Metrics details
A long-standing goal in neuroscience is to understand how a circuit’s form influences its function
we reconstruct and analyze a synaptic wiring diagram of the larval zebrafish brainstem to predict key functional properties and validate them through comparison with physiological data
We identify modules of strongly connected neurons that turn out to be specialized for different behavioral functions
The eye movement module is further organized into two three-block cycles that support the positive feedback long hypothesized to underlie low-dimensional attractor dynamics in oculomotor control
We construct a neural network model based directly on the reconstructed wiring diagram that makes predictions for the cellular-resolution coding of eye position and neural dynamics
These predictions are verified statistically with calcium imaging-based neural activity recordings
This work demonstrates how connectome-based brain modeling can reveal previously unknown anatomical structure in a neural circuit and provide insights linking network form to function
connectomics has provided a strong anatomical basis for the computations underlying motion processing
within and across most vertebrate brain regions
the connectivity is highly recurrent without obvious topographic structure
it remains unclear how the neural coding properties of the system emerge from and relate to the underlying connectivity and cellular properties
We reconstructed ~3,000 neurons as completely as the borders of the volume allow through human proofreading of an automated segmentation
By applying graph clustering algorithms to the connectome
we reveal that this naively disorganized structure hides a strongly modular hierarchical organization
we find two anatomically defined modules that are specialized for different behaviors: one for eye movements and the other for body movements
The oculomotor module is in turn subdivided into two submodules specialized for movements of each eye
each submodule contains a three-block cyclic substructure
Our linking of structure and behavior by modularity analysis at synaptic resolution is unique for the vertebrate nervous system
we take a more direct approach: use the wiring diagram to estimate a synaptic weight matrix characterizing physiological interactions between neurons and literally insert that matrix into a network model incorporating a minimal number of additional constraints from physiology
the predictions turn out to be statistically consistent at a population level with neural activity recorded by calcium imaging of larval zebrafish during oculomotor behavior
Three-dimensional rendering of reconstructed neurons
The large green cell body in the foreground is the Mauthner neuron (Mcell); Ro
The inset (top left) shows the location of the unilateral EM volume (black box) relative to the olfactory bulb (OB)
Automatic synapse detection and partner assignment
Postsynaptic densities (PSDs) identified by a convolutional network
Postsynaptic densities (red) overlaid onto the original raw image together with an exemplar presynaptic (blue) and postsynaptic (yellow) partnership identified by a second convolutional network
Sagittal view of the identified ABDM (green) and ABDI (magenta) neurons overlaid over representative EM planes; R
The asterisk (*) indicates the Mauthner cell soma
Coronal planes showing the locations of the ABDM (left) and ABDI (right) neurons at the planes indicated by dotted black lines in the sagittal view
Black boxes highlight nerve bundles from these populations
Representative ABDM and ABDI neurons with arrows indicating the axons
Reconstructions of large and small RS neurons and Ve2 neurons
To demonstrate that this graph-theoretic procedure identified biologically relevant modules and to suggest functional roles of these modules
we then examined the patterns of connections between the central and peripheral populations
we present the resultant organization in a hierarchical manner
matrix of connections in the ‘center’ of the wiring diagram
with neurons clustered into two modules (modA and modO)
matrix of connections from center to large RS and ABD neurons in the periphery
example connected pair of modO neurons (light and dark blue) and the overlap of their axons with the dendrite of an ABD internuclear cell (magenta)
The grid in the background is the same in both images to facilitate comparison
Locations of reconstructed neuron somas (modA
blue) projected onto the horizontal plane and one-dimensional (1D) densities along the mediolateral (bottom) and rostrocaudal (left) axes
Closed circles are neurons with complete somas inside the reconstructed EM volume
Open circles are locations of the primary neurites exiting the top of the EM volume for cells with somas above the volume
The inset cartoon shows the region of the hindbrain in the figure
Postsynapses of neurons in modA and modO along with 1D densities
Every fifth postsynaptic density is plotted for clarity
Presynapses of neurons in modA and modO along with 1D densities
Every tenth presynaptic terminal is plotted for clarity
Schematic illustrating the definition of a potential (that is
false) synaptic connection identified when a presynaptic terminal (for example
axon 2) is proximal (red) to a postsynaptic density (for example
dendrite 1) but not actually in contact with it
Ratio of the number of within-module to the number of between-module synapses versus threshold distance for true and potential synapses
The table lists the actual true synapse densities for the data point with an asterisk (*)
Ratio of numbers of synapses from neurons in modA and modO to peripheral neurons (ABD and RS)
we decided to probe to what extent these distributions could be contributing to modularity
We also identified, at the population level, statistical differences in other anatomical features of modA and modO neurons and synapses (Extended Data Fig. 2), such as total arbor length and synapse distance from the soma (Extended Data Fig. 2a–c)
we note that the total number of synapses onto a neuron (regardless of origin) was 310 ± 261 for modA neurons
1,576 ± 1,555 for peripheral RS neurons and 411 ± 167 for ABD neurons
the binary division into two modules is the first step in a hierarchical procedure that reveals further substructure
a, Top, matrix of connections within modO organized into two submodules termed modOM and modOI. Bottom, projections of modOM and modOI onto ABDM and ABDI neuron populations. b, Locations of reconstructed neuron somata along with 1D densities for neurons within modOM (blue) or modOI (brown). The symbols, inset and orientation are as in Fig. 2c
Postsynaptic densities (c) and presynaptic terminals (d) in modOI and modOM
Every fifth synaptic site was plotted for clarity
Ratio of the number of within-module synapses for modOM and modOI to the number of between-module synapses as a function of potential synapse distance
The table lists the actual number of true synapses for the data point with an asterisk (*)
Ratio of the number of synaptic contacts between a modO submodule and its preferred peripheral partner versus those between a modO submodule and its nonpreferred peripheral partner
The numbers in the tables represent normalized synapse counts defined as the ratio of the sum of all synapses in a block to the product of the number of elements in the block
Ocular preference index for modOM and modOI neurons
A value of 1 or –1 indicates connections to only one ABD population
A value of 0 indicates an equal number of connections to each ABD population
Population-level differences between modOM and modOI and their interconnections were also evident in the statistical distributions of synapse size and synapse distance from the soma (Extended Data Fig. 2d,e)
The results above suggest the existence of two weakly connected submodules within the oculomotor network
To gain insight into whether these submodules contained substructure
we next examined the eigenvalues of the modO connectivity matrix
The set of eigenvalues of a connectivity matrix
contains hallmark signatures of the matrix’s underlying structure
To understand the relationship between the eigenspectrum and network structure
a, Eigenvalue spectrum for modO when connections are shuffled (Methods)
with modO treated as a single block (left) or as two blocks consisting of modOM and modOI with interconnections removed (middle) or intact (right)
Eigenvalue spectrum for the actual connectome
Matrix of synaptic connections for modO and its connections to the ABD
Cells are grouped by block identity in a seven-block SBM
The orange and purple boxes highlight cycles in the connections within blocks OM1–OM3 and blocks OI1–OI3
Gray ticks indicate the location of Ve2 cells
Eigenvalue spectrum of modO after the cycles are decoupled by eliminating connections between the internuclear cycle and the other four blocks (d) and when the connections within the internuclear cycle are additionally shuffled (e)
Diagram of connections between blocks in modO
Solid lines indicate the most prominent connections
and dashed lines indicate weaker connections
orange) eigenvectors for modO (top) and modO with the two cycles decoupled as in d
the leading eigenvectors approximately combine the eigenvectors found in the decoupled case
The leading eigenvector approximates a scaled sum of the two decoupled eigenvectors
and the second leading eigenvector approximates a scaled difference of the decoupled eigenvectors
this suggests that activation of the pattern of modOM neurons corresponding to the first eigenvector may generate ‘conjugate eye movements’ (eyes moving together in the same direction
which requires coactivation of the ABDM and ABDI populations)
whereas activation of the second eigenvector may be critical for maintaining either disconjugate eye movements (eyes moving in opposite directions) or deviations from conjugate eye movements
Two of these graph-theoretically derived blocks would not be easily identifiable as part of modO by naively tracing connections back from the periphery
Block OM1 of the motor submodule projects extremely weakly to the motor neurons but has the strongest projections to and receipt of projections from the internuclear submodule
it appears to be involved nearly solely in internal processing
block OI3 of the internuclear cycle has relatively little connection to the ABD
appear to divide into two halves with different functions for each half; for block OM3
whereas the other half provides the strongest projection to the \({{\rm{O}}}_{{{\rm{Ve}}}^{2}}\) block
We hypothesized that modO contains the majority of the ‘neural integrator’ for horizontal eye movements that transforms angular velocity inputs into angular position outputs
This transformation has been suggested to depend on a relatively high degree of recurrent interactions within the velocity-to-position neural integrator (VPNI)
it is not known how these interactions shape the single-neuron coding properties of neurons within modO and its peripheral outputs in the ABD
Relative eye position sensitivities from the connectome-based model (gray) and imaging of real cells (green)
Same as d except that the model uses potential synapses instead of the actual connectome
Cumulative variance explained for the leading principal components of the STA of the firing rates of the model (gray) or deconvolved fluorescence of imaged cells (green) for the period between 2 and 6 s after a saccade
best-fit amplitudes of the exponentials for each cell in the model (gray) and each imaged cell (green)
Note in d that VPNI cells were defined experimentally by having a sufficiently large correlation with eye position; thus
the lowest sensitivity simulated VPNI cells would not have been counted if they occurred in a functional imaging dataset
the final synaptic weight matrix took the form \({W}_{ij}=\pm \beta \frac{{N}_{ij}}{{\sum }_{k}{N}_{ik}}\)
Because the imaged neurons come from different fish than the reconstructed one
they cannot be placed in one-to-one correspondence with neurons in our EM volume
we resorted to a population-level comparison
although the bimodality seen in the model ABD populations was not clearly evident
We compared these simulations to three classes of neurons (VPNI
which could not easily distinguish between ABDM and ABDI neurons
This suggests that the functional properties of the circuit depend on the spatially precise connections revealed by the EM connectome
although the seven-block model is required to recover the cyclic connectivity of the network and the separate vestibular-dominated block \({{\rm{O}}}_{{{\rm{Ve}}}^{2}}\)
it is not required to reveal the slowest timescale decay dynamics
This work shows how the neural coding properties throughout a hindbrain network relate to its synapse-resolution structure
Through connectomic reconstruction and analysis
we reveal that hindbrain regions previously thought to be largely unstructured instead contain a hierarchical modular organization that closely aligns with known motor functions
Directly inserting the connectome into a network model statistically predicts the single-neuron coding properties assessed with two-photon calcium imaging throughout the reconstructed volume
representing a breakthrough in deriving neuronal properties within a topographically heterogeneous network from the connectome
EM-resolution analysis was critical to revealing the above network structure and predictions
as there were large discrepancies when lower-resolution analysis based on potential synapses was used to assess connectivity
The resulting connectome and modular analysis tools are being provided as an open resource to the community
Comparisons between model predictions and physiological data at the level of single cells
might require more sophisticated modeling of cell- and synapse-specific biophysics
As more connectomes become available in other settings
it will be important to consider which physiological constraints need to be incorporated to make appropriate use of these powerful datasets
Answers to this question depend on many factors
including the breadth of behaviors to be produced in a single model
the range of dynamics of the constituent components and the degree to which the model is to produce quantitative versus qualitative matches to data
when guided by knowledge of the various behaviors a circuit participates in and appropriate physiological constraints gleaned from recordings and perturbations of activity
it may be possible in even more complex circuits to identify physiological modules whose function can be well understood using the connectome-based analysis and modeling approach taken here
and the linear system was solved using conjugate gradient descent
The mean residual errors were in the range of 0.5–1.0 pixels after relaxation
The intersection alignment was split into a translation step (pre-prealignment)
a fast coarse elastic step (rough alignment) and a slow fine elastic step (fine alignment)
a central patch of the given montaged section was matched to the previous montaged section to obtain the rough translation between two montaged sections
the montaged images were offset by that translation
and then a small number of correspondences were found between the two montaged sections
The sections were then aligned using an affine transformation fit using least squares
regularized with a 10% (empirically derived) weighting of the identity transformation to reduce shear accumulating and propagating across multiple sections
Proceeding sequentially allowed the entire stack to get roughly in place
The mean residual errors after prealignment were in the range of 3.5 pixels after relaxation
In the subsequent rough and fine alignment steps
the blockmatches were computed and filtered between bandpassed neighboring sections in a regular triangular mesh
followed by a conjugate gradient descent on the linear system
Splitting the elastic step into rough and fine alignments allowed the search radius to be reduced during the fine alignment relative to what would have been necessary with a direct attempt
thereby lowering the likelihood of spurious matches as well as the computing time
These labeled subvolumes were used as the ground truth for training convolutional networks to detect neuronal boundaries
We used 187.7 million voxels for training and reserved 6.7 million voxels for validation
neuronal reconstructions were checked and if necessary corrected by expert in-house image analysts who each had more than 5,000 h of experience
The accuracy of the players in the crowd compared to experts (assuming experts are 100%) was >80% in the first round and ~95% after the second round of tracing
The validated reconstructions were subsequently skeletonized for analysis purposes
Player accuracy was calculated as an F1 score
All scores were calculated as a sum over voxels
TP was assigned when both the player and the expert agreed that the segmentation was correct
FN was assigned when the player missed segments that were added in by the expert
and FP was assigned when the player erroneously added segments that did not belong
Two F1 scores were calculated for each player
No player played the same neuron in both rounds
Only the most experienced players on Eyewire were allowed to participate
A small group of four highly experienced players received an invitation to test this new dataset
The players were given the title of ‘Mystic’
which was a new status created to enable gameplay and became the highest achievable rank in the game
Subsequent Mystic players had to apply for the status to unlock access to the zebrafish dataset within Eyewire
There was a high threshold of achievement required for a player to gain Mystic status
Each player was required to reach the previous highest status within the game as well as complete 200+ cubes a month and maintain 95% accuracy when resolving cell errors
they were granted access to the zebrafish dataset and given the option to have a live tutorial session with an Eyewire Admin
There was also a prerecorded tutorial video and written tutorial materials for players who could not attend the live session or who desired a review of the materials
Newly promoted players were also given a special badge
a new chat color and access to a new chat room exclusive to Mystics
These rewards helped motivate players by showing their elevated status within the game as well as giving them a space to discuss issues specific to the zebrafish dataset
Cells were parceled out in batches to players
Each cell was reconstructed by only one player at a time
Once this player had finished their reconstruction
a second player would check over the cell for errors
a final check was done by an Eyewire Admin
a special graphical user interface was built into the game that allowed players to see the status of each cell currently online
A cell could be at one of the following five statuses: ‘Need Player A’
These statuses indicated whether a cell needed to be checked or was in the process of being checked and whether it needed a first-
the username of the player or Admin who had done a first
It was made mandatory that the first and second checks were performed by two separate players
Collaboration and feedback were important parts of the checking process
If a player was unsure about an area of the cell they were working on
they could leave a note with a screenshot and detail of the issue or create an alert that would notify an Admin
If a ‘Player B’ or an Admin noticed a mistake made earlier in the pipeline
they could inform the player of the issue via a ‘Review’ document or through an in-game notification (player tagging)
To differentiate the zebrafish cells from the regular dataset
This tag helped identify the cells as separate from the e2198 retinal Eyewire dataset and also populated them to a menu of active zebrafish cells within Eyewire
Players were rewarded for their work in the zebrafish dataset with points
Points earned while playing zebrafish were added to a player’s overall points score for all gameplay done on Eyewire and appeared in the Eyewire leaderboard
we constructed a weighted undirected graph from the point cloud
where the neighboring points are connected with an edge and the edge weight is computed from the DBF
We then took the point with the largest DBF as source and found the furthest point as the target
The shortest path from source to target in the graph was computed as the skeleton nodes
The surrounding points were labeled as visited
and the closest remaining unvisited point was taken as the new source
We repeated this process until all the points were visited
The skeleton node diameter was set as its DBF
The skeleton nodes were postprocessed by removing redundant nodes
merging single-child segments and smoothing the skeleton path
All skeletonization was performed at multum in parvo level 4
All 361 synapses in the ground truth were labeled with their synaptic partners
and the partner network used 204 synapses as a training set
73 as a validation set and the remaining 84 as a test set
The final network was 95% accurate in assigning the correct partners of the test set after 380,000 training iterations
The final cleft network was applied across the entire image volume and formed discrete predictions of synaptic clefts by running a distributed version of connected components
Each cleft was assigned synaptic partners by applying the partner network to each predicted cleft within nonoverlapping regions of the dataset (1,024 × 1,024 × 1,792 voxels each)
In the case where a cleft spanned multiple regions
the assignment within the region that contained most of that cleft was accepted
Cleft regions whose centroid coordinates were within 1 μm and were assigned the same synaptic partners were merged together to merge artificially split components
postsynapses on axons and presynapses on dendrites) were cleaned by querying the identity of the ten nearest synapses to every synapse
where each synapse was associated with its closest skeleton node on both the pre- and postsynaptic sides
If the majority of the ten nearest neighbors were of the same identity (presynaptic or postsynaptic)
If the majority were of an opposing identity
these synapses were assigned incorrectly and were deleted
This process eliminated 1,975 falsely assigned synapses (~2% of the total)
These corresponding points were used to determine an affine transform using the MATLAB least squares solver (mldivide)
the intermediate EM stack in the same reference frame as the Z-Brain atlas was used as the template to register the high-resolution EM stack
This was performed in a similar manner by selecting corresponding points and fitting an affine transform
This transform was used to map the reconstructed skeletons from high-resolution EM space to the reference atlas space
We define the periphery as those cells with vanishing (<10−8) eigencentrality but nonzero degree centrality
All but 62 of these 2,344 neurons had strictly 0 eigencentrality
The remaining 540 recurrently connected neurons are defined as the ‘center’ of the graph
See below for the effects of varying the eigencentrality threshold for center–periphery division
We applied two graph clustering algorithms to divide the center into two supermodules and obtained similar results from each algorithm. The clustering from the Louvain algorithm is presented in the main text and that of the spectral algorithm in Extended Data Fig. 3
We further subdivided each supermodule into subclusters using an SBM
In addition to the Louvain graph clustering algorithm
we also clustered the ‘center’ with an alternative graph clustering algorithm
We used a generalized spectral clustering algorithm for weighted directed graphs to bisect the zebrafish ‘center’ subgraph, as proposed by Chung39
E) and its weighted adjacency matrix \(A\in {{\mathbb{R}}}_{\ge 0}^{n\times n}\)
where Aij indicates the number of synapses from neuron i to neuron j
one can construct a Markov chain on the graph with a transition matrix Pα
such that \({[{P}_{\alpha }]}_{ij}:= (1-\alpha )\cdot {A}_{ij}/{\sum }_{k}{A}_{ik}+\alpha /n\)
The coefficient α > 0 ensures that the constructed Markov chain is irreducible
and the Perron–Frobenius theorem guarantees that Pα has a unique positive left eigenvector π with eigenvalue 1
where π is also called the stationary distribution
The normalized symmetric Laplacian of the Markov chain is \({\mathcal{L}}=I-\frac{1}{2}\left({\Pi }^{1/2}{P}_{\alpha }{\Pi }^{-1/2}+{\Pi }^{-1/2}{P}_{\alpha }^{\top }{\Pi }^{1/2}\right)\)
We modified the directed_laplacian_matrix function in the NetworkX package (https://networkx.github.io) to calculate the symmetric Laplacian for sparse connectivity matrices
The spectral gap for the eigenvector centrality subgraph is \({\lambda }_{2}^{{\mathrm{eigen}}}=0.137\) and for the partitioned oculomotor (modO) module is \({\lambda }_{2}^{{\mathrm{eigen}}_{{\mathrm{OM}}}}=0.256\)
Categorization of functional cells into cell type was guided by registration to the EM dataset
Candidate functional ABD neurons were identified by proximity (6 μm) to any ABD neuron from the registered EM dataset
Functional Ve2 neurons were identified by proximity (6 μm) to any Ve2 neuron from the registered EM dataset; because the above restrictions filtered out all of the candidate Ve2 neurons
which had very weak sensitivity to spontaneous eye movements
in this case we simply used the constraint that these neurons be deemed active in the CaImAn-MATLAB step
Candidate VPNI cells were determined to be the remaining cells in R4 to R7/8 that satisfied the above restrictions and were more than 30 μm away from the center of the abducens
Comparison of the resulting relative firing rates across neurons in different populations was justified as we observed similar sensor expression levels and baseline noise levels in these populations
because the eye position and fluorescence were recorded at different sampling rates
we linearly interpolated the values of neuronal activity at the eye position sample times
we determined \(\tilde{k}\) as the slope resulting from a linear regression (with offset) to r using E as a regressor
Because we do not know the cell’s responsive direction or preferred eye a priori
once with movements to the left as positive and once with movements to the right as positive) and used the value of \(\tilde{k}\) that resulted in the highest R2 value
Directed connection weights between each pair of neurons were set in proportion to the number of synapses from the presynaptic neuron onto the postsynaptic neuron divided by the total number of synapses onto the postsynaptic neuron
\({W}_{ij}=\pm \beta \frac{{N}_{ij}}{{\Sigma }_{k}{N}_{ik}}\)
we assume that each element Wij corresponds to the fraction of total inputs to neuron i that are provided by neuron j
We then constructed a linear rate model for the network
governed by \(\tau \frac{d{r}_{i}}{dt}=-{r}_{i}+{W}_{ij}{r}_{j}\)
where ri is the firing rate of the ith neuron
and τ is an intrinsic cellular time constant
τ for ABD and Ve2 neurons was fixed at 100 ms
The scale factor β and the intrinsic time constant τ for the remaining putative VPNI neurons then provided two free parameters that could be used to set the timescale of persistence for the leading two eigenvectors of the network
For a given choice of scale factor and VPNI neuron time constant
we simulated the response of the network to a random pulse of excitatory input and compared the time course of the leading principal components of the simulated network to that of the calcium imaging data
These parameters were tuned so that the simulations roughly matched the decay times of the leading two principal components in the data
resulting in an intrinsic VPNI neuron time constant of 1 s and a scale factor set such that the leading eigenvalue of the network was equal to 0.9
These free parameters of the network model were not finely tuned
and the precise values used are not critical to the results obtained here
For both the simulated network and the calcium imaging data
we fit each neuron’s firing rate during the period between 2 s and 6 s following a saccade to a double exponential function
\(r(t)={a}_{1}{e}^{-t/{\tau }_{1}}+{a}_{2}{e}^{-t/{\tau }_{2}}\)
where the time constants were fixed at 10 s and 4 s
leaving the amplitudes of each exponential as the only free parameters
These time constants were chosen because a simulated network with leading eigenvectors having these time constants had principal components of its neuronal firing rates that consisted of mixtures of exponentials whose summed time courses approximately matched those of the leading two principal components of the data
We found that the correlation between these two amplitudes in simulation better matched the correlation seen in the data when the saccadic input consisted of fixed and random components
The exact number of leading eigenvectors included in the fixed component is not important to achieve this tuning of the correlation between a1 and a2
We chose to use the leading three eigenvectors because the eigenvalues associated with them were clearly separated from the central disk of eigenvalues
we briefly summarize factors relevant for rigor and reproducibility that have been addressed in more detail elsewhere in the manuscript
Reconstructions were semiautomated and validated (and if necessary corrected) by in-house image analysis experts
Synapses were automatically segmented with a convolutional network that was 95% accurate when tested on ground truth data; an error correction step checking for preidentity/postidentity eliminated 2% of the total
During subsequent analysis of connectivity
Randomization was used extensively in determination of modular organization
Investigators were not blinded during these analyses
Fluorescence microscopy data were previously acquired from 20 animals50
No statistical method was used to predetermine sample size
A one-way ANOVA (with multiple comparison correction; normality was assumed) on STA activity was used to identify activity of significance
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this article
Raw EM images, segmentation information, neuronal skeletons and identified synapse data are available at https://seung-lab.github.io/zebrafish/home/
Wiring specificity in the direction-selectivity circuit of the retina
Central vestibular tuning arises from patterned convergence of otolith afferents
Organization of the gravity-sensing system in zebrafish
Whitening of odor representations by the wiring diagram of the olfactory bulb
The fuzzy logic of network connectivity in mouse visual thalamus
Network anatomy and in vivo physiology of visual cortical neurons
Anatomy and function of an excitatory network in the visual cortex
Dense connectomic reconstruction in layer 4 of the somatosensory cortex
The neuroanatomical ultrastructure and function of a biological ring attractor
Building an allocentric travelling direction signal via vector computation
Transforming a head direction signal into a goal-oriented steering command
A visual motion detection circuit suggested by Drosophila connectomics
Space-time wiring specificity supports direction selectivity in the retina
Spatial patterns of persistent neural activity vary with the behavioral context of short-term memory
Specific evidence of low-dimensional continuous attractor dynamics in grid cells
In vivo intracellular recording and perturbation of persistent activity in a neural integrator
Correlated discharge among cell pairs within the oculomotor horizontal velocity-to-position integrator
Functional dissection of circuitry in a neural integrator
A structural and genotypic scaffold underlying temporal integration
Electron microscopic reconstruction of functionally identified cells in a neural integrator
Formatio reticularis and reticulospinal tracts
their visceral functions and possible relationships to tonicity and clonic contractions
Mapping a sensory–motor network onto a structural and functional ground plan in the hindbrain
Reading the book of memory: sparse sampling versus dense mapping of connectomes
Species-specific wiring for direction selectivity in the mammalian retina
Optogenetic localization and genetic perturbation of saccade-generating neurons in zebrafish
Convolutional nets for reconstructing neural circuits from brain images acquired by serial section electron microscopy
Synaptic partner assignment using attentional voxel association networks
In 2020 IEEE 17th International Symposium on Biomedical Imaging (ISBI) 1–5 (IEEE
Whole-brain activity mapping onto a zebrafish brain atlas
Discharge properties of morphologically identified vestibular neurons recorded during horizontal eye movements in the goldfish
Evidence for a widespread brain stem escape network in larval zebrafish
Control of visually guided behavior by distinct populations of spinal projection neurons
Spinal projection neurons control turning behaviors in zebrafish
Neurogeometry and potential synaptic connectivity
Statistical mechanics of community detection
Laplacians and the cheeger inequality for directed graphs
Random matrices: universality of ESDs and the circular law
Cyclic structure with cellular precision in a vertebrate sensorimotor neural circuit
A modeling framework for deriving the structural and functional architecture of a short-term memory microcircuit
Optogenetic perturbations reveal the dynamics of an oculomotor integrator
Chronology-based architecture of descending circuits that underlie the development of locomotor repertoire after birth
Homeostatic synaptic plasticity: local and global mechanisms for stabilizing neuronal function
A proposed neural network for the integrator of the oculomotor system
Discharge patterns in nucleus prepositus hypoglossi and adjacent medial vestibular nucleus during horizontal eye movement in behaving macaques
Anatomy and discharge properties of pre-motor neurons in the goldfish medulla that have eye-position signals during fixations
Ramp-to-threshold dynamics in a hindbrain population controls the timing of spontaneous saccades
A model of the neural basis of the rat’s sense of direction
Representation of spatial orientation by the intrinsic dynamics of the head-direction cell ensemble: a theory
Persistent neural activity: prevalence and mechanisms
A tale of two species: neural integration in zebrafish and monkeys
Spatial gradients and multidimensional dynamics in a neural integrator circuit
Encoding of eye position in the goldfish horizontal oculomotor neural integrator
Functional architecture underlying binocular coordination of eye position and velocity in the larval zebrafish hindbrain
Dimensionality reduction reveals separate translation and rotation populations in the zebrafish hindbrain
The mechanics of human saccadic eye movement
Evidence for wide range of time scales in oculomotor plant dynamics: implications for models of eye-movement control
Pattern generation in the lobster (Panulirus) stomatogastric ganglion
Connectome-constrained networks predict neural activity across the fly visual system
Imaging ATUM ultrathin section libraries with WaferMapper: a multi-scale approach to EM reconstruction of neural circuits
Elastic volume reconstruction from series of ultra-thin microscopy sections
VAST (volume annotation and segmentation tool): efficient manual and semi-automatic labeling of large 3D image stacks
An error detection and correction framework for connectomics
31st International Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems (eds
U-Net: convolutional networks for biomedical image segmentation
In 18th International Conference on Medical Image Computing and Computer-Assisted Intervention (eds
Batch normalization: accelerating deep network training by reducing internal covariate shift
32nd International Conference on Machine Learning (eds
Caffe: convolutional architecture for fast feature embedding
22nd ACM International Conference on Multimedia (eds
et al.) 675–678 (Association for Computing Machinery
Kingma, D. P. & Ba, J. Adam: a method for stochastic optimization. Preprint at https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1412.6980 (2014)
Lee, K., Zung, J., Li, P., Jain, V. & Seung, H. S. Superhuman accuracy on the SNEMI3D connectomics challenge. Preprint at https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1706.00120 (2017)
Chunkflow: hybrid cloud processing of large 3D images by convolutional nets
Paszke, A. et al. Automatic differentiation in PyTorch. PyTorch https://pytorch.org/tutorials/beginner/basics/autogradqs_tutorial.html (2017)
Zlateski, A. & Seung, H. S. Image segmentation by size-dependent single linkage clustering of a watershed basin graph. Preprint at https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1505.00249 (2015)
Digital museum of retinal ganglion cells with dense anatomy and physiology
TEASAR: tree-structure extraction algorithm for accurate and robust skeletons
8th Pacific Conference on Computer Graphics and Applications (eds
Robust registration of calcium images by learned contrast synthesis
In 2016 IEEE 13th International Symposium on Biomedical Imaging (ISBI)
A morphological study of abducens nucleus motoneurons and internuclear neurons in the goldfish (Carassius auratus)
Segmental homologies among reticulospinal neurons in the hindbrain of the zebrafish larva
Fast unfolding of communities in large networks
Hierarchical block structures and high-resolution model selection in large networks
Stochastic blockmodels and community structure in networks
Geometry and structural plasticity of synaptic connectivity
Reconstruction and simulation of neocortical microcircuitry
CaImAn an open source tool for scalable calcium imaging data analysis
Estimating regression models with unknown break-points
marks ipsilateral descending excitatory interneurons that participate in the regulation of spinal locomotor circuits
A structural and functional ground plan for neurons in the hindbrain of zebrafish
Sensorimotor computation underlying phototaxis in zebrafish
Download references
Visser for manual annotation and proofreading of neuron reconstructions
Wong for help with image data transformation for Eyewire and A
We acknowledge support from R01 NS104926 and R01 EY027036 (E.R.F.A.
R01 EY021581 and Simons Foundation Global Brain Initiative (E.R.F.A
NIH-NINDS Brain initiative award 5U19NS104648 (M.S.G.)
Intelligence Advanced Research Projects Activity via Department of Interior/Interior Business Center contract number D16PC0005 and assistance from Google
decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript
The US Government is authorized to reproduce and distribute reprints for Governmental purposes notwithstanding any copyright annotation thereon
Present address: Center for Computational Neuroscience
Present address: Department of Physiology and Pharmacology
These authors contributed equally: Alex Sood
These authors jointly supervised this work: H
Institute for Computational Biomedicine and the Department of Physiology and Biophysics
Department of Ophthalmology and Vision Science
performed registration and data analysis and wrote the paper
Sood designed and conceptualized the computational model
performed data analysis and interpretation and wrote the paper
developed the code for data generation and curation in Eyewire
registered and analyzed the light microscopic data and interpreted the data
performed the clustering algorithm comparisons
performed synapse detection and partner assignment
developed Eyewire algorithms and data manipulation software
developed Eyewire algorithms and performed Eyewire system administration
performed Eyewire moderation and data curation
designed and conceptualized the computational model
Eyewirers performed neuron reconstruction online
The remaining authors declare no competing interests
Nature Neuroscience thanks the anonymous reviewers for their contribution to the peer review of this work
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations
a. Connectivity matrix (as in Fig. 2) with identification (arrows) of small RS neurons that were part of the center and inclusion into the periphery of the remaining small RS neurons along with the large RS neurons
Visualization of the large and small classes of RS neurons in the periphery (ro - rostral; c - caudal; m - medial; l - lateral)
Visualization of small vSPNs that are part of the ‘center’ in modA and are indicated by arrows above the rows in a
Histogram of neuronal pathlength in modA (n = 251) and modO (n = 289) for all cells (left)
those with somata in the reconstructed volume (middle)
and those with somata outside the reconstructed volume (right)
p is the significance value based on a two-sided Wilcoxon-rank sum test (RS-test)
Histogram of synaptic size (detected PSD voxels [vx]) for connections within (left) and between (right) modules modA and modO
Table (here and below) summarizes the mean and standard deviations
distance from somata to synaptic site along the neurite
Histogram of synapse sizes (detected PSD) of neurons within-module (left) and between-modules (right) for modOI and modOM
Histogram of synapse locations for neurons within the oculomotor modules modOI and modOM
Connectivity when the center is organized by spectral clustering into two modules
Normalized number of synapses within and between relevant cell groups
Connectome for modO and its connections to the abducens with the eigencentrality threshold for inclusion in the center raised to exclude 25% of the cells that were previously included in the center
Cells are ordered by block identity after fitting a stochastic block model with 8 blocks
an eighth block was needed to sequester the vestibular cells into their own block
Colored rectangles highlight two cycles in the block structure
one connecting primarily to ABDM (orange) and the other primarily to ABDI(purple)
Association matrix for block assignments when segmentation of the center is repeated 100 times after random addition and deletion of synapses according to the estimated precision and recall of synapse detection (see Methods)
a random variation of the connectome caused 0.5% of neurons to change block assignments
Each dot indicates the presence of one or more synapses between two cells in the center network or from a cell in the center to a cell in the periphery
determined by using Louvain clustering to split the center into an axial module (modA) and an oculomotor module (modO)
followed by Stochastic Block Modeling to find substructure in each module
Simulated firing rates for three neurons in response to a sequence of three simulated saccades at intervals of seven seconds (see Methods)
Each trace is normalized to the peak firing rate reached by that neuron during the first fixation
Error bars on the cumulative variance explained (mean) show the standard deviation across the 100 random variations of the network
but for the variations of the network used in b
middle) and eigenvalues (bottom) for 100 networks in which all synapses within modO were shuffled while maintaining the in-degree and out-degree of each cell
the position sensitivities of all shuffled networks (green) are compared to the actual network (gray) for each cell class (VPNI
shuffled networks (x-axis) are compared to the actual network (y-axis) on a cell-by-cell basis
with the colors indicating which block each cell belonged to and opacity indicating the relative frequency of the eye position sensitivities produced for each cell across all of the shuffles
Same as a except that modO was partitioned into two blocks using a stochastic block model (SBM) and each group of synapses within each block and between each pair of blocks was shuffled separately
but with ModO split into two sub-blocks (b) or seven sub-blocks (c) using a stochastic block model
Synapses were shuffled separately for each possible pairing of presynaptic block and postsynaptic block
Stimulating a complex mode of a network gives rise to a linear combination of two spatial patterns of activity
one corresponding to the real part of the eigenvector and one corresponding to the imaginary part
The level of activity in each pattern oscillates over time while the overall amplitude decays
so that each neuron follows a trajectory of the form Ae−ηt sin (ωt + φ)
If the decay is fast enough relative to the frequency of oscillation
as occurs for the complex modes of the internuclear and motor cycles
oscillations will not be evident in the single-neuron firing rates
for the complex mode of the internuclear cycle
a range of potential single-neuron firing rate trajectories corresponding to different phase offsets
from zero initial activity (purple) to maximal initial activity (blue)
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41593-024-01784-3
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
a shareable link is not currently available for this article
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science
The brain region that controls eye movement is structurally similar in fish and mammals
but the zebrafish system contains only 500 neurons
Working with week-old zebrafish larva, researchers at Weill Cornell Medicine and colleagues decoded how the connections formed by a network of neurons in the brainstem guide the fishes’ gaze. The study
found that a simplified artificial circuit
based on the architecture of this neuronal system
In addition to shedding light on how the brain handles short-term memory
the findings could lead to novel approaches for treating eye movement disorders
Organisms are constantly taking in an array of sensory information about the environment that is changing from one moment to the next
the brain must retain these informational nuggets long enough to use them to form a complete picture—for instance
linking together the words in a sentence or allowing an animal to keep its eyes directed to an area of interest
“Trying to understand how these short-term memory behaviors are generated at the level of neural mechanism is the core goal of the project,” said senior author Dr. Emre Aksay
associate professor of physiology and biophysics at Weill Cornell Medicine
Mark Goldman at the University of California Davis and Dr
To decode the behavior of such neuronal circuits
neuroscientists use the tools of dynamical systems
This involves building mathematical models that describe how the state of a system changes over time
where the current state determines its future states according to a set of rules
will remain in a single preferred state until a new stimulus comes along
causing it to settle into a new activity state
each of these states can store the memory of where an animal should be looking
But what parameters help to set up that type of dynamical system
One possibility is the anatomy of the circuit: the connections that form between each neuron and how many connections they make
Another likely possibility is physiological strength of those connections
which is established by a myriad of factors like the amount of neurotransmitter being released
the type of synaptic receptors and the concentration of those receptors
To understand the contributions from circuit anatomy
Aksay and his collaborators looked to larval zebrafish
these fishlets are swimming around and hunting prey
a skill that involves sustained visual attention
the brain region that controls the animals’ eye movement is structurally similar in fish and mammals
But the zebrafish system contains only 500 neurons
we can analyze the entire circuit—microscopically and functionally,” Dr
“That’s very difficult to do in other vertebrates.”
Using an array of advanced imaging techniques
Aksay and colleagues identified the neurons that participate in controlling the animals’ gaze and then determined how these neurons are wired together
They discovered that the system consists of two prominent feedback loops
each containing three clusters of tightly connected cells
The researchers used this distinctive architecture to build a computational model
They found that their artificial network could accurately predict activity patterns of the zebrafish circuit which they validated by comparing their results to physiological data
I was surprised how much of the behavior of the circuit we could predict from the anatomical architecture alone.”
the researchers will explore how the cells in each cluster contribute to the behavior of the circuit—and whether the neurons in the different clusters have distinct genetic signatures
Such information could allow clinicians to therapeutically target those cells that may malfunction in eye movement disorders
The findings also provide a blueprint for unraveling the more complex computational systems in the brain that rely on short-term memory
such as those involved in deciphering visual scenes or understanding speech
This study was supported in part by the National Institutes of Health grants from the National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke R01 NS104926 and Brain initiative award 5U19NS104648; the National Eye Institute R01 EY027036
R01 EY021581 and K99 EY027017; and the National Cancer Institute UH2 CA203710
Back to News
Follow me: X/ Twitter, Telegram and Facebook
Yusuf Güner Aksay, a 41-year-old former teacher who was dismissed from his job by a government decree as part of a post-coup purge in Turkey, has died of brain cancer in the southern province of Mersin, the Kronos news website reported on Sunday
Aksay’s death was announced on social media by opposition deputy and human rights advocate Ömer Faruk Gergerlioğlu
Yine KHK, yine ölüm!Mersin-Tarsus-Olukkoyağıda Yusuf sınıf öğretmeni KHK'li Güner Aksay kolon kanseri ile verdiği mücadeleyi kaybetti, cenaze namazı bugündü.Eşi de KKHlıydı. 2 çocuğu vardı. Cezaevinde 60 ay kaldı, yatarını bitirdi ve tahliye sonrası kansere yakalanmıştı. pic.twitter.com/PuymJT3OGz
Reports also said he was sentenced by a court to more than seven-and-a-half years in prison over his alleged links to faith-based Gülen movement
His wife was also dismissed from her job by a government decree
Aksay was one of the more than 100,000 civil servants summarily dismissed from their jobs as part of the Turkish government’s response to a failed military coup in July 2016
The government declared a state of emergency that lasted for two years during which a series of executive decree-laws saw the mass dismissal of civil servants without due process
In addition to being removed from their jobs and permanently excluded from civil service
the decree-laws also had secondary implications such as being flagged on the social security databases in a way that intimidates potential private sector employers and travel bans preventing victims from seeking employment abroad
Those dismissed were also deprived of any meaningful legal remedy
and a review commission set up by the government in the face of international pressure was slammed by human rights groups due to its lack of independence from political influence and its opaque review procedures
The treatment of the purge victims has been described as “civil death.”
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan has been targeting followers of the Gülen movement
inspired by Turkish Muslim cleric Fethullah Gülen
since the corruption investigations of December 17-25
which implicated then-prime minister Erdoğan
Dismissing the investigations as a Gülenist coup and conspiracy against his government
Erdoğan designated the movement as a terrorist organization and began to target its members
He intensified the crackdown on the movement following the 2016 abortive putsch that he accused Gülen of masterminding
Gülen and the movement strongly deny involvement in the coup attempt or any terrorist activity
In addition to the thousands who were jailed
scores of other Gülen movement followers had to flee Turkey to avoid the government crackdown
traverses have become one of the dominant ways of getting your name in the history books
That’s what happened in Kyrgyzstan last month when a three-person team completed the first-ever traverse of the “Aksay horseshoe,” enchaining 15 peaks in the Tien Shan Mountains in a single
The achievement was announced on the Russian climbing site Mountain.ru. Climbers Tikhon von Stackelberg and Roman Abildaev, led by Egor Matveenko, completed the traverse between Feb
They started with the ascent of Box Peak (4,240m) on the Mikhailov route and finished with the peak of Semyonov-Tyan-Shansky (4,875m)
but a guiding website said that the Aksay Glacier and its surrounding mountains offer some of Kyrgyzstan’s best hiking and climbing
According to Mountain.ru, the horseshoe traverse completed last month includes the following peaks. The numbers correspond to a panoramic photo posted on the site and visible in the above Facebook post. (Russian climbing grade scale and explanation available here.)
An award-winning journalist and photographer
Andrew McLemore brings more than 14 years of experience to his position as Associate News Editor for Lola Digital Media
climber and traveler who currently lives in Medellin
he’s hanging out with his dog Campana
Sign up to receive ExplorersWeb content direct to your inbox once a week
School of Engineering and Applied SciencePrinceton
The International SAMBO Federation (FIAS) is a non-governmental
non-profit organization that unites National SAMBO Federations
FIAS is the only internationally recognized organization responsible for the development of SAMBO worldwide
The FIAS website regularly features SAMBO news
as well as SAMBO videos and photos from SAMBO competitions
It also includes the official competition calendar of the International SAMBO Federation
and other documents regulating tournaments in Sport SAMBO
The dates displayed for an article provide information on when various publication milestones were reached at the journal that has published the article
activities on preceding journals at which the article was previously under consideration are not shown (for instance submission
All content on this site: Copyright © 2025 Elsevier B.V.
Metrics details
Aksay Kazakhs are the easternmost branch of Kazakhs
the genetic diversity of Aksay Kazakhs and its relationships with other Kazakhs still lack attention
we analyzed the non-recombining portion of the Y-chromosome from 93 Aksay Kazakhs samples
using a high-resolution analysis of 106 biallelic markers and 17 STRs
The lowest haplogroup diversity (0.38) was observed in Aksay Kazakhs among all studied Kazakh populations
The social and cultural traditions of the Kazakhs shaped their current pattern of genetic variation
Aksay Kazakhs tended to migrate with clans and had limited paternal admixture with neighboring populations
Aksay Kazakhs had the highest frequency (80%) of haplogroup C2b1a3a1-F3796 (previous C3*-Star Cluster) among the investigated Eurasian steppe populations
which was now seen as the genetic marker of Kerei clan
NETWORK analysis indicated that Aksay Kazakhs originated from sub-clan Kerei-Abakh in Kazakhstan with DYS448 = 23
TMRCA estimates of three recent descent clusters detected in C2*-M217 (xM48) network
one of which incorporate nearly all of the C2b1a3a1-F3796 Aksay Kazakhs samples
respectively; this is coherent with the 7th to the 11th centuries Altaic-speaking pastoral nomadic population expansion
the Kazakhs lived in dome shaped felt tents called yurts
present Kazakhs took up a semi-nomadic or sedentary lifestyle
with only some Kazakhs maintaining the seasonal migrations
The Kazakhs’ marriage system is monogamy in a patrilocal and exogamous way
The genetic relationships of Aksay Kazakhs with other Kazakhs still lack attention
we collected and tested 93 male Kazakh samples from Aksay Kazakh autonomous county in northwestern China
Map with the sampling points of Aksay Kazakhs and other studied Kazakhs
The distributions of the Kazakhs are shown in gray
The phylogenetic relationship of Y-chromosome haplogroups surveyed in this study and their frequencies in the studied Kazakhs is exhibited in the lower half of the figure
The marker names are shown along the branches
and haplogroup names are shown on the right side according to ISOGG Y-DNA Haplogroup Tree 2018
Potentially paraphyletic undefined subgroups are distinguished from recognized haplogroups by the asterisk symbol
Phylogenetic relationship between Aksay Kazakhs and reference populations analyzed by PCA with the frequencies of haplogroups
Reduced Median joining network of Y-chromosome haplogroups C3*-M217(xM48) (a) and haplogroup C2a1a3-M504+s (b)
Haplotypes are represented by circles with area proportional to the number of individual
Different matrilineal contributions to genetic structure of ethnic groups in the silk road region in China
Y-chromosome variation in Altaian Kazakhs reveals a common paternal gene pool for Kazakhs and the influence of Mongolian expansions
Genetic variation in the enigmatic Altaian Kazakhs of South-Central Russia: insights into Turkic population history
History of the Kazakhs in the Gansu province of China
The Y-chromosome C3* Star-Cluster Attributed to Genghis Khan’s Descendants is Present at High Frequency in the Kerey Clan from Kazakhstan
Mitochondrial and Y-chromosomal profile of the Kazakh population from East Kazakhstan
A genetic landscape reshaped by recent events: Y-chromosomal insights into central Asia
Development of the Kazakhstan Y-chromosome haplotype reference database: analysis of 27 Y-STR in Kazakh population
cultural and geographic landscapes of transoxiana
Genetic structure of qiangic populations residing in the western Sichuan corridor
Present Y Chromosomes Refute the Roma/Gypsy Origin of the Xuejiawan People in Northwest China
LI Hui (eds) Languages and Genes in Northwestern China and Adjacent Regions
Hu K, Yan S, Liu K, Ning C, Wei LH, Li SL, et al. The dichotomy structure of Y chromosome Haplogroup N. arXiv:1504.06463 https://arxiv.org/abs/1504.06463v1 (2015)
The effective mutation rate at Y chromosome short tandem repeats
with application to human population-divergence time
Zhang D, Cao G, Xie M, Cui X, Xiao L, Tian C, et al. Y Chromosomal STR haplotypes in Chinese Uyghur, Kazakh and Hui ethnic groups and genetic features of DYS448 null allele and DYS19 duplicated allele. Int J Legal Med. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00414-019-02049-6 (2019)
Whole-sequence analysis indicates that the Y chromosome C2*-Star Cluster traces back to ordinary Mongols
Phylogeography of the Y-chromosome haplogroup C in northern Eurasia
Whole sequence analysis indicates a recent southern origin of Mongolian Y-chromosome C2c1a1a1-M407
Phylogeny of Y-chromosome haplogroup C3b-F1756
an important paternal lineage in Altaic-speaking populations
Y-chromosome descent clusters and male differential reproductive success: young lineage expansions dominate Asian pastoral nomadic populations
Inner Asian states and empires: theories and synthesis
Annals of the autonomous prefecture of Aksai Kazaks
Lanzhou: Gansu People’s Publishing House (1993)
Simple study of the national characteristics Kazak Islamic religion
Download references
We are grateful for the trust of the sample donors
This work was supported by National Social Science Foundation of China (19VJX074)
Scientific and Technology Committee of Shanghai Municipality (18490750300)
National Natural Science Foundation of China (91731303
Innovation Team Project of Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (31920190030)
These authors contributed equally: Shao-Qing Wen
MOE Key Laboratory of Contemporary Anthropology and B&R International Joint Laboratory for Eurasian Anthropology
Key Laboratory of Evidence Science of Gansu Province
Gansu Institute of Political Science and Law
China University of Political Science and Law
Medical College of Northwest Minzu University
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s10038-020-0759-1
The conflicts on this part of the Kyrgyz-Tajik border have become chronic
but there is no progress in resolving this issue yet
Follow us on LinkedIn
The presidents of Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan are preparing for a meeting, during which issues of accelerating the demarcation and delimitation of the disputed parts of the joint border will be discussed. The exact date and place of the event is not reported by their representatives yet. It is known that Jeenbekov will travel to Tajikistan with a working visit, where negotiations on bilateral border cooperation are going to take place.
On the eve of this meeting on July 22 at the Aksay – Voruh area, another conflict occurred between the residents, which resulted in the death of one citizen of Tajikistan and hospitalization of wounded people from both sides, including police officers and border guards.
Since July 22, the Voruh – Isfara highway, which connects the Tajik enclave with its main territory, has been blocked by the residents of the Kyrgyz village of Aksay. In response, the military of Tajikistan blocked the Batken – Leilek highway, which passes through the territory of Tajikistan.
According to the results of the meeting of the heads of the border agencies and the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the two republics, now, law enforcement agencies of Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan are jointly patrolling the border, where the situation is stable.
On the Aksai-Voruh area, conflicts occur annually between local residents due to the absence of the clear borderline.
Despite the latest incident, the scheduled meeting of the two leaders will take place.
Below we present a commentary by a political scientist from Bishkek, Emil Juraev, prepared on this issue:
Bishkek did not forget about its villages in a remote region for so long, but it also leaves these areas of the Batken region with a lower level of attention, with a lower priority compared to larger areas. The Batken events of 1999 and 2000, because of which the Batken region itself was created, became a kind of an alarm clock and the authorities began to pay more attention to this area.
At the moment, there are almost no realistic approaches to solving controversial issues along the border line. Leaving everything as it is, just trying to agree meters and centimeters of the border and drawing the dividing line, even if it is conceivable – it means many controversial issues on water, roads, pastures and other needs that will remain and continue to arise.
To reconcile any exchange of territories, so that some villages can be completely relocated to new places and thus solve the issue of enclaves and other difficulties, is also an almost impossible option, entailing both cost and extreme resistance or dissatisfaction of the inhabitants affected by this exchange.
It would be extremely disadvantageous for Kyrgyzstan to allocate a small territory in order to give way to the village of Voruh to connect with the main territory of Tajikistan – and it would leave the conflict potential of this area as it is.
For a more complex and civilized resolution of the issue – so that the two countries and especially the residents of these areas do not need to line the borders, but live an interconnected, peaceful and good life, it will take even more. First, it is needed to ensure the economic and social development of these areas on a high level, to provide good quality of education, public and legal order, and the build the entire necessary infrastructure.
Establishing peace and resolving these disputes, therefore, will require not only technical work, or only economic, but also sociable: neighboring communities will have to learn to accept each other with respect and trust, and not as enemies.
This article was prepared as part of the Giving Voice, Driving Change – from the Borderland to the Steppes Project implemented with the financial support of the Foreign Ministry of Norway. The opinions expressed in the article do not reflect the position of the editorial or donor.
notify us by selecting that text and pressing Ctrl+Enter
Researchers at Weill Cornell Medicine have identified a population of neurons that drive animal brains to initiate actions without prompting from an external stimulus such as food or prey
The preclinical finding is a significant step toward solving what has been one of the big unanswered questions in neuroscience
The study, published July 6 in Nature Communications
used advanced experimental techniques to monitor the activities of the neurons in larval zebrafish
while also monitoring the fishes’ eye movements
This approach allowed the investigators to identify neurons that
are involved in triggering self-initiated scanning eye movements called saccades
Prior studies in humans and animals have shown that decisions in response to stimuli are often preceded by changes in the firing rates of particular neurons
after which the action occurs – suggesting that a certain level of massed neuronal activity is required for the brain’s “decision” to initiate action
But experimentally demonstrating that this ramping of neuronal activity doesn’t merely precede an action but also triggers it has been more challenging
especially when the action is internally generated rather than influenced by external stimuli
“In this study we were able not only to identify neurons whose activity ramps before spontaneous eye movements, but also to demonstrate for the first time that such ramp activity actually initiates self-driven behavior,” said first author Dr. Alexandro Ramirez, a postdoctoral research associate in the laboratory of Dr. Emre Aksay
an associate professor of physiology and biophysics at Weill Cornell Medicine
Zebrafish are popular lab animals for biological research because they are easy to keep and study
and have a quick life cycle compared to larger species such as mice
their larvae have relatively transparent brains that are highly accessible to modern microscopic imaging
while having a manageable number of neurons
Ramirez and Aksay and their colleagues used advanced techniques including a high-resolution microscopy method called two-photon imaging to monitor the activities of all neurons in the hindbrain
which prior studies have implicated in eye movements
use intermittent saccades to scan their surroundings
and these seemingly spontaneous eye movements happen even in the dark
The researchers mapped the activity patterns in hundreds of thousands of hindbrain neurons in several individual zebrafish larvae and identified a specific set of these neurons whose activity reliably ramps up in the seconds prior to a saccade
The scientists then showed that when they inactivated these pre-saccade neurons
subsequent saccades were delayed – implying that these neurons are involved in initiating saccades
and also suggesting that removal of these neurons reduced the brain’s ability to reach the needed threshold level of massed activity
The findings on their own help demonstrate the causal role of ramping neurons in actions such as saccades
but also demonstrate the broad potential of the zebrafish model for teasing apart the neural circuitry of volitional
“We can observe and manipulate brain cells in real time with this system
and that should allow us in time to get at the detailed cellular and circuit mechanisms that give rise to this pre-action ramping activity,” said Aksay
who is also an associate professor of computational neuroscience in computational biomedicine in the HRH Prince Alwaleed Bin Talal Bin Abdulaziz Al-Saud Institute for Computational Biomedicine at Weill Cornell Medicine
The researchers also hope eventually to set up a screening system to find small molecules that can enhance or inhibit the functions of specific sets of pre-action ramping neurons
“Decision-making circuits similar to the one we examined in this study are involved in a range of behaviors
including those involving higher cognitive functions that are impaired in diseases such as attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder,” Aksay said
“Further understanding of the mechanisms by which this ramping activity arises and can be manipulated will foster treatments for disorders of volitional control.”
Jim Schnabel is a freelance writer for Weill Cornell Medicine
Get Cornell news delivered right to your inbox
Eighteen Princeton University faculty members were transferred to emeritus status in recent action by the Board of Trustees
Kofi Agawu has advanced the study of music across genres
His research spans the disciplines of music scholarship to encompass music theory and analysis
His subjects of inquiry include a broad swath of music — from works by Mozart and Mahler to Schubert and Stravinsky
as well as the music of the Ewe people of his native Ghana
He joined the Princeton faculty in 1998; in the 2006-07
he spent the academic year teaching at Harvard University
He is the author of “Playing With Signs: A Semiotic Interpretation of Classical Music,” the landmark study “African Rhythm: A Northern Ewe Perspective,” “Representing African Music: Postcolonial Notes
Agawu has served as director of graduate studies; mentored students in music history
and ethnomusicology; and attracted scores of undergraduates to his courses on African music
Behrman Award for Distinguished Achievement in the Humanities
He earned his bachelor’s degree from the University of Reading University
a master’s degree from King’s College London and a Ph.D
Ilhan Aksay is a leading researcher in the science and technology of materials processing
He earned his undergraduate degree from the University of Washington-Seattle and his Ph.D
from the University of California-Berkeley
he joined the Princeton faculty as professor in the (then called) Department of Chemical Engineering
Aksay has a history of groundbreaking research throughout his career
He was the principal force behind the measurement and understanding of phase equilibria in the Al2O3-SiO2 system in the 1970s
colloidal processing of ceramics in the 1980s
and bio-inspired processing of materials through self-assembly in the 1990s
an invention led by Aksay and his Princeton colleague
focused his attention on fundamental studies of the properties of these systems and their utility in engineering applications
Many of his scientific studies have resulted in patents (more than 50 U.S
patents issued on key aspects of his work) and been licensed by companies such as Dow Chemical
His depth of understanding of fundamental issues and an innovative approach to problem solving have enabled him to tackle challenging problems in important emerging materials technology areas such as ceramic armor and high-temperature superconductors
Douglas Arnold has broad research interests in American politics
with special interests in congressional politics
He is one of the nation’s leading congressional scholars
He is the author of three core research books: “Congress and the Bureaucracy: A Theory of Influence,” “The Logic of Congressional Action” and “Congress
the Press and Political Accountability.” He is the editor and contributor to two books on the future of Social Security and remains actively engaged in research on this area of public policy
In addition to his service to the politics department
Arnold directed two graduate programs in the Woodrow Wilson School
He earned his bachelor’s degree from Union College and his Ph.D
was founding director of the University’s Andlinger Center for Energy and the Environment
and served as dean of the School of Engineering and Applied Science since 2016
She earned an undergraduate degree from the University of California-Berkeley and her Ph.D
from the California Institute of Technology
Carter has earned wide recognition for fundamental research contributions as well as for her vision for harnessing science and policy to produce lasting solutions to societal problems
including those of energy and the environment
Her research spans the fields of chemistry
applied mathematics and engineering and has included creating quantum mechanical tools for understanding and analyzing the behaviors of large numbers of atoms and electrons in materials
This highly influential work led in recent years to Carter’s research on creating effective fuel cells
using sunlight to generate electricity and make liquid fuels from carbon dioxide and water
and investigating lightweight metal alloys for vehicles and fusion reactor walls
Carter is a member of the National Academy of Sciences
She has written more than 300 scientific publications and delivered 500 invited and plenary lectures worldwide
Among her most cited works are her pioneering advances in “orbital-free density functional theory,” which allow the study of the quantum mechanical interactions of a large number of atoms in a way that was previously impossible
Such work is critical in developing new materials and relating the atomic-level structure of materials with their large-scale performance
She will become the executive vice chancellor and provost of the University of California-Los Angeles
Thomas Funkhouser is one of the world's foremost experts in computer graphics
pioneering the use of computers to analyze
human-computer interaction and machine learning
He earned his bachelor’s degree from Stanford University and his Ph.D
he has been exploring how the machine learning revolution can be extended to 3-D shapes: how deep neural networks can be trained to understand both the details and the overall structure of 3-D environments
including how to predict what might be hidden in parts of the scene that cannot be observed directly
He is a fellow of the Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) as well as the ACM SIGGRAPH Academy
and has received numerous honors and awards including the ACM SIGGRAPH Computer Graphics Achievement Award
Sloan Fellowship and the National Science Foundation CAREER Award
especially in relation to inequality and public policy
He is the author of “Affluence & Influence: Economic Inequality and Political Power in America” and “Why Americans Hate Welfare: Race
Media and the Politics of Anti-Poverty Policy,” and co-author (with Benjamin Page) of “Democracy in America
What Has Gone Wrong and What We Can Do About It.”
Much of his research has been published in the most selective outlets in political science as well as widely recognized outside the discipline
He is a member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences
and his work has been supported by nearly all of the most selective social science grants and fellowships available to scholars of American politics
He has held fellowships at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton
the Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences at Stanford and the Russell Sage Foundation
His work is influential and esteemed in and out of the academy
and has garnered attention from leading news outlets around the globe and across the political spectrum
Gilens earned his bachelor’s degree from the University of California-Santa Cruz and his Ph.D
Carol Greenhouse focuses her research on the discursive and experiential dimensions of state power
especially federal power in the United States
and the reflexive and critical connections — in the U.S
and elsewhere — between ethnography and democracy
She joined the Princeton faculty in 2001 and is a recipient of the President’s Award for Distinguished Teaching
“Praying for Justice: Faith Order and Community in an American Town,” was one of the inaugural texts in contemporary American legal studies within the discipline of anthropology
legal anthropology focused primarily on cultures outside the United States
Greenhouse is also the author of “The Paradox of Relevance: Ethnography and Citizenship in the United States,” “Transnational Law: Cases and Problems in an Interconnected World” (with Alfred Aman Jr) and “Law and Community in Three American Towns” (with Barbara Yngvesson and David Engel); as well as edited volumes
“Democracy and Ethnography: Constructing Identities in Multicultural Liberal States” and “Ethnography in Unstable Places: Everyday Life in Contexts of Dramatic Political Change” (with Elizabeth Mertz and Kay Warren)
Her forthcoming book is “Landscapes of Law: Practicing Sovereignty in Transnational Terrain” (co-edited with Christina Davis)
She is a member of the American Philosophical Society and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences
Hendrik “Dirk” Hartog is a leading historian of law and has spent his scholarly life focused on the difficulties and opportunities that come with studying how broad political and cultural themes have been expressed in everyday legal conflicts
He has worked in a variety of areas of American legal history: on the history of city life
on the history of constitutional rights claims
on the history of slavery and emancipation
and on the historiography of legal change and of legal history
He is the author of “Public Property and Private Power: the Corporation of the City of New York in American Law
1730-1870,” “Man and Wife in America: a History,” “Someday All This Will Be Yours: A History of Inheritance and Old Age,” and “The Trouble with Minna: A Case of Slavery and Emancipation in the Antebellum North.”
He was affiliated with Princeton’s Program in Law and Public Affairs
and from 2006-15 he directed Princeton’s Program in American Studies
diversifying the scope and content of American studies on multiple levels
He received the President’s Award for Distinguished Teaching in 2011 and the Graduate Mentoring Award in 2018.
from New York University School of Law and his Ph.D
Jeremy Kasdin is a leading researcher in the areas of space systems design
He is co-chair of the Science Definition Team for the Wide Field Infra-Red Survey Telescope (WFIRST) mission and adjutant scientist for the Coronagraph Instrument
He has accepted a position at the University of San Francisco and will be named the Eugene Higgins Professor of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering
Kasdin joined the Princeton faculty in 1999
he initiated an interdisciplinary group that drew from many areas including astrophysics
as well as the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton
which met weekly to brainstorm about searching for Earth-like planets
The coronagraph approach to planet imaging was an outcome of these conversations
and it inspired NASA to change its perspective on the best method for exoplanet imaging.
Jeremy also had an affiliated appointment in the Department of Astrophysical Sciences
Jeremy led a collaborative team investigating high-contrast imaging techniques for detecting and characterizing terrestrial exoplanets
That group has pioneered the use of pupil-plane coronagraphs and external occulters for space-based imaging
The Princeton team also developed some of the key techniques for wavefront control with a coronagraph
He earned his bachelor’s degree from Princeton and his Ph.D
as the number of undergraduates concentrating in computer science grew from 25 per year to more than 160
LaPaugh was one of the professors who organized and coordinated the advising of undergraduate independent work
and served effectively as departmental representative from 2014-18
running the largest undergraduate concentration in the University’s history
She also served 2000-04 as the head of Forbes College
during which time she participated in the planning for Princeton’s transition to the four-year residential college system
Anson Rabinbach is a specialist in modern European history with an emphasis on intellectual and cultural history who has served on Princeton’s faculty since 1996
He has published extensively on Nazi Germany
Austria and European thought in the 19th and 20th centuries
He earned his bachelor’s degree from Hofstra University and his Ph.D
He is the author of “The Crisis of Austrian Socialism: From Red Vienna to Civil War 1927-1934,” “The Human Motor
“In the Shadow of Catastrophe: German Intellectuals Between Enlightenment and Apocalypse” and “The Third Reich Sourcebook (with Sander Gilman)
He helped co-found the journal New German Critique in 1974 and served for many years on the editorial board of Dissent magazine
His current research is on concepts invented in the 20th century
It emphasizes World War II exchanges between European and American intellectuals
Harvey Rosen helped shaped the field of public finance as a researcher
author and professor at Princeton for 45 years
He also has served as the director of the Center for Economic Policy Studies at Princeton
He has published over 80 academic articles
many in the leading journals of economics. His research interests span numerous areas in public finance
including the effects of taxation on labor supply
He wrote two undergraduate textbooks, “Microeconomics” (with Michael Katz) and “Public Finance.”
Rosen served at the Treasury Department as the deputy assistant secretary (tax analysis) in the first Bush administration
he served on the President’s Council of Economic Advisers in the second Bush administration
he received the National Tax Association’s most prestigious award
Holland Medal for distinguished lifetime contributions to the study and practice of public finance
which opened as Princeton's sixth residential college in fall 2007
He was a member of the Four-Year College Program Planning Committee
helping to develop the blueprint for the new system
He earned his bachelor’s degree from the University of Michigan and his Ph.D
Jorge Sarmiento studies and models ocean circulation
and the impacts of circulation and metabolism on the oceanic distribution of those elements involved in biological cycles (primarily CO2
He came to Princeton as a 1978 as a research associate and became a faculty member in 1980
he also serves as the director of the Southern Ocean Carbon and Climate Observations and Modeling Program (SOCCOM)
a six-year NSF funded program established in 2014 with scientists at eight American institutions and multiple foreign collaborators
SOCCOM members are engaged in observing and modeling the physical circulation of the Southern Ocean and the large-scale processes linking biological carbon fluxes and ocean chemistry
providing information about the nature and activity of Southern Ocean ecosystems
He was the long-time director of the Program in Atmospheric and Oceanic Sciences at Princeton and the director and scientific leader of the Cooperative Institute for Climate Science
a collaboration between Princeton and NOAA
and the Cooperative Institute for Modeling the Earth System
Sarmiento is co-author (with Nicolas Gruber) of the graduate textbook “Ocean Biogeochemical Dynamics.” He served as an associated faculty member with the Andlinger Center for Energy and the Environment
the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering
He earned his bachelor’s degree from Swarthmore College and his Ph.D
David Spergel is an astrophysicist with research interests ranging from the search for planets around nearby stars to the shape of the universe
He joined the faculty in 1987 and received the President’s Award for Distinguished Teaching in 2013
Using microwave background observations from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Satellite and the Atacama Cosmology Telescope
These observations have played a significant role in establishing the standard model of cosmology
He is one of the leaders of the Simons Observatory
which will include a planned millimeter-wave telescope that will enable the next step in studying the microwave sky and probing the history of the universe
Spergel is co-chair and is shaping the overall mission of the Wide Field Infrared Survey Telescope (WFIRST) science team
which will study the nature of dark energy
complete the demographic survey of extrasolar planets
characterize the atmospheres of nearby planets
and survey the universe with more than 100x the field of view of the Hubble Space Telescope
He is an associate faculty member in the Department of Physics
Spergel was awarded a MacArthur Foundation grant in 2001 and is the recipient of the 2010 Shaw Prize and the 2015 Dannie Heineman Prize for his breakthroughs in our understanding of the universe
he received the Breakthrough Prize in Fundamental Physics
as well as NASA’s Exceptional Public Service Medal
awarded to any nongovernment individual for important contributions to NASA projects
He is a member of the National Academy of Sciences and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences
Jacqueline Stone is an internationally acclaimed leader in the study of Japanese Buddhism
Her current research areas include death and dying in Buddhist cultures
and traditions of the “Lotus Sutra,” particularly Tendai and Nichiren
She is the author of “Original Enlightenment and the Transformation of Medieval Japanese Buddhism,” and “Right Thoughts at the Last Moment: Buddhism and Deathbed Practices in Early Medieval Japan.” She has co-edited “The Buddhist Dead: Practices
“Readings of the Lotus Sutra” (with Stephen F
Suzuki Professor in Buddhist Studies at Princeton)
she was elected to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences
she received a President’s Award for Distinguished Teaching from Princeton
She earned her bachelor’s degree from San Francisco State University and her Ph.D
James Stone is a leading researcher on the use of large-scale direct numerical simulations to study the gas dynamics of a wide range of astrophysical systems
from protostars to clusters of galaxies. He has also made important contributions to understanding the structure and evolution of the interstellar and intergalactic medium
he received the Brouwer Award in recognition of outstanding contributions to the field of dynamical astronomy
He received his bachelor’s from Queens University in Kingston
Eric Wood works in the areas of hydroclimatology with an emphasis on land-atmosphere interactions for climate models and for water resource management
He is also known for the enormous impact he has had on the field of hydrology — through teaching
mentoring graduate students and professional service to the global scientific community
he made significant advances that moves the field closer to realizing the promise of global hydrology
Eric proposed the development of hyperresolution land surface models
which enabled discovery of patterns of river flows
floods and drought at scales ranging from regional to global
in 2017 Eric was awarded the American Geophysical Union’s highest honor in hydrology
He is widely recognized as a visionary in examining Earth's water cycle
having shed new light on the role of water in the climate system and developing groundbreaking analytical tools
He will remain at Princeton as a senior scholar
continuing to develop hyperresolution land surface models
He will pursue new research avenues modeling infectious disease transmission and its relation to highly resolved hydrologic processes
Wood earned his bachelor’s degree from the University of British Columbia and his Ph.D
Her research focuses on DNA replication and chromosome structure in yeast
telomeres and replication fork progression
She has contributed groundbreaking insights into the nature and function of telomeres
the unusual structures at the ends of eukaryotic chromosomes
Her lab also discovered and characterized the first eukaryotic accessory DNA helicases
which are enzymes that allow the replication fork to move past hard-to-replicate sites such as stable protein complexes and DNA secondary structures
Her influential contributions to the understanding of telomeres has been recognized by many honors
including election to the National Academy of Sciences and
to the American Academy of Arts and Sciences
She has been continuously funded by the National Institutes of Health since 1979
and was awarded a prestigious Merit Award in 2000
A champion of expanding the participation of women and underrepresented minorities in science
she has participated in efforts at both Princeton and around the country to bring greater diversity to the discipline
She received her bachelor’s from Cornell University and her Ph.D
Metrics details
Organisms have the capacity to make decisions based solely on internal drives
it is unclear how neural circuits form decisions in the absence of sensory stimuli
Here we provide a comprehensive map of the activity patterns underlying the generation of saccades made in the absence of visual stimuli
We perform calcium imaging in the larval zebrafish to discover a range of responses surrounding spontaneous saccades
from cells that display tonic discharge only during fixations to neurons whose activity rises in advance of saccades by multiple seconds
When we lesion cells in these populations we find that ablation of neurons with pre-saccadic rise delays saccade initiation
We analyze spontaneous saccade initiation using a ramp-to-threshold model and are able to predict the times of upcoming saccades using pre-saccadic activity
These findings suggest that ramping of neuronal activity to a bound is a critical component of self-initiated saccadic movements
inputs that could be a source of confounding signals
none of these studies could unambiguously report on the activity of individual neurons since calcium sensors were distributed throughout the cell
potentially introducing neuropil contamination
We combined two-photon calcium imaging and single-cell perturbations to identify a population of neurons controlling the timing of upcoming saccades
Our combined imaging and perturbation study provides three notable findings
we generated a comprehensive map of neuronal activity patterns underlying spontaneous saccades and subsequent fixations—these maps are generated while animals are in the dark
ensuring that the signals are internally generated
and with a nuclear-localized calcium sensor
we found neurons in the hindbrain whose activity rises above baseline in a direction-selective manner multiple seconds before the decision to saccade
the time and rate of rise of these cells is consistent with a ramp-to-threshold model
which can be used to predict saccade timing
evidence implicating these cells in controlling the proper patterning of spontaneous saccades
These findings not only provide insights into the mechanisms controlling the choice of when to shift gaze
but also establish a new model system for understanding the neuronal processes underlying spontaneous
These results show that larval zebrafish can self-initiate a simple yet varying pattern of horizontal eye movements
We will refer to cells with significant STAs as eye-movement responsive
This pre-saccadic rise is suggestive of activity that is involved in the timing of upcoming saccades
a role which we will explore further in the remainder of this paper
we found that ~5% of hindbrain neurons in larval zebrafish had responses associated with spontaneous saccades and fixations
and the response profile of this population was diverse
The diversity included cells with step-like profiles expected for ABD neurons and integrator neurons
and cells with burst-like responses expected for saccade generator neurons
The distribution also contained neurons whose activity is better described as anticipating upcoming movements
consistent with a role in saccade initiation
Within the continuum described above were cells whose population average activity steadily rose ahead of the upcoming saccade
Because this form of dynamics appears to anticipate a future movement
it is reasonable to speculate that neurons with such activity play an important role in saccadic preparation or timing
We now turn our attention to a closer examination of such neurons
with a focus on single-trial and single-cell level analyses that can capture variations missed with averaging
pre-saccadic rise events occurred ahead of saccades in one direction
although there were occasions where cell activity also rose before saccades in the opposite direction or failed to rise
dF/F for a small number of cells (n = 5) was significantly correlated with upcoming saccades in both directions
Given the small number of these cells we did not consider them in further analyses
Rise events generally lasted multiple seconds
and there was variability in the duration and rate of the rise both within and across cells
activity tended to rise to consistent values at the time of saccade
even though duration of rise varied by 50% or more
We will refer to these cells as pre-saccadic rise (SR) neurons
To quantitatively characterize the dynamics of SR cells, we assessed several features of their activity before and at the time of saccade that could elucidate their role in initiating the upcoming spontaneous saccade (Fig. 4b and “Methods”)
To examine how the initiation of activity related to saccade occurrence
we measured the time when activity rose above baseline
and compared that to the time of upcoming and previous saccades
We also measured whether the time of activity rise scaled with fixation duration
To determine whether neuronal activity consistently rose to similar values
we measured activity at the time of saccade
the activity of SR neurons is more informative of upcoming saccades than previous saccades
we found that SR cell activity can rise within any fraction of the fixation time
to begin rising later in the fixation for longer fixation durations
If SR cell activity determines when a spontaneous saccade should occur
we should be able to predict whether a saccade is about to happen based on the output of SR populations
we show that SR pre-saccadic dynamics can be used to predict saccade direction and time
we also detail the relationships between the time at which an SR cell begins rising ahead of a saccade and the speed at which activity rises
and 94% using single-cell activity or population averages consisting of 4 or 16 cells
an ideal observer who has knowledge of the saccade transition probabilities would guess that an upcoming saccade is directed towards the opposite direction of the previous saccade and be correct 77% of the time (given that successive saccades occur in the same direction 23% of the time
see section Larval zebrafish generate spontaneous eye movements with a range of inter-saccade times)
the CP performance is better than the performance of an ideal observer
These results indicate that spontaneous SR population activity contain information regarding the upcoming saccade direction
an ideal observer who has knowledge of the time of previous saccade and knowledge of the fixation duration probability distribution predicted saccade times with a timing error of 51%
and could not produce predictions that are correlated to the actual saccade times (cc = 0.00; see “Methods”)
the pre-saccadic dynamics of SR population activity can be used to predict when saccades will occur
It is unknown where the signals to initiate spontaneous saccade arise
The activity of the SR neurons we identified suggest that they initiate saccades when their population level activity reaches a threshold value
In the simplest instantiation of this model
activity is summed across cells and compared with a threshold value
losses in the number of SR cells would lead to a longer time until saccades occur
These results provide evidence for a hindbrain role in spontaneous saccade initiation
but significant correlation between increase in fixation duration and estimated fraction of ablated SR cells
we measured the effect on fixation duration after ablating single SR neurons
we observed an increase in fixation duration after ablating a small number of hindbrain neurons
The magnitude of the increase was largest when we specifically targeted SR cells
Both cluster and single-cell ablation experiments suggest that SR neurons play a significant role in the preparation for spontaneous saccades
We combined focal laser ablations and calcium imaging to comprehensively map neuronal function and activity during a self-initiated behavior
We simultaneously measured eye movements and neuronal activity throughout the hindbrain of larval zebrafish
while they made spontaneous saccades in the dark
We discovered neurons in the hindbrain whose activity rises above baseline in a direction-selective manner multiple seconds before the occurrence of a saccade
a causal role for these cells in the decision to perform a spontaneous saccade
These data thus help elucidate the mechanism of a simple self-initiated behavior
Our discovery of SR neurons in the hindbrain depended upon a comprehensive
single-cell resolution map of activity during spontaneous eye movements in the dark
Comprehensive spatial coverage was obtained by two-photon calcium imaging
which allowed us to image activity even at the deepest regions of the hindbrain where one-photon approaches suffer from poor resolution and signal-to-noise
Single-cell resolution of activity was ensured by coupling two-photon microscopy with nuclear-localization of the calcium sensor
allowing us to distinguish the activity profiles of even closely packed neurons
We maintained a focus on internally generated dynamics by monitoring activity while animals made spontaneous saccades in the absence of any visual cues
This effort allowed us to identify both a broad spatial distribution of the various signal types and strong regional characteristics
including a pronounced switch in the directional sensitivity of eye-position-related signals as one crosses from rhombomere 1 to 2
a clustering of burst neurons in the ventral portions of rhombomeres 2 and 3
and a high density of SR neurons in dorsal portions of rhombomeres 2 and 3
it will be of interest in the future to determine what role SR neurons play in orientation behaviors more broadly
build a solid foundation for exploring and understanding how visual and volitional signals are combined and transformed into motor commands for oculomotor behavior and potentially other orientation tasks
Our comprehensive mapping of this buildup activity enabled us to show a titration between the degree of disruption to the readiness signal and delays in the initiation of saccades
single-cell ablations of SR neurons led to significant delay in saccade initiation that was two-fold greater than any delays following ablation of nearby non-SR cells
These results suggest that the spontaneous decision to move the eyes requires the buildup of activity in SR cells
Our work thus builds upon prior studies of signaling during voluntary movements by drawing a direct link between readiness signals and self-initiated movement
which would preclude us from seeing certain dynamical properties
such as approximate linear ramping activity of SR cells
weaker nonlinearities not accounted for in our analysis can cause discrepancies in our estimates of firing rate
particularly at low values and high values following saccades in burst and burst-tonic neurons
These discrepancies can also cause the slope and time of rise of SR cells to be artificially shortened from the actual times
the systematic nature of such nonlinearities would still allow us to observe the coarse dynamical profiles of cell responses and properties
such as the dependence of slope on time of rise
it is possible that the SR signal in the hindbrain provides the initial kernel of activity needed to prepare movement during cued behaviors
The mechanistic insights that one can obtain on readiness in larval zebrafish will hopefully allow us to understand a broad set of decision-making processes
the experimenter manually selected (using roipoly in MATLAB) a region-of-interest about which the eyes were free to move
Pixels within the region-of-interest whose intensity values were below a manually selected threshold were classified as belonging to the eyes
The threshold was chosen during the experiment by manually trying various values and selecting the one that achieved the best segmentation quality
two ellipses were fit to the resulting binary image using the MATLAB regionprops function
Eye position equaled the orientation of the fitted ellipse about its time-averaged value
We used the MATLAB “\” operator to solve the affine transformation \({\bf{y}}={\bf{Tx}}\,{\boldsymbol{+}}\,{{\bf{T}}}_{{\bf{0}}}{\boldsymbol{\otimes }}{\bf{1}}\) for the 3 × 3 matrix
and the 3 × 1 translation vector \({{\bf{T}}}_{{\bf{0}}}\)
where \({\bf{y}}\) and \({\bf{x}}\) are the 3 × k matrices of points chosen from the bridge brain and brain being registered respectively
\({\bf{1}}\) is a k × 1 vector of all ones and \({\boldsymbol{\otimes }}\) denotes the outer product
We repeated this procedure to find corresponding points and an associated transformation matrix between the bridge brain and the Elavl3-H2B brain (Elavl3 is another name for the HuC gene) available on the Z-Brain website
which implements image registration via cross-correlation
The dftregistration algorithm estimates the peak in the two-dimensional cross-correlation between the reference image and movie frame being registered
Each movie frame is then translated by an amount determined from the peak location
the dftregistration algorithm works in Fourier space to calculate cross-correlations
We used MATLAB’s built-in fast Fourier transform software (fft2) to compute each frame’s two-dimensional discrete Fourier transform (DFT) and to compute the two-dimensional DFT of the reference frame
The motion-correction algorithm described above returned a scalar metric for each movie frame that indicated how well the frame matched the reference after correction
the frame was considered too aberrant to be useful and the fluorescence of all pixels in this frame were replaced by NaNs
the dftregistration algorithm returned an error value related to the square root of one minus peak
normalized cross-correlation between a given frame and the reference
we computed the median error across all frames and the median absolute deviation (MAD) of the error across all frames
If a given frame’s error value was greater than five times the MAD plus the median that frame’s pixels were replaced by NaNs
The algorithm models a calcium fluorescence movie as the product of two nonnegative matrices
one containing spatial locations and the other containing calcium time series for each active cell
To determine the nonnegative matrices that best-fit the data
we implemented a procedure based on the demo_script.m file provided with the code
After initializing the spatial and temporal components
we ran one iteration of spatial and temporal updates
where components correlated with each other were merged and components that were poorly correlated with the data were removed
followed by a final spatial and temporal update
We first found initial estimates for the spatial
This function ran several steps: (1) it spatially filtered the fluorescence movies (Gaussian kernel with standard deviation set to 5
(2) It greedily selected locations where the spatial estimates explained the largest amount of spatio-temporal variance
nonnegative matrix factorization to produce spatial
(4) It refined these estimates using a hierarchical
(5) It ran a rank 1 nonnegative matrix factorization on the spatio-temporal residual to initialize the background spatial and temporal components
We updated the initial estimates of the spatial footprints and the background component
using the constrained nonnegative Lasso algorithm implemented in the update_spatial_components function
We used the dilate option which restricted the search of possible nonzero component values to a dilated version of that component’s nonzero values found in the previous iteration (dilation was performed using a 4-pixel radius (1.4 µm) disk-shaped structuring element)
The new components are then post-processed by the following operations: (i) two-dimensional median filtering with a default size of 3 × 3 pixels
(ii) morphological closing with a square-shaped structuring element (3 pixels long)
and (iii) “energy” thresholding with threshold set to 0.99
We then updated the estimates of the temporal components using the update_temporal_components function with an auto-regressive parameter
This function updated components using a block-coordinate descent algorithm (we used two iterations) which
ran a thresholding operation (at a threshold of 0) on the activity of each component after removing the effect of all the other components
we removed spatial or temporal components that were poorly correlated with the raw data (space and time r values returned by classify_comp_corr function were <0.05) or whose spatial footprint areas were smaller than a value of 16 pixels squared which equaled 2.1 µm2
We then merged spatially overlapping components with highly correlated temporal activity (cc > 0.95)
VPNI cells were selected as cells in rhombomeres 5–8 whose Pearson correlation coefficient between fluorescence and eye position was reasonably high (>0.5)
As an initial approximation of the effects of calcium buffering on the relationship between firing rate and eye position
we convolved the eye position using an exponential decay kernel with a 1-s decay time before measuring the correlation
We then fit a decaying exponential function (\(A{e}^{-t/\tau }+b\)) to the average fluorescence triggered around nasally directed saccades made by the eye ipsilateral to the cell
\(b\) was chosen as the average value of the ipsiversive STA 1–2 s prior to saccade
\(A\) and \(\tau\) were found by minimizing the squared error between the model and data using an interior-point algorithm (MATLAB fmincon) with \(\tau\) constrained to be positive and \(A\) constrained to be larger than \(b\)
We used the median value of \(\tau\) from cells that were well fit by the exponential decay model (r2 > 0.8)
as the parameter for the auto-regressive model (we converted the value from seconds to the equivalent discrete-time model)
sparse deconvolved output from this temporal update as our estimate of deconvolved neural activity
We estimated each component’s noisy fluorescence activity as the trace that resulted after spatially averaging the fluorescence video using that component’s spatial values as weights
We registered each cell to a reference brain (see “Methods” section “Registration of individual planes to the Z-Brain atlas”) and excluded cells that were registered to the midbrain
we analyzed time-averaged images to infer cell locations since the CaImAn algorithm cannot find non-active cells (non-active cells are included as part of a single background term)
For each motion-corrected fluorescence movie
we calculated the median intensity across time for each pixel and analyzed the resulting time-averaged image to find individual cell nuclei locations
We performed a morphological opening on the time-averaged image (MATLAB function imopen) with a disk-shaped structuring element that had a radius equal to 4 pixels (1.4 µm)
The opening operation with this structuring element tended to make it easier to segregate the disk-shaped nuclei in the image
We then found local intensity maxima of the opened image by looking for connected pixels with equal intensity that were greater than the intensity of external boundary pixels (MATLAB function imregionalmax)
We measured the locations of individual cell nuclei measuring the regions of connected pixels that corresponded to local intensity maxima
we excluded any regions-of-interest that had an area greater than most cell nuclei areas
which we determined by manual measurements (18.7 µm2 which translated to 144 pixels squared)
We determined the times of saccade occurrence by calculating the crossing times of eye velocity past a threshold
we first filtered out fluctuations in eye position using a median filter (medfilt1 in MATLAB)
The exact value of the filter order depended on the eye position sampling rate
but was chosen to correspond to 500 milliseconds
We then approximated eye velocity as the difference in filtered eye position at consecutive time points divided by the time difference between these points
The threshold was set to three standard deviations above the mean-absolute velocity or 10° s−1
A single saccadic event typically consisted of several consecutive points whose velocity was above the threshold
We took the initial point as the time when the saccade occurs
During head/body movements the eye position traces become corrupted
One signature we used to determine when head/body movements occur is the time between threshold-crossing events (this signature was used in combination with the criteria listed in “Methods” section “Detecting samples corrupted by animal movement”)
Separate experiments with video recordings of the entire body suggested that unusually short intervals between events typically indicate that the events occur during sudden head/body movements
we did not consider threshold-crossing events that were spaced apart in time 1.4 s or less to be saccades
We measured the lower and upper bounds of the confidence intervals as the 0.025 and 0.975 quantiles across the bootstrapped samples
This procedure varied the significance level for each comparison by the formula \(\frac{\alpha }{N-j+1}\)
where \(j\) was the index of the comparison after sorting p values from low to high
\(\alpha\) was the desired family-wise error rate
and \(N\) was the total number of comparisons
We set \(\alpha\) to 0.01 and set the number of comparisons to 72,304 (36,152 active cells with STAs available for analysis times two to account for both saccade directions
see “Methods” section “Saccade-triggered average calculation”)
We rejected the null hypothesis for 6,712 cells (19% of 36,152 active cells)
The probability that a hindbrain cell is eye-movement responsive is therefore 0.05 (the probability that a given active hindbrain cell is eye-movement responsive
times the probability that a hindbrain cell is active
We ran a PCA to search for lower-dimensional representations of STAs across the population of eye-movement responsive cells
We combined STAs of deconvolved fluorescence from all eye-movement responsive cells (across all planes and fish recorded) and from both directions (around saccades to the left and right) resulting in a matrix
that had \(N=13\text{,}424\) rows (6,712 cells times two directions) and \(T=31\) columns (time around the saccade is evaluated at 31 discrete-time bins of size 1/3 s)
To focus our analysis on the variations in dynamics across cells
we divided each STA by its L2 norm before performing PCA
and \({c}_{i3}\) are plotted on the \({c}_{1}\)-axis
We normalized these coefficients to have unit norm
for \(i=1,\ldots ,N\), \(j=1,2,3\). We then transformed \({{\bf{c}}}^{\prime}\) into spherical coordinates (see Fig. 3c)
Statistics and Machine Learning Toolbox function ksdensity with bandwidth parameter equal to 10° for \({\boldsymbol{\Phi }}\) and 3° for \({\boldsymbol{\Theta }}\))
Each population average shown in Fig. 3g is constructed by averaging together all non-normalized STAs triggered to saccades to the left with a specific value of \(\phi\)
the average under the column \(\phi\) = 105 was constructed by first finding the STAs triggered to saccades to the left with \(\phi\) within 15° of 105 and then averaging these together
Letting \({{\bf{f}}}_{i,:}\) denote the \({i}{{\rm{th}}}\) STA and \({{\mathcal{S}}}_{105}\) denote the set of integers that index leftward STAs with \(\phi\) = 105
\({{\mathcal{S}}}_{105}=\big\{i|{97.5\le \Phi }_{i} \,<\
112.5,\text{and}{{\bf{f}}}_{{\boldsymbol{i}},}:\,\text{is}\,\
\text{leftward} \,\,\text{saccades}\big\}\)
the population average under the column \(\phi\) = 105 is computed as
are constructed using all principal components and only use the angles in \({\boldsymbol{\Phi }}\) to group STAs
the population averages that are displayed can reflect variations not captured by the first three components
K-means was used to cluster the normalized coefficients (defined in Eq. (3) and associated text) found by PCA on STAs from eye-movement responsive cells (Supplementary Fig. 2)
we focused on the normalized coefficients that scale the first three principal components
We created a six-dimensional vector by combining the normalized coefficients that correspond to the STA triggered to saccades to the left and right
using a different number of clusters on each run (between 2 and 10) to group the combined coefficients
and we used the silhouette value to measure cluster quality
The silhouette value for an individual vector measures how close that vector is to other vectors in its own cluster relative to its distance with vectors in other clusters
The value for the \({i}{{\rm{th}}}\) vector is defined as the minimum average distance from the \({i}{{\rm{th}}}\) vector to all vectors in different clusters than the \({i}{{\rm{th}}}\) vector
minus the average distance from the \({i}{{\rm{th}}}\) vector to other vectors in the same cluster
The silhouette value is normalized by max(ai
bi) in order for it to range from +1 to −1 with vectors that are well matched to their cluster having values near +1
and with vectors that are randomly clustered having values near 0
The color displayed was determined by the value where the histogram peaked or
in cases where the histogram had multiple modes
was determined by the value at a randomly chosen peak
An eye-movement responsive cell was classified as an SR cell if its dF/F response before upcoming saccades was significantly correlated with time before saccade
We measured two Spearman correlations for each eye-movement responsive cell
Statistics and Machine Learning Toolbox function corr with option type set to Spearman) on values of dF/F and time before saccade concatenated from all fixations before saccades to the left
The other correlation was computed on values of dF/F and time before saccade concatenated from all fixations before saccades to the right
The Spearman correlation can be used to measure monotonic (not only linear) relationships between two variables \(X\) and \(Y\)
It is calculated as the standard Pearson correlation coefficient applied to the ranks of \(X\) and \(Y\)
We did not interpolate fluorescence activity before computing the correlation coefficients
Since we were interested in cells whose activity is related to upcoming saccade
we did not include activity that was within 2 s of the previous saccade
where eye-movement responsive cells might have post-saccadic fluorescence decays
We computed a p value for each correlation by testing the hypothesis that rho = 0 against the alternative that the correlation was greater than 0 (tail option set to right)
A neuron was considered to have significant pre-saccadic activity if we rejected the null hypothesis for any of the cell’s two correlation coefficients at a significance level of 0.01
we used the Holm–Bonferroni method (as described in “Methods” section “Selection of eye-movement responsive cells”) with the number of comparisons set to 13,424 (the number of eye-movement responsive cells times two directions)
as the time point before its deconvolved fluorescence increased >0.1
We estimated the rate of pre-saccadic rise in SR cells by finding the slope of the best-fit line of pre-saccadic deconvolved fluorescence with time
To construct the best-fit line we used time from pre-saccadic rise to the time of upcoming saccade as a regressor to a linear regression that fit deconvolved fluorescence values
The linear approximation was reasonable for 72% of the fixations (correlation between regression fit and data was >0.4)
We excluded fixations where we were unable to measure the slope with linear regression
We predicted saccade direction using interpolated SR activity before saccadic events
the phrase “interpolated SR activity” refers to linear interpolation of deconvolved fluorescence activity to a grid of equally spaced time points (using 1/3 s bins) starting from the previous saccade to the upcoming saccade
the CP measures relationships between neuronal discharges and binary behavioral choices
We adapted this metric by using the spontaneous decision to saccade to the left or the right as our binary behavioral variable
and population average deconvolved fluorescence at a given time before saccade as our neural read-out
At discrete time points before upcoming saccades
we made two histograms of interpolated SR activity
was comprised of values of interpolated SR activity before saccades to the right (left) from SR cells significantly correlated with upcoming saccades to the left (right)
was comprised of interpolated SR activity before saccades to the left (right) from SR cells significantly correlated with upcoming saccades to the left (right)
Saccade direction was predicted using a threshold on population activity
We plotted the fraction of interpolated SR activity from the signal distribution that was above threshold (the true positive rate) versus the fraction of interpolated SR activity from the noise distribution that was above threshold (the false positive rate) across multiple threshold values
The CP was calculated as the area under the resulting curve
which would equal 0.5 if activity and upcoming saccade direction were not related
we computed multiple CPs each conditioned on a different fixation duration (fixing durations to values 2–20 s) and then computed the CP SEM across fixation durations
We modeled the population average dynamics
at values of time \(t\) after population activity begins to rise
where \(D\) is the population activity slope
a saccade will occur and \(y\) should equal \(\kappa\) if the ramp-to-threshold model is accurate
We constructed a running estimate of \(D\) by first measuring when the actual population activity, \(\widetilde{y}\left(t\right),\) began to rise. Note that we are distinguishing the population activity measured from data, \(\widetilde{y}\left(t\right)\), from the model of population activity, \(y(t)\), specified by Eq. (8)
We measured when \(\widetilde{y}\left(t\right)\) began to rise as the time when the derivative in \(\widetilde{y}\left(t\right)\) crossed a threshold of 35 (arbitrary units)
Note that under our convention we set this event to occur at time 0
The derivative was approximated as the difference between population activity at each time point divided by the interpolated time bin interval
We created a running estimate of \(D\) using the median value of the derivative from time 0 until time
We substituted our running estimate of the slope into Eq. (9) to yield a running estimate of \({t}_{r}\)
We then tested this prediction against a new measurement of population activity constructed from the remaining 40% of cells
we repeated this procedure on 10,000 randomly selected subsets from randomly chosen fixation durations
we determined the fraction of saccades that could be accurately predicted given knowledge of the elapsed time since last saccade and the distribution of fixation durations
an ideal observer could predict upcoming saccade times by guessing a time that minimizes some cost function that measures error between the actual saccade time and the guessed time
We tried three cost functions (mean-squared error
and all-or-none error) and report results in the text from the one that performed the best (all-or-none error)
We repeated this procedure until we saw a lesion
which we determined by looking for a multi-spectrum spot that was much brighter than the fluorescence of surrounding tissue
Lesion sizes with this procedure were generally ~5 µm in diameter
To increase the size of the lesion we lowered the average laser power to values of 30–50 mW and scanned the ablated region at these lower powers
We stopped scanning the ablated region once it grew to ~30 µm in diameter
We waited between 30 and 120 min after ablation before recording post-lesion eye movements
The fraction ablated was equal to \({n}_{c}\) divided by the total number of SR cells used to construct the map
ablations did not occur even after three to five attempts
most likely due to laser power absorption from pigmentation
We did not try to ablate a cell after attempts
we repeated three cycles of finding cells of interest in a single plane
then searching for more cells of interest in subsequent planes
we took time-averaged images of the entire hindbrain dorsal of the Mauthner cell and used this stack to register ablated cells to the Z-Brain Atlas
we performed the same procedure but targeted cells that failed to pass our criteria for being considered eye-movement responsive
For each fish, we measured fractional changes in median fixation duration after ablation. Since we were concerned with a spontaneous behavior, we could not control the number of fixations that were recorded during the timeframe of each experiment. As a result, our measurements would have had different accuracies per animal (Supplementary Table 1)
if we calculated fractional changes without accounting for the different number of samples per fish
To control for this difference in accuracy
we made repeated measurements of the fractional change per fish with each repeated measurement computed using the same number of fixations before and after ablation
we randomly sampled without replacement \({N}_{{{\min }}}\) fixations before and after ablation
The exact value of \({N}_{{{\min }}}\) was based on animals with the fewest number of fixations available after excluding animals that stopped making saccades after ablation; animals whose average saccade rate never increased above one saccade per direction per minute were excluded (n = 3 animals from cluster ablation experiments
if we denote the number of fixations before or after ablation (indexed by \(i\)) from animal \(j\)
then \({N}_{{{\min }}}=\mathop{{{\min }}}\nolimits_{i,j}{n}_{{ij}}\)
The number of times we repeated each measurement of fractional change in median fixation duration varied per fish and was determined by how many more fixations each animal made compared to \({N}_{{{\min }}}\)
the number of times we repeated each measurement for animal \(j\) equaled \({\rm{round}}\,(\frac{\mathop{{{\min }}}\nolimits_{i}{n}_{{ij}}}{{N}_{{{\min }}}})\)
The fractional change in median fixation duration was computed as the difference in median fixation duration (after minus before ablation) divided by the median fixation duration before ablation
Using \(l\) to denote the index of the repeated measurement in animal \(j\) and \({t}_{{ijml}}\) to denote the \({m}{{\mathrm{th}}}\) randomly sampled fixation duration (integer \({m}\) varies from 1 to \({N}_{{\rm{min }}}\)) in condition \(i\) (\(i\)=1 denotes before ablation and \(i\) = 2 denotes after ablation)
the fractional change in fixation duration was computed as:
\({\rm{round}}(\frac{\mathop{{{\min }}}\nolimits_{i}{n}_{{ij}}}{{N}_{{{\min }}}})\) and j = 1
For each sample of \({\bf{y}}\) for control and SR-targeted animals
we ran a Wilcoxon rank-sum test (100 tests in total) of the null hypothesis that the medians are equal between the distribution of \({\bf{y}}\) for SR-targeted and the distribution of \({\bf{y}}\) from control animals against the alternative that the median is greater in SR-targeted animals
and median p values across the 100 runs were also presented in the results
MATLAB function ranksum with the appropriate value of tail was used to perform the one-sided Wilcoxon tests
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article
Hirnpotentialänderungen bei Willkürbewegungen und passiven Bewegungen des Menschen: Bereitschaftspotential und reafferente Potentiale
Neuronal activities in the primate motor fields of the agranular frontal cortex preceding visually triggered and self-paced movement
Parietal area 5 and the initiation of self-timed movements versus simple reactions
Role of primate basal ganglia and frontal cortex in the internal generation of movements
III Neuronal activity in the supplementary motor area
Neural antecedents of self-initiated actions in secondary motor cortex
Cerebellar neurodynamics predict decision timing and outcome on the single-trial level
Fronto-parietal cortical circuits encode accumulated evidence with a diversity of timescales
Neural integrators for decision making: a favorable tradeoff between robustness and sensitivity
Neural circuits for evidence accumulation and decision making in larval zebrafish
Evidence accumulation during a sensorimotor decision task revealed by whole-brain imaging
An accumulator model for spontaneous neural activity prior to self-initiated movement
Preparing and selecting actions with neural populations: toward cortical circuit mechanisms
in The Oculomotor and Skeletalmotor Systems: Differences and Similarities Vol
Motor cortex signals for each arm are mixed across hemispheres and neurons yet partitioned within the population response
Conservation of preparatory neural events in monkey motor cortex regardless of how movement is initiated
Effects of caudate microstimulation on spontaneous and purposive saccades
get set: brainstem circuitry underlying saccadic initiation
Modification of saccadic eye movements by GABA-related substances
Effect of muscimol and bicuculline in monkey superior colliculus
Deficits in eye movements following frontal eye-field and superior colliculus ablations
Evidence for efference copy for eye movements in fish
Visuomotor deficits following ablation of monkey superior colliculus
Effect of unilateral cerebral cortical lesions on ocular motor behavior in monkeys: saccades and quick phases
Delay activity of saccade-related neurons in the caudal dentate nucleus of the macaque cerebellum
The development of eye movements in the zebrafish (Danio rerio)
Laser ablations reveal functional relationships of segmental hindbrain neurons in zebrafish
Brain-wide circuit interrogation at the cellular level guided by online analysis of neuronal function
Basic organization principles of the VOR: lessons from frogs
Insights into decision making using choice probability
Single-trial spike trains in parietal cortex reveal discrete steps during decision-making
Discharge characteristics of medial rectus and abducens motoneurons in the goldfish
Regression-based identification of behavior-encoding neurons during large-scale optical imaging of neural activity at cellular resolution
Whole-brain activity maps reveal stereotyped
distributed networks for visuomotor behavior
Brain-wide mapping of neural activity controlling zebrafish exploratory locomotion
Brain-wide organization of neuronal activity and convergent sensorimotor transformations in larval zebrafish
Coordination of the eyes and head during visual orienting
Readiness discharge for spontaneous initiation of walking in crayfish
Sequential synaptic excitation and inhibition shapes readiness discharge for voluntary behavior
Breathing is coupled with voluntary action and the cortical readiness potential
Bridging neural and computational viewpoints on perceptual decision-making
Three challenges for connecting model to mechanism in decision-making
Neural control of voluntary movement initiation
Representation of accumulating evidence for a decision in two parietal areas
Cerebellar disruption impairs working memory during evidence accumulation
Threshold mechanism for saccade initiation in frontal eye field and superior colliculus
The brainstem burst generator for saccadic eye movements: a modern synthesis
The neural integrators of the mammalian saccadic system
Anatomy and physiology of saccadic long-lead burst neurons recorded in the alert squirrel monkey
Linking neurons to network function and behavior by two-photon holographic optogenetics and volumetric imaging
Integrative whole-brain neuroscience in larval zebrafish
Instrumentation for measuring oculomotor performance and plasticity in larval organisms
Globally optimal stitching of tiled 3D microscopic image acquisitions
Fiji: an open-source platform for biological-image analysis
In 2016 IEEE 13th International Symposium on Biomedical Imaging (ISBI) 1123–1126 (IEEE
Efficient subpixel image registration algorithms
A simple sequentially rejective multiple test procedure
A circuit motif in the zebrafish hindbrain for a two alternative behavioral choice to turn left or right
Ramirez, A. D. & Aksay, E. R. F. Ramp-to-threshold dynamics in a hindbrain population controls the timing of spontaneous saccades. figshare https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.14558064.v1 (2021)
Ramirez, A. D. & Aksay, E. R. F. Ramp-to-threshold dynamics in a hindbrain population controls the timing of spontaneous saccades. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4743159 (2021)
Download references
We thank Chao Young and Misha Ahrens for generating the Tg(HuC:GCaMP6f-H2B) line and sharing ahead of publication
We thank the RARC team at Weill Cornell Medicine for animal care and husbandry
and Karel Svoboda for helpful discussion and feedback on the manuscript
Funding for this work was provided by NIH grant K99 EY027017
and the Simons Foundation Global Brain Initiative
carried out the experiments and analyzed the data; A.D.R
The authors declare no competing interests
Peer review information Nature Communications thanks Martin Haesemeyer and the other anonymous reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-24336-w
A Tibetan fox is pictured after snow in Aksay Kazakh Autonomous County
2021 shows herdsmen driving camels on the way to summer pastures in Aksay Kazakh Autonomous County
northwest China's Gansu Province.Photo:Xinhua
2021 shows camels on the way to summer pastures in Aksay Kazakh Autonomous County
Wild yaks are seen at the Haltent grassland in the Kazak Autonomous County of Aksay
Kiangs (Equus kiang) are seen at the Haltent grassland in the Kazak Autonomous County of Aksay
Tibetan gazelles are seen at the Haltent grassland in the Kazak Autonomous County of Aksay
Argali sheep are seen at the Haltent grassland in the Kazak Autonomous County of Aksay
A wolf is seen at the Haltent grassland in the Kazak Autonomous County of Aksay
2024 shows the autumn scenery of Tianzi Mountain at the Zhangjiajie national forest park in Zhangjiajie
2024 shows the autumn scenery at the Wuxia Gorge
one of the Three Gorges on the Yangtze River
2024 shows the autumn scenery at the Sanjiangkou ecological tourism area in Tongjiang City
People visit the Binhe Park in Yiyang County
Luoyang City of central China's Henan Province
2024 shows a train passing forest and fields in Shangzhi City
2024 shows elks wandering at the Tiaozini wetland in Dongtai City
2024 shows autumn scenery in Niangniangzhuang Town
Zunhua City of north China's Hebei Province
People visit the Huyangxia scenic spot in the Kazak Autonomous County of Aksay in northwest China's Gansu Province
2024 shows the autumn scenery in Xiji County of Guyuan City
northwest China's Ningxia Hui Autonomous Region
A new technique for printing extraordinarily thin lines quickly over wide areas could lead to larger
less expensive and more versatile electronic displays as well new medical devices
Solving a fundamental and long-standing quandary
chemical engineers at Princeton developed a method for shooting stable jets of electrically charged liquids from a wide nozzle
which produced lines just 100 nanometers wide (about one ten-thousandth of a millimeter)
offers at least 10 times better resolution than ink-jet printing and far more speed and ease than conventional nanotechnology
“It is a liquid delivery system on a micro scale,” said Ilhan Aksay
“And it becomes a true writing technology.”
Aksay and graduate student Sibel Korkut published the results Jan
The paper also includes as a co-author Dudley Saville
a chemical engineering professor who initiated the project but died in 2006
The research was funded by grants from the Army Research Office
Developing a deep understanding of the fundamental physics behind the process rather than building highly specialized equipment
the researchers were able to use a nozzle that is half a millimeter wide
or 5,000 times wider than the lines it produced
The key to the process is something called an “electrohydrodynamic (EHD) jet” -- a stream of liquid forced from a nozzle by a very strong electric field
Such jets were first investigated in 1917 and are now commonly used in a variety of industrial processes
one of the main features of EHD jets is that the stream of liquid becomes unstable soon after it leaves the nozzle and either whips around uncontrollably or breaks up into fine liquid drops
Engineers have used these effects to their advantage in spinning fibers and in industrial electrospray painting
but the reason for the whipping instability
two researchers working independently -- Princeton graduate student Hak Poon and Cornell University physicist Harold Craighead -- found that the jet was stable for a very short distance after leaving the nozzle
but the result was still not practical and the reasons were still elusive
“To understand how to control the jet in any engineering application we had to understand why this was happening,” Aksay said
Korkut took up the challenge and worked for nearly six years to nail down the mechanisms at play
she found that a key factor was that the liquid jet was transferring some of its electrical charge to the surrounding gas
which breaks into charged particles and carries some of the electrical current
Korkut’s predecessors and other scientists had looked only at the density of the electrical charges on the surface of the liquid jet
Expanding her view of the system led Korkut to a simple way to control the stability of the jet by changing the gas and the amount of water vapor
She was able to produce an extremely straight and stable jet more than 8 millimeters from the nozzle
(See video image of straight and whipping jets here: www.princeton.edu/~cml/html/EHDPself-assembly.html.)
The result is highly practical not only because of the fineness of the stream but also because the large size of the nozzle and the distance from the nozzle to the printed surface will prevent clogs or jams
Aksay said a chief use for the technique could be in printing electrically conducting organic polymers (plastics) that could be the basis for large electronic devices
Conventional techniques for making wires of that size (100 nanometers) require laboriously etching the lines with a beam of electrons
which can only be done in very small areas
The new technique can lay down lines at the rate of meters per second as opposed to millionths of a meter per second
Another application would be to use a liquid that solidifies into a fiber for making precise three-dimensional lattices
Such a product could be used as a scaffold to promote blood clotting in wounds and in other medical devices
Princeton University has filed for a patent on the discovery and has licensed rights to Vorbeck Materials Corp.
a specialty chemical company based in Maryland
“Electronics is a huge potential application for this discovery,” said John Lettow
president of Vorbeck and a 1995 chemical engineering alumnus of Princeton
“The printing technique could greatly increase the size of video displays and the speed with which high performance displays are made.” Lettow said the technique also could be used in creating large sensors that collect information over a wide area
such as a sensor printed onto an airplane wing to detect metal fatigue
publishing the results in the premier physics journal marks a gratifying conclusion to years of painstaking work that offered no guarantee of a practical answer
“You are digging into a hole and you don’t know if you will hit the bottom,” Korkut said
Even though she began to see improved stability of the jet after five years
she still did not have a precise handle on the causes
Aksay and Saville pressed her to have a deeper understanding before publishing the results
“It took more than a year after we saw the clues
We had to look at many possibilities,” Korkut said
Aksay said Korkut succeeded because of her persistence
are not responsible for the accuracy of news releases posted to EurekAlert
by contributing institutions or for the use of any information through the EurekAlert system
Copyright © 2025 by the American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS)
Research: Hierarchically Structured Self-Assembled Materials
We have also examined the structural evolution at the micron length scale (below)
Mature particles possess distinctive curvatures
while particles collected at earlier times show some evidence of amorphous structure (in the sense that the edges are not well defined)
The aim of the biomaterials effort is to produce bone graft substitutes that mimic the properties of bone
As pure ceramic proves to be too "brittle" for bone
it has been proposed that a composite of the two materials would provide a better match with natural bone
we are now able to fabricate prototype composites