of service user and employee
a fact that involves both opportunities and risks
We were surprised that only a few persons interviewed evaluated these tensions negatively
suggesting that the demarcation between (“ill”) patients and (“healthy”) employees—a demarcation common in mental health care—played a minor role in Geesthacht
the question is whether more regulation in Geesthacht would have led to a better model
Clear rules and structures always involve the risk of establishing rigid roles and opportunities
and open character of the Geesthacht model of participation was possible primarily because local structures and processes evolved in their own ways
with the responsibility to manage the various projects being left up to the participants themselves
Due to a variety of regulations and laws that have been implemented in recent years in Germany
such an approach has become less feasible in the inpatient sector
in spite of the fact that it has positive effects as demonstrated
which is possible in Geesthacht right from the beginning of treatment
tolerating risks and the willingness to take responsibility are substantial parts of the relationship and finding new methods with unknown outcomes is explicitly permitted
The application of “mental health care as an on-going project” entails risks as well
If people are not able to communicate their needs
if power relations and dependencies are not dealt with transparently
then those people who already have little influence in the care system may be the ones who continue to suffer
There is significant room for improvement regarding these issues remaining in Geesthacht as well
To what extent the openness and vibrancy of the project could be lost when dealing with these issues remains to be seen
As described, the Geesthacht model also works well because many of the roles and opportunities for participation are not well-defined or clearly established. Therefore, it remains uncertain to what extent the employees with lived experience are actually working in accordance with the principles and methods of peer support (42)
some of these employees have received prior
no conclusions could be drawn from the interviews
despite the fact that the issue was addressed frequently
the danger of employees with lived experience being instrumentalized and asked to “toe the line,” but on the other hand
this loose framework also constitutes part of the spirit behind the project
Whether this ambiguity also represents added value in developing the field of peer support could be the subject of further research
the scope of this contribution allows us to cover in detail only those opportunities to participate in the fields of work and activities in Geesthacht
We have not reported here the significant results that we believe have also been achieved in the areas of participation in housing and treatment
In relation to the earlier question of whether the model described meets the standards of the CRPD
we will therefore only consider this area of participation in the areas of work and activity
it depends on the individual case to what extent equal rights are applied in Geesthacht and how power imbalances play a role
accessibility of the various options for participation
and to what extent work is compensated appropriately
Maybe it is precisely here that there is a clear need to catch up if the concepts of the CRPD are to be applied across the board
Geesthacht is a place where the boundaries between employees and service users are drawn less strictly
relationships have been built up for years that transcend the traditional therapist and patient roles
which in many places continue to exist strongly and are very separate from one another
a common sense of belonging in work and life
and not only of analytical value and should serve as a model for the implementation of projects elsewhere
In terms of compliance with the principles of the CRPD
the situation of (former) service users in Geesthacht regarding participation in work has improved considerably
This model has allowed them to become a substantial part of an activity-related and social network and
the model in Geesthacht reveals the existing barriers to implementation of equal opportunities
even in the presence of strong motivation and the intense commitment of all participants
Many things remain to be done that must be initiated and managed structurally
The datasets underlying the current study are not publicly available due to the used data protection declaration and the nature of qualitative interviews where individual participants could be possibly identified. Parts of the dataset are available from the research group on reasonable request. Requests to access the datasets should be directed at Sebastian von Peter, c2ViYXN0aWFuLnZvbnBldGVyQG1oYi1mb250YW5lLmRl
The studies involving human participants were reviewed and approved by Ethics Commission of Medical School Brandenburg Theodor Fontane; Institutional Ethics Committee of the Carl Gustav Carus University Dresden
The patients/participants provided their written informed consent to participate in this study
SP and JS drafted the first version of the manuscript. SP was responsible for the background, result, and discussion section. JS drafted material and methods and developed tables, figures, and Supplementary Material
All authors were involved in preparing and conducting the present part of the PsychCare study
critically reviewed and commented on the manuscript
and read and approved the final version of the manuscript
This study was funded by the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) Innovation Fund in Germany (grant reference no
The funder had no role in the design of the study and is not involved in its execution
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest
The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyt.2021.634080/full#supplementary-material
1. Beeker T
Conducting a process evaluation coproduced by people with lived experience of mental distress – a metareflection and methodological concept
2. Additional income is a capped amount that a person receiving a disability pension is allowed to receive for short-term or marginal employment
3. A mini-job is a marginal job with a maximum income of 450 Euros per month or short-term employment for a few weeks or months
1. United Nations. Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. (2016). Available online at: https://www.un.org/disabilities/documents/convention/convention_accessible_pdf.pdf (accessed April 11
Google Scholar
Recovery in Mental Health: Reshaping Scientific and Clinical Responsibilities
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
3. Bundestag D. Gesetz zur Stärkung der Teilhabe und Selbstbestimmung von Menschen mit Behinderungen. (2016). Available online at: http://www.bmas.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/PDF-Meldungen/2016/bundesteilhabegesetz.pdf (accessed February 6
“Ich sehe es tatsächlich als Zwischenschritt” – eine qualitative Analyse der Implementierungsbedingungen und -hürden von Stationsäquivalenter Behandlung in Berlin und Brandenburg
Multiperspective and multimethod evaluation of flexible and integrative psychiatric care models in Germany: study protocol of a prospective controlled multicenter observational study (PsychCare)
Participants' employment status and experiences in the year after the Experienced Involvement training
7. BMJV. §64b SGB V - Modellvorhaben zur Versorgung psychisch kranker Menschen. (2012). Available online at: https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_5/__64b.html (accessed September 9
8. European Commission. Mental health care – psychiatric hospital beds. (2019). Available online at: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/de/web/products-eurostat-news/-/EDN-20191009-1 (accessed April 11
Changes in German Mental Health Care by implementing a global treatment budget—a mixed-method process evaluation study
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Kompetenzen und Rollen(-erwartungen) von Genesungsbegleitern in der psychiatrischen Versorgung – Ein partizipativer Forschungsbericht
Genesungsbegleitung und stationsäquivalente Behandlung
Specific components for integrative and flexible care models according to § 64b SGB V
Evaluation of new flexible and integrative psychiatric treatment models in Germany- assessment and preliminary validation of specific program components
Participatory and collaborative strategies in psychiatric research
PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Needs and Experiences in Psychiatric Treatment (NEPT) – a user generated measure to evaluate cross-sectoral mental health services
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods
Google Scholar
Peer interviewers in mental health services research
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
20. Mayring P. Qualitative content analysis: theoretical foundation, basic procedures and software solution. Klagenfurt: SSOAR Open Access Repository (2014). p. 143S. Avaialble online at: http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:0168-ssoar-395173 (accessed April 11
Recovery as an occupational journey: a scoping review exploring the links between occupational engagement and recovery for people with enduring mental health issues
An occupational perspective of the recovery journey in mental health
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
The social nature of recovery: discussion and implications for practice
Participation in work: a source of wellness for people with psychiatric disability
PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Associations between occupational and social interaction factors and well-being among people with psychiatric disabilities living in supported housing in Sweden
“Being normal” and self-identity: the experience of volunteering in individuals with severe mental disorders—a qualitative study
Exploring narrative meaning making through everyday activities
Google Scholar
Meaningful Activities and Recovery (MA&R): the effect of a novel rehabilitation intervention among persons with psychiatric disabilities on activity engagement—study protocol for a randomized controlled trial
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Unemployment impairs mental health: meta-analyses
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Poor mental health influences risk and duration of unemployment: a prospective study
Unemployment and mental health scarring during the life course
How can the mentally ill achieve sustained employment
Supported employment versus pre-vocational training
Effects of local unemployment rate on vocational outcomes in a randomized trial of supported employment for individuals with psychiatric disabilities
Google Scholar
Vocational rehabilitation for subjects with severe mental illnesses in Germany
Psychosomatic inpatient rehabilitation: the German model
PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Programme characteristics and everyday occupations in day centres and clubhouses in Sweden
The effectiveness of supported employment for people with severe mental illness: a randomised controlled trial
Social firms as a means of vocational recovery for people with mental illness: a UK survey
PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text
How do social firms contribute to recovery from mental illness
42. Penny D. Defining “Peer Support”: Implications for Policy, Practice, and Research. (2018). Available online at: https://www.ahpnet.com/AHPNet/media/AHPNetMediaLibrary/White%20Papers/DPenney_Defining_peer_support_2018_Final.pdf (accessed April 11
Google Scholar
Habicht J and Schwarz J (2021) Supported Employment
Participatory Case Study Report of the Geesthacht Model
Received: 26 November 2020; Accepted: 23 March 2021; Published: 23 April 2021
Copyright © 2021 von Peter, Göppert, Ziegenhagen, Beeker, Glück, Groth, Groß, Reinholdt, Boerma, Heißler, Habicht and Schwarz. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY)
distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted
provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited
in accordance with accepted academic practice
distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms
*Correspondence: Sebastian von Peter, c2ViYXN0aWFuLnZvbnBldGVyQG1oYi1mb250YW5lLmRl
Disclaimer: All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations
Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher
94% of researchers rate our articles as excellent or goodLearn more about the work of our research integrity team to safeguard the quality of each article we publish
The news: Pathology services provider Sonic Healthcare has signed binding agreements to acquire Germany’s Laboratory Group Dr
Kramer & Colleagues (LADR) for an enterprise value of €423 million ($698.6 million)
The numbers: Sonic said it would issue shares in the company to the sellers worth a maximum of €222 million
which would be funded from Sonic’s existing cash and debt facilities
The transaction is expected to be immediately earnings per share (EPS) accretive
reaching high single-digit percentage accretion after three years
Sonic said the return on invested capital (ROIC) will significantly exceed its cost of capital once synergies are achieved
The context: Sonic said there is strong cultural and operational alignment between its German business and LADR
with significant synergy potential in multiple areas of operations
LADR is one of the top five medical laboratory groups in Germany with more than 2,800 full-time equivalent staff
with its central laboratory located in Geesthacht
providing high-quality testing services delivered through a network of stand-alone and hospital-based laboratories throughout Germany
LADR also has a presence in Poland and a small joint-venture interest in Finland
The Polish laboratory is majority owned by LADR and operates under the brand ‘badaj.to’
and is believed to be the fourth largest laboratory group in Poland with annual revenue of €30 million
Sonic will also get a 15% interest in a separate German medical laboratory business
Sonic will inherit a put/call structure for the remaining 85% of equity in this group
with expected cash outflow for this transaction to be €55 million by calendar year 2027
The source: ASX announcement
is to build a new silicones plant at its Geesthacht site in Northern Germany
multi-purpose silicones manufacturing facility (expected to be operational by the end of 2019) will be a “double-digit million-euro” investment for the company
though it declined to give an exact figure at this stage
The facility will provide additional capacity for Evonik’s range of silicones and silane-terminated polymers
which the company sells under the brand names Polymer VS and Polymer ST
head of the interface and performance business line at Evonik
said: "The planned investment at the Geesthacht site has an important strategic significance by helping us to further strengthen our focus on innovative specialty chemical products"
In addition to the silicones build the company is building a facility for filling tank trucks at the Geesthacht location
head of the polymer and construction specialties product line: “this will simplify the delivery and storage process for our customers and in doing so increases efficiency
“The additional production capacity will also create room for us to develop new products…and to react to future demands in the adhesives and sealants market.”
The Geesthacht site will focus on silicones and nanotechnology
Addition- and condensation-curing silicones
along with silane-terminated polymers are used as binders in adhesives and sealants and have applications in electronics and medicine
Silica-based nanomaterials also have a range of applications
including use as property-enhancing additives in fibre composites in the automotive and aerospace industry
Evonik acquired the Geesthacht site when it bought Hanse Chemie in 2011
which became fully integrated into the Evonik Group in 2016
The upgrades to the facilities and capabilities of the site represent the next phase of Evonik’s investment
Article by Amanda Jasi
Covestro to build world-scale MDI plant
Johnson Matthey set targets to lower waste and improve safety on journey to net zero
UK sets up centre to advise on critical minerals, amid warnings of supply risks
US aims to create semiconductor manufacturing clusters by 2030
Singapore "model factory" to help SMEs
Process Engineer - Safety Specialist
Process Engineering Lead
Process Engineer - Upstream
Process Engineer - Lower Carbon
A conversation with the experts: watch the recordings of our previous webinars and sign-up to attend future online webcasts
You do not have to be a chemical engineer to join IChemE
Our global membership community includes people from a range of disciplines who have an interest in and/or relevant experience in chemical engineering
View a wider selection of the archive from within the Magazine section of this site
We offer readers a flexible range of subscription options and you are certain to find one that suits your needs
Process Engineer - Safety Specialist
view job
Process Engineering Lead
view job
Process Engineer - Upstream
view job
Process Engineer - Lower Carbon
view job
Quality Engineer
view job
Process Control and Simulation Lead
view job
Process Controls Engineer
view job
Process Controls Engineer - Alarm Management
view job
© 2025 Institution of Chemical Engineers
Site by Technical Labs
Create your free account to receive personalised content alerts and Re:action
our weekly newsletter of the top chemical science stories handpicked from a range of magazines
journals and websites alongside insight and analysis from our expert editorial team
Tell us what you think. Take part in our reader survey
By Lucy Balshaw2021-03-01T14:27:00+00:00
Scientists in Germany have created an alloy with an exceptionally low corrosion rate – lower
than ultra high-purity magnesium – that they say approaches stainless magnesium
by alloying pure magnesium with tiny amounts of calcium
abundance in the Earth’s crust and excellent electrochemical properties
biomedical and energy-storage applications
magnesium’s weight makes it attractive from a sustainable perspective – it is significantly lighter than aluminium
so replacing aluminium with stainless magnesium in cars and aeroplanes could reduce fuel consumption and carbon dioxide emissions
using magnesium on an industrial scale is limited because it corrodes in aqueous environments
Source: © Daniel Höche/Helmholtz-Zentrum Geesthacht
The team tested their new alloy alongside two commercial alloys by immersing them in 3.5wt% NaCl solution for 6 months
‘Our magnesium–calcium alloys were prepared by conventional casting processes,’ explains Min Deng from the Helmholtz Centre for Materials and Coastal Research in Geesthacht
‘Pure magnesium and pure calcium were melted at high temperatures in a steel crucible
the new alloy retains the properties of pure magnesium
it can resist corrosion because the calcium reduces the cathodic water reduction kinetics
allows the development of a protective surface film and stabilises impurities (such as iron and silicon) within the alloy
the processing route for [our] magnesium–calcium alloy with [its] superior performance is quite simple
The alloy could have ‘biomedical applications, such as scaffolds and implants, because it seems to reduce significantly the formation of hydrogen bubbles, [which are] common in existing magnesium implant materials, [and] the formed corrosion products are not expected to be toxic,’ comments Polina Volovitch
who studies corrosion at Chimie ParisTech in France
‘Application in aqueous batteries could also be [possible].’
‘Practical applications of stainless magnesium are many and varied. Certainly portable electronics come to mind, but as a wonder material, the world is magnesium’s oyster,’ adds Nick Birbilis
who specialises in material sustainability and corrosion science at the Australian National University
so let’s see what magnesium will bring us.’
This article is free to access until 12 April 2021
M Deng et al, Mater. Horiz., 2021, 8, 589 (DOI: 10.1039/d0mh01380c)
Site powered by Webvision Cloud
Scientists of the Geesthacht GKSS Research Centre have developed a radar system with which it is possible to study the behaviour of sea waves
This technology will be used immediately on the North Sea on the FINO3 research platform in order to determine the interactions between offshore wind power machines and swells
The location of the FINO3 research platforms
is located approximately 80 kilometres to the west of Sylt where up to 80 wind power plants will be located in just a few years
FINO3 is used by researchers to estimate the environmental consequences and technical risks of offshore wind energy parks
Changes in the sea swell are also of great interest in addition to the observations of bird migration or the measurement of lightening frequencies on the sea
To determine how much of an effect large waves and what is known as 'breakers' have on wind power plants and to what extent the structures can change the surrounding swell
the coastal researchers of the Geesthacht GKSS Research Centre installed a Doppler radar approximately 50 metres above sea level on the FINO3 lattice mast
we can even track the individual waves for the first time"
GKSS Department Manager of Radar Hydrology
Ziemer and his team have studied the swell and the behaviour of large breakers
The information is transmitted by FINO3 to Geesthacht via satellite
The frequency of large breakers and the force which creates the steep giant waves are of particular interest not only to researchers but also the designers and operators of offshore wind power plants or oil platforms
Each individual wind rotor creates turbulent air flows in its "tow" and periodical movements
which can have an effect on other structures
This can result in undesired or even dangerous vibrations
If there is an interaction between the waves and the individual wind power plants
This means in a wave field which is harmless without a windmill park
very high waves can be created by these interferences which could possibly have a critical effect on these plants
"I am sure that we will soon be able to better assess the swells and the force of the breakers," says Friedwart Ziemer
This means that the breaker behaviour could be taken into account better in planning and the stability of the systems can be more predictable
Solid position on the COSYNA North Sea monitoring system
The FINO3 research platform will be an important component in the new COSYNA measurement network initiated by GKSS
A comprehensive monitoring system will be created in the German North Sea area to record
predict and provide scientific analysis of the current state and development of the coastal waters with the major COSYNA project (Coastal Observation System for Northern and Arctic Seas)
FINO3 will provide the Geesthacht coast researchers information on seafaring and the wind
The Doppler radar technology was developed by the GKSS employees in unison with the Technical University of Saint Petersburg
The initial test readings with the new wave radar from the shore have already been carried out successfully
are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert
by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system
Copyright © 2025 by the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS)
There is a potential for solar power of up to five megawatts in total at Vattenfall’s pumped storage plants in Germany
and the first project has now been launched at the pumped storage plant in Geesthacht near Hamburg
Aerial photo of Geesthacht pumped storage plant with solar plant to the left of the water pipes
Vattenfall is further expanding its solar electricity generation and is currently checking the extent to which areas at the company's German pumped storage plants are suitable
Vattenfall experts are currently determining the potential for around five megawatts of new solar power generation in total
This includes free space at the pumped storage dams
photovoltaic systems on the roofs of operating buildings as well as free space on previously unused areas
The pv@hydro project has started at the Geesthacht pumped storage plant on the Elbe in Schleswig-Holstein
The existing solar modules have been replaced with new
higher-performance modules as part of a repowering scheme and on top of that the plan is to install further photovoltaic modules with an output of close to 2 MW at the upper reservoir dam in Geesthacht
Additional photovoltaic systems may later be added to the pumped storage plants in Wendefurth (Saxony-Anhalt)
Hohenwarte (Thuringia) and Markersbach (Saxony).Peter Apel
CEO of Vattenfall Wasserkraft GmbH: "Vattenfall aims to be fossil free within one generation
That's why it makes sense for us as a company to further promote the expansion of renewable energies
particularly in regions where we have already been a firm part of the local energy infrastructure for decades through our pumped storage plants."
the solar energy is thus not used to operate the pumps at the pumped storage plant but fed into the grid through the pumped storage plant’s existing grid connection
Head of the Solar & Batteries unit at Vattenfall
adds: "We find very good conditions for the construction of photovoltaic systems at the pumped storage plants
The use of the existing technologies leads to synergies that can also benefit the profitability of such projects
PV@hydro is an excellent example of how the existing and new energy worlds can be combined within the scope of the energy transition in Germany."
Vattenfall has further solar projects in the pipeline or already underway
the company is building around 30 MW of new photovoltaic facilities in 2018
Vattenfall plans to invest some €100 million in expanding solar energy in 2018 and 2019
excess electricity generated in the electricity system can be used to pump large amounts of water from a lower reservoir to an upper reservoir where it is stored as potential energy
When additional electricity is needed in the system
water can be released from the upper reservoir through the huge water pipes that also brought it up to the upper reservoir and used to propel the turbines installed at the lower reservoir
In contrast to hydro power plants located in rivers there is no natural inflow to the upper reservoirs of pumped storage plants
The capacity of the wind power plants and solar plant installed in Germany is continuously increasing
Thanks to the further expansion of the renewable energy sources
there will be an increasing need for storage capacity as well as the short-term availability of balancing energy to stabilise transmission networks in future
Hydro in Germany operates eight pumped storage power plants
Vattenfall’s market share in total installed pumped storage plant capacity in Germany is roughly 40 % (3,000 MW of 7,000 MW in total)
Vattenfall’s power plants
Cement currently accounts for 8 per cent of the world's carbon dioxide emissions – but if you look at the research and the progress in the industry
Researcher Josie Harrison is developing an AI-model to facilitate the reuse of already extracted materials
As the operating life of existing Swedish nuclear reactors is being extended to 80 years
the availability of spare parts will be crucial
Contact us
LinkedIn
YouTube
Instagram
Facebook
Vattenfall is a European energy company with approximately 21,000 employees
For more than 100 years we have electrified industries
supplied energy to people's homes and modernised our way of living through innovation and cooperation
More about Vattenfall
Das Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon in Geesthacht betreibt internationale Spitzenforschung für eine Welt im Wandel: Rund 1.000 Beschäftigte erschaffen Wissen und Innovationen für mehr Resilienz und Nachhaltigkeit – zum Wohle von Klima
Das wissenschaftliche Spektrum des Hereons umfasst Hochleistungswerkstoffe
Verfahren und umweltschonende Technologien für die Mobilität und neue Energiesysteme
Darüber hinaus werden Biomaterialien für die Medizin und zur Steigerung der Lebensqualität erforscht
Mithilfe von Forschung und Beratung begegnet das Hereon den Herausforderungen des Klimawandels lösungsorientiert und ermöglicht über ein umfassendes wissenschaftliches Verständnis ein nachhaltiges Management und den Schutz der Küsten- und Meeresumwelt
Der Weg von der Idee zur Innovation führt über Experimentalstudien, Modellierungen und künstliche Intelligenz bis hin zum Digitalen Zwilling
Damit wird interdisziplinär der Bogen vom grundlegenden wissenschaftlichen Verständnis komplexer Systeme hin zu Szenarien und praxisnahen Anwendungen geschlagen
In Schleswig-Holstein ist das 1956 gegründete Zentrum die größte außeruniversitäre Forschungseinrichtung
Neben dem Hauptsitz in Geesthacht und dem Campus Teltow bei Berlin hat das Hereon Außenstellen in Hamburg
Prozent beträgt der Frauenanteil bei Hereon
Die Küstengebiete im globalen Wandel
Küstenschutz an Nord- und Ostsee bei Meeresspiegelanstieg
Künstliche Muskeln für Roboter
Die Entwicklung von Biomaterialien für die Regeneration des Körpers
Küsten als Lebens- und Wirtschaftsraum bewahren
Leichtere Autos und Flugzeuge bauen, um das Klima zu schonen
Ein weltweit einzigartiges Forschungsschiff bauen
Mit KI neuartige, ressourcenschonende Materialien schneidern
Die Stadt der Zukunft auf das Klima der Zukunft vorbereiten
Das Welt-Klimawissen in regionale Modelle übertragen
Die Entwicklung einer ultrastarken Bio-Faser als Ersatz für Kunststoffe
Die Konstruktionspläne der Natur verwenden
ein Ziel: Wasserstoffexperte Thomas Klassen und der Batteriewissenschaftler Martin Winter im Gespräch über die Autos der Zukunft
die Chancen der Antriebstechnologien – und die größten…
Max-Planck-Straße 1 21502 Geesthacht