Please select what you would like included for printing:
Copy the text below and then paste that into your favorite email application
Francesco “Frank” or “Lib” Dell’Ovo
passed away in the comfort of his home surrounded by loving family on Thursday
Frank is survived by his loving wife of forty-nine years
and Ennio Dell’Ovo of Boston; eight grandchildren
and Lincoln “Cheech”; along with many nieces and nephews
Vittorio and Antonietta (Monfreda) Dell’Ovo
He graduated from North High School and served in the National Guard
Frank and his family operated Dell’Ovo’s on Shrewsbury Street for many years
before he turned the operations over to his son Anthony in 2014
where the restaurant remains a “go to” place for so many
It was there that Frank met many great people
and where his love of feeding people and conversing with them was shown daily
Frank worked for the Worcester Telegram and Gazette
Having grown up in the shadow of Mount Carmel Church
Frank was proud of his heritage and remained bound to Shrewsbury Street his entire life
and his grandchildren were his pride and joy
He could fix anything he set his mind to and loved to cook
but for any occasion where he’d be with family and friends
He enjoyed “The Wonder of It All” and simply enjoyed a great life
Calling Hours and a Funeral Service will be Tuesday
in the MERCADANTE FUNERAL HOME & CHAPEL
donations in his memory may be made to the Pancreas and Liver Institute at Beth Israel Deaconess Hospital
Enter your phone number above to have directions sent via text
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply
Service map data © OpenStreetMap contributors
You are using an outdated browser. Please upgrade your browser to improve your experience
Connecting decision makers to a dynamic network of information
Bloomberg quickly and accurately delivers business and financial information
Versione italiana
Italy halted all non-essential industry as it navigated the first major outbreak of Covid-19 outside of China
With demand for electricity – and its wholesale price – already slumping
it looked like a lean moment for the energy business
But Roberto Bracco and his power-trading team at Repower AG
had spent more than a decade deploying a trading pattern that raked in large sums even on the slowest days
Bracco knew his company’s gas-powered generating plant might lose money if it sold electricity into Italy’s regular power market – known as the “day-ahead” because it’s settled a day in advance
But he also knew the plant could stay out of that market entirely and perhaps do far better
Whenever day-ahead trading fails to yield enough electricity for any particular area
must fill the gap by buying power in an ancillary market that’s almost always more expensive
had long held strong market power: It’s one of three power plants near Naples that are together crucial for keeping the region’s lights on
Teverola disappeared from the day-ahead but offered electricity in the dispatch market at €490 per megawatt hour – roughly 18 times the average day-ahead price on that day
Terna accepted Teverola’s offer for 24 hours straight
and Repower brought in €1.88 million instead of the €100,840 available in day-ahead
according to a Bloomberg News analysis of Italian electricity records
What would have been a losing day in the regular market
Terna then billed Italian businesses and consumers for all of it
more than a dozen Italian power companies – including state-controlled Enel SpA
the nation’s largest – deployed the same technique to get the same sort of premiums in the dispatch market
There’s nothing illegal about this practice – and Repower and other producers defended it
saying they had to avoid losses in the often-volatile and low-paying day-ahead market
The day-ahead “has always been the primary market for the sale of the plant’s production,” Bracco said in a statement responding to a detailed list of questions sent to Repower
“If and when the production was not sold on the energy market it was only because the margins would have been negative with insufficient revenues to cover the production costs.”
Bloomberg’s analysis shows that roughly half of the time when companies collected a dispatch premium
the day-ahead market would have been unprofitable – based on a widely accepted industry formula used to determine gas-fired power plants’ hourly generation costs
The firms told Bloomberg that the cost-of-production formula doesn’t account for other expenses they face
such as transporting gas or using fuel to warm up their plants
Enel said its “total relevant costs” include “both variable and fixed management costs (for example operation
depreciation and amortization as well as return on capital).”
One of three gas plants operated by Tirreno Power
It was awarded the most money of any plant in Italy
it’s clear – from executives’ celebratory comments during earnings calls as well as simple mathematics – that the dispatch market’s higher prices helped companies do far better than merely avoiding losses
dispatch premiums totaled €1.2 billion – or 238% more than companies would have received at the day-ahead price
Bracco said he expected to do well in dispatch during lockdown
but the magnitude of Repower’s 2020 profits surprised even him
“It went above estimates,” the 53-year-old
wearing a navy blue Lacoste tennis shirt and white-soled boat shoes
said in an interview at Repower’s Milan offices
Italian power authorities introduced an attempt at reform
Terna now pays many producers an annual fee to guarantee supply while capping dispatch prices at levels linked to production costs
Terna spent hundreds of millions more in 2022 via this new “capacity market” than it saved
Italy’s experience – as reflected in the glimpse Repower provided into the rarely seen world of power trading – shows that such money-making maneuvers are neither new nor easy to fix
Read more from Power Plays
a series about the ways consumers lose on energy bills
Long before Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine sent energy prices soaring
Italy’s dispatch market left consumers vulnerable to what regulators have called an electricity “game” that benefits firms with strong market power
the dispatch market was intended to apply a competitive free market to the problem of providing enough electricity to fill all of Italy’s needs
If traders can choose between one option that offers them tight margins and another that can make them huge sums
it’s a sign that the market isn’t perfectly competitive
Europe has failed to learn the Enron lesson
infamously helped trigger rolling blackouts in California by manipulating its electricity market in 2000
which led to a series of regulatory changes
prices and grid stability are hashed out simultaneously as part of the regular market
and companies with few competitors face strict limits on what they can ask for
a professor of energy policy at the Hertie School in Berlin
But European regulators often still use two-step systems that separate the regular market from the tools that grid operators use to secure enough electricity to meet demand
power firms can charge whatever the grid operator will pay
And the grid operator will pay ever higher prices if the plant has too few competitors
“You create perverse incentives for gaming” when these markets don’t operate on a “cost-based regulated basis,” Hirth said
Bloomberg News is examining energy markets in Europe and elsewhere. Got a tip or a story to share? Get in touch with us at powerpricing@bloomberg.net
more than a dozen Italian market participants
schedulers and their counterparts at grid operator Terna
described a system that provides lopsided advantages to energy suppliers
Traders are like chess players who face the same
When certain conditions arise – low demand
maintenance issues – they can easily predict what Terna will do
Bracco said “there has never been any arbitrage strategy” and noted that Terna decides whether the dispatch market is needed
Dispatch is very different from the day-ahead “in terms of size and purpose
and it is natural that very different prices can arise between the two.”
Terna said in a statement that rising gas prices hampered its efforts to save consumers money via its new capacity market
Without the new system – which also provides an incentive for companies to keep power plants online to maintain the network’s security – electricity inflation in Italy would have been even worse
“The capacity market prevented the costs of the energy market from rising further.”
These changes have taken years to accomplish
Italian regulators had been expressing concerns about power companies’ use of the dispatch market for at least a decade
Competition authorities investigated multiple firms over alleged abuses during that time
One of the first was Repower and Roberto Bracco
Energy supply in Italy flows freely in the north
where power lines connect in every direction from Turin to Milan to Venice
But the rest of the country follows narrow stretches of coast along either side of the mountains that run the length of the “boot,” with fewer generators to call upon
Regulators identified these electricity generators as having strong market power in the areas they served
In May 2010, a whistleblower wrote to Italy’s competition authority alleging that the firms running Naples’ three major power plants had formed “a cartel aimed at keeping the prices offered for electricity dispatching services high.”
none of the three plants had been offering any energy in the day-ahead on Sundays
documents from the competition authority’s investigation show
That created a need for dispatch power — and in that market
the three plants would rotate who made the winning offer
the next Napoli Levante and the one after that Teverola
The whistleblower alleged that the organizer of the “cartel” was the head of trading at Repower Italia
Public documents don’t name any of the employees implicated in the probe
but Bracco spoke openly about it with Bloomberg
“It started with an anonymous letter,” he said
and therefore it was probably someone inside Repower who sent the anonymous letter.”
He denies colluding with competitors – though he acknowledges Repower became a frequent participant in the dispatch market under his leadership
Repower initially sold its electricity almost exclusively in the day-ahead during hours of peak demand
But margins tightened during the Great Recession in 2008 and 2009
demand dropped low enough to set prices below Teverola’s costs
So Bracco’s team began dropping out of the day-ahead and offering only in dispatch
“We kept the plant out if the plant was going to lose money,” he said
Italy’s grid first began hooking up wind and solar plants
which could undercut gas generators’ prices in the day-ahead
But because wind and solar couldn’t turn on and off on command
they couldn’t offer their power in dispatch
Soon Repower was “principally” earning its money from dispatch
investigators dug through emails and found references to contacts among the three companies
a Repower employee emailed to ask Bracco what he had learned from the competitor
according to the competition authority’s findings
the competition authority delivered a ruling: The Naples trio had indeed operated as a cartel between April and August 2010
The authority called their Sunday trading pattern the “hat trick,” a reference to scoring three goals in a soccer match
Napoli Levante’s owner Tirreno Power €116,097 and the company running Sparanise €80,389
Tirreno Power called the fine “a minor ‘symbolic’ penalty” and added that Italian regulators did not start “any further investigation” into the matter
“therefore recognizing that it was not necessary to modify the market rules.” Sparanise’s owner
and that Repower filed an ultimately fruitless appeal as an expression of its innocence
the penalty was small compared with the damages that had been originally alleged
Under Italian and European Union law, when any company’s market power is especially large, regulators can investigate whether it has engaged in “abuse of dominant position,” including by charging excessive prices. The Italian Competition Authority has wielded the law against drug makers and tech companies such as Alphabet Inc.’s Google
the competition authority and the power regulator
Investigators found that Enel and its competitors had helped spike the cost of dispatch in an isolated region in the heel of Italy’s boot that relies heavily on one of its power plants
dispatch charges for the area around Brindisi were about €320 million higher than in the year before
Enel kept its four-unit Brindisi Sud plant out of the day-ahead market on weekends
Soon the region had daily power shortfalls
Enel was there offering the same Brindisi Sud electricity for hefty sums
“From that moment on the plant was ‘regulated,’ that is
operating according to the established rules and remunerations
with no more room for anti-competitive behavior,” Rome-based ARERA said in a statement to Bloomberg
Enel collected far more in dispatch premiums than any other company
a former government-run monopoly that’s now three-quarters owned by private shareholders
said “the bidding behavior of a plant should be more properly evaluated by comparing its overall revenues with the total relevant costs.” When most power generators offer in dispatch they “have no way of being certain” that they will be accepted
Despite the competition authority’s investigations
most power plants – those that didn’t collude with one another and those that weren’t deemed “essential” – were still allowed to freely deploy the same technique: stay out of the day-ahead market
then offer power at higher prices in the dispatch market to fill the holes they helped create
Terna and ARERA continued looking for ways to bring costs down
But they faced a looming danger: Traditional fuel-burning plants were being decommissioned as renewables grabbed market share
leading to what Terna called a “strong reduction” in supply over the previous decade
this threatened to put consumers at an “unacceptable” risk of blackouts and shortages
That’s why Terna introduced its capacity market
companies would bid for lump sum payments to guarantee that they would offer supply no matter what
their dispatch market prices could never exceed a cap determined by the cost of production
New plants coming online would get higher payments
which encouraged firms to build new plants in addition to keeping old ones
Terna held its first capacity auction to set each bidding company’s fees
though the new setup wouldn’t go into effect until the start of 2022
Bracco said the new market seemed better suited to larger firms with more plants
his firm’s trading approach hadn’t changed
regardless of the decade-old collusion case
When Teverola’s prospects in the day-ahead were poor – often on Sundays and other low-demand days – he and his traders kept the plant out
a grim and defiant nightly ritual set in across Italy
television stations broadcast the government’s announcement of daily death counts
while city dwellers leaned out their windows and balconies to sing
joining what was becoming a worldwide trend
Terna had to go into the dispatch market more often
The profits from dispatch would become “much
Sunday was the only day of the week where the premium averaged more than half a million euros..
most days averaged more than €800,000
The €1.88 million haul came on a Sunday – March 22
the first day after the industrial lockdown announcement
The ensuing Monday and Tuesday were almost as lucrative
bringing in €1.6 million and €1.3 million respectively
The three plants in the Naples cluster were all making money in the dispatch market
ARERA noticed what was going on and warned in a report that summer that clusters of “pivotal” dispatch plants in southern Italy
had collective market power that made their service areas “vulnerable” and could turn the dispatch market into “a game repeated infinite times.”
ARERA said in a statement that its 2020 findings “immediately required Terna to take prompt action to make all the procedural changes to the market system.” To encourage Terna to make fixes
it would receive a percentage of those savings as a bonus payout
2020 had become an unexpected boon for Italian power firms
several pointed to dispatch income as a key reason why
said it saved the company’s year: “In the face of a drastic general decrease in production
the healthy results achieved are mainly attributable to the higher volumes of sales made on the Dispatching Services Market.”
Tirreno Power said in a statement that Bloomberg’s reporting doesn’t take “account of what actually happened on the market at the time
thus driving to fundamentally flawed conclusions.” With the pandemic’s low demand being largely satisfied by renewable electricity sources
gas-fired generators were mainly needed in dispatch
“This was an unprecedented and exceptional condition,” Tirreno Power said
the firm pointed to how Teverola provided “balancing energy on a targeted basis
once again making a substantial contribution to the good corporate results.”
Yet for Italians who lost their livelihoods
the arrangement meant their power bills didn’t drop noticeably
even if they’d kept the lights off for months in their shuttered shops
“We have all lived in a situation of crisis and enormous difficulty,” said Alessandra Durando
who manages the finances for her husband’s vintage furnishings boutique
“There’s someone who’s made a business out of this?”
The Teverola plant sits far off a four-lane industrial road
the plant’s operation and maintenance manager
donned an orange hard hat to walk the grounds
which are no larger than a couple football fields
Gas flows into the plant through a pipe that enters a hangar-like building
two turbines sit side by side making electricity
a practically windowless space with an array of 14 computers
security camera monitors and light blue walls serves as the control room
One screen displays the production schedule
while another shows the plant’s output in real time
after Terna launched its new capacity market
output for the dispatch market immediately crashed
the dispatch market is practically dead,” Gentile said
On most days in the past year, the power Teverola pumps out has been purchased in the regular day-ahead market. With the dispatch market withered, “the contribution to earnings made by Teverola was way below expectations and the results of previous years,” Repower said when announcing its 2022 results
Repower’s Italian business broke even during the first half of 2023
ARERA said in a statement that its capacity incentives “drastically reduced” the problem of high dispatch costs
“solving problems that arose and overcoming critical issues that had arisen in previous years.”
the new system didn’t save consumers money
The dispatch-related expenses that Terna charged to consumers fell by €508 million to €1.92 billion in 2022
But the new capacity market expenses went from zero to €1.2 billion
That means that in its first year of operation
the new system resulted in a net higher expense of €692 million
which Terna passed on to Italians’ power bills
Terna noted that the new price caps are tied to the cost of gas
which increased significantly in 2022 and drove electricity prices far higher across Europe
This cut into how much money could be saved on the dispatch market
adding that improvements to its grid and trading strategies also helped cut dispatch costs
But the capacity market is not a substitute for a deeper overhaul of the Italian energy market
a professor of power systems at the Politecnico di Torino
“In the long term you need something else,” including grid upgrades that allow wind power to be stored so it can support the network during times of stress the way gas-fired plants do
Expenses fell enough for it to receive €334.7 million in bonuses last year under ARERA’s incentives for trimming dispatch-related costs
They buoyed Terna’s bottom line 13.5% to €834.1 million
Not all that profit went back into improving Italy’s electricity system
The grid operator also boosted its dividend for shareholders by 8% to €632 million
Though the government appoints Terna’s CEO
the Italian state only owns 18% of the firm
putting them in line for the rest of the annual payout
About 10% indirectly belongs to the Chinese government
Terna charged Italian businesses and residents on their monthly bills
just as it did for dispatch costs during lockdown
Bloomberg analyzed public data from Gestore dei Mercati Energetici, an Italian state-owned company that operates the country’s power markets. The GME publishes hourly transaction records across markets where electricity is offered and bid, including a regular day-ahead market (MGP) that meets most of the country’s power demand and an ancillary market (MSD) that helps Terna
handle congestion on the grid and ensure supply and demand are balanced
hourly energy blocks are traded for the day before the power is delivered
The MGP market opens on the ninth day before the day of delivery and closes at 12pm the day before delivery
The MSD market then opens the day before delivery at 12:55pm and closes at 5:00pm
where power producers submit the price and quantity at which they are willing to generate electricity
and consuming units submit the price and quantity at which they are willing to buy
For each settlement hour and each zone of the grid
a clearing price is determined by the intersection of demand and supply curves
All the producers who offer a price at or below where the curves intersect
Terna acts as the central counterparty and accepts offers directly from producers at the prices offered
Prices in the MSD are often multiple times higher than in the MGP when there is congestion or insufficient power on the grid
which can occur if producers oversupply or withhold power
a publicly-traded company with both governmental and private shareholders
then passes the MSD cost to consumers via a special “uplift” fee on their energy bills
By comparing the prices and quantities electricity producers offered at each market
Bloomberg found a pattern of withholding capacity in MGP and reaping multiple-times-higher prices in MSD
To arrive at an estimate of the dispatch premium
Bloomberg included only instances when a given producer sold zero power in MGP but then
for the same settlement hour on the same delivery day
Bloomberg subtracted the zonal MGP price from the MSD price awarded
and then multiplied the difference by the quantity of energy awarded
Bloomberg’s analysis did not include some other, more sophisticated forms of gaming, such as when generators buy back MGP commitments in the Intra-Day Market
in some cases generators sold power below market prices in the MSD for technical reasons
Bloomberg subtracted any potential losses in the MSD market from overall figures to arrive at a conservative estimate of dispatch premium
To estimate a typical gas-powered generator’s marginal cost of production, Bloomberg considered the historical prices of natural gas and the cost of the European Union’s CO2 emission allowance, using Italian PSV Natural Gas Futures and EUA Futures data provided by the Intercontinental Exchange
In consultation with traders and expert researchers in the field
we arrived at the following formula that assumes production efficiency of 50% and a CO2 factor of 0.19 for natural-gas burning:
Estimated Marginal Cost of Production = ((European Carbon Emission Allowance Futures) * 0.19 + Italian PSV Natural Gas Futures) * 2
commitment and courage of Christopher Columbus…but in so doing
we indeed honor the courageous actions of those who brought their Italian culture…along with their families… to seek the American dream and all that is the best of our Nation
We gain inspiration by the personal story of Christopher Columbus
Columbus Day honors Christopher Columbus the explorer
Hundreds of celebrations across America this weekend recognize our Italian heritage
This is a time to reflect on the challenges
achievements and significant contributions of Italians to our American culture; and take collective pride and patriotism in the genuine and lasting spirit of our Nation whose liberties and freedoms shine as a beacon for the entire world
the freedoms we hold dear as Americans were greatly assisted by our Italian American forefathers
We as Italian-Americans should take pride in the fact that Our Declaration of Independence bears the signatures of two Italian Americans…William Paca from Maryland
and Ceaser Rodney from Delaware; our independence was established and our Nation was formed with the help of three Italian regiments with over 1,500 soldiers
that crossed the Atlantic Ocean to fight side-by-side with the American patriots against British rule in the Revolutionary War
which at the time was a significant addition to the Continental Army
List any and every field of endeavor—-any achievement in our Nation…and Italian-Americans are part of it
the success of our Nation has drawn heavily from the industry and resourcefulness of Italian immigrants and their families
the same can be said for the values brought by Italians that helped to make us a great Nation
The millions who came here brought with them a distinct strength of character
a determined sense of personal responsibility and respect
that I share a personal story of my family with you
As one who loves learning about history…if I could choose to go back in any time to witness personally…I would choose to travel back around a hundred years ago to Sparanise
And I would give anything to be seated at the dinner table in their small apartment when my grandfather and grandmother engaged in their discussions with my father and Aunt Madeline
to leave the land of their birth; the land where all their families still lived; and discuss what sacrifices they would have to make to rip away from their home and their homeland to build a new life in America
my grandfather could come to America and work
but needed a steady job and enough financial where-with-all before his family could also immigrate
Can you imagine: leaving home; traveling by boat over a 3,000 mile ocean to find work; not seeing your wife
your son and daughter for over seven years while you worked long hours in a factory
rented room and saved every penny you could to make sure your family would be allowed to join you as soon as possible
All this sacrifice to build a better life for your family…a better life for your family in America
and courage is the story of my family…and the beautiful story is the history of all our families
It is the story replicated millions of times over
It is a story that echoes all across this room and all across America…I am sure you all heard your grandfathers and grandmothers tell this story of your family time and again
It is the story of us….it is the story we celebrate here today on this Columbus Day…and it is the story that made our Nation strong and true and free
The real courage honored today is forged by the spirit of Christopher Columbus that encouraged all those who left their homeland to build a better life for their families by immigrating to America
They did not have a sense of entitlement and were not looking for a hand-out
They were looking for work in whatever form to pursue the American dream
and the opportunity to represent you in the New York State Senate
The same pride my Italian grandparents and father felt when they became naturalized American citizens
The same pride your own families must have in your personal and professional accomplishments and contributions to your community
Our Nation is so much stronger because of the spirit we honor today
January 7th 2011 at Notre Dame Long Term Care Center in Worcester
William is survived by his wife of 50 years
He also leaves many nieces and nephews both here and in Italy
and Attorney Mary Italiano all of Worcester; and two brothers
Armando Robert Italiano of Worcester and Guido Italiano of North Grafton predeceased him
His parents were the late Pasquale and Michelina (DeRosa) Italiano
William and his family came to Worcester when he was one year old
He attended Belmont School and then Commerce High School
graduating in the Class of 1931-B after 3 1/2 years
During those years he was a member of the Blackfriars Dramatic Society
a violinist in Orchestra A and President of his Class for three consecutive years
he graduated from Boston University with a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration specializing in Commercial Education
He continued at Boston University and completed his MBA in 1937
He began teaching in the Worcester Public Schools in 1937 at Commerce High School
Army Air Corps and was the recipient of the American Theater and Asiatic Pacific Theater Campaign Ribbons
After he was discharged in 1946 he returned to teaching
In addition to teaching he served as the Principal of the Worcester Evening High School from the 1960’s until 1972
he retired from North High School after 45 years of teaching
William worked his entire life as a carpenter and owner of WSI Construction Co
He was a member of numerous clubs and organizations
For 62 years he belonged to The Sodality of Our Lady
on his 50th year anniversary in the Sodality
he received an Apostolic Blessing from Pope John Paul II
He was also a member the American Legion Eastside Post 201
a founding member of the former ITAM Club and a Charter Member of the West Boylston Lions Club
his smile and his fun-filled personality touched everyone he met
The family would like to thank the staff and residents of The Notre Dame Long Term Care Facility for creating an environment that allowed William to live his final years in keeping with the way he lived his entire life: fun-filled and surrounded by warm and compassionate people
with a Mass at 10:00 in Our Lady of Good Counsel Church
January 10th from 4-7 PM at the funeral home
memorial donations may be made to the Maffei Capuano Italiano Scholarship Fund at Our Lady of Mt