About us | Advertise with us | Contact us Posted: 9 December 2015 | Stephan Schwarzinger, Felix Brauer and Paul Rösch, Research Center for Bio-Macromolecules, University Bayreuth, ALNuMed GmbH / Bernd Kämpf, FoodQS GmbH, Markt Erlbach | 2 comments Honey – for thousands of years it has been the only source of sweet taste and it still is the prototype of an all-natural In particular with the growing trends for organic food and a healthy life-style honey has enjoyed steadily increasing popularity The reasons for this are complex and interwoven and have their origin in bee diseases climate change as well as agro-industrial production methods an increasing number of honeys mixed with non-natural sweet syrups has been detected in the international trade Such economically motivated adulteration is seen also in other foods such as fruit juice and it is most reliably exposed by NMR-profiling This technology is based on the comparison of hundreds of spectral features of authentic honeys with the sample to be tested… Owed to its special role as sweet food in the development of mankind honey today enjoys special protection by the law1 serious issues in honey production complement the rise in the demand for honey including the Varroa mite putting stress on bee colonies by transferring other bee pathogens and the intensification of agricultural production with an escalating use of fertilizers have led to a phenomenon called colony collapse disorder (CCD) CCD resulted in losses of more than 80% of the hives in certain cases in the past years2 the changing climate impacts honey production when long periods of rain in the flowering season resulted in a complete loss of production in some European countries Economically motivated adulteration on the rise Production shortages lead to price increases which in turn give rise to a growing number of adulterated honeys in the market In the particular case of honey the authentic product is diluted with various sugar syrups which are produced at industrial scales from or wheat at a fraction of the price of honey or products with the pollen being removed are strictly forbidden in the European market but are accepted elsewhere and thus participate in global trade Economically motivated adulteration not only includes mixing of honey with cheap syrups but extends to disguising the geographic origin of a particular honey Honey laundry became public recently in the ‘Honeygate’ scandal in the USA where honey from China was wrongly declared on a large scale to obfuscate its country of origin Lost excise duties were rumoured to be as high as USD 180 million3 To further obscure the product’s geographical origin – typically tested by analysing the pollen spectrum – pollen is now increasingly being filtered out of the honey which – on the other hand – is simple to verify Counterfeiting honey with plant-derived sugar syrups honey consisting mainly of the two mono-saccharides glucose and fructose is adulterated with its main constituents exhibit a different ratio of the stable isotopes of carbon which can be proven by stable isotope ratio mass spectrometry (IRMS) a method routinely used in honey analysis4 and other C3-plants cannot be detected by the same method typically a combination of several analytical methods is applied today that includes IRMS enzymes used in industrial syrup production as well as small molecule markers for foreign syrups dedicated substances can be used to test for authenticity requiring a set of different analytical techniques All this takes a lot of time and is costly; more complex issues such as those involving a food’s provenance cannot be answered at all by only quantifying a limited set of substances authenticity and unveil adulteration in just one measurement Remedy is provided by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy a technique that is also applied in medical imaging (MRT) which typically focus on the detection of specific pre-selected markers (‘targeted analysis’) an entire spectrum of the ingredients of the sample is recorded high-resolution NMR spectroscopy permits the ‘non-targeted’ detection and – at the same time – quantification of typically several dozens of substances within a single measurement the method is predestined for the efficient analysis of complex substance mixtures as found in food: unlike methods using no time-consuming separation of the components in a mixture is required the sample can also be measured without extensive chemical preparation (e.g due to its unique dynamic range the reproducible retrieval of signals arising from substances at very low concentrations (ppm range) in the presence of highly concentrated compounds (% range) is possible Since the plants are genetically identical the same ingredients are to be expected in both cases in the form of the plants’ metabolic products (metabolites) Yet variations in climate and soil quality will lead to relative differences in concentration the systematic differences in concentration of a range of metabolites can be aggregated into a pattern which can be used as a marker for geographical origin or the absence of unlawful adulterations the NMR-spectrum of an unknown sample can be compared with spectra from authentic reference samples by automatic methods These mathematical procedures can then be used to classify new and unknown samples by comparison with the reference database The procedure is already routinely used in the FoodScreenerTM (Bruker BioSpin Germany) for fruit juice (SGF-ProfilingTM) and wine (Wine-ProfilingTM) where a significant number of quantitative quality parameters required by regulatory bodies are obtained5 and processing can be recorded in full automation during a measurement time of just 15 minutes Also in the case of honey NMR spectroscopy offers a versatile multi-parameter screening tool to test for quality and adulteration with minimal time effort and cost Precondition for such analysis is the establishment of a sufficiently large reference spectra database of material with proven authenticity A consortium of several analytical laboratories specialised in honey analytics and the NMR-based instrument maker and solution provider Bruker BioSpin worked together to develop this database as major part of the new the Honey-ProfilingTM which works on the base of the well established FoodScreenerTM platform Conventional analytics had been used to support conformity of data base entries methods included mellisopalynology (pollen analysis) to verify botanical variety and geographical origin classical quality parameters such as glucose as well as the classical methods for detection of adulteration as above A total of up to 18 different parameters were determined for each authentic sample To ensure creation of a sufficiently large database covering many floral varieties as well as worldwide origins the Honey-Profiling consortium had to undertake an unparalleled collaborative effort in the honey business to establish statistical models for discriminating adulterated from authentic samples a suitably large number of adulterated samples is required a large number of samples were mixed with syrups and bee-feed at defined levels the Honey-ProfilingTM Consortium has measured several thousand honeys including comprehensive supplementary conventional analysis This way a previously unmatched coverage of the natural variation of ingredients of authentic honey can be defined which is indispensable to define the ingredient profile of authentic honey The acquired knowledge builds the foundation for establishing a positive definition of how authentic honey should look like Any deviation from the patterns found in the database that does not match any variety or geographical origin might be an indication for an adulteration Inclusion of samples from different years of vintage secures that the statistical models generated are generally applicable The large scatter in geographic origins further ensures that a large variety of poly-floral patterns are represented in the database even annual changes in floral composition in a honey are covered which may be due to climate change or changes in agro-culture are surveyed by annual updates of the database by the members of the Honey-ProfilingTM consortium at the same time leading to an increase of coverage by the database For Honey-ProfilingTM a remote data analysis concept was established located and maintained by Bruker BioSpin where the NMR spectrum of the samples is recorded at the user’s site and remotely evaluated has proven to be successful already in the case of fruit juice and wine testing: To ensure comparable and robust analytical results both the modules for statistical testing as well as for targeted direct quantification of substances are also carried out as server-based services by Bruker BioSpin which results in a straightforward interpretation of the data for the user also allows fast implementation of new statistical models and targeted parameters as these become available These central modules for quantification as well as the untargeted statistical testing for origin and adulteration were accredited as apart of the Bruker BioSpin laboratory’s flexible accreditation early in 2015 according to the ISO 17025 standard for fruit juices and also honey and are available to FoodScreenerTM platform users For comparison of NMR spectra generated by third-party laboratories reproducibility of the spectra is of utmost importance as well as ease of operation Honey is dissolved and samples were mixed with Bruker BioSpin Wine-Profiling buffer and the pH was precisely adjusted utilizing an automated Bruker pH titration unit NMR spectra are obtained by a standardized FoodScreenerTM platform from Bruker BioSpin The system is operated in a push-button mode and automatically takes over all necessary steps for obtaining reproducible high-quality spectra The system is under full control of a LIMS system which controls operation of the NMR spectrometer and communicates with the server at Bruker BioSpin It is of pivotal importance to judge a honey by several criteria simultaneously which Honey-ProfilingTM provides from a single measurement and in an automatically generated report interpretable by the food specialist This shall be demonstrated in three examples we demonstrate the power of Honey-ProfilingTM to verify a given country of origin This is of growing importance as the country of origin is increasingly used in marketing and declared on the honey jar label In many countries – if declared on the label – the honey must exclusively originate from this named country when a non-EU honey is used in a blend this honey must not be labelled as originating from EU countries Figure 1 (page 00) depicts an excerpt of the report for a honey where the supplier has claimed Bulgaria as country of origin first testing for the region of origin (here Europe) the honey’s NMR profile is compared with authentic samples from the claimed country of origin It can clearly be seen in the traffic-light summary of the report (Figure 1A) that the country of origin claimed does not match the reference database the country of origin is not Bulgaria (Figure 1C) Experience shows that falsely declared origin often is accompanied by additional manipulations Honey-ProfilingTM also allows testing for the variety without the need of pollen analysis a blossom honey labelled as honeydew can easily be detected (Figure 2 Not only statistical classification immediately identifies the fraud (Figure 2B) Honey-ProfilingTM also provides numerous quantitative parameters strengthening the overall analysis The comparison with the distribution of a parameter being looked at in comparison with the reference database has proven particularly useful It can clearly be seen that concentrations for glucose and the sum of glucose and fructose are too high in comparison with all other honeydew honeys while turanose concentration is too low when compared to the reference distribution for honeydew honey (Figure 2C) At present Honey-ProfilingTM can classify honeydew and poly-floral honey as well as mono-floral varieties which due to its anti-bacterial activity reached high prices in the market specific marker compounds correlating with the value of this honey (MGO phenyllactic acid) are determined allowing rapid analysis of this expensive honey Testing for adulteration can also be done without this information as shown in Figure 3 The poly-floral honey tested was supplied without further information about its possible origin the traffic-light summary of the Honey-ProfilingTM report immediately signals a possible addition of syrup By systematic comparison of the ratio of a large number of NMR signals in authentic and proven adulterated honeys a set of indices was derived that indicates adulteration a corresponding remark is made in the report which are absent in all authentic honeys (or vice versa) are detected in the course of univariate analysis the corresponding region in the spectrum is reported (Figure 3B) In most cases of addition of syrup clear indications can be found in the spectra such as the presence of elevated concentrations of oligo-saccharides or maltose or maltotriose (Figure 3C) the deviation depicted in Figure 3C originates from the addition of rice syrup using a highly automated NMR approach in combination with a carefully assembled centralised database of authentic as well as known adulterated samples it is possible by means of ISO 17025 accredited untargeted methods to establish quantitative molecular fingerprints characteristic for natural honeys from different varieties and different origins An important advantage of this approach is the fact that even yet unknown adulterations can be detected by untargeted uni- or multivariate tests as NMR is quantitative for all signals detected above a threshold intensity it also permits a targeted approach with a multitude of parameters simultaneously Since NMR covers the analytical statements of several methods conventionally used in quality and authenticity testing of honey it can contribute to saving time and costs as well as producing so far unavailable information on authenticity and adulteration Bremen) for many insightful discussions and Britta Zimmermann (ALNuMed) for expert technical help Council Directive 2001/110/EC of 20 December 2001 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Varroa_destructor (2010) The German bee monitoring project: a long term study to understand periodically high winter losses of honey bee colonies (2012) Effects of neonicotinoid dust from maize seed-dressing on honey bees http://www.foodsafetynews.com/2013/02/honeygate-sting-leads-to-charges-for-ille-gal-chinese-honey-importation/#.U-H6lVY4ywc (2008) Improved detection of honey adulteration by measuring differences between 13C/12C stable carbon isotope ratios of protein and sugar compounds with a combination of elemental analyzer — isotope ratio mass spectrometry and liquid chromatography — isotope ratio mass spectrometry (δ13C-EA/LC-IRMS) (2009) NMR-based multi parametric quality control of fruit juices: SGF profiling (2013) Targeted and nontargeted wine analysis by (1)h NMR spectroscopy combined with multivariate statistical analysis Differentiation of important parameters: grape variety  Stephan Schwarzinger studied technical chemistry in combination with business administration at the University of Linz This was followed by a period of post-doc work at The Scripps Research Institute before joining the Department of Biopolymers at the University of Bayreuth in 2000 where he completed his habilitation in 2006 in biophysical chemistry he served as interim head of the Department of Biochemistry at the University of Bayreuth A member of the BIOmac research centre since 2010 he has been adjunct professor there since 2013 His research interests include NMR methods for the characterisation of flexible proteins and the application of combined analysis methods Bernd Kämpf studied food chemistry at the FH Isny Since 1999 he is head of the laboratory and head of quality assurance at Breitsamer and Ulrich 2014 he was appointed executive manager at FoodQS His interests lie in the field of honey analytics Felix Brauer completed his graduate studies in biochemistry and a master’s in biochemistry and molecular biochemistry at the University of Bayreuth He has worked as a research assistant at ALNuMed GmbH and doctorand at RC BIOmac since 2013 His research interests include NMR-based food analytics and the integration of methods used in metabonomics and spectroscopic profiling Paul Rösch studied physics at the universities of Karlsruhe and Heidelberg before receiving his doctorate at the Max Planck Institute for Medical Research in Heidelberg This was followed by a post-doc at the University of Pennsylvania Medical School in the USA and a post as research assistant at the Max Planck Institute for Medical Research in Heidelberg he completed his habilitation in biophysics at the University of Heidelberg He has been head of the Department of Biopolymers since 1990 and Executive Director of the Research Centre for Bio-Macromolecules (RC BIOmac) at the University of Bayreuth since 2007 His key areas of research are NMR-based biomedical structural research focusing in particular on the molecular basis of food allergies and research into bacterial transcription as a target for new antibiotics , 2 comments All subscriptions include online membership giving you access to the journal and exclusive content By By , , , By By Thank for this technogy we are interested to send our Raw Black and green honey for NMR Honey profiling I am a Scientist and setting up Quality Assurance Lab for Honey Testing in India for export purposes This new innovation seems to be more reliable than LC-EA-IRMS I have got few samples analyzed from Intertek may i know terms and conditions including financial aspects Comment * document.getElementById("comment").setAttribute( "id" "a21162013566d5f6766ea417beb17f02" );document.getElementById("de5d8d4fb7").setAttribute( "id" Write for us | Advertise with us New Food is published by: Russell Publishing Ltd.Court LodgeHogtrough HillBrasted © Russell Publishing Limited, 2010-2025. All rights reserved. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy Website design and development by e-Motive Media Limited Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website These cookies do not store any personal information CookieDescriptioncookielawinfo-checkbox-advertising-targetingThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Advertising & Targeting".cookielawinfo-checkbox-analyticsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent WordPress Plugin The cookie is used to remember the user consent for the cookies under the category "Analytics".cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessaryThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".cookielawinfo-checkbox-performanceThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent WordPress Plugin The cookie is used to remember the user consent for the cookies under the category "Performance".PHPSESSIDThis cookie is native to PHP applications The cookie is used to store and identify a users' unique session ID for the purpose of managing user session on the website The cookie is a session cookies and is deleted when all the browser windows are closed.viewed_cookie_policyThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies It does not store any personal data.zmember_loggedThis session cookie is served by our membership/subscription system and controls whether you are able to see content which is only available to logged in users.