Look out for your first newsletter in your inbox soon
The best of Los Angeles straight to your inbox
We help you navigate a myriad of possibilities
Sign up for our newsletter for the best of the city
By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from Time Out about news
Sign up for our email to enjoy Los Angeles without spending a thing (as well as some options when you’re feeling flush)
Our newsletter hand-delivers the best bits to your inbox
Sign up to unlock our digital magazines and also receive the latest news
By entering your email address you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and consent to receive emails from Time Out about news, events, offers and partner promotions.
Los Angeles
Photograph: Jesse Hsu | Eggplant escabeche
Photograph: Jesse HsuPreviousNext/10Photograph: Jesse Hsu | Lamb neck shawarma
Photograph: Jesse HsuPreviousNext/10Photograph: Jesse Hsu | Wood-fired pita bread
Photograph: Jesse HsuPreviousNext/10Photograph: Jesse Hsu | Rose clove chocolate doughnuts
Photograph: Jesse Hsu | Foie gras halva with buckwheat loaf
Photograph: Jesse HsuPreviousNext/10Review
Bavel draws upon Levantine culinary traditions in a sprawling
plant-filled dining room offset by a string-lit patio
The menu lends itself to family-style dining
seasonal vegetables and some of the best hummus in Los Angeles
Middle Eastern-inspired specialty cocktails and a Mediterranean-heavy wine list complement starters like fried quail and oyster mushrooms kebab. Though the reservation process is just as difficult at Bavel as it is at Bestia
Both restaurants have helped usher in the era of the Arts District as a veritable dining destination—and though you’d honestly come away pleased with a meal at either one
Bavel is the couple’s finest restaurant in my book
Every small plate here is carefully considered and packed with flavor; the substantial
far pricier entrées are equally dazzling. Save room for one of Gergis’s excellent desserts
Thanks for subscribing! Look out for your first newsletter in your inbox soon!
twitterinstagramspotifyAbout us
Contact us
Time Out magazine
This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks
The action you just performed triggered the security solution
There are several actions that could trigger this block including submitting a certain word or phrase
You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked
Please include what you were doing when this page came up and the Cloudflare Ray ID found at the bottom of this page
Alejandro Albalá leaves viewers speechless by sharing new and unexpected information about Claudia Bavel
he revealed some of the celebrities the influencer had on her radar: “She tried to meet with him
It was on January 28 when Iker Casillas and this well-known adult content creator became the protagonists of Diez Minutos
the magazine published images of them walking through the streets of Barcelona
Claudia Bavel's love life under scrutiny | TelecincoSince then, Claudia Bavel's romantic affairs have become one of the main topics in our country's social press
the influencer has had several affairs with various well-known figures
However, the one who undoubtedly came out worst off from this situation was the former Betis player, Joaquín Sánchez
Alejandro Albalá has returned to the set of TardeAR with new and revealing information about Claudia Bavel
Alejandro Albalá tells everything he knows about Claudia Bavel | MediasetAccording to the television collaborator himself
he had a romance with Claudia Bavel in the past
what has most caught the attention of viewers is the confession he made afterward
Claudia Bavel tried some time ago to meet with a famous actor from our country: “She tried to meet with him
Alejandro Albalá has claimed that when he met Claudia Bavel
she had a list with the names of several celebrities
her intention was to coordinate a meeting to be captured by the paparazzi
the television collaborator had no problem sharing more details about this list with his colleagues on TardeAR
were in the model's sights when he had contact with her years ago
they met in August 2023 at a mutual friend's house who resides in the United States
rumors were circulating about an alleged infidelity of Rauw Alejandro to Rosalía with a young blonde linked to several singers
Alejandro Albalá claims that Claudia Bavel had a list of potential conquests | en.e-noticies.cat
MediasetThis is why Claudia Bavel expressed her desire to achieve something similar
“She wanted to achieve the same thing because she gained a lot of fame in the United States
many followers on social media,” the panelist explained
Alejandro Albalá claimed that the influencer
strategically sought “who can I hurt the most”
NEW ON FACEBOOK! 📲 Click here to receive the hottest royal and celebrity news directly to your Facebook, for FREE and EXCLUSIVE! Don't miss out!
One of the celebrities on her list was the singer Ozuna
who at that time was facing “a big problem with his wife”
Other names that emerged within the Latin American music scene were Bad Bunny and J
Alejandro Albalá left all the viewers speechless by confirming that some Spanish celebrities were also on Claudia Bavel's radar
but it didn't work out,” Alejandro Albalá firmly stated before making it clear that these are just some of the names: “There were quite a few more”
Among the numerous lists spotlighting the best restaurants in America comes one from OpenTable, which features 19 California eateries. Yet, OpenTable’s list of the top 100 restaurants in 2024 is driven by its millions of verified users
which means California’s sizable representation on this list is thanks to the people
the number of times they made reservations in advance and other metrics
From historic restaurants to buzzy new spots
here are the California restaurants that made OpenTable’s list (and perhaps will make your list to try in 2025)
Cesarina in San Diego is a trattoria, a word used to signify a more casual restaurant serving traditional Italian food, said Travel and Leisure
Expect fresh pasta and tableside dessert at a restaurant that said it's “inspired by our ‘everything made in house’ credo.”
Cowboy Star Restaurant and Butcher Shop is a steakhouse with a “Western flair” thanks to its aesthetic
familiar steakhouse sides and a happy hour
Evvia Estiatorio, Palo AltoEvvia Estiatorio has served Greek cuisine in Silicon Valley for nearly three decades. It’s among the San Francisco Chronicle’s top Palo Alto restaurants
Fishing with Dynamite by chef David LeFevre opened in 2013 and offers guests oysters
lobster and other seafood dishes within walking distance of the Manhattan Beach Pier
insideOUT, San DiegoInsideOUT is an LGBTQ-owned restaurant that boasts alfresco dining with a Mediterranean and California-inspired menu
One look at its Instagram reveals just how far the restaurant takes its themed dining experiences
such as when insideOUT transformed into a “spring oasis” earlier this year with its Japanese cherry blossom trees and a seasonal menu
Jeune et Jolie diners can expect French cuisine “through the vibrant lens of our Southern California landscape,” the restaurant said
experience a four-course menu at the Michelin-starred restaurant
More: Your guide to Michelin star dining in California, including 7 new additions in 2024 not to miss
The sister restaurant to Evvia Estiatorio, Kokkari Estiatorio brings the “old-world charm of a rustic Mediterranean country inn” to its diners. It’s among Eater San Francisco’s list of classic restaurants that every San Franciscan must try
Musso & Frank Grill, Los AngelesMusso & Frank Grill
a Hollywood institution that celebrated its 105th anniversary this year
Marilyn Monroe and Elizabeth Taylor over its history
Musso’s boasts of serving the original fettuccine alfredo recipe from Italy
brought to the restaurant by Hollywood stars Mary Pickford and Douglas Fairbanks
Providence is a two-starred Michelin restaurant by James Beard award-winning chef Michael Cimarusti, who presents diners with “the finest sustainable seafood” with “sophisticated technique,” according to the restaurant. As OpenTable editors put it
and exceptional service that doesn’t feel stuffy — just the way LA fine dining should be.”
Saffy’s, Los AngelesSaffy’s serves "Middle Eastern homestyle cooking" from the folks behind Bestia and Bavel
dinner and dessert all at this Los Angeles restaurant
The Dock brings dining to the to the bayfront
Diners praise the restaurant for its service and views on OpenTable
Paris Barraza is a trending reporter covering California news at The Desert Sun
New SA made and SAFC supported Netflix series Territory premieres this week on Thursday
The biggest Netflix series ever made in South Australia
with both production and post production taking place here as well as filming in the Northern Territory
the neo-western drama follows a fight for power in the remote and unforgiving Australian outback
Emerging South Australian screen creatives Sonja van Bavel and Clare Elvia both undertook attachments on Territory as part of the majority South Australian crew on the production
We sat down with them to ask about their experiences on set
what it’s like to work in the screen industry
and their advice for other emerging screen creatives
Sonja van Bavel is an emerging set decorator and art department crew member
She previously completed an SAFC Professional Crew Attachment in set decorating on Talk To Me
and has worked in the art department on SA made and SAFC supported films The Royal Hotel and The New Boy
Sonia was selected for an SAFC Professional Crew Department in the Art Department on Territory
working with a team that included South Australian practitioners Assistant Set Decorator Daniel Wilson
Senior Buyer/Dresser Jen Drake and Buyer/Dressers Shona Hannagan and Ben Conroy
How did you get started in the screen industry
I always had a passion for film and production design
I developed a natural curiosity in combining the two and began to explore working in the film industry
After moving back to Adelaide from Alice Springs in 2020
Art Director Laura Ockenden connected me with filmmaker Kahli Gaskin
who was generous enough to give me my first gig as Art Director on her indie film
What do you love about working in the screen industry
To be a small part of helping make Australian stories come to life in my hometown with the SA Film Corporation has been a dream come true
I used to walk past Glenside before it was Adelaide Studios (but by then had been featured in the acclaimed film Shine) promising myself I’d pursue my dream of working in the industry one day
I feel so alive and energised working with so many moving parts and exceptionally creative people on a final product
To be amongst the inner workings of the Art Department and translate the Production Designer’s vision into sets
props and costume is a language I understand
Particularly rewarding has been the opportunity to draw on my background curating First Nations artwork
and textiles from art centres across the country for productions including Territory (Netflix) and most recently Top End Bub (Amazon Prime)
What was it like working as an Art Department Attachment on Territory
Learning from and working alongside creatives who are at the top of their game gave me insight which I would’ve never had otherwise
Set Decorators and Buyer/Dressers who put an awe-inspiring amount blood
It was an incredible process to be a part of and has served as a touchstone of calibre to strive for
I also enjoyed (and continue to enjoy) meeting suppliers
wisdom and generosity to contribute to filmmaking
and for crew to have someone who is learning on the job can be a real challenge
So much respect for those who have taught me with patience under pressure
Lots of ducks paddling furiously underwater
finishing the job and leaving so many new film friends and family was really the biggest challenge
What was the most useful or surprising thing you learned during your attachment
to understanding “on set” protocols and discovering the many cogs of different departments
The more you look in your peripheral vision and discover how other departments outside your own operate
Do you have any advice for up-and-coming crew members who are considering applying for an attachment
Working as an Attachment is a lot like an apprenticeship for film
There is a level of freedom that allows for “testing the waters” and helping you find the right fit
enjoy the process and make sure you stay well caffeinated
Why do you think initiatives like the SAFC’s Professional Crew Attachments are important
There aren’t really any other opportunities to have such hands-on experiences in the industry at such a high level
With so many productions in South Australia
fostering emerging talent is crucial to maintain the standard of creativity and that is currently alive and thriving in our state
I feel the industry here in SA has always been encouraging and embracing
fostering an encouraging environment for growth
Where would you like to see yourself in 10 years
but I hope I’m still trying to better myself
Clare Elvia is a proud Badimia Yamatji woman and emerging editor. She currently works as a part-time editor at Adelaide’s community broadcaster Channel 44 and also edited the SAFC’s First Nations Showreel
She was selected for an Editing Attachment through the Screen Territory First Nations Production Ready Bootcamp
delivered in Darwin in partnership with Netflix
working with SA editor Sean Lahiff to get hands on experience with post-production on a major streaming service series
I found my footing in the screen industry through the SAFC and Channel 44’s First Nations Internship Program back in 2022
I received valuable mentorship and support to cultivate my passion for editing and shortly upon completing my internship I was fortunate enough to obtain a part-time editing position
I get to work on some really exciting projects at Channel 44 with some cool creative partners
hard-working people who I am constantly learning from and who make me feel valued
I’m very grateful to have found my start through Channel 44 as it has led me to some pretty amazing opportunities and experiences
It’s very rewarding to be a part of the process of creating interesting and diverse stories for screen which bring different emotions
and then to see how those stories resonate with the people who watch them
I also love getting to meet and collaborate with some amazing and insanely talented people
I am very fortunate for all the friendships I have made so far in this industry
What was it like working as an Editing Attachment on Territory
My attachment on Territory was super exciting and fulfilling
I learned so much and getting to see how a production of this large a scale runs just completely blew my mind
What was your biggest highlight working on Territory
There are so many highlights to choose from
I just really enjoyed working with and learning from the whole post-production and editorial team
Being able to sit in with editor Sean Lahiff while he was working and pick his brain about his processes was very cool and I’m super thankful for it
I also got to visit the set for a day while they were filming some simulated travel scenes
It was nice getting to meet some of the cast and crew who you wouldn’t normally get to meet when working in post
I think the biggest challenge for me was getting over my impostor syndrome and fear of being in the way
I quickly realised that I absolutely deserved to be there
and I deserved to make the most of my experience by learning all that I possibly could
I felt very welcomed by everyone I met during my attachment and was encouraged to ask all the questions
no matter how silly I thought they might come across
Probably learning to work with Avid Media Composer for the first time
It initially took me a while to wrap my head around it
but I’m glad to have the experience using it as it’s the industry standard for these larger-scale projects and I’ll feel more prepared for the future jobs (fingers crossed!) that might require it
If there’s an attachment position available in the department you want to work in
absolutely apply for it and express a keen interest
if you’re successful in getting the attachment
make the most of it and learn all that you can – it will be immensely worthwhile
Why do you think Attachment initiatives like the one you participated in are important
It’s crucial for the industry to foster these kinds of initiatives for emerging creatives
especially for First Nations people and other underrepresented groups
They allow for skill development and an invaluable hands-on learning experience
while getting to connect and work closely with industry professionals
These attachment opportunities can be a major stepping stone in advancing the careers of up-and-coming screen practitioners
and also encourage upskilling and diversity across the various departments
In 10 years I would love to see some more production credits under my name and to be more established as an editor
Subscribe to the Latest News & Updates from SAFC
First Nations viewers are advised that this website may contain images and voices of people who have passed away
Claudia Bavel puts Cepeda against the ropes | Europapress, @telecincoes, en.e-noticies.cat PEOPLE Claudia Bavel Puts Cepeda Against the Ropes in '¡De Viernes!': 'I'm Willing'Claudia Bavel sat on '¡De Viernes!'
where she talked about her relationship with Iker Casillas and her messages with Cepeda.08/02/2025 09:03:00h by Cristo Fernández
Claudia Bavel has returned to the eye of the storm. After her first interview on ¡De Viernes!, the young woman returned to the set to address new controversies about her personal life. The model now faces the reaction of Iker Casillas and the leak of messages with the singer Cepeda
The young woman has confirmed that she doesn't want to be silenced
which is why she has confessed that she wants to put all the rumors to rest: "I'm willing."
she was blunt: "I didn't expect him to issue a statement with the intention of silencing me," she confessed live
The influencer was upset with the reply from the former footballer and hinted that she has more information that could come to light
Claudia Bavel returned to "¡De Viernes!" | TelecincoBut the night brought more surprises
Claudia spoke to the media and threw a poisoned dart at Luis Cepeda
"Just another one who retracts from the little brain cell he has," she said without hesitation
The singer tried to deny the messages he exchanged with her
confirmed that the conversations were real
and accused Cepeda of trying to divert attention
"I'm willing to defend myself against any criticism," she asserted with determination
The model appeared defiant and made it clear that she doesn't fear the consequences
The tension increased when new details about the conversations were revealed
Claudia claimed that Cepeda tried to manipulate the situation to discredit her
Her statements have put the singer in check
Claudia has confirmed that when she had those messages with the artist
he was in a relationship while she was single
This has left Cepeda in a complicated situation
The discussion has gained momentum on social media
where followers from both sides debate the truthfulness of the accusations
Iker Casillas's reaction has been much talked about
His official communication sought to minimize the impact of Claudia's statements
The model has hinted that she could reveal more compromising details if necessary
Claudia Bavel spoke about her relationship with Iker Casillas in her interview | MediasetThe scandal continues to grow. Iker Casillas
The media is already waiting for the next developments
Below, the culinary legend dishes on her favorite L.A. eats.
$24, 500 Mateo St. #102., Downtown L.A., baveldtla.com
The Farmer’s PlateA.O.C. WEST HOLLYWOOD» “The Farmer’s Plate is one of those dishes that’s an absolute staple and Suzanne executes so perfectly. Gorgeous roasted farmers market vegetables, muhammara balanced with the chickpea puree, wood fire toast with the creamy burrata. I have to have it every time I go! Often I add on a Chicories salad to take it over the top!”
$20, 8700 W. 3rd St., West Hollywood, aocwinebar.com
AnkimoN/SOTO» “This takes me back to our City Restaurant days. Monkfish liver is just so absolutely delicious on its own. When you add the sweet and sour sumiso, the citrus of yuzu and spice of kosho, it’s the perfect bite I often dream about.”$17, 4566 W. Washington Blvd., Mid City, n-soto.com
By Jasmin RosembergEditor
Thelma Golden will celebrate Lauren Halsey and U.K.-based singer Griff will take the stage
featured A-list designers and Otis College standouts who earned scholarships for innovation in Fashion Design
lawyers say Boston Police Officer John O'Keefe showed injuries consistent with a dog attack and plan to present a case against Chloe
a German Shepherd who was re-homed by the owner's of the house where the cop's body was found in a snowbank
Magazine’s takeaways on five notable topics from President Donald Trump’s first 100 days of his second term
consumers are stocking up on household items
and bites from THEBlvd and Hinoki & the Bird
Brant Cox
And really, everything about this place will have you plotting a return visit. The staff is friendly (though they do have a habit of instructing you on how to eat everything, including hummus), there isn’t a disappointing dish on the menu, and the room feels like a big, orchestrated party, whether you’re sitting at the white marble bar or in one of the big round booths.
There's still a strong chance you'll need to book a reservation in advance (even if you're eating at 5pm), but that comes with territory. Bavel remains a fine-tuned restaurant machine that we'll find any excuse to visit, and we recommend you do the same.
Arts District
few places in LA do it better than Bestia in the Arts District
Middle EasternMediterranean
East Hollywood
Saffy's is a fantastic Middle Eastern kebab spot in East Hollywood
MediterraneanMiddle Eastern
Los Feliz
the Mediterranean-Middle Eastern restaurant in Los Feliz
breezy restaurant you can use for any occasion
Please enable JS and disable any ad blocker
Days after learning all the details about the latest scandal involving Iker Casillas
She took the opportunity to confess to the press everything she knows about the latest controversy involving the footballer and her client
There is no doubt that, in recent weeks, the former Real Madrid goalkeeper has become one of the main figures in our country's social press. All this after part of his personal life was exposed
Iker Casillas and Claudia Bavel are at the center of one of the controversies of the moment | en.e-noticies.cat
what really put Iker Casillas in a bind were the statements Claudia Bavel made during her visit to ¡De Viernes
the adult content creator did not hesitate to share with the program some of the conversations she had with the athlete during their relationship
provoked an immediate reaction from Iker Casillas
The former footballer issued a statement through social media where he announced that he had "given instructions for any violation of my privacy and/or honor[...]to be legally pursued."
Yola Berrocal speaks about this controversy to the media | Europa PressNow
a team from Europa Press had the opportunity to speak with Yola Berrocal
the right-hand woman of the adult film actress broke her silence to confess what she knows about the latest scandal involving her client and Iker Casillas
There is no doubt that, thanks to her position as Claudia Bavel's representative
Yola Berrocal is one of the people who knows the Iker Casillas scandal best
Yola Berrocal talks about the controversy of Iker Casillas | Europa Press
en.e-noticies.catThat's why a team of reporters from the aforementioned news agency didn't hesitate to ask her about this entire controversy
Questions that the TV personality did not refuse to answer
Yola Berrocal wanted to reveal how her client is doing after her latest television interview
Claudia has been heavily criticized for making certain information about Iker Casillas public:
she is an unbelievable person," the representative assured
However, when asked if Iker Casillas has contacted her client after the statements she made on social media
"I am not the right person to talk about this issue
Barren Academy of Virtual and Expanded Learning (BAVEL) teacher Pam Carter conducts a fully online class
BAVEL has been holding online-only classes for 15 years
When all public schools had to move their learning online in March due to the COVID-19 pandemic
many educators began turning to the school for tips on how to make online education work.Photo submitted
Kentucky schools and others across the country scrambled to set up online classes due to COVID-19 shutdowns
educators sought advice on how to do that successfully
Though many schools had some form of virtual program
this was their first experience with full-time remote learning
Kentucky educators had an example: the Barren Academy of Virtual and Expanded Learning (BAVEL)
which for 15 years has been doing what other Kentucky schools suddenly needed
chief digital officer in the Kentucky Department of Education (KDE) Office of Education Technology
said when a dozen or more districts sought help in launching virtual programs this summer
his first move was to connect them with BAVEL
“They’ve been doing this for a very long time and they do it very well,” he said
BAVEL’s personnel were ready to help districts think through how to create virtual programs
who oversees BAVEL as director of instruction for Barren County Schools
The first of KDE’s guidelines for digital learning is to ensure the content is aligned with the Kentucky Academic Standards, Park said. His office has a catalog of all virtual courses offered by various Kentucky schools, and BAVEL has the most, he said.
BAVEL was never built around helping students retake classes, rather providing a rigorous and unique education, said former Metcalfe County Superintendent Benny Lile. Even though Metcalfe County students usually decided against taking courses through BAVEL, he said checking it out often changed their perspective on education – helping them accept that there was no easy way to learn and online classes could be just as demanding as in-person instruction.
“If that’s the lesson learned, then cumulatively I think it’s all really good,” he said.
The first essential factor, whether for non-traditional instruction during COVID-19 or a permanent online program, is a clearly established vision for what the program should accomplish, said Phillip Napier, BAVEL’s director of communication and assessment. Other schools’ visions for online programs may be very different from BAVEL, but the important thing is for everyone involved to understand it, he said.
Next, schools must understand how they’ll facilitate student success, Napier said, such as determining the technology infrastructure they will they need and ensuring students get the right support.
Then schools need to anticipate and overcome the barriers they and their students will face, from gaps in technology to transporting students to standardized testing sites.
Some people have had bad online experiences, often because they found it impersonal, Napier said. BAVEL seeks to ensure that when its students graduate, they’ve had a chance to develop “soft skills” as well as academic ones.
BAVEL’s leaders agree that any new online program needs to “start small” to plan and prepare.
“Really, it’s all about meeting the needs of the students,” Harper said. Many of their students wouldn’t have been successful if they hadn’t had the options BAVEL’s online program provides, he said.
BAVEL administrators Jeanelle McGuire, (top center), Melinda Owens (bottom left) and Phillip Napier (bottom right) hold a video conference with students Gracyn Wellman (top left), Madeleine Edge (top right) and Justin Burba (bottom center).Photo submitted
Park, who oversees all online and virtual school networks in the state, said KDE is launching expanded ideas of what that statewide virtual learning network looks like. Much of his office’s work is expanding how technology can help traditional classroom teachers in day-to-day learning, he said.
One of Kentucky’s educational gaps, however, has been providing opportunities for any student to enroll in a high-quality, all-virtual program, Park said. As the state’s longest-serving full-time virtual school, BAVEL serves as a benchmark, he said.
“We really look at them as the source of excellence for doing full-time virtual school really well,” he said. “Because of the demonstrated success of BAVEL, we’re now up to 38 school districts that have a virtual academy or virtual school approach, and they are accepting students from other districts.”
BAVEL does a great job ensuring its program is the right fit for student applicants, working closely with families, Park said.
This summer, Park and Ben Maynard in KDE’s Office of Education Technology asked BAVEL personnel to hold a professional development session for teachers in other districts. That online event took place July 16, dealing with the history of online education in Kentucky, BAVEL itself, and what its educators have learned about providing a solid virtual-only education.
Park’s office is working on using some Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act funds to help other districts host their own virtual academies, he said.
Barren County School District runs and funds BAVEL, using Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Support Education Excellence in Kentucky (SEEK) funding, Harper said.
BAVEL has two full-time instructors, 46 part-time teachers, three directors and an administrative assistant, Napier said. It’s accredited through the NCAA, so its graduates who are student athletes in their home districts are eligible to play in college, he said.
More than 2,500 students have taken BAVEL courses and more than 600 have graduated through BAVEL, according to the school.
Th school serves students statewide, said Jeanelle McGuire, BAVEL’s director of admissions.
Students who enroll in BAVEL take classes under reciprocal agreements between the school and their home districts at a cost of $50 per course. But that’s a deposit refundable upon graduation, she said.
Putting down a deposit shows that students are committed to a course, Napier said. And getting it back when they graduate is “icing on the cake,” he said.
Students from districts without reciprocal agreements can take BAVEL classes, too, but in their case the per-course charge isn’t refundable and may vary depending on which classes they take and how many, Napier said.
This year, BAVEL has reciprocal agreements with 66 of the state’s 171 districts.
BAVEL values its partnerships with other school districts, universities and the state’s community and technical college system, Harper said. Barren County is one of the top feeders of students to Western Kentucky University (WKU), and last spring the university started talks with BAVEL on a closer collaboration, he said.
Aiding that potential collaboration is BAVEL’s recent move from Barren County School District offices to a building on WKU’s Glasgow campus. That will allow BAVEL to draw from WKU’s advising resources and other campus features, Napier said.
Normally, administrators and the two full-time instructors have offices in BAVEL’s campus building, while the part-time teachers work from home, he said.
When schools shut down in the spring, all BAVEL staff were able to work from home – even having their office phones physically installed in their houses, Harper said.
“We had the technology infrastructure to do that pretty seamlessly,” he said.
“Just a handful of our local students that needed another option for fulfilling their requirements to get their high school diploma,” he said. Providing that alternative is the reason BAVEL was founded.
When Napier began at BAVEL in 2010, the school had 75 students.
“The next school year we ended up somewhere around the 200 mark,” he said. For fall 2020, enrollment is up about 20% over 2019.
Though growth has been steady, the number of unique students fluctuates annually, Napier said.
“What really tells our story is the number of course enrollments,” he said. Fewer total students may enroll in any given year, but more of them are enrolled full time.
This year BAVEL has 292 students altogether.
Those students make up 2,768 individual enrollments, meaning individual classes, Napier said.
Usually about 85% of students are full time, but in 2020, that rose to 92%, he said.
Other virtual schools will accept students from other districts, but unless those districts have reciprocal agreements, parents have to pay out of pocket, Park said.
He wants to expand virtual networks’ footprint so more districts have reciprocal agreements with multiple partners.
“No one should expect it to be free, but there’s a funding conversation that has to take place with every district,” Park said.
“It’s important to remember that we didn’t just get here overnight,” he said. “We are, even at this point, still experiencing growing pains and still learning what authentic online learning really looks like.”
One of the biggest investments is not technology, Napier said. It’s people: teachers and support staff who follow students’ progress.
“It’s really about that whole experience and knowing there are people on the other end that care,” he said.
Owens monitors students’ coursework, discussing issues with them if they fall behind and encouraging them further if they’re doing well. She seeks to make sure students really understand their curriculum and can discuss it, not just recite it.
Regular, personal contact with teachers is built into BAVEL’s curriculum, Harper said.
Much of that is enabled or assisted by the evolution of videoconferencing over the past decade, Owens said. In the early years, students had to enroll in person, then could do it by phone and now can use Google Meet from their first day.
Everyone wants the socialization benefits that come from in-person school, but learning can work very well online, Lile said.
For districts working to set up a permanent routine of virtual education, the main factor is determining up front what they want their online presence to be like, he said.
“I think one of their big things is, there’s always been a teacher behind the course,” Lile said. BAVEL classes are far more than working through and submitting assignments via computer, he said.
Δdocument.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() );
The Kentucky Department of Education (KDE) publishes Kentucky Teacher to communicate directly with the state’s 40,000 public school teachers. The stories of this award-winning publication include news, perspectives, and practical, workable ideas for guiding students to higher levels of achievement.
Tap to enable a layout that focuses on the article
× (()=>{const e=document.getElementById("yt-img-oxeiyPFEt40");e&&e.addEventListener("load",(t=>{t.target.naturalWidth<=120&&(e.parentNode.children[0].srcset=e.parentNode.children[1].srcset=e.src)}),{once:!0})})() L.A
Times Today airs Monday through Friday at 7 p.m
The hummus with nduja at Bavel in the Arts District
The Middle Eastern-inspired restaurant is our 2019 Restaurant of the Year
Rarely does a sophomore restaurant eclipse its predecessor in the way that Bavel has captured the stomachs and Instagram feeds of Los Angeles diners. Try to find a serious (or not so serious) gourmand who hasn’t posted a photo of the gargantuan lamb neck shawarma, the fiery prawns, the hummus or the layered malawach bread.
When you think about the meals you obsess over and the dishes you wake up wishing you’d eaten more of, Bavel comes to mind. This is the Middle Eastern-inspired restaurant by Ori Menashe and Genevieve Gergis, the two chefs who opened Bestia in the Arts District in 2012.
It’s a restaurant that wonderfully encapsulates the all-things-Middle-Eastern movement sweeping Los Angeles. It was the restaurant name on everyone’s lips this past year, often uttered as a question due to the variances in pronunciation. (It’s buh-VELL.)
View this post on Instagram Made this reservation a month ago, with no idea what extra significance it would take on. Every bit as good as everyone says it is.
A post shared by Zach Brooks (@midtownlunchla) on Jul 23
The Restaurant of the Year was picked by Jonathan Gold in the past
Bill Addison and Patricia Escarcega will name next year’s winner
Amy Scattergood and I picked up the torch to put together the paper’s 101 Restaurants We Love list
it fell on us to consider Restaurant of the Year
The hummus is reason enough to give Bavel all the awards. In Gold’s review of the restaurant
he beautifully described the complexities of the humble dish:
airy purée surrounding a big spoonful of chunkier
denser stuff; a green rivulet of olive oil; smears of spicy
Gergis’ desserts are passionate, delicious and can sometimes defy logic and even gravity. It took her several tries to get that crème brûlée to set just perfectly over the date purée beneath it. And she will make a licorice lover out of us all; not eventually, but at the exact moment you dip into her licorice root ice cream bon bons
high ceiling and exceptionally well-dressed clientele
A busy Saturday night here is the irrefutable nucleus of the Los Angeles dining universe
But not only is this restaurant of the now
it is also something Menashe and Gergis have been wanting to open for years
craveable cooking that draws from both Menashe’s and Gergis’ backgrounds in Morocco
Reserve a table
Jenn Harris is a columnist for the Food section and host of “The Bucket List” show. She has a BA in literary journalism from UC Irvine and an MA in journalism from USC. Follow her @Jenn_Harris_.
Food
World & Nation
Subscribe for unlimited accessSite Map
While it seemed like an eternity to us on the other side
as he rode the rollercoaster of opening something very new and very personal: Bavel is an homage to his Jewish-Turkish-Moroccan heritage and his wife and pastry chef Genevieve Gergis’s Egyptian background
Here he takes us into the notebook that held together not only his random thoughts but himself in the midst of constant change
fear of living up to the rumored restaurant
I bought this notebook almost four and a half years ago
It’s a green Mead composition book with wide lines
We were going on our first vacation after we first opened Bestia in November 2012
We closed the restaurant for 12 days because everyone was working six days a week and needed time off
I’d sit out on the patio and start writing for two hours until she woke up
and that might change to 20 grams or none of that
Courtesy of Ori MenasheThere are probably 200 ideas in this notebook
It kept me going when we ran into complications with opening Bavel
We leased the space and started construction when we split with our business partner
We tore up the plans and started from scratch
I’m going to continue to develop dishes.’ And up until two weeks before the opening of Bavel
Grilled octopus with an herby yogurt at Bavel
When I’m 50, I’m going to look back at the Bavel notebook and crack a big smile on my face.
2/16 Licorice ice cream bon bon: sour licorice caramel
3/16 Strawberry sumac and sweet cheese pastry: pistachio ice cream
4/16 Malawach: ancient grain crispy layered bread
6/16 Slow-roasted lamb-neck shawarma: crème fraiche tahini
7/16 A look inside chefs Ori Menashe’s and Genevieve Gergis’ newest restaurant
8/16 Grilled oyster mushrooms with wild nettle purée
9/16 A look inside chefs Ori Menashe’s and Genevieve Gergis’ newest restaurant
10/16 Grilled oyster mushrooms
11/16 Chefs Ori Menashe and Genevieve Gergis at their newest restaurant
12/16 It gets loud inside Bavel
13/16 A look inside chefs Ori Menashe’s and Genevieve Gergis’ newest restaurant
15/16 Bavel has Middle Eastern influences
16/16 Chefs Ori Menashe and Genevieve Gergis at their newest restaurant
Print Restaurant Critic The seriousness of a Middle Eastern restaurant rests in its hummus
vaguely sour hummus is OK to send off in your children’s brown-bag lunches
and the mayonnaise-y over-garlicked stuff may be exactly what you want to see alongside a takeout roast chicken
The mealy paste that comes next to the watery tabbouleh on a mezze plate serves its purpose
the ones that inspire hour-long drives and dinnertime haiku
tend to labor over their fragrant goo as assiduously as a French baker might over her baguettes
Great hummus must never be taken for granted
So while the overwhelming popularity of Bavel may have a lot to do with the grilled octopus with yogurt or the marinated okra with whipped feta and mint
I am guessing that it is the hummus that keeps Ori Menashe up at night
and the chef-owner can creditably claim that most of the dishes are less Yemenite or Moroccan or Israeli than they are in some way his own
The pita has inflated into a sphere on the hot fire
evolved gluten network of a slow-risen country loaf
And as you scrape the bread between one density and the other
the dish becomes an essay in the nuances of texture and fragrance
Bavel is a soaring converted warehouse near downtown’s 4th Street Bridge
on a block where Sonic Youth once played a free show on the street; all brick and chunky wood
and what looks like a forest of air plants cascading from a huge frame that is improbably not anchored with macramé
The cooks in the open kitchen knot bandannas around their foreheads in the style made famous by Menashe at his nearby restaurant Bestia
you will not be surprised to hear that Bavel is also extremely loud
You will be drinking salty island wines from Sardinia and the Canary Islands
Your date will barely hear you above the din
You will wonder whether there is a point to an old-fashioned made with lamb-fat-washed bourbon or a pisco sour with pink peppercorns
You will probably be having a very good time
Long before last year’s wave of Israeli restaurants washed over Los Angeles
restaurant obsessives had been waiting for Bavel
a project Menashe announced not long after he opened Bestia
He had been cooking Italian food for most of his career
and some of Bestia’s best dishes leaned toward the Eastern Mediterranean as much as they did toward Italy
Nobody in town was really cooking full-throttle Levantine food powered by anything like Menashe’s reliance on woodfire
house-cured meats and fermented vegetables
and at a time when everyone you knew had at least one Yotam Ottolenghi cookbook on their shelves
everybody yearned for a restaurant that would do for Middle Eastern cooking what Spago had done for Italian food a decade before
So if you were already a fan of Menashe’s food
you almost knew what to expect: crisp lamb flatbread
like Armenian lahmajoun in a midlife crisis
or a salad of cucumber and shaved artichoke hearts tossed with celery
orange blossom water and a sprinkling of crushed pistachio
The cured meat plate runs Middle Eastern instead of Italian
with spicy housemade versions of the Armenian sausage sujuk
Turkish basturma and harissa-spiked salami instead of prosciutto and speck
are scented with the cardamom-rich Yemenite spice blend hawaij and served with a bit of spicy crème fraîche as a dipping sauce
The best dish at Bavel could well be the grilled oyster mushrooms
with a bitter wild nettle purée and an electric sprinkle of tart sumac
Almost everything seems touched with fire and cumin; coarse salt and fresh mint
perfumed with toasted fig leaf and dried borage blossoms
which is to say duck liver whipped with sesame and served with slabs of grilled buckwheat toast
a Yemenite flatbread that you see in most Israeli cafes
hinting at stolidness but exploding into a hundred layers when you bite into it
herbed cream and even spicy fermented strawberry jam
The emblematic dish at Bestia lately has probably been the lamb neck
profoundly meaty slab that he finishes with a slash of tart salsa verde
So it makes sense that the best big meat dish at Bavel is the lamb neck “shawarma,” slow-roasted until it almost collapses in on itself
(Menashe says he has a cook working full-time on just the spice blends
and I can believe it.) You carve off a bit of the dripping meat
tuck in the vegetables — you have constructed the ultimate taco al pastor of the Middle East
and the rich meat seems to transform from solid to ethereal liquid in an instant
and the beef cheek tagine with couscous tastes like the best thing you ever made out of an Ottolenghi book
but you are going to want to try the shawarma at least once
Middle Eastern dinners don’t tend to be long on sweet endings
unless you count a cookie or two or a handful of dates to nibble with your mint tea
Her baklava is an alternative Georgian version
that resembles a babka wrapped in crisp pastry
and her oozing chocolate doughnut holes are Middle Eastern only in the hint of rosewater
And her best dessert — a puck of chocolate-enrobed licorice ice cream with Maldon salt
a dead ringer for the chocolate-covered Lakrids licorice candy from Denmark — may be Middle Eastern only in that the licorice root comes from the region
I take home pounds and pounds of that salty licorice every time I go to Copenhagen
I couldn’t have been happier to taste its essence in a formal dessert
Ori Menashe and Genevieve Gergis translate the Middle East to downtown L.A
Location: 500 Mateo St., Los Angeles, (213) 232-4966, baveldtla.com.
Prices: Spreads, $11-$19; flatbreads $16-$17; appetizers $7-$24; entrees $38-$42.
Details: 5-11 p.m. Sundays and Tuesdays to Thursdays; 5 p.m. to midnight Fridays and Saturdays. Credit cards accepted. Full bar. Valet parking.
Recommended dishes: Hummus; malawach; grilled oyster mushrooms; lamb-neck shawarma; licorice ice cream bonbon.
Jonathan Gold was the restaurant critic for the Los Angeles Times. He won the Pulitzer Prize in criticism in 2007 and was a finalist again in 2011. A Los Angeles native, he began writing the Counter Intelligence column for the L.A. Weekly in 1986, wrote about death metal and gangsta rap for Rolling Stone and Spin among other places, and was delighted that he managed to forge a career out of the professional eating of tacos. Gold died July 21, 2018.
Eater talks to chefs and founders Genevieve Gergis and Ori Menashe about their second restaurant in Los Angeles
But Bestia helped launch the neighborhood into one of the hottest in Los Angeles
paving the way for the less cloistered Bavel
which sits in a more visible building along Mateo Street just south of the 4th Street bridge
buzzing with energy once the room fills up
Menashe and Gergis talk to Eater about the successes of the past 10 months, and how much they’ve learned in this sophomore effort compared to their opening at Bestia.
Bavel has been the most critically and publicly praised restaurant of the past year. The acclaim is damn near universal, and a lot of that has to do with the hard work of Menashe, Gergis, and their team. Here’s how Gergis and Menashe feel about the response:
OM: We’re thrilled with the outcome of everything. I wasn’t really sure how people would perceive this cuisine and the way we execute it. We’re happy that people are appreciating and enjoying what we’re doing.
On opening a second restaurant, and all the lessons learned after opening Bestia six years ago:
OM: It was a really fun experience opening a second restaurant. You have a lot fewer obstacles because you learned so much from the first one. It was so much better to open Bavel with the experience that we had from Bestia.
GG: It’s like having a kid. (Menashe and Gergis have a daughter named Saffron). The first time is a disaster. A restaurant is the same.
OM: I was more calm and not as stressed. You’re more in control, and you have a better understanding of your abilities. We took a month to train staff, instead of week or two we had with Bestia. At Bavel, we have a larger dish pit and had enough plates. Also we had a lot of veterans from Bestia too, so the training process was a lot easier.
On doing this kind of Middle Eastern cuisine in a city that’s full of great Middle Eastern restaurants:
OM: Everyone has their style of doing Middle Eastern food. All of them are great, and all of them are unique in their own way. I don’t know if I could compare Bavel to them. I enjoy all of them. I’m happy that more Middle Eastern restaurants are opening because I think it’s good for the culture.
GG: Places like Kismet are doing something very different from what we’re doing. Kismet doesn’t have pita or hummus on their menu. It’s hard to compare when they have their own style. Sure they use za’atar and other similar flavor profiles. I think it’s easier to compare Italian food because it’s all pasta to pasta to pasta.
OM: We don’t have a lot of high-end Middle Eastern restaurants to compare Bavel to. No one is following a trend of dishes or styles. With something like pizza, you can compare things like the texture of the dough, sauce, fermentation. I guess the only thing you could compare Bavel to would be our hummus.
On which opening Menashe and Gergis are prouder of — Bestia or Bavel:
OM: We’re proud of Bestia because it was a long shot. The area was a complete unknown. We opened with the lowest budget on the planet, and we were barely able to make it. Most of the money came from our friends. But we’re proud of Bavel because it’s the cuisine of our heritage. We’re proud of both of them, and especially the two teams that are running them.
On LA’s stature in the national food scene:
OM: It’s amazing to see all these chefs come and open restaurants here. It’s a pretty cool time in LA right now. A lot of these chefs see this as a land of opportunity. The farms, the produce — they just want to see what they can do with the products we have. People would always say LA is great but there’s just no culture. There’s so much fucking culture here it’s insane.
OM: They say, the chef is an asshole. That’s the Beverly Hills culture. You’ll never win if you try to please those kinds of diners, but we do try to be as nice as possible.
OM: We have a ton of things to improve, and it’s the reason for us to go to work every day. We’re going to tweak things, elevate and change things on the menu. We haven’t even been through all of the seasons yet. Change is something that’s super important to us — we want to serve new dishes, and we want to bring old items back on the menu.
Oops. Something went wrong. Please enter a valid email and try again.
a column dedicated to our very opinionated editors’ favorite things to eat
“Our philosophy at both restaurants is utilizing all parts of the animal," Menashe says. “This is one of the parts that the butcher is always stuck with, because nobody wants to deal with the neck. We figure out ways to showcase how good it can be.”
“We’ve probably undergone the greatest behavior change experiment in human history in the last nine months.” — Jay Van Bavel
associate professor of psychology at New York University
Earlier this month, Behavioral Scientist teamed up with Knowable Magazine to host a discussion about the science of behavior change during COVID-19
I had the privilege of moderating the conversation with our guests
behavioral scientist Katy Milkman and social neuroscientist Jay Van Bavel.
The two shared their insights on a range of topics—vaccine uptake
how political identity and polarization have impacted public health
their behavior-change bright spots from an otherwise challenging year
If you didn’t get a chance to attend the event, you can view the complete conversation on YouTube or listen to it on SoundCloud
Below are four of the most thought-provoking things I learned about behavior change during the pandemic from Katy and Jay.
Why understanding the root causes of political identity and polarization are key for public health
“Getting at the root-causes element of behavior change is fundamental to understanding what’s going on,” he said
and it was some kind of medicine and that was polarized by our political leaders
“So it’s not a problem with masking per se
Individuals might say I don’t trust the masks
but those same individuals are not trusting anything
because of this polarization and the way the media landscape is set up
because of this polarization and the way the media landscape is set up.”
“I think that’s why it’s important to understand it at that level
because this is an issue that’s not going away in the U.S.”
Canada has a conservative and a liberal party
and they’ve been increasing in polarization
but their leaders there decided to all come together.”
He referenced a study that found that the political leaders from different parties were speaking about the pandemic with similar levels of seriousness
Jay concluded: “If leaders … get on the same page about the seriousness of this
you’re going to have much more effective behavior change
The power of megastudies to help us understand how to boost vaccine uptake
Katy explained: “We set up two megastudies
One was with two large hospital systems … We wanted to test different ideas around messages that could be pushed to patients in text messages leading up to a healthy visit
The other study was with Walmart and their pharmacy team with hundreds of thousands of customers…
About 700,000 [customers] were randomized to get different messages encouraging them to come and get a flu shot this year.”
“It’s really important to send messages that are clear
One of the big winners was also highlighting for someone
They focused on understanding follow through
“Estimates suggest it’s anywhere between 30 to 70 percent of us who will say I am going to get this colonoscopy
and then don’t actually show up.” The goal was to “bridge that follow-through gap,” Katy said
Katy and her team were able to bring together about 130 scientists to test dozens of ideas
only the data from the first megastudy with the two hospitals systems is in
The key takeaways for Katy so far are that “it’s really important to send messages that are clear
“One of the big winners … was also highlighting for someone
Almost implying there’s a default that we expect you to get this
“A lot of the behavioral science that we would expect to work well did
or surprising actually didn’t perform as well as I might have expected,” she concluded
Are people more likely to change their behavior if they have personal experience with COVID-19
A viewer asked a terrific question: What is the impact on your behavior if you have personal experience with COVID-19
Katy: “There’s this really great research by Ido Erev
who studied the way we react to described versus experienced risk
None of us had experienced this scary disease but we’d read about it in the papers and heard that it could kill a huge portion of the population
we were terrified and a lot of people took drastic measures
but maybe no one you know has gotten sick or been affected…
When we experience risk we’re much less likely actually to behave in a risk-averse way
and part of that is that we don’t experience the rare negative events and so we underweight their likelihood
“So when we know someone or something really bad happens to someone in our network
that shock can actually be helpful in reminding us that risk is very real even though you hadn’t experienced it before.”
Jay: “That was my prediction last March…
and I think that works in almost every domain
but I’m just going to tell you the data from the U.S
I had to write in a paper that I was wrong about this.
“What we found in our data is that as the pandemic spread into [politically conservative] areas
it didn’t have any impact on their social distancing
the partisan gap between Democrats and Republicans grew bigger
So this was a horrifying piece of evidence—that being exposed to risk in your neighborhood
your town isn’t necessarily going to be good evidence for you to change your behavior
That was probably the most disheartening piece of data I’ve ever had in any of my research
“This was a horrifying piece of evidence—that being exposed to risk in your neighborhood
your town isn’t necessarily going to be good evidence for you to change your behavior.”
“I do think there’s trickiness—for the average person in most cases that actually is a really good principle and likely true
at least over the time frame we looked at it.”
Katy: “Do you think that’s a decent proxy for having someone have a negative experience
when I talk to some of my friends … they know people who’ve gotten COVID and been fine
So having it spread in their community actually didn’t give them the really negative perception
it rather gave them exposure to the nonrare events
I would still make a prediction that that might change your behavior
But the death rate is like less than one percent of people who get it
so I think if you could hone in on those one percent of people and people around them
“But 99 percent of people—Donald Trump embodied this
He was in the hospital on oxygen and it didn’t change any of his behavior
He just kept holding giant rallies with people who knew that he had been hospitalized from it
he hosted an event and it led to Herman Cain
a former Republican presidential candidate
and he didn’t seem to change his behavior either
science (and scientists) shone brightly this year
Last year was a tough one. But there were also reasons for hope. We concluded our conversation with Katy and Jay sharing their behavior change bright spots from the past year. Here’s what they picked. [Jump to this part of the conversation, 53:50]
Katy: “This whole year has been an extraordinary success in terms of behavior change
we would have liked it to go even smoother and even farther and even faster
But it is remarkable the collective change in behavior that we have seen to save lives
by not having concerts and staying at home and working from home and all of the sacrifices we’ve made
“Another bright spot to me scientifically actually has been how incredibly willing scientists have been to pivot and help whenever asked…
a governor’s office called and wanted help
and we just put up a Google Sheet and asked [scientists] to write in their suggestions
and it’s amazing to see how committed everyone is to helping.”
Jay: “This pandemic has changed the way I do science—to be much more cooperative and collaborative
and I think I’m never going to go back
The other thing I think that is important to me is to think about what are the silver linings
what habits can we keep… We’ve reduced travel
The next big crisis we’re going to face as humanity is the climate-change crisis
and we’re going to change a lot of behavior and policies around that.”
we have the opportunity to reflect on how our lives changed in 2020 and set out a plan for 2021
If we want to put the pandemic in the rearview mirror sooner rather than later
we’ll have to reduce the divisions that emerged during the last year and embrace the collaborative energy that has helped us get through it.
Become a Subscriber — Special offer: Receive a copy of the award-winning print edition
or a Behavioral Scientist t-shirt or hat when you join at the Print + Digital + Events or Investor level
Evan Nesterak is the co-founder and editor-in-chief of the Behavioral Scientist
After the commotion caused around Claudia Bavel's latest television appearance
Yola Berrocal has taken a new step forward
The representative has made a U-turn by revealing the final decision made by Luis Figo: "There is no lawsuit[...]it has already been communicated."
On February 28, this well-known actress and adult content creator returned to the set of ¡De Viernes!. But this time, she did so to talk about the risqué conversations she had with the footballer Joaquín Sánchez
outraged by Claudia Bavel's latest statements | Europa PressHowever
the most talked-about part of the night was the statements made by Yola Berrocal's client about Luis Figo
the Portuguese tried to flirt with her at one of the parties she attended with Iker Casillas
As expected, Claudia Bavel's words did not sit well with the athlete
So much so that he didn't think twice about threatening the influencer through social media:
They should wash their mouth before referring to me
I will take legal action in response to this defamatory information." A warning that prompted Yola Berrocal's immediate reaction
Yola Berrocal and her manager rectify on social media | en.e-noticies.cat
GTRESBavel's manager issued a statement in which the influencer retracted her statements
despite having claimed otherwise 48 hours earlier on ¡De Viernes!
Yola Berrocal has reappeared in front of Europa Press's cameras and has revealed the current status of this controversy
A moment in which she exposed the decision the footballer has made with her client
a team from the aforementioned news agency had the opportunity to speak for a few minutes with Yola Berrocal
A moment they took advantage of to ask her about all the latest developments related to Claudia Bavel and Luis Figo
Yola Berrocal claims the issue with Luis Figo is solved
| Europa PressWith a big smile on her face and visibly calmer
the athlete is not going to take legal action against the influencer
she had no qualms about sharing how her client is currently doing: "Very well
Both Claudia Bavel and her manager are convinced that their statement apologizing has been enough to calm Luis Figo's spirits
the footballer shared their statements on his own profiles
Restaurant chef-owners Ori Menashe
(Dania Maxwell / Los Angeles Times) Menashe’s talents with the dish have a fresh platform at Saffy’s
the couple’s new kebab and small plates restaurant in East Hollywood named for their daughter Saffron
The flashier of the pair includes a dollop of long-simmered fava beans brightened with lemon and fermented serrano chiles; a soft-boiled egg perches on the side as a bonus
halved to reveal its jammy insides and sprinkled with cumin and big flakes of salt
It’s an advanced course in subtle contrasts: the way the mulchy favas melt into the blitzed chickpeas; the interplay of earthy flavors; and how a pool of good olive oil can flatter and unite all the ingredients it bathes
the Yemeni hot sauce rendered here more herbal than scorching
brings in the acidic jolt that Menashe favors
is the handful of pine nuts scattered over the top
The cost of exquisite pine nuts — long and tapered rather than short and squat
buttery and with the freshest ones hinting of resin — has lately skyrocketed
come from the south of Lebanon; savoring even a couple of them in each bite makes for a rare treat
crisped slices of challah crusted with black and white sesame seeds
I don’t want to see the traditional khubz (Arabic flatbread) or pita broadly replaced as accompaniments
egg-rich toast through drifts of hummus is undeniable
Patrons of Saffy’s sit down to order an early dinner
(Dania Maxwell / Los Angeles Times) Details like these make Saffy’s another victory for Menashe and Gergis
focusing on kebabs with a dozen or so California-inflected salads and starters
it may have appeared that the duo was striving for something more casual among their growing businesses
The Art Deco space in the Merrick Building — which housed the short-lived Brooklyn import Five Leaves and sits across the street from the Church of Scientology’s “Big Blue” building — has a slightly more informal air than its older siblings
though boomingly loud like the others; a recently installed awning that stretches nearly to the curb added significant
It’s evident in the fleet of single-minded chefs
their foreheads covered by multicolored bandannas
many of whom worked at Bestia or Bavel for years
It’s unmistakable in the precision of the cooking that channels the spice-fragrant
though many friends and peers from the area increasingly rebuff the term) and North Africa
Grayson Hestir prepares cocktails at the bar
(Dania Maxwell / Los Angeles Times) One can argue how “casual” may be best defined these days; I certainly wouldn’t label Saffy’s as inexpensive
Overall Menashe and Gergis don’t quite seem capable of a stripped-down
The corner of Fountain Avenue and North Catalina Street is the place to be in Los Angeles mid-2022
You can see the crowd filling the sidewalk from blocks away
Soon you’re shouting in conversation among the dining room’s pink and earth tones — the gilded geometrics of the booths and light fixtures recall glamorous magazine stills of Beirut or Marrakesh in their 1960s eras — or breathing a little easier at a table outside
like tequila-spiked cherry limeade or a Vesper spritzed with rose water and lemon oil
appear quickly and often disappear just as swiftly
A grilled lobster skewer
serrano-lime yogurt and sprouting cilantro
(Dania Maxwell / Los Angeles Times) If you know Bavel
you’ll recognize the same master formula at Saffy’s: a grab bag of flavors expressing the couple’s upbringings (Gergis’ family is of Egyptian ancestry; Menashe grew up in Israel and also has Turkish and Moroccan roots)
A flecked ring of smoky eggplant puree cradles a juicy heap of chopped tomatoes dotted with milky feta and nigella seeds; cinnamon shimmers distantly like heat rising over the horizon
Preserved Meyer lemon and the woodsy sweetness of ras el hanout bring spark to the familiar pairing of carrots and yogurt
Break open the falafel; it is the green of a tea garden in spring
An appetizer of grilled lobster has been threaded onto a skewer as a prelude to the meatier courses ahead
Slathered in a mix of green harissa and lime-scented yogurt without overpowering the lobster’s sweetness
it’s a splurge at $32 … and also the most compelling use of that costly seafood I’ve consumed so far this decade
Kebabs come with a very Angeleno array of condiments: an herbed tahini salad that evokes Green Goddess dressing; tangy, vivid-orange amba running over the top like runaway mango pickle lava; and a small tea cup’s worth of crimson chile crisp. You may lose yourself in trying various groupings of tastes and textures. You will hopefully emerge as sated as I have each meal.
Desserts, admittedly, run casual, including a swirl of seasonal soft-serve ice creams (peach and raspberry was the big summer hit) and crème caramel perfumed with orange blossom. A handsome slice of chocolate cake, crowned with a correct, generous ratio of ganache, lands at most tables.
The bakery draws intermittent crowds so far. It gives Gergis and Menashe something to strive for, since their newest restaurant has — predictably for their track record — reached the height of its powers almost immediately.
4845 Fountain Ave., Los Angeles, (424) 699-4845, saffysla.comPrices: Appetizers $9-$32, kebabs $18, larger format mains $26-$65, desserts $10-$12.Details: Restaurant open 5-11 p.m. Tuesday-Sunday. Coffee and tea shop open 8 a.m.-3 p.m. Wednesday-Sunday.Recommended dishes: hummus tahini, tomato salad, falafel, lobster skewer, shawarma, lamb kebabs, chocolate cake.
Bill Addison is the restaurant critic of the Los Angeles Times. He is recipient of the 2023 Craig Claiborne Distinguished Restaurant Review Award from the James Beard Foundation, among numerous other accolades. Addison was previously national critic for Eater and held food critic positions at the San Francisco Chronicle, the Dallas Morning News and Atlanta magazine.
Travel & Experiences
Lifestyle
Metrics details
The COVID-19 pandemic represents a massive global health crisis
Because the crisis requires large-scale behaviour change and places significant psychological burdens on individuals
insights from the social and behavioural sciences can be used to help align human behaviour with the recommendations of epidemiologists and public health experts
Here we discuss evidence from a selection of research topics relevant to pandemics
social and cultural influences on behaviour
we note the nature and quality of prior research
including uncertainty and unsettled issues
We identify several insights for effective response to the COVID-19 pandemic and highlight important gaps researchers should move quickly to fill in the coming weeks and months
the virus had spread to more than 118,000 cases and caused 4,291 deaths in 114 countries
leading the World Health Organization to declare a global pandemic
The pandemic has led to a massive global public health campaign to slow the spread of the virus by increasing hand washing
wearing masks in public and physical distancing
Infographic depicting a selection of topics from the social and behavioural sciences relevant during a pandemic
Topics covered here include threat perception
We have highlighted relevant findings in each area as well as critical gaps in the literature
Insights and implications for policy should be interpreted with caution because there is very little published social science research on the current pandemic
our discussion often draws from different circumstances than the current pandemic (for example
laboratory experiments examining hypothetical scenarios)
and the quality of the evidence cited varies substantially (for example
correlational studies vs field experiments; single studies vs systematic reviews of substantial evidence)
we try to describe the quality of evidence to facilitate careful
We call for the scientific community to mobilize rapidly to produce research to directly inform policy and individual and collective behaviour in response to the pandemic
we discuss how people are likely to perceive and respond to threats and risk during a pandemic and downstream consequences for decision-making and intergroup relations
We highlight some insights for public health experts
A shared sense of identity or purpose can be encouraged by addressing the public in collective terms and by urging ‘us’ to act for the common good
religious or community leaders) that are credible to different audiences to share public health messages can be effective
Leaders and the media might try to promote cooperative behaviour by emphasizing that cooperating is the right thing to do and that other people are already cooperating
Norms of prosocial behaviour are more effective when coupled with the expectation of social approval and modelled by in-group members who are central in social networks
Leaders and members of the media should highlight bipartisan support for COVID-related measures
as such endorsements in other contexts have reduced polarization and led to less-biased reasoning
There is a need for more targeted public health information within marginalized communities and for partnerships between public health authorities and trusted organizations that are internal to these communities
Messages that (i) emphasize benefits to the recipient
(iii) align with the recipient’s moral values
(iv) appeal to social consensus or scientific norms and/or (v) highlight the prospect of social group approval tend to be persuasive
Given the importance of slowing infections
it may be helpful to make people aware that they benefit from others’ access to preventative measures
Preparing people for misinformation and ensuring they have accurate information and counterarguments against false information before they encounter conspiracy theories
can help inoculate them against false information
Use of the term ‘social distancing’ might imply that one needs to cut off meaningful interactions
A preferable term is ‘physical distancing’
because it allows for the fact that social connection is possible even when people are physically separated
The results suggest that strong fear appeals produce the greatest behaviour change only when people feel a sense of efficacy
whereas strong fear appeals with low-efficacy messages produce the greatest levels of defensive responses
Communication strategies must strike a balance between breaking through optimism bias without inducing excessive feelings of anxiety and dread
people may rely on negative information about COVID-19 more than other information to make decisions
The media usually report on COVID-19 negatively—for example
by reporting the number of people infected and those who die—as opposed to those who recover or experience only mild symptoms
This may increase negative emotion and sensitize people to otherwise neglected risks for themselves or others
Research is needed to determine whether a more positive frame could educate the public and relieve negative emotions while increasing public health behaviours
people are less likely to die from over-reaction than from under-reaction
not responding to signs of danger until it is too late
use of the notion of panic can be actively harmful
News stories that employ the language of panic often create the very phenomena that they purport to condemn
They can foster the very individualism and competitiveness that turns sensible preparations into dysfunctional stockpiling and undermine the sense of collective purpose which facilitates people supporting one another during an emergency
Slowing viral transmission during pandemics requires significant shifts in behaviour
Various aspects of social and cultural contexts influence the extent and speed of behaviour change
we describe how aspects of the social context
may help decision-makers identify risk factors and effectively intervene
messages that provide in-group models for norms (for example
members of your community) may therefore be most effective
We may therefore leverage the impact of any behaviour change effort by targeting well-connected individuals and making their behaviour change visible and salient to others
a message with compelling social norms might say
‘the overwhelming majority of people in your community believe that everyone should stay home’
Nudges and normative information can be an alternative to more coercive means of behaviour change or used to complement regulatory
legal and other imposed policies when widespread changes must occur rapidly
Members of these communities may be more likely to be wary about the public health information they receive
less willing to adopt recommended safety measures and potentially more susceptible to ‘fake news’
This suggests the need for more targeted public health information and for partnerships between public health authorities and trusted organizations that are internal to these communities
This is another reason why interpersonal transmission of the virus could be more likely in independent cultures than in interdependent cultures
Tight rules regarding social distancing are critical
yet looseness within these constraints may also help to spawn the development of creative technical solutions that are needed to contain the pandemic
as well as creating novel tools to help people feel connected
The cumulative evidence here suggests that very different strategies might be called for in varying cultural contexts in the fight against COVID-19
The decrease in in-person contact due to COVID-19 may reduce cross-partisan interactions and information sharing
it is hard for the public to distinguish scientific evidence and facts from less reliable sources of information
we discuss the challenges associated with different forms of misinformation during a pandemic
as well as strategies for engaging in effective science communication and persuasion around public health
other approaches beyond debunking are needed
finding credible sources for different audiences who are able to share public health messages might prove effective
It may therefore be useful to identify which messages work best on which populations not only to generate policy support but also to ensure individuals’ actions needed to combat the spread of the virus
we consider how research on morality and cooperation can encourage prosocial behaviours by individuals and groups
Zero-sum thinking means that while it might be psychologically compelling to hoard protective materials (sanitizer
it may be helpful to make people aware that others’ access to preventative measures is a benefit to oneself
it may be best to have decisions behind life-for-life trade-offs perceived as systematic and coming from governmental agencies rather than from physicians themselves
may encourage people to make sacrifices for others
reframing decisions to carry on with ‘business as usual’ during a pandemic as active decisions
This suggests that leaders and the media can promote cooperation by making these behaviours more observable
Crises like the COVID-19 pandemic create an opportunity for leadership across groups of varying levels: families
Leadership can coordinate individuals and help them avoid behaviours that are no longer considered socially responsible
we discuss the roles of trust and compliance with leaders
effective identity leadership and supporting group members
Reliable information and public health messages are needed from national leaders and central health officials
But local voices can amplify these messages and help build the trust that is needed to spur behavioural change
there is a risk that people will avoid acts of citizenship and instead embrace a philosophy of ‘everyone for themselves’
celebrities and community leaders model exemplary behaviour and sacrifice could help promote prosocial behaviour and cooperation
To increase people’s willingness to take a pandemic seriously and engage with other nations to defeat it
citizens and leaders may need to accept that their country is at risk
and find ways to share resources and expertise across national boundaries
the pandemic is likely to function as a major stressor
especially in terms of chronic anxiety and economic difficulties
Such effects may be exacerbated by self-isolation policies that can increase social isolation and relationship difficulties
we consider some strategies to mitigate the virus-linked threats to social connection
Distancing threatens to aggravate feelings of loneliness and could produce negative long-term health consequences
This means one can be isolated but not lonely
the term ‘social distancing’ might imply that one needs to cut off meaningful interactions
A useful alternative term might be ‘physical distancing’
to help highlight the fact that social connection is possible even when people are physically separated
Special attention should be placed on helping people who are less familiar with these technologies to learn how to take advantage of digital connections
The recalibration process involves both (i) lowering broad expectations that the course of true love in the time of COVID-19 will run smoothly while also (ii) sustaining high expectations in those domains where the relationship can deliver in these conditions
Research is needed to see if adopting these mind-sets can help some people harness the stress during a pandemic for positive growth
Clinical course and risk factors for mortality of adult inpatients with COVID-19 in Wuhan
Lunn, P. et al. Using behavioural science to help fight the coronavirus. ESRI Working Paper No. 656 March 2020. http://aei.pitt.edu/102644/ (2020)
Biology of Plagues: Evidence from Historical Populations
The ecology of human fear: survival optimization and the nervous system
Experimental evidence of massive-scale emotional contagion through social networks
Affective signals of threat increase perceived proximity
A meta-analysis of fear appeals: implications for effective public health campaigns
Depressive symptoms are associated with unrealistic negative predictions of future life events
Wise, T., Zbozinek, T. D., Michelini, G., Hagan, C. C. & Mobbs, D. Changes in risk perception and protective behavior during the first week of the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States. Preprint at PsyArXiv https://osf.io/dz428 (2020)
Risk as analysis and risk as feelings: some thoughts about affect
The functions of affect in health communications and in the construction of health preferences
Graphic warning labels elicit affective and thoughtful responses from smokers: results of a randomized clinical trial
Pictorial cigarette pack warnings: a meta-analysis of experimental studies
and electric shocks: on the affective psychology of risk
and muggers: on the affective psychology of value
Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 46
Ecological and cultural factors underlying the global distribution of prejudice
With Malice Toward Some: How People Make Civil Liberties Judgments
Us and them: intergroup failures of empathy
Neurocognitive basis of racial ingroup bias in empathy
They see us as less than human: metadehumanization predicts intergroup conflict via reciprocal dehumanization
A neurobiological association of revenge propensity during intergroup conflict
waves of hate from the Plague of Athens to A.I.D.S
Russell, A. The rise of coronavirus hate crimes. The New Yorker https://www.newyorker.com/news/letter-from-the-uk/the-rise-of-coronavirus-hate-crimes (2020)
Another view of “we”: majority and minority group perspectives on a common ingroup identity
The extended contact effect: knowledge of cross-group friendships and prejudice
The role of social identity processes in mass emergency behaviour: an integrative review
Facing the Unexpected: Disaster Preparedness and Response in the United States
in International Encyclopedia of the Social and Behavioural Sciences (eds
The nature of collective resilience: survivor reactions to the 2005 London bombings
Applying crowd psychology to develop recommendations for the management of mass decontamination
Stiff, C. The game theory of panic-buying – and how to reduce it. The Conversation http://theconversation.com/the-game-theory-of-panic-buying-and-how-to-reduce-it-134107 (2020)
Social influence: compliance and conformity
Attitude change: persuasion and social influence
The construction of social norms and standards
in Social Psychology: Handbook of Basic Principles 799–829 (Guilford Press
The effects of perceived social norms on handwashing behaviour in students
in Changing the Culture of College Drinking: A Socially Situated Health Communication Campaign (eds
A focus theory of normative conduct: a theoretical refinement and reevaluation of the role of norms in human behavior
in Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 24
Knowing what to think by knowing who you are: self-categorization and the nature of norm formation
An experimental study of homophily in the adoption of health behavior
Social contagion theory: examining dynamic social networks and human behavior
Social network sensors for early detection of contagious outbreaks
Social network targeting to maximise population behaviour change: a cluster randomised controlled trial
A 61-million-person experiment in social influence and political mobilization
Inside the Nudge Unit: How Small Changes Can Make a Big Difference (Random House
Dynamic norms promote sustainable behavior
Plumbing poverty: mapping hot spots of racial and geographic inequality in U.S
The social determinants of chronic disease
Poverty and disasters in the United States: a review of recent sociological findings
E.) 181–203 (Springer International Publishing
Benefit inequality among American workers by gender
Communities in Action: Pathways to Health Equity
Racial/ethnic differences in multimorbidity development and chronic disease accumulation for middle-aged adults
Individual-level evidence for the causes and consequences of social capital
Factors relating to misanthropy in contemporary American society
An empirical test of the reciprocal nature of social capital
Culture and the self: Implications for cognition
A cultural task analysis of implicit independence: comparing North America
Self-assertive interdependence in Arab culture
Behavioral adjustment moderates the link between neuroticism and biological health risk: a U.S.-Japan comparison study
On the benefits of explaining herd immunity in vaccine advocacy
Interdependent self-construal predicts emotion suppression in Asian Americans: an electro-cortical investigation
Differences between tight and loose cultures: a 33-nation study
The strength of social norms across human groups
Tightness-looseness across the 50 United States
Societal threat and cultural variation in the strength of social norms: an evolutionary basis
Rule Breakers: How Tight and Loose Cultures Wire Our World
The tie that divides: cross-national evidence of the primacy of partyism
The origins and consequences of affective polarization in the United States
Authoritarianism and polarization in American politics
The rise of negative partisanship and the nationalization of U.S
The partisan brain: an identity-based model of political belief
Exposure to ideologically diverse news and opinion on Facebook
The hostile audience: the effect of access to broadband internet on partisan affect
Emotion shapes the diffusion of moralized content in social networks
The incidental pundit: who talks politics with whom
The parties in our heads: misperceptions about party composition and their consequences
Inaccurate group meta-perceptions drive negative out-group attributions in competitive contexts
The influence of partisan motivated reasoning on public opinion
Ellis, E.G. The coronavirus outbreak is a petri dish for conspiracy theories. Wired https://www.wired.com/story/coronavirus-conspiracy-theories/ (2020)
A major event has a major cause: evidence for the role of heuristics in reasoning about conspiracy theories
The popularity of conspiracy theories of presidential assassination: a Bayesian analysis
Conspiracy theories as part of history: the role of societal crisis situations
The dark side of meaning-making: how social exclusion leads to superstitious thinking
The effects of anti-vaccine conspiracy theories on vaccination intentions
The robust relationship between conspiracism and denial of (climate) science
Political extremism predicts belief in conspiracy theories
Exposure to intergroup conspiracy theories promotes prejudice which spreads across groups
Kofta, M., Soral, W. & Bilewicz, M. What breeds conspiracy antisemitism? The role of political uncontrollability and uncertainty in the belief in Jewish conspiracy. J. Pers. Soc. Psychol. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspa0000183 (2020)
In search of an imaginary enemy: Catholic collective narcissism and the endorsement of gender conspiracy beliefs
Prevention is better than cure: addressing anti‐vaccine conspiracy theories
Evaluating the fake news problem at the scale of the information ecosystem
Social media and fake news in the 2016 election
Less than you think: prevalence and predictors of fake news dissemination on Facebook
Rumors and health care reform: experiments in political misinformation
Misinformation and its correction: continued influence and successful debiasing
Guess, A. & Coppock, A. Does counter-attitudinal information cause backlash? Results from three large survey experiments. Br. J. Polit. Sci. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0007123418000327 (2018)
Effective strategies for rebutting science denialism in public discussions
Displacing misinformation about events: an experimental test of causal corrections
in Social Media and Democracy: The State of the Field (eds Persily
Misinformation and its correction: Cognitive mechanisms and recommendations for mass communication
The elusive backfire effect: mass attitudes’ steadfast factual adherence
Pennycook, G., McPhetres, J., Zhang, Y. & Rand, D. Fighting COVID-19 misinformation on social media: Experimental evidence for a scalable accuracy nudge intervention. Preprint at PsyArXiv https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/uhbk9 (2020)
Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 1
Inoculating the public against misinformation about climate change
A meta-analysis of research on inoculation theory
Good news about bad news: gamified inoculation boosts confidence and cognitive immunity against fake news
Fake news game confers psychological resistance against online misinformation
Roozenbeek, J., van der Linden, S. & Nygren, T. Prebunking interventions based on “inoculation” theory can reduce susceptibility to misinformation across cultures. Harv. Kennedy Sch. Misinformation Rev. https://doi.org/10.37016//mr-2020-008 (2020)
not biased: susceptibility to partisan fake news is better explained by lack of reasoning than by motivated reasoning
Belief in fake news is associated with delusionality
Bago, B., Rand, D. G. & Pennycook, G. Fake news, fast and slow: deliberation reduces belief in false (but not true) news headlines. J. Exp. Psychol. Gen. https://psycnet.apa.org/doi/10.1037/xge0000729 (2020)
Dias, N., Pennycook, G. & Rand, D. G. Emphasizing publishers does not effectively reduce susceptibility to misinformation on social media. Harv. Kennedy Sch. Misinformation Rev. https://doi.org/10.37016/mr-2020-001 (2020)
Fighting misinformation on social media using crowdsourced judgments of news source quality
Clayton, K. et al. Real solutions for fake news? Measuring the effectiveness of general warnings and fact-check tags in reducing belief in false stories on social media. Polit. Behav. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11109-019-09533-0 (2019)
Presenting quantitative information about decision outcomes: a risk communication primer for patient decision aid developers
The elaboration likelihood model of persuasion
Advances in Experimental Social Psychology 19
Source factors in persuasion: a self-validation approach
Lessons from the faith-driven response to the West Africa Ebola epidemic
A review and conceptual framework for understanding personalized matching effects in persuasion
It’s not all about me: motivating hand hygiene among health care professionals by focusing on patients
Moral reframing: a technique for effective and persuasive communication across political divides
The pivotal role of perceived scientific consensus in acceptance of science
Scientific agreement can neutralize politicization of facts
The gateway belief model: a large-scale replication
Individuals with greater science literacy and education have more polarized beliefs on controversial science topics
The polarizing impact of science literacy and numeracy on perceived climate change risks
The evidence for motivated reasoning in climate change preference formation
Consumer conviction and commitment: an appraisal-based framework for attitude certainty
The mere perception of elaboration creates attitude certainty: exploring the thoughtfulness heuristic
Making it moral: merely labeling an attitude as moral increases its strength
and the Gap between Us and Them (Penguin Press
The emotional dog and its rational tail: a social intuitionist approach to moral judgment
The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion
Groups in mind: the coalitional roots of war and morality
in APA handbook of Personality and Social Psychology
Volume 2: Group Processes 123–149 (American Psychological Association
Morality and the Regulation of Social Behavior
Morality in groups: on the social-regulatory functions of right and wrong
Folk-economic beliefs: an evolutionary cognitive model
Zero-sum bias: perceived competition despite unlimited resources
Inference of trustworthiness from intuitive moral judgments
Patients on the Trolley Track: The Moral Cognition of Medical Practitioners and Public Health Professionals
Motivated Bayesians: feeling moral while acting egoistically
Ambiguity and excuse-driven behavior in charitable giving
Uncertainty about the impact of social decisions increases prosocial behaviour
Partner choice creates competitive altruism in humans
Reputation helps solve the ‘tragedy of the commons’
Patterns of moral judgment derive from nonmoral psychological representations
Reluctance to vaccinate: omission bias and ambiguity
Accountability amplifies the status quo effect when change creates victims
Five rules for the evolution of cooperation
Climate change: what psychology can offer in terms of insights and solutions
Humans choose representatives who enforce cooperation in social dilemmas through extortion
One for all: what representing a group may do to us
The provision of a sanctioning system as a public good
Positive interactions promote public cooperation
“Do the right thing:” the effects of moral suasion on cooperation
Increasing altruistic and cooperative behaviour with simple moral nudges
Community-based crisis response: evidence from Sierra Leone’s Ebola outbreak
Tsai, L.L., Morse, B.S. & Blair, R.A. Building credibility and cooperation in low-trust settings: persuasion and source accountability in Liberia during the 2014–2015 Ebola crisis. Comp. Polit. Stud. https://doi.org/10.1177/0010414019897698 (2020)
Public health and public trust: survey evidence from the Ebola virus disease epidemic in Liberia
Patterns of demand for non-Ebola health services during and after the Ebola outbreak: panel survey evidence from Monrovia
Institutional trust and misinformation in the response to the 2018-19 Ebola outbreak in North Kivu
Social identity and the dynamics of leadership: Leaders and followers as collaborative agents in the transformation of social reality
The New Psychology of Leadership: Identity
Believing in “us”: exploring leaders’ capacity to enhance team confidence and performance by building a sense of shared social identity
Stressing the group: social identity and the unfolding dynamics of responses to stress
The link between leadership and followership: how affirming social identity translates vision into action
The Myth Of Leadership: Creating Leaderless Organizations
On sanction-goal justifications: How and why deterrence justifications undermine rule compliance
Why People Cooperate: The Role of Social Motivations
Looking up to virtue: averting gaze facilitates moral construals via posteromedial activations
Collective narcissism and its social consequences
Understanding defensive and secure in-group positivity: the role of collective narcissism
‘They will not control us’: ingroup positivity and belief in intergroup conspiracies
The need to belong: desire for interpersonal attachments as a fundamental human motivation
Advancing the social identity approach to health and well-being: progressing the social cure research agenda
Emotion elicits the social sharing of emotion: theory and empirical review
Interpersonal emotion regulation: Implications for affiliation
The New Psychology of Health: Unlocking the Social Cure
Loneliness matters: a theoretical and empirical review of consequences and mechanisms
and mortality in old age: a national longitudinal study
Loneliness: Human Nature and the Need for Social Connection
Helping others regulate emotion predicts increased regulation of one’s own emotions and decreased symptoms of depression
Comparing the happiness effects of real and on-line friends
Passive Facebook usage undermines affective well-being: experimental and longitudinal evidence
a more thoughtful mind in the midst of disagreement
Does online technology make us more or less sociable
a preliminary review and call for research
The psychological impact of quarantine and how to reduce it: rapid review of the evidence
The dark side of inclusion: undesired acceptance increases aggression
Owen, L. Five ways the coronavirus is hitting women in Asia. BBC News https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-51705199 (2020)
Socioeconomic status and intimate relationships
Couples and stress: how demands outside a relationship affect intimacy within the relationship
in The Oxford Handbook of Close Relationships (eds
Life course transitions and natural disaster: marriage
The All-or-Nothing Marriage: How the Best Marriages Work
Optimizing stress: an integrated intervention for regulating stress responses
Optimizing stress responses with reappraisal and mindset interventions: an integrated model
Arousal and physiological toughness: implications for mental and physical health
Embodying psychological thriving: physical thriving in response to stress
Dehydroepiandrosterone as a regulator of immune cell function
Posttraumatic growth: conceptual foundations and empirical evidence
The role of stress mindset in shaping cognitive
and physiological responses to challenging and threatening stress
Rethinking stress: the role of mindsets in determining the stress response
The boomerang effect a synthesis of findings and a preliminary theoretical framework
Revisiting the theory of psychological reactance: Communicating threats to attitudinal freedom
in The Persuasion Handbook: Developments in Theory and Practice (eds
Collective emotions and social resilience in the digital traces after a terrorist attack
The MAD model of moral contagion: the role of motivation
attention and design in the spread of moralized content online
Economic deprivation and early childhood development
The impact of unemployment on health: a review of the evidence
Why health communication is important in public health
Download references
Department of Psychology & Neural Science
University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy
Social and Cognitive Neuroscience Laboratory
Department of Psychology and the Kellogg School of Management
Division of Infectious Diseases and Global Public Health and Department of Political Science
School of Psychological and Cognitive Sciences
PKU-IDG/McGovern Institute for Brain Research
Department of Humanities and Social Sciences and Computation and Neural Systems Program
Sloan School and Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences
Department of Psychology University of Cambridge
Simone Schnall & Sander van der Linden
Institute for Brain and Behavior Amsterdam
Department of Experimental and Applied Psychology
The corresponding authors (J.V.B and R.W.) came up with the idea for the paper
and S.R.Z.) wrote and edited the paper and are listed in alphabetical order
Rothschild for his help in inserting citations and organizing the list of biographical references
The authors declare no competing interests
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41562-020-0884-z
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
a shareable link is not currently available for this article
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science
Here’s what to know about the upcoming Saffy’s on Fountain
Two of LA’s biggest restaurant names are on the move, as Ori Menashe and Genevieve Gergis plan a brand new restaurant in the heart of East Hollywood. Menashe and Gergis are the husband and wife partnership team behind two of the city’s biggest hits in Bestia and Bavel
and now they’re going much more casual along Fountain
The incoming restaurant, named Saffy’s after their daughter Saffron Menashe
has been quietly in the works for months now
While menu details are still being finalized
this will definitely fit into the broad Middle Eastern perspective — including Egyptian and Israeli flavors — that the pair know so well
Saffy’s will operate as a more casual offering from the group (including director of operations and partner Leah Bunch)
Both Bestia and Bavel are dinner-only destinations
so this will be the first time that Menashe and Gergis have teamed up to feed the lunch and afternoon crowds
The incoming Saffy’s takes over the former Five Leaves space at the corner of Fountain and Catalina, across the street from the always-busy Found Oyster and legacy neighborhood brunch restaurant Square One. Despite a years-long build-out, the previous Brooklyn-based tenant lasted only a scant nine months before closing up shop in February 2020
just one month before the first round of restaurant closures and lockdowns as a result of the ongoing pandemic
The space at 4845 Fountain Avenue has been boarded up since then
though work has been ongoing inside over the past few months
While Menashe and Gergis have been mostly quiet about the coming expansion, word has been trickling out in the neighborhood and beyond for some time. Over the weekend, the group even began an open employment call on its social media channels
Metrics details
An Author Correction to this article was published on 06 April 2022
This article has been updated
Changing collective behaviour and supporting non-pharmaceutical interventions is an important component in mitigating virus transmission during a pandemic
In a large international collaboration (Study 1
we investigated self-reported factors associated with public health behaviours (e.g.
spatial distancing and stricter hygiene) and endorsed public policy interventions (e.g.
closing bars and restaurants) during the early stage of the COVID-19 pandemic (April-May 2020)
Respondents who reported identifying more strongly with their nation consistently reported greater engagement in public health behaviours and support for public health policies
Results were similar for representative and non-representative national samples
Study 2 (N = 42 countries) conceptually replicated the central finding using aggregate indices of national identity (obtained using the World Values Survey) and a measure of actual behaviour change during the pandemic (obtained from Google mobility reports)
Higher levels of national identification prior to the pandemic predicted lower mobility during the early stage of the pandemic (r = −0.40)
We discuss the potential implications of links between national identity
and public health for managing COVID-19 and future pandemics
we respond to this call for behavioural science on the pandemic
we present the results from two large-scale global studies across 67 (Study 1) and 42 (Study 2) countries
testing key predictors of public health support during COVID-19
Focusing on the potential role of national identity
we examine the role of key social motives in collective behaviour during the pandemic
and political leaders identify important factors and design more effective behavioural interventions to increase compliance with actions such as maintaining spatial distance and restricting travel during a pandemic
Our primary hypothesis is that stronger NI will be associated with greater support for and compliance with public health measures
in identifying associations with compliance with public health measures
we examined whether NI and narcissism were distinct from PI in explaining public health support
All the worldmaps were produced using R packages
The map is from the package ‘rworldmap’ and is licensed-free from South
rworldmap: A New R package for Mapping Global Data
We analyzed these data using multi-level models in which persons were treated as nested within countries51
We also included a measurement level to control for individual differences in how consistently people responded to items that were meant to measure the same construct
Our analyses estimated relationships at the individual level while controlling for country-level differences
did people who had a stronger NI endorse public health measures such as spatial distancing (e.g.
reducing physical contact) more strongly than people with a weaker NI
A set of regression coefficients was estimated for each country
and the means of these coefficients were tested for statistical significance
the standard errors of these coefficient incorporated “Bayesian shrinkage” meaning that less reliable observations (countries and individuals) influenced parameter estimates less than more reliable observations
We also adjusted for the COVID-19 infection and mortality rates within each country to ensure that public health support was not merely a function of local risks
we focused our interpretations on the person-level findings that were statistically significant at the p < 0.001 level
(The results with the Human Development Index (HDI) are available in the Supplementary Information)
Participants generally reported following the guidelines for contact and hygiene and they supported policies that were intended to reduce the impact of COVID-19 (i.e., means for all three measures were above 8, on scales ranging from 0 to 10; see Table 1)
The public health measures were correlated with one another (estimated correlations > 0.38)
NI was positively correlated with both NN (r = 0.38) and right-wing PI (r = 0.18)
NI was significantly and positively related to all public health measures
Individuals with stronger NI (relative to other people within their own nation) reported stronger support for increasing spatial distance and improving physical hygiene and endorsed COVID-19 public health policies more strongly than individuals with weaker identification
The coefficients reflecting the relation between national identity and each of the health measures are presented for each country from strongest (top) to weakest (bottom)
We created an index of NI using the two relevant items from the World Value Survey (i.e.
national pride and closeness to their nation) and an index of physical mobility by averaging community movement across all available places (i.e.
See “Methods” for details about the sample and measures
We examined whether countries with higher average NI prior to the pandemic predicted a stronger change in mobility in response to COVID-19 restrictions during April and May 2020 (This period mirrored when we collected most of the samples in Study 1)
We conducted our analysis for the full sample of 42 countries in which aggregate data which was publicly available for both for the NI and the mobility scores
Google mobility is depicted as a mean change in mobility during April and May 2020 (i.e.
blueish colours indicate a greater reduction of mobility during this period while reddish colours indicate a smaller reduction of mobility)
Grey shading is the 95% confidence interval
Based on this latter perspective we predicted
that NI was positively associated with support for and engagement with public health behaviours around the globe
In two global studies combining person-level and country-level analyses
the strength of national identity robustly predicted public health support
operationalized as behavioural health intentions (i.e.
and reduced physical movement patterns during the pandemic
We found this pattern with self-report measures at the person-level and using measures of actual mobility at the country level
The fact that national identity is associated with large-scale behaviour in real life provides ecologically valid evidence for our main hypothesis
these results are consistent with our hypothesis that NI is related to greater behaviour change in compliance with public health policies
We note that the results showing a decline in mobility should be treated with caution
as in the mobility report location accuracy and the categorization of places can vary between countries
people who identified more strongly with their nation reported greater engagement with critical public health measures around the globe
mobilizing people around a shared national identity might require considerable nuance
Future work should examine the impact of different types of identity appeals during a pandemic and isolate the causal influence of national identity on real behaviour
These partisan gaps in distancing predicted subsequent increases in infections and mortality in counties that voted for Donald Trump
partisanship was a stronger predictor of distancing than many other economic or social factors (e.g.
and media consumed by people from different identity groups
stronger group identification is not always associated with engagement in public-health behaviour
while NI and NN were associated positively with support for public health measures
right-wing PI was negatively associated with these outcomes
This suggests that a collective identity might be associated with valuing the protection of the entire group during a pandemic
even after adjusting for their ideological differences
these effects were much smaller than those for national identity and depended on the context
Future work should thus carefully consider cross-national differences in human development as well as social norms associated with national identity
typically restricted to the narrow western and educational setting of American or European university students
and non-representative participants from industrialized
is a truly global issue underscoring the importance of gathering samples outside these WEIRD cultures
it was striking to see that the same person-level association between NI and our public health measures was in the same direction in almost every country we studied
Although we managed to collect data from a wide variety of countries and territories
we were unable to obtain samples from every nation (especially in Africa and the middle east)
we encourage future research in these countries to see if the same dynamics are at play
Another element of our paper was an attempt to collect representative or stratified samples in Study 1
While most studies in psychology focus on convenience samples (e.g.
it is important to gather samples that are more diverse with regards to gender
and other key risk factors during a pandemic
Collecting representative samples affords the opportunity to help make better generalizations to the wider population within each country as well as the broader sample of countries around the globe
we were not able to obtain representative samples from most nations
we are unable to make strong generalizations about the populations in those countries
But note that we did directly compare the findings in more vs
less representative samples and found no significant difference in the overall relationship between NI and all three public health measures (see Supplementary Information for details)
nations have been among the most important actors for implementing policy or promoting national health guidelines
but sub-national units and international organizations such as the World Health Organization also play an important role
Our large-scale studies suggest that identification with one’s nation is positively associated with support for and engagement in critical behavioural public health measures
Understanding the role of social identity appears to be an important issue when addressing public health crises
The sample includes countries from all continents except for Antarctica
Americas) while others are underrepresented (e.g.
We encouraged teams to collect nationally representative samples
Of the 67 countries in which data were collected
representative samples were collected in 28
and both types of sampling were used in three countries
To determine if the relationships that were the focus of our paper varied as a function of the type of sample
we conducted analyses that compared coefficients for countries that had the three types of samples
These analyses found only one difference as a function of type of sample
Type of sample moderated the slope between spatial distancing and national identity
and the estimated slope for countries that collected representative samples was 0.16
whereas it was 0.08 for countries that collected convenience samples
both were statistically significant from 0 (p < 0.001)
Each participant completed a series of psychological measures and self-reported public health behaviours (see complete survey with all items in Supplementary Information)
Participants completed the scales in random order
which included the following sample item: “My (national group) deserves special treatment.” The nationalities were provided by the survey researchers
These measures used an 11-point slider scale with three labels items: 0 = “strongly disagree”
We included the terms left-leaning and right-leaning to make the item generalizable to numerous political systems
we included three measures of public health support
“During the days of the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic
I have been staying at home as much as practically possible”
we learned that the five-item scale had low reliability (α = 0.002)
after dropping one bad item the scale had acceptable reliability (α = 0.72)
all analyses reported in the paper use this four-item version of the scale.) A physical hygiene scale
I have been washing my hands longer than usual”
I have been in favour of closing all schools and universities”
We used an 11-point “slider scale with three labels: 0 = “strongly disagree”
which was re-coded to a scale from 0 to 10
These variables had very little impact on the results and are not discussed further
All measures will be made publicly available upon publication at the Open Science Framework website
The analyses examined within-country (person-level) relationships between behavioural health-protective responses to COVID-19 (i.e.
and policy support) and individual differences in collective concerns (i.e.
We also examined the moderating effects of country‑level differences on these person-level relationships
we examined if these person-level relationships between collective concerns and health-protective measures varied as a function of between-country differences in overall human development as measured by the HDI or national rates of COVID-19 infections and mortality
Level 2 (person-level): π0jk = b00k + r0jk
Level 3 (country-level): b00k = g000 + u00k
π0jk is a random coefficient representing the mean response for person j in country k
b0j is a random coefficient representing the mean of y for country k (across the j persons in each country)
eijk represents the error associated with each measure
and the variance of rijk constitutes the within-country variance
the coefficients from one level of analysis are passed up to the next
g000 represents the grand mean of the country-level means (b00ks) from the person-level model
and the variance of u00k constitutes the level 3
follow-up analyses indicated that a reliable scale could be created from items 1
family or colleagues was therefore dropped from the final analyses
The next set of analyses examined relations between scores on the HDI and the means of the person-level measures
This model was a variant of the unconditional model
HDI scores were entered as a predictor in the country-level model presented above (level 3)
MLM analyses do not estimate standardized coefficients
and to simplify the interpretation of the results
HDI scores were standardized prior to analysis (and
Note that these analyses account for the reliability of scales
we estimated a latent mean for each construct
we examined person-level relationships between the three COVID-19 protection measures (modelled as outcomes) and NI
Predictors were defined as the mean scores for each scale
To account for relationships among the predictors
all predictors were entered at the person level of the model
Predictors were entered group-mean centred and were modelled as randomly varying
because this was done using a three-level model in which the first level was a measurement level
Entering predictors as randomly varying meant that the model account for the possibility that slopes varied between countries
consisting of an intercept and a set of slopes
and these estimates were “passed up” to the country level where they were tested for significance
The model is below (item level is not shown)
Level 2 (person-level): π0jk = b00k + b01k*(NN) + b02k*(NI) + b03k*(PI) + r0jk
The hypothesis of interest was tested by assessing the significance of the g010
Was the mean slope between an outcome and a predictor significantly different from 0
These unstandardized coefficients represent the expected change in an outcome for a one-unit increase in a predictor
the random error terms for all predictors were significant at p < 0.001
It was significantly and positively related to all three measures (even after adjusting for NN and PI)
Individuals with stronger NI (relative to other people within their own nation) reported stronger support for limiting physical distance and improving physical hygiene than individuals with weaker identification
and they also endorsed COVID-19 public health policies to a greater extent
NN was significantly positively related to two of the three protective measures (albeit weakly)
Individuals scoring higher in NN supported recommendations for physical hygiene and endorsed COVID-19 related policies more strongly compared to individuals with lower levels of NN
The relationships between PI and public health support were negative (albeit weakly) for all three measures
indicating that individuals with more left-leaning or liberal political orientation tended to endorse recommendations for contact and hygiene and supported COVID-19-related policies more strongly than those with more right-leaning or conservative political orientation
Effect sizes were estimated using a similar procedure to that used for estimating effect sizes at the country-level. Effect sizes were defined as the percent reduction in the person-level variance of a null model (Table 2) associated with the inclusion of the three predictors (collective narcissism
The three predictors accounted for 8% of the person-level variance of the contact measure
for 7% of the person-level variance of the hygiene measure
and 5% of the person-level variance of the policy support measure
we examined if person-level relations (slopes) between collective concerns and COVID-19 public health support varied across countries as a function of HDI by adding HDI scores to the level 3 model that examined slopes
The relationships between NI and each of the three public health measures were not heavily impacted or moderated by HDI
we observed only two modest moderating effects
We found that HDI moderated the relationships between NN and spatial distancing (g011 = −0.03
The relationship between NN and spatial distancing was negative in countries that had higher HDI scores (the estimated slope for a country +1 SD on the HDI was 0.037) but positive in countries that had lower HDI scores (the estimated slope for a country −1 SD on the HDI was 0.027)
We also found that HDI moderated the relationship between PI and hygiene (g031 = −0.016
The overall negative relationship between right-wing PI and hygiene was stronger in countries that had higher HDI scores (the estimated slope for a country +1 SD on the HDI was −0.031) than in countries that had lower HDI scores (the estimated slope for a country −1 SD on the HDI was 0.002
We note that these effects were not statistically significant at the p < 0.001 threshold we used for Study 1 so we recommend interpreting them with caution
NI was computed based on indices from the first release of data from Wave 7 of the World Value Survey
The surveys were conducted between early 2017 to mid-2020
All countries employed random probability representative samples of the adult population (We computed country averages using default weights applied in the World Values Survey dataset
our results are very similar whether are not these weights are applied)
we used the national pride question: “How proud are you to be [country’s nationality]
this source item actually refers to pride of “being a citizen [of the country].” A response choice was available for respondents who were not citizens of the country where they were interviewed in Wave 7 of the World Value Survey
While some countries differ in terms of their ethnic or civic-based notions of citizenship
we used NI to denote overall identification with a specific national polity.) We excluded the latter category and re-coded the remaining responses on a scale from 0 = Not at all proud to 3 = Very proud
The second item captured closeness to one’s country: “People have different views about themselves and how they relate to the world
would you tell me how close do you feel to [country]?” 1 = Very close
We re-coded the responses on a scale from 0 = Not close at all proud to 3 = Very close
(Note that participants can refuse to respond or indicate “I don’t know” to both items
These responses were coded as missing.) The two items were positively correlated at country-level (r = 0.31
so we averaged them to create a composite index of NI (M = 2.38
Community mobility was computed based on Google Community Mobility Reports
which indicate how people’s aggregate physical movement has changed over time
The reports show movement trends over time across different categories of places: retail and recreation
Percentage change for each day is computed relative to a baseline
during the 5-week period from Jan 3 to Feb 6
To create our overall index of reductions in community mobility
we computed average indices for each of the places over April and May 2020 (to roughly match the time frame of Study 1)
We then created a composite index of mobility by averaging mobility across all places
with residential mobility reverse-coded (α = 0.91
This translates to a 35% reduction in movement from the start of the calendar year to the spring in these 42 nations
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Research Reporting Summary linked to this article
A Correction to this paper has been published: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-022-29658-x
World Health Organization. Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic. https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019 (2021)
Scientific and ethical basis for social-distancing interventions against COVID-19
and intentions to reduce the spread of COVID-19
Transnational social implications of the use of the “war metaphor” concerning coronavirus: a birds’ eye view
Group-level self-definition and self-investment: a hierarchical (multicomponent) model of in-group identification
A single‐item measure of social identification: reliability
Differentiation Between Social Groups: Studies in the Social Psychology of Intergroup Relations (Academic Press
The psychology of prejudice: ingroup love and outgroup hate
Global social identity and global cooperation
Social identification effects in social dilemmas: a transformation of motives
Identity and emergency intervention: how social group membership and inclusiveness of group boundaries shape helping behaviour
Does identification predict community involvement
Exploring consequences of social identification among the Jewish minority in Poland
How group identification helps to overcome the dilemma of collective action
Toward an integrative social identity model of collective action: a quantitative research synthesis of three socio-psychological perspectives
Using social and behavioural science to support COVID-19 pandemic response
In Together Apart: the Psychology of COVID-19 (eds Jetten
Commemoration in crisis: a discursive analysis of who ‘we’ and ‘they’ have been or become in ceremonial political speeches before and during the Greek financial downturn
and policy attitudes in the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic
Partisan differences in spatial distancing predict infections and mortality
In Together Apart: The Psychology of COVID-19 (eds Jetten
Together Apart: The Psychology of COVID-19 (Sage Publications Ltd
Social network-based distancing strategies to flatten the COVID-19 curve in a post-lockdown world
Strategies for mitigating an influenza pandemic
Interventions to mitigate early spread of SARS-CoV-2
in Liberal Nationalism and Its Critics: Normative and Empirical Questions (eds Gustavsson
Toward a measure of patriotic and nationalistic attitudes
The paradox of group-based guilt: modes of national identification
and reactions to the in-group’s moral violations
Collective narcissism moderates the effect of in-group image threat on intergroup hostility
Cutting the forest down to save your face: narcissistic national identification predicts support for anti-conservation policies
Collective narcissism predicts ingroup image defense
and support for greenwashing versus genuine proenvironmental campaigns
Adaptive and maladaptive behaviour during the COVID-19 pandemic: the roles of dark triad traits
Study the role of hubris in nations’ COVID-19 response
right or wrong: does activating system justification motivation eliminate the liberal-conservative gap in patriotism
‘They will not control us’: in-group positivity and belief in intergroup conspiracies
Populism as identity politics: perceived in-group disadvantage
Political ideology predicts perceptions of the threat of COVID-19 (and susceptibility to fake news about it)
The effect of messaging and gender on intentions to wear a face covering to slow down COVID-19 transmission
Sjåstad, H. & Van Bavel, J. J. The best-case heuristic: Relative optimism in a global health pandemic. Pre-print at https://psyarxiv.com/pcj4f/ (2021)
Ideological and psychological predictors of COVID-19-related collective action
and health compliance across three nations
In Cross-Cultural Research Methods in Psychology (eds Matsumoto
World Values Survey: Round Seven – Country-Pooled Datafile (JD Systems Institute & WVSA Secretariat
Google. COVID-19 Community Mobility Reports. https://google.com/covid19/mobility/ (2020)
a minority of one against a unanimous majority
Measuring realistic and symbolic threats of COVID-19 and their unique impacts on well-being and adherence to public health behaviours
Polarization and public health: partisan differences in social distancing during the coronavirus pandemic
The impact of coronavirus in Brazil: politics and the pandemic
A rare moment of cross-partisan consensus: elite and public responses to the COVID-19 pandemic in Canada
In The Social Developmental Construction of Violence and Intergroup Conflict (eds Vala
et al.) 105–120 (Springer International Publishing
Harari, Y. N. The world after coronavirus. https://www.ft.com/content/19d90308-6858-11ea-a3c9-1fe6fedcca75 (2020)
Too great to act in solidarity: the negative relationship between collective narcissism and solidarity‐based collective action
Empirical correlates of cosmopolitan orientation: etiology and functions in a worldwide representative sample
United Nations Human Development Programme. Human Development Report 2019. http://hdr.undp.org/sites/default/files/hdr2019.pdf (2019)
An interactive web-based dashboard to track COVID-19 in real time
HLM 7: Linear and Nonlinear Modeling (Scientific Software International
A practical guide to understanding reliability in studies of within-person variability
Hierarchical Linear Models: Applications and Data Analysis Methods (2nd ed.) (Sage Publications
Measurement reliability and agreement in psychiatry
Mplus User’s Guide (8th ed.) (Muthén & Muthén
United Nations Development Programme. Human Development Index (HDI). http://hdr.undp.org/en/content/human-development-index-hdi (2020)
Download references
The authors wish to thank Katie Eilish Brown for constructive comments throughout the editorial process
We also acknowledge the following funding sources: John Templeton Foundation (JTF) - 61378 [Van Bavel] Narodowe Centrum Nauki (National Science Centre) - 2018/29/B/HS6/02826 [Cislak] RCUK | Medical Research Council (MRC) - MR/P014097/1 [Lockwood] Economic Social Research Council Impact Acceleration Award
Taiwan (Ministry of Science and Technology of Taiwan) [Lin] Aarhus Universitets Forskningsfond (Aarhus University Research Foundation) - AUFF-E-201 9-9-4 [Mitkidis] Vetenskapsrådet (Swedish Research Council) - 2018-00877 [Olsson] Aarhus Universitets Forskningsfond (Aarhus University Research Foundation) - 28207 [Otterbring] Carlsbergfondet (Carlsberg Foundation) - CF20-0044 [Petersen] Ministarstvo Prosvete
Nauke i Tehnološkog Razvoja (Ministry of Education
Science and Technological Development of the Republic of Serbia) - 47010 [Todosijević] NOMIS Stiftung (NOMIS Foundation) [Tsakiris] Ministry of Science and Technology
Technology and Innovation | Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (National Council for Scientific and Technological Development) - 309905/2019-2 [Boggio] Research Council of Norway through its Centres of Excellence Scheme
FAIR project No 262675 [Sjåstad] Institute of Social Sciences Ivo Pilar [Pavlović] J
William Fulbright Program [Azevedo] Institute for Lifecourse Development
University of Greenwich [Birtel] Institute of Social Sciences Ivo Pilar [Franc] Project Pro.Co.P.E.
IMT School (PAI2019) [Bilancini] Italian Ministry of University and Research - PRIN 2017 (20178293XT) [Boncinelli] Princeton Graduate Student Research Funding (Program in Cognitive Science) [Vlasceanu] Corruption Laboratory on Ethics
University of Virginia [Yucel] Institute for Lifecourse Development
University of Greenwich [Farmer] Research Council of Norway through its Centres of Excellence Scheme
FAIR project No 262675 [Ay] Charles Koch Foundation
Center for the Science of Moral Understanding [Gray] Australian Research Council (DP180102384) [Levy] JSPS KAKENHI (JP16H03079
and 21H03784) [Yamada] St Andrews and Stirling Graduate Programme Research Funding [Schönegger] Institute of Social Sciences Ivo Pilar [Maglić] São Paulo Research Foundation - FAPESP (2019/27100-1) [Sampaio] Institute of Social Sciences Ivo Pilar [Mikloušić] Seele Neuroscience Social Projects Fund (2020/004) [Monroy-Fonseca] São Paulo Research Foundation - FAPESP (2019/26665-5) [Rego]
Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL
Department of Psychology and Neural Science
Aleksandra Cichocka & Bjarki Gronfeldt
SWPS University of Social Sciences and Humanities
Aleksandra Cislak & Marzena Cypryańska
Fahima Farkhari & Carolin-Theresa Ziemer
National Research University Higher School of Economics (HSE)
National University of Science and Technology (NUST)
Social Studies and Social Intervention Research Center; COIDESO
Center for Research in Contemporary Thought and Innovation for Social Development]
Soledad Palacios-Galvez & Iván Rodríguez-Pascual
Latin American Brain Health Institute (BrainLat)
Department of Educational and Counselling Psychology
Mostak Ahamed Imran & Hapsa Hossain Farhana
Caroline Leygue & Octavio Salvador-Ginez
Center for Research in Econometric Theory and Applications
Department of Leadership and Organizational Behavior
John Paul Minda & Clara Alexandra Stafford
Mateo Andres Córdoba-Delgado & Juliana Molina-Paredes
Department of Psychiatry and Medical Psychology
Department of Behavioral and Cognitive Sciences
National School for Political Studies and Public Administration
Institute for Research and Development-Kurdistan
Soulaimane El Mimouni & Tarik Nesh-Nash
Moral Psychology and Decision Sciences Research Incubator
Department of Psychological and Social Sciences
London School of Economics and Political Science
Social Policy Institute of the Ministry of Labor
Family and Social Affairs of the Slovak Republic
Cognitive Computational Neuroscience Research Unit
Neurological Institute Foundation Casimiro Mondino
Department of Brain and Behavioral Sciences
Laboratory of Social and Cognitive Psychology
Cavite State University-General Trias City Campus
Department of Social Policy and Intervention
Raymond Boadi Frempong & David Stadelmann
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
LMU Center for Leadership and People Management
Department of Neuroscience and Biomedical Engineering
Graduate School of Human Sciences Human Sciences
The City University of New York (CUNY) Graduate Center
Australian National Centre for the Public Awareness of Science
Graduate School of Humanities and Sociology
Department of Public Administration and Sociology
Hungarian Academy of Sciences Center of Excellence
Department of Global Economics and Management
Western Interdisciplinary Research Building
National University of Political Studies and Public Administration (SNSPA)
Research Institute at Medical University of Plovdiv)
The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology
Department of Behavioural Sciences and Learning (IBL)
Aleksandra Cichocka coordinated ethics approval
Valerio Capraro and Hallgeir Sjåstad designed the study
Flavio Azevedo coordinated data curation efforts
Sampaio prepared the dataset and its metadata
Rêgo and Aleksandra Cichocka organised project documentation
and maintained the ICSMP project’s website
Tung and Ming-Jen Lin assisted with data preparation
Ceren Ay contributed to various phases of the organisation
and Valerio Capraro were responsible for creating the authors’ list
Yucheng Zhang acted as national team leaders and were responsible for data collection in their own country
Zwaan were involved in the translation of the survey in their local language and in data collection
All authors revised and approved the final manuscript
André Krouwel (ownership and stocks in Kieskompas BV
No other authors reported a competing interest
reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-27668-9
Former Real Madrid and Spain goalkeeper Iker Casillas has hit back at ex-porn star Claudia Bavel's recent claims in an emotional statement
Following the success of Italian restaurant Bestia in the burgeoning Downtown Los Angeles Arts District
husband-and-wife team Ori Menashe and Genevieve Gergis have opened Bavel in the same neighbourhood
this time with a focus on Middle Eastern-Mediterranean food.
used the bones of an old warehouse to embrace the gritty location and the current popularity of this cuisine: washed bare brick walls
oversized industrial windows and soaring sawtooth skylights provide the canvas for hanging chandelier planters and walls of greenery evoking Moroccan lattice work
saffron and tumeric hues are revealed through the custom-made floor tiles by local company Fireclay
lantern-like pedant lights and furnishings such as the upholstered banquettes and the bar stools
Menashe has pulled together a varied menu with dishes such as the creamy duck ‘nduja hummus made from garbanzo beans and Jerusalem mix spice and served with puffy wood-fired pita; or a delicious slow-roasted lamb neck laffa schwarma stuffed with fermented cabbage
a cocktail of lamb fat bourbon and blue plum brandy over smoked ice
Website
escapism and design stories from around the world direct to your inbox
View Google Maps
Carole Dixon is a prolific lifestyle writer-editor currently based in Los Angeles
and was formerly the LA City editor for the Wallpaper* City Guides to Los Angeles.
Metrics details
A major barrier to climate change mitigation is the political polarization of climate change beliefs
In a global experiment conducted in 60 countries (N = 51,224)
we assess the differential impact of eleven climate interventions across the ideological divide
we find political polarization of climate change beliefs and policy support globally
with people who reported being liberal believing and supporting climate policy more than those who reported being conservative (Cohen’s d = 0.35 and 0.27
we find no evidence for a statistically significant difference between these groups in their engagement in a behavioral tree planting task
This conceptual-behavioral polarization incongruence results from self-identified conservatives acting despite not believing
rather than self-identified liberals not acting on their beliefs
We also find three interventions (emphasizing effective collective actions
writing a letter to a future generation member
and writing a letter from the future self) boost climate beliefs and policy support across the ideological spectrum
and one intervention (emphasizing scientific consensus) stimulates the climate action of people identifying as liberal
None of the interventions tested show evidence for a statistically significant boost in climate action for self-identified conservatives
We discuss implications for practitioners deploying targeted climate interventions
The current paper examines the political polarization of climate change at the level of beliefs and behaviors
and the causal impact of several behavioral climate interventions on beliefs
and individual-level action across the ideological divide between people around the world identifying as liberal versus conservative
suggesting that political identity has a causal influence on differences in climate change beliefs and policy support
there is good reason to believe that polarized beliefs will be mirrored in polarized action that can mitigate climate change (e.g.
Given these partisan differences in the responses to interventions
we assessed whether people who are liberal and conservative are differentially affected by a wide range of climate interventions
we find political polarization of climate change beliefs and policy support around the globe
with people who reported being liberal believing and supporting climate policy more than those who reported being conservative
we find no evidence for a statistically significant difference between these groups in the degree to which they engaged in a behavioral tree planting task
We find that climate action on this task results from self-identified conservatives acting despite not believing in climate change rather than self-identified liberals failing to act on their beliefs
When assessing the effects of the interventions
we find that three boost climate beliefs and policy support across the ideological spectrum (emphasizing effective collective action
and writing a letter from the future self)
and one intervention stimulates the climate action for those that identify as liberal (emphasizing scientific consensus)
Participants then completed demographic variables scales (including their ideological leaning on social and economic issues)
To replicate prior patterns of political polarization of climate change beliefs in this large global sample
we first analyzed the participants in the control condition
the reported statistics follow from two-tailed tests
Political ideology was measured in a self-report fashion on a scale (ranging from 0 = liberal/left wing to 100 = conservative/right wing)
Belief in climate change (Panel A), climate policy support (Panel B), and climate action (Panel C), as a function of self-reported political ideology (measured from 0 = liberal to 100 = conservative), in the control condition (N = 4302). Vertical lines represent 95% bootstrapped confidence intervals of the means at each level of political ideology; Fitted lines represent the best fit linear regression lines.
The degree of polarization (where higher scores reflect greater polarization)
operationalized as the absolute value of the difference between self-reported liberals’ and conservatives’ climate beliefs (Panel A)
Each country’s means and confidence intervals of these polarization scores for each outcome can be found in Figs
But does the polarization of climate change at the conceptual level (i.e.
beliefs and policy support) translate into polarization at the behavioral level (i.e.
engaging in one type of individual-level climate action)
Panel A: Standardized scores of climate belief (in pink) and climate action (in gray) as a function of self-reported political ideology
Panel B: Mean climate action of self-reported liberals (in dark blue) and conservatives (in red) as a function of mean climate beliefs
fitted lines represent the best-fit linear regression lines; Error bands represent 95% confidence intervals
Policy support was also more strongly associated with the tree-planting behavior for self-identified liberals compared to self-identified conservatives (i.e.
suggested by an ideology by policy interaction when predicting behavior: β = −0.0002
This interpretation is particularly promising for interventions aiming at increasing climate action
a critical component of the climate crisis response
Our data suggest that the political resistance to believing in climate change or supporting climate policy may not translate into a behavioral resistance to engaging in at least one type of individual-level climate action
we investigated the impact of 11 climate interventions on the climate beliefs
and individual-level climate action of self-identified liberals and conservatives
Interventions’ impacts on climate beliefs (Panel A)
split by self-reported political ideology (liberals in blue and conservatives in red; N = 51,224)
Vertical lines indicate the average in the control condition for each ideological grouping
Error bars represent 95% confidence intervals of the means
Upward triangles indicate significant increases
downward triangles indicate significant decreases
and circles indicate no statistically significant differences
These results suggest that a reason for the negative effects observed in some of the interventions might have been due to the limited time budget participants had for the study
such that less time was allocated to planting trees in the conditions with longer interventions
The results may also suggest that in the absence of time constraints
scientific consensus and binding moral foundations) might even increase individual-level pro-environmental behavior
the degree to which these findings generalize to behaviors that do not hinge on time (e.g.
direct donations) should still be empirically assessed in future studies
participants who identified as conservative may have conceptualized tree planting as an alternative to system-level action on climate
Future research should disentangle these processes
which could help assess the generalizability of these findings to other behaviors
both at the individual as well as at the collective or systemic levels
Six of the eleven tested interventions increased the climate beliefs of participants who identified as liberal (decreasing psychological distance
and binding moral foundations); five interventions increased their policy support (emphasizing effective collective actions
and system justifying messaging); and one intervention increased their climate action (scientific consensus)
For participants who identified as conservative
five interventions increased their climate beliefs (decreasing psychological distance
three interventions increased their policy support (writing a letter to the future generation
but no intervention increased their climate action
eight interventions significantly decreased their tree planting efforts (emphasizing effective collective actions
When targeting the climate action of people who are conservative
the behavioral toolbox for interventions in this space is sparser
the behavioral science field would benefit from future research investigating intervention strategies aimed at stimulating climate action across ideological divides
Given the importance of political polarization in addressing climate change
we provide additional explanations for the green gap phenomenon
previously discussed as liberals’ failure to act on their pro-environmental beliefs
we find the green gap can also arise through the converse process—climate actions (e.g.
planting trees) can be elicited in people who are conservative in spite of their climate change skepticism
Additional evidence for eliciting climate action without attempting to change beliefs comes from the interventions’ effects on the actions of participants who identified as conservative
most interventions decreased the number of trees they planted
suggesting that when framed as climate change solutions
people who are conservative engage in pro-environmental behaviors to a lesser extent
we are interested in exploring alternative processes for eliciting pro-environmental behaviors that don’t involve changing climate beliefs
We hope this data exploration resource can facilitate the advancement of science by offering researchers the ability to test additional hypotheses
which should then be empirically verified in follow-up experiments
We also urge scholars to incorporate these findings into their theories
this feature of our data should be considered when interpreting the results
Future research should thus replicate the current findings in more controlled environments that may benefit from lower attrition rates
we hope our results can inform and increase the potential of future targeted interventions in this space
given the heterogeneity of the effects observed across ideologies and outcomes
we also recommend future research targeting mechanisms to consider these dimensions for optimal impact
the present work provides global evidence of the complex relationship between political ideology and climate change beliefs
providing evidence for a conservative-oriented green gap
Our analyses also have critical implications for the design and deployment of theoretically derived targeted interventions aimed at boosting climate awareness and action around the world
Scholars and policymakers in this space can leverage our findings to implement interventions selected to optimize outcomes
given the ideological composition of a target community
empirically informed response to the climate crisis
Ethics approval was obtained independently by each research team from the respective Institutional Review Board (IRB) associated with their institution
Analyses only included datasets submitted along with IRB approval
Participants’ data came from a previously collected dataset45
A total of 83,927 completed the study between July 2022 and July 2023
59,440 participants from 63 countries passed the two attention checks (i.e.
Please select the color purple from the list below; To indicate you are reading this paragraph
please type the word 60 in the text box below.) and correctly complete the WEPT demo
ideological information was only available for 51,224 participants (Mage = 39.62
2398 declined to state gender) from 60 countries
The control condition contained a sample of 4,302 participants (Mage = 39.52
Gender was collected via self-report and was included (along with age
and income) as a covariate in the primary analyses reported here to assess for potential effects on the measured outcomes
Given the differences in data collection timelines in each country
the initial version of this manuscript did not include this full sample; upon data collection completion in July 2023
The results between the initial partial sample and the final sample did not differ
Participants in the control condition were asked to read a short
thematically unrelated text from the novel Great Expectations by Charles Dickens
while participants in the experimental conditions were exposed to an intervention
participants in all conditions were asked to rate (in random order) their (1) climate beliefs
and (3) willingness to share climate information on social media
participants were given the chance to contribute to tree-planting efforts by completing the WEPT
participants in the control condition were asked to complete an additional set of variables
all participants were asked to fill out a series of demographics
which included another attention check (In the previous section
you viewed some information about climate change
To indicate you are reading this paragraph
please type the word sixty in the text box below.)
We administered the entire survey in the participants’ primary language of their country of residence
Climate beliefs were operationalized as participants’ responses to the question: How accurate do you think these statements are
(from 0 = Not at all accurate to 100 = Extremely accurate)
The four statements were: Taking action to fight climate change is necessary to avoid a global catastrophe; Human activities are causing climate change; Climate change poses a serious threat to humanity; and Climate change is a global emergency
Cronbach’s alpha of this scale in this dataset was 0.866
Climate policy support was measured as participants’ level of agreement (from 0 = Not at all to 100 = Very much so)
Cronbach’s alpha of this scale in this dataset was 0.844
To measure action with real-world impact performed at a cost to participants
we used a modified version of the work for environmental protection task (WEPT)
This task is a multi-trial online procedure that detects consequential pro-environmental behavior by allowing participants the opportunity of engaging in voluntary cognitive effort (i.e.
screen numerical stimuli) in exchange for donations to an environmental organization
This measure has been validated and has been found to correlate to self-reports and objective observations of other pro-environmental behaviors and conceptually related measures
Participants were first exposed to a demonstration of the WEPT
in which they were instructed to identify all target numbers for which the first digit is even and the second digit is odd (4 out of 18 numbers for the demonstration)
Participants could only advance to the next page upon correctly completing the demonstration
they were told that planting trees is one of the best ways to combat climate change and that they would have the opportunity to plant up to 8 trees if they chose to engage in additional pages of the task (one tree per page completed)
which participants had to screen for target numbers
participants were shown a pictogram of 8 trees
one of which was colored green to mark their progress in the task
Participants could exit the task at any point without penalty
For a binary version of this continuous measure
we computed a median split of the continuous ideology measure within each country and labeled participants who scored above their country’s ideology average as conservatives and participants who scored below their country’s ideology average as liberals
This research utilized data collected by the International Collaboration to Understand Climate Action
Local researchers from across the world (60 countries in total represented in the data in this research) were invited to collaborate on the design
as well as lead individual research projects stemming from the collected data
Collaborator roles and responsibilities were agreed to before data collection began
individual IRB approval by local ethics review committees was required before data collection began
For the full list of IRB review committees
we conducted robust mixed effect models and weighted least squares mixed models to complement our primary analyses and formally account for any potential violations of residual normality and homoscedasticity
we found identical results to those reported in the main text
we are highly confident in the robustness of our models and results
Further information on research design is available in the Nature Portfolio Reporting Summary linked to this article
Social tipping dynamics for stabilizing Earth’s climate by 2050
A Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
II and III to the Sixth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (eds Core Writing Team
Consensus on consensus: a synthesis of consensus estimates on human-caused global warming
Greater than 99% consensus on human caused climate change in the peer-reviewed scientific literature
Politicization and polarization in climate change news content
Growing polarization around climate change on social media
Corporate funding and ideological polarization about climate change
The politicization of climate change and polarization in the American public’s views of global warming
Understanding and countering the motivated roots of climate change denial
Understanding the effects of partisan identity on climate change
Meta-analyses of the determinants and outcomes of belief in climate change
Political divisions over climate change and environmental issues in Australia
Australian politicians’ beliefs about climate change: political partisanship and political ideology
Scepticism and uncertainty about climate change: dimensions
Uncertain climate: an investigation into public scepticism about anthropogenic climate change
A widening gap: Republican and Democratic views on climate change
It’s political: how the salience of one’s political identity changes climate change beliefs and policy support
Public Participation in Medical Screening Programs: A Socio-psychological Study (No
The health belief model and preventive health behavior
Political and nonpolitical belief change elicits behavioral change
Multiple processes by which attitudes guide behavior: the MODE model as an integrative framework
Understanding Attitudes and Predicting Social Behavior (Prentice-Hall
The privileged liberal principle–implementation gap: how the personal behavior of privileged liberals contributes to social inequality
Internal and external barriers to eco‐conscious apparel acquisition
The green purchase behavior of Hong Kong young consumers: The role of peer influence
Drivers of pro-environmental purchasing behavior
A social dilemma perspective on green buying
Towards closing the attitude-intention-behavior gap in green consumption: a narrative review of the literature and an overview of future research directions
Just don’t call it climate change: climate-skeptic farmer adoption of climate-mitigative practices
Large-scale behavioural data are key to climate policy
A network approach to investigate the dynamics of individual and collective beliefs: Advances and applications of the bending model
At least bias is bipartisan: a meta-analytic comparison of partisan bias in liberals and conservatives
Psychological reactance from reading basic facts on climate change: the role of prior views and political identification
and blue enough to be green: effects of moral framing on climate change attitudes and conservation behaviors
The scientific consensus on climate change as a gateway belief: experimental evidence
Exposure to scientific consensus does not cause psychological reactance
A research agenda for climate change communication and public opinion: the role of scientific consensus messaging and beyond
Rational irrationality: modeling climate change belief polarization using Bayesian networks
The effect of information provision on public consensus about climate change
Effects of consensus messages and political ideology on climate change attitudes: inconsistent findings and the effect of a pretest
Addressing climate change with behavioral science: a global intervention tournament in 63 countries
and the possibility of “system-sanctioned change”
The Work for Environmental Protection Task: a consequential web-based procedure for studying pro-environmental behavior
Forming attitudes that predict future behavior: a meta-analysis of the attitude-behavior relation
Behavioral paradigms for studying pro-environmental behavior: a systematic review
Goal-directed conservation behavior: the specific composition of a general performance
Multidimensional partisanship shapes climate policy support and behaviours
Promoting pro-environmental action in climate change deniers
Co-benefits of addressing climate change can motivate action around the world
In The Best American Magazine Writing 2018 (eds The American Society of Magazine Editors) 271–294 (Columbia University Press
Getting liberals and conservatives to go green: political ideology and congruent appeals
Field interventions for climate change mitigation behaviors: a second-order meta-analysis
The neglected 95% revisited: is American psychology becoming less American
Demand-side solutions to climate change mitigation consistent with high levels of well-being
Collective responses to global challenges: the social psychology of pro-environmental action
Going fossil free: a lesson in climate activism and collective responsibility
In Climate Change Research at Universities: Addressing the Mitigation and Adaptation Challenges (ed
Understanding the climate responsibility associated with elections
MTurk research: review and recommendations
Quantifying the potential persuasive returns to political microtargeting
The 12 item Social and Economic Conservatism Scale (SECS)
Political ideology shapes the amplification of the accomplishments of disadvantaged vs
Why we (usually) don’t have to worry about multiple comparisons
R: A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing (R Foundation for Statistical Computing
Fitting linear mixed-effects models using lme4
Analysis of Ordinal Data With Cumulative Link Models—Estimation with the R-package Ordinal
Morey, R. D. & Rouder, J. N. BayesFactor: computation of Bayes factors for common designs. v. 0.9.12–4.2 https://cran.r-project.org/package=BayesFactor (2018)
Robustness of linear mixed‐effects models to violations of distributional assumptions
Vlasceanu, M. et al. Addressing Climate Change With Behavioral Science: A Global Intervention Tournament in 63 Countries. The International Climate Psychology Collaboration: Climate Change-related Data Collected From 63 Countries https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/YTF89 (2024)
Berkebile-Weinberg, M., Goldwert, D., Doell, K, Van Bavel, J., Vlasceanu, M. The Differential Impact of Climate Interventions Along the Political Divide in 60 Countries, climatepolarization https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.10815267 (2024)
Normative appeals motivate people to contribute to collective action problems more when they invite people to work together toward a common goal
Testing the impact and durability of a group malleability intervention in the context of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict
How collective-action failure shapes group heterogeneity and engagement in conventional and radical action over time
The future is now: reducing psychological distance to increase public engagement with climate change
Short horizons and tempting situations: lack of continuity to our future selves leads to unethical decision making and behavior
Reassessing emotion in climate change communication
Climate of silence: pluralistic ignorance as a barrier to climate change discussion
The impact of place and legacy framing on climate action: a lifespan approach
The Gateway Belief Model (GBM): a review and research agenda for communicating the scientific consensus on climate change
Using a news article to convey climate science consensus information
The salience of future impacts and the willingness to pay for climate change mitigation: an experiment in intergenerational framing
Download references
These authors contributed equally: Michael Berkebile-Weinberg
contributed to the conception or design of the work
Nature Communications thanks James Druckman
and Elke Weber for their contribution to the peer review of this work
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-024-48112-8
Claudia Babel returns to the charge against Iker Casillas | en.e-noticies.cat, Instagram, @imclaudiabavel, GTRES PEOPLE 180º Turn After the Latest Revelation by Claudia Bavel About Iker CasillasClaudia Bavel turns to her social media to issue a new and unexpected statement related to Iker Casillas.09/02/2025 14:23:00h by Vanesa González
Claudia Bavel has returned to social media with a new and revealing post that has surely meant a U-turn in her controversy with Iker Casillas
the adult content creator has unveiled new details about the current relationship she maintains with the athlete
It was last Tuesday, February 4, when the former Real Madrid goalkeeper took to his X account to issue a new statement. In it, the athlete exploded like never before due to the media pressure he has been exposed to in recent days
New chapter in the controversy of Iker Casillas and Claudia Bavel | en.e-noticies.cat
@imclaudiabavelThis situation originated from the photographs that the magazine Diez Minutos published in its latest issue
Iker Casillas can be seen walking through the streets of Barcelona with Claudia Bavel
Since then, all eyes have been on this well-known former player. However, it was the model's visit to ¡De Viernes! that truly tested the athlete's patience
Iker Casillas reported that he had “given instructions for any violation of my privacy and/or honor[…]to be legally pursued.”
Iker Casillas explodes after Claudia Bavel's visit to "¡De Viernes!" | MediasetJust one day after the former Real Madrid goalkeeper broke his silence on social media, Claudia Bavel returned to her Instagram profile with her own statement
Imitating the structure of Iker Casillas's document
the adult content creator made a new and surprising revelation about the player
A decision that has given a U-turn to this plot
Claudia Bavel issued her own statement on social media
to all the information exposed by the player
In the first section, she makes it clear that, “like anyone, I have the right to share my experiences without it implying an attack or a violation of others' privacy.” “I have always been transparent with my community[…]and I have never sought to harm anyone with my words,” she added
Claudia Bavel issues her own statement | Instagram
Claudia Bavel asserts that “it's important to remember that a relationship
she firmly believes that “expressing my side of the story is not an invasion of privacy
but the exercise of my right to free expression.”
So much so that she assures that her intention “has never been to commercialize or harm anyone with my statements.” In this case
Meanwhile, Claudia Bavel confirms that she “finds it surprising that my testimony is intended to be presented as an attack.” And she assures that “at all times I have disseminated truthful information that serves as a reply to the denial of a romantic relationship.”
Claudia responds to all the accusations that have been made against her | en.e-noticies.cat
@imclaudiabavelIn the fourth section of her statement
Claudia Bavel points out that “in a world where more and more transparency is demanded[…]it's concerning that there is an attempt to silence my voice.” Or even
“to present me as a person seeking notoriety at the expense of others.”
“Not everything is valid to discredit someone or to impose a single version of the story,” adds Claudia Bavel
And she considers that “respect for privacy is essential.”
“But so is respect for the truth and the right of each person to share their perspective without being unfairly labeled,” clarifies the alleged ex-partner of Iker Casillas
Claudia Bavel regrets “that this situation has escalated in this way and that there is an attempt to turn my account into a matter of honor or defamation.”
“I haven't sought conflict or confrontation
but I won't allow my message to be distorted or to be accused of acting in bad faith,” she adds
and in defense of “her right to express myself freely,” Claudia Bavel wanted to issue a warning to Iker Casillas
“I reserve the necessary actions to protect my integrity and my reputation against any attempt at misinformation or unfounded attack against me.”
I had to teach my afternoon Introduction to Psychology class today to over 300 students from my cell phone while I was trapped in my apartment building elevator with my two young kids
this has to go down as the most stressful — and surreal — teaching experience of my life.
I'm currently teaching a huge Intro to Psychology class this fall
But given the risks of the pandemic as well as public health guidelines
with over 360 students from around the world joining me every few days to learn about the science of the mind.
Moving such a massive course online has been a challenge
so the class has truly been a blast to teach
I have to get my kids from the local daycare at 3 p.m
My 10-year-old son loves to crash my course and share his thoughts on the brain and perceptual illusions
but the students find it funny so I don't mind.
walked through the city to pick up my kids
and then we arrived back at my apartment building at 3:20 p.m
and I breathed a sigh of relief that I was going to make it to my class on time
Class was scheduled to start in 10 minutes.
Then it quickly lurched to a halt and started dropping
I got that feeling in my stomach that happens when you're in a roller coaster and it starts falling
I realize we are suddenly trapped on the 3rd floor.
But I used the call button in the elevator to contact the staff
They promised to contact a repairman from the elevator company to help us escape
I started texting people to figure out what to do
My 8-year-old daughter started getting scared
which led my son to tease her about overreacting
He's normally a cool cucumber in any situation
Things were melting down pretty good at that point
But my internet reception was horrible (you know when it only has one bar of reception)
and I wasn't high enough to access my WiFi either.
I managed to login into my NYU Classes website to contact my students
I managed to login and send out an email announcement to the class by 3:28 p.m
The subject line was: "Trapped in my elevator
a certain level of camaraderie had developed in the elevator
My kids and I had a dawning recognition that we were all in this together and would pull through
I reminisced about the time I was stuck in the elevator with my son Jack five years ago
We also snapped a few selfies to remember the moment
I started to worry about my poor students and how I would manage to finish the lecture on time
The mid-term was coming up the following week and there would be no time to make up the content
I made an executive decision to try and teach from the friendly confines of the elevator
I desperately tried to get enough internet access to login into NYU Classes and access my Zoom link.
But Zoom made this incredibly hard on my phone
They needed me to download an app and then login
this was the biggest challenge of the entire ordeal.
But the internet was so weak that I couldn't speak to the students
I logged out and logged in again using the phone link
I would just give the lecture over the phone without video or slides
I could see there were over 200 students already in the room and they were just chatting
speculating about my new life in the elevator
Their lives seemed somehow fuller than our life in the elevator
I'M ON THE CALL!" They heard and recognized me
I could hear one student yelling to her roommate that her professor was trapped in an elevator
Others seemed excited to give this a try; apparently they'd never been taught from a professor stuck in an elevator before
It would give the class a fresh new twist.
Then it dawned on me that I had no way of showing them my carefully crafted slides on the conscious and unconscious mind
Had I made a mistake by jumping on the call
Then I just started talking about consciousness
It went surprisingly well for a stressed-out guy giving a lecture over his phone with no notes while trapped in an elevator with his kids.
But I felt it was only fair under the circumstances.
I realized my kids are just staring at me with perplexed looks on their faces
but seemed bemused as I raised my voice to explain how we have many mental processes that operate outside our awareness
After about 50 excruciatingly long minutes in the elevator
We could see our beautiful nondescript lobby and the sun beaming in from the front doors
We cautiously stepped out into freedom.
I was able to catch the other elevator upstairs
and give the rest of the lecture from the now-seemingly-normal confines of my kitchen table
It all seemed weirdly normal in the moment
Each step just seemed to logically follow the prior step
This is a lesson I'll cover in a later lecture on rationalization
I'm now deeply aware of how absurd this was
I will not be teaching in elevators in the future
user-friendly experience designed with our community in mind
More content and resources are on the way as we continue to enhance the site
so thank you for your understanding as we work to make it even better
X
The Philadelphia Police Department needs the public’s assistance in locating 38-year-old Missing Person Derya Van Bavel
She was last spoken to via phone on Monday
a tattoo of a flower and a cherry on her back and was last seen wearing a green dress
Anyone with any information on Derya’s whereabouts is asked to please contact South Detectives Division at 215-686-3013 or 911
215.686.TIPS (8477)
Police Headquarters400 N Broad StreetPhiladelphia
we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information
Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site to improve your browsing experience
please read our Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy
throw open a surefire Middle Eastern hit this week
Chef Ori Menashe tends to be a serious guy — just ask anyone who’s worked for him. But it’s hard not to notice the smile he carries when talking about his new restaurant Bavel, a supremely sunny Arts District option set to open to the world on Friday
“I’ve been cooking Italian food for 16 years,” says Menashe from a corner table at the new place
keeping one eye on the conversation and the other on a full kitchen staff that is firing the entire Bavel menu from start to finish — twice
“And it’s all been leading to this place.”
Unlike his Downtown mega-hit Bestia
which started with a pizza and pasta focus but has over the years emerged as something of a melding of Menashe’s Italian and Middle Eastern worlds
Bavel will be he and wife Genevieve Gergis’s full-footed foray into Los Angeles’s modern Middle Eastern movement
The pair have a cultural history in countries like Israel
and Bavel is a combination and culmination of much of that past
It’s easy to want to linger inside the Studio UNTLD-designed (in collaboration with Gergis) restaurant
which sits in a repurposed Arts District warehouse not far from Bestia proper
There’s a free-hanging garden of indoor plants hovering above the dining room
and when lit at night the whole thing feels like a glowing green chandelier
Brick walls have been mellowed to an off-white hue
and toned-down blue and yellow tiles pair up with gold fixtures
and eventually the entire property will be humming with life thanks to an attached Verve Coffee and other tenants beyond
comes in as a partner and overall director of operations
keeping an eye on everything from the patio to the pastry station at once
Bavel officially opens to the world on Friday
keeping evening hours only to start (lunch will follow)
That means Sundays and Tuesday through Thursday from 5 to 11 p.m.
with a Friday and Saturday extension until midnight
with Genevieve in the back making the pastry station come to life
This is the place they’ve both wanted for so many years
and now all that’s left is to get to work — which is reason enough for Ori to smile
Bavel500 Mateo St.Los Angeles
The group behind Bestia and Bavel opens Saffy’s
Menashe and Gergis are no newlyweds (literally, and in the restaurant sense). Together they’ve managed to marry big flavors and disparate tastes from across the Middle East and Italy at their two endlessly popular restaurants Bestia and Bavel
They’ve shaped the careers of a generation of line cooks
and front-of-house staff who spent years at either restaurant (or both)
they even managed to have a daughter named Saffron
It’s all converged on this busy block of Fountain
and it’s all hands on deck for the family’s first new opening in four years
a casual and flavorful collection of grilled meats and warm breads
is almost all Menashe (Gergis still does the desserts
Saffy’s will open for dinner to start, meaning mellow nights under low lights as the warm waft of wood-fired, spit-roasted meat permeates the dining areas. There are actually views directly into a portion of the kitchen where diners can watch the sparks fly — as they do at Bavel — as well as a curvy bar and long banquettes for groups to mingle
allowing diners to enjoy the LA breezes as a stained glass glow pours out into the night
Lunch will follow soon and with it a whole new menu format for Gergis and Menashe
There will be shawarma sandwiches and salads and other easy-eating items
some pulled from the dinner menu and others made just for the sunlight crowd
Menashe says that he’s looking forward to the challenge of creating some of LA’s best shawarma and hummus
no small feat with the city’s rich Israeli
including turmeric mussels and large-format group meals
the pair is also planning a small next-door cafe called Saffy’s Coffee & Tea Shop
which will provide espresso drinks and a variety of well-steeped teas
With the rise in foot traffic along this block that has been made famous over the years by the Scientology Center
and Salvadoran restaurants dotting the area to the north and south
more coffee and bread still seems like a good idea — though again
it’s a first for the family and for director of operations/partner Leah Bunch
who oversees the group’s now-trio of projects
Ori, Genevieve, and Saffron’s new Saffy’s opens June 1 at 4845 Fountain Avenue, keeping hours from 5 p.m. to 11 p.m., Wednesday through Sunday. Reservations are available via OpenTable
Your request appears similar to malicious requests sent by robots
Please make sure JavaScript is enabled and then try loading this page again. If you continue to be blocked, please send an email to secruxurity@sizetedistrict.cVmwom with:
why the news media has a strong negativity bias
why tribalism is inflamed by online activity
and how the internet can make us seem like the worst versions of ourselves
Van Bavel emphasizes that many of the group psychology dynamics that can make social media seem like a dumpster fire are also core to what makes humankind such a special and ingenious species
We discuss the four dark laws of online engagement and the basics of group psychology
If you have questions, observations, or ideas for future episodes, email us at PlainEnglish@Spotify.com
Derek and Jay Van Bavel dive into the basics of group psychology and discuss how that plays a part in social media engagement
you and I are going to spend most of this episode talking about your empirical research on how the internet
holds a fun-house mirror to the human condition and why I think the incentives and engagement structures of social media are truly driving many people slowly insane
What’s the big question that you and your lab are trying to answer
I think the big question that’s animated me for the last 20 years in my research is about the nature of groups and identity and how they work
how our brain responds to being in a group or seeing members of other groups
have been dropped in this modern technological environment with social media and artificial intelligence
I’m fascinated by studying how that all plays out: how is that manipulated
the brain is a pretty ancient piece of machinery
Group psychology has to be a relatively ancient concept
We’ve been living in groups for hundreds of thousands of years before the internet came along
what would I learn on day one about how groups change my own identity and my sense of what is true and false in the world
So maybe I’ll give you a couple principles
The first is: All it takes is a flip of a coin for us to feel part of a group and start to identify with it
where we just literally flip coins and put people on the blue team or the red team
But if anybody has ever grown up playing recreational sports
you go to the gym and you randomly get picked onto a side to play a sport for an hour or two
and that automatically triggers a different psychological mindset
And even people who were strangers a few minutes before are people we suddenly like more
and we’re able and willing to cooperate with them in ways we wouldn’t have if they were strangers
And this happens to us also if you go to a professional sporting event
You’re giving a high five to someone sitting next to you who has a Yankees jersey if you’re a fan
even though you might [have never known] them before
And so that’s the psychology that all of us walk around in
The other part of it that a lot of people don’t get
You walk into a stadium with a jersey on and see everybody else wearing those colors
Or let’s say you turn on a movie and you’re watching an alien invasion
it’s just all of humanity against this alien invasion
So we can get triggered to think of ourselves as different types of members of groups or as members of different types of groups depending on the situation we’re in
Thompson: It’s almost as if the desire to belong to any group is pre-downloaded in us
and therefore thinking outside of groups seems to be the really key challenge
If it is so easy for us to adopt a group psychology
where it’s all just one big mass of group psychology overlapping group psychology overlapping group psychology
the hardest thing to do is to try to “think for yourself” when we so want to think as if we belong to any of these groups
So having spent several hours reading your papers from the last few years this morning and yesterday and thinking about them as a collective
“the four bad laws of internet and social media engagement.” Because I feel like you and your lab have been—in researching how group psychology and dynamics and social media and the internet affect us
you found your way to these four laws of what it is that drives bad engagement on the internet
But here are the four laws that I’ve taken from your research
Number one is that negativity drives engagement
out-group animosity drives engagement online
emotional language drives engagement online
if you didn’t understand what some of those terms meant
we will absolutely define them in just a few minutes
But what I want to do with you with our time together is to explain where these ideas come from—because they’re all derived from your work in the last few years—and what they mean
I want to start with a paper you published last year on negativity bias in the news
In a randomized study of 105,000 headlines and 370 million impressions from a data set of articles published by the online news dispensary Upworthy
you found that so-called “negative” words increased the click-through rate by more than 2 percent
and the prevalence of positive words in a news headline decreased the likelihood of any headline being clicked on
what did this paper show that was so important
I think one of the things that psychologists are very familiar with is the idea that bad is stronger than good
that people pay more attention to or are more motivated by bad things than we are good things
And I’ll go back to a bit of an evolutionary explanation for this again: You can imagine your ancestors walking around the African savanna
And so there’s a motivation to try to find food
But if they potentially see something and it could kill them
that’s dramatically more significant to their survival
And so they have to err on the side of avoiding things that are negative and risky
And our ancestors who did that over generation after generation after generation were more likely to survive
And so we have brains that are wired to detect threats and super-tuned to them more than they are to detect rewards
it leads.” But of course social media and internet websites have hijacked that as well
came from the classic website that engineered virality online
So we got access to the Upworthy data archives
And what Upworthy was famous for in the early days of the internet was doing A/B testing
and they would try one headline on their website and see how many people clicked and then randomly assign half of the other people who came to their website to see a different headline
and then pick the one that was most popular and keep it up
they had more traffic than The New York Times
They were so viral that Facebook had to change its news algorithm because people were getting really frustrated by all the clickbait from Upworthy headlines and leaving Facebook to go get it
And so they really engineered this through data
we can see not what their theory is about what works; we can see with their experimental A/B testing what actually gets people to click through an article.” And
they’re more likely to click to negative content
negative headlines for the exact same story
This excerpt was edited for clarity. Listen to the rest of the episode here and follow the Plain English feed on Spotify
Host: Derek ThompsonGuest: Jay Van BavelProducer: Devon Baroldi
Subscribe: Spotify
ArchiveWe’ve been around since Brady was a QB
GLASGOW Ky.-As schools prepare to have students return to the classrooms this fall
a local school district wants to emphasize a virtual option for those who prefer it
The Barren Academy of Virtual and Expanded Learning
is a fully accredited online educational experience for all grade levels
with an expansion to all grade levels being announced in 2021
It’s made to be unique compared to the NTI used previously
Even as education moves away from the pandemic
BAVEL representatives want to remind incoming students that BAVEL is an option for students in a variety of scenarios
if the student has a part-time job while attending school
Representatives say BAVEL State assessments are consistently at or above state averages
and they’ve seen students flourish from the program
“I have seen such an impact that BAVEL has been able to make in people’s lives
I’ve seen students who have grown immensely in their independence
and motivation for school,” said BAVEL guidance counselor Pam Carter
BAVEL also serves students in schools all across Kentucky
For more information, or to register for BAVEL, follow this link
Watch WNKY Live
When Los Angeles restaurant Bestia opened in 2013
it quickly became one of the most coveted reservations
The husband and wife duo behind the rustic Italian favorite
the Middle Eastern inspired Bavel and Saffy’s
East West Bank has worked with the duo at every stage of their growth
helping them share the food they grew up eating
creating a sense of place and belonging within the community
and inspiring their employees to follow their own dreams
Are Not FDIC InsuredAre Not Bank GuaranteedMay Lose Value
Are Not Insured by Any Federal Government AgencyAre Not Deposits
and East West Bank with compass logo are separately registered trademarks of East West Bank in the United States and other countries
Arda Guler set to start in crucial El Clasico for Real Madrid
Athletico Palermo rewards players with lifetime escort services
the legendary Real Madrid and Spain goalkeeper
has been at the center of dating rumors after being seen with Claudia Bavel
a former adult film actress and OnlyFans model
stayed at the same luxury hotel in the Catalan capital and were later photographed attending a winery event in Vilanova i la Geltrú
The event was also attended by former Real Madrid stars Luis Figo and Michel Salgado
The pair reportedly left the hotel separately the following morning
this is not the first time rumors have linked them
Spanish journalist Javier Hoyos claimed to have spotted the two sharing a passionate kiss at an upscale restaurant near the Costa Brava
When asked about their relationship recently
Bavel neither confirmed nor denied the speculation
saying: “We are two single people.”
who has nearly 250,000 followers on Instagram and reportedly earns £17,000 per month from OnlyFans
describes herself as a “content creator and ex-adult film actress.” She regularly shares glamorous and revealing photos
building a strong following as a model and influencer
Since splitting from Sara Carbonero in 2021 after five years of marriage
Casillas has been linked to several high-profile women
previously had a brief relationship with Keita Baldé
the Spanish-born Senegalese international who currently plays in Turkey
affectionately known as “Saint Iker” for his miraculous saves
retired from football in 2020 after suffering a heart attack while training with FC Porto
both for his punditry work and personal life
neither Casillas nor Bavel has publicly confirmed a romantic relationship
but their repeated appearances together have fueled speculation
A post shared by 𝑪𝑳𝑨𝑼𝑫𝑰𝑨 𝑩𝑽 (@imclaudiabavel)
Nogomania.com is a premier destination for football enthusiasts
delivering fresh and in-depth content from the heart of the Ex-Yu region's football scene
Real Madrid legend Iker Casillas has raised eyebrows after being spotted on what appears to be a romantic getaway with former adult film actress and OnlyFans model
known for his illustrious career and once-fairytale romance with Sara Carbonero
was reportedly seen in Barcelona with the stunning 28-year-old brunette
fuelling speculation of a budding relationship
According to Spanish magazine Diez Minutos via Daily Mail
Casillas and Bavel were snapped together last Tuesday while staying at the same Barcelona hotel.
The duo attended an exclusive wine-tasting event in Vilanova i la Geltrú
approximately 30 miles from the Catalan capital
alongside former Real Madrid teammates Luis Figo and Michel Salgado
paparazzi managed to capture them leaving the unnamed hotel separately in the early hours of the morning
Spanish journalist Javier Hoyos previously alleged that he had spotted Casillas and Bavel sharing a passionate kiss at an upscale restaurant near Costa Brava in May last year.
While neither party has publicly confirmed their relationship
Bavel teased in a recent interview:"We are two single people."
Since his split from TV and radio presenter Sara Carbonero in March 2021
has been linked to several high-profile women
including former Miss Spain Maria José Suárez and journalist Ana Quiles
his rumoured involvement with Bavel is particularly intriguing
given her past in the adult film industry and her lucrative OnlyFans career
who once dated Senegalese footballer Keita Baldé
describes herself online as a "content creator and ex-adult film actress."
with nearly 250,000 Instagram followers on her main account
where she showcases her curvaceous figure in jaw-dropping outfits.
known as ‘San Iker’ for his miraculous goalkeeping saves
is widely regarded as one of the greatest goalkeepers of all time.
including five La Liga titles and three UEFA Champions League trophies.
Casillas also played a pivotal role in Spain’s golden era
captaining the national team to back-to-back European Championship victories in 2008 and 2012
as well as their historic FIFA World Cup triumph in 2010.
After a career spanning more than two decades
Casillas retired in 2020 following a heart attack he suffered while training with FC Porto.
Former champion has hailed Evra ahead of his MMA debut
Paris Saint-Germain's top scoring forward is a doubt for the Champions League semi-final second leg clash against Arsenal
FIFA has relegated one African club over match-fixing allegations
Time and where to watch Nigeria's Efe Ajagba take on Congo's Martin Bakole in a fight for African boxing king
Time and where to watch Flying Eagles of Nigeria's 2nd U20 AFCON group game against Young Atlas Lions of Morocco
Former England player who rejected the chance to represent the Nigerian national team now wants to replace Eric Chelle
See what fans are saying about the robbery of Nigerian boxer Efe Ajagba against Congolese star Martin Bakole as Battle of Africa ends in a draw
Artificial intelligence weighs in on the speculations surrounding Victor Osimhen's future
The Swiss star has clapped back at her critics once more
CR7 celebrated the two leading women in his life with a special message
has grabbed the headlines with a stunning outfit while attending a concert
Chelsea defender Marc Cucurella was emotional
wiping away tears as he spoke about the personal challenges his son's autism has brought upon him
Max Verstappen welcomes his first child with Kelly Piquet just days before racing in the 2025 Miami Grand Prix
Love may have brought them to Italy but it could not keep the world's most followed female footballer and her Brazilian boyfriend together
Barcelona unveil a bold new El Clásico kit featuring Travis Scott's Cactus Jack logo in partnership with Spotify
Afrobeats finds the fast lane as three Nigerian stars rev up the soundtrack for the most anticipated racing film of the year
World 100m champion Sha'Carri Richardson featured in a WHOOP star-studded ad alongside Liverpool football captain Virgil van Dijk and other sporting stars
Jannik Sinner is set to make his comeback from a doping ban amid swirling rumours of a new romance
Hulk married his ex-wife's niece for the second time in back in January
Junelle Bromfield and Noah Lyles delved into details on their wedding plans set for spring 2026
lovebirds Noah Lyles and Junelle Bromfield gave more details on their high profile wedding scheduled to happen in Spring 2026
Victor Osimhen's girlfriend embarked on a mini-vacation to Dubai with their adorable daughter
Yung Miami has responded to the claims on social media that she's chasing after Cleveland Brown's newest recruit Shadeur Sanders
Maya Jama was at Wembley to cheer on Ruben Dias as Pep Guardiola's team reached a third successive FA Cup final
No flaws for Ori Menashe and Genevieve Gergis’s Bestia follow up
This week, Jonathan Gold shares his thoughts on Bavel, not even two months after Ori Menashe and Genevieve Gergis’ blockbuster opening
Gold hardly utters a negative comment about the Bestia founders’ sophomore effort
but he does say that the restaurant can get pretty loud
as one might expect at an Arts District warehouse space
the Times critic waxes poetic about a few standout dishes
And he declares the oyster mushrooms as the best dish:
The pièce de résistance may well be the lamb neck shawarma:
The best big meat dish at Bavel is the lamb neck “shawarma,” slow-roasted until it almost collapses in on itself
[...] You carve off a bit of the dripping meat
pastry maven Gergis gets her due with a nod to her outstanding ode to licorice:
Ultimately, the Goldster seems to confirm all the hype. Bavel is certainly one of the hottest restaurants in Los Angeles
but now those reservations will likely be even more difficult to secure
Ori Menashe and Genevieve Gergis Image by Bestia
It’s a bit of a surreal experience opening “Bavel.”
makes no mention of what many consider the worst year to ever to befall the industry
And at a time when the conflict is front page news
Shukshuka or hummus at Abu Hassan or foie gras
And those photographs are an exercise in pure escapism: like the food porn shots of bronzed whole chickens and plump heads of cauliflower hanging on metal hooks over the blaze of a wood-fired oven
And Menashe’s impossibly good-looking family
down to an adorable toddler daughter named Saffron
cookbooks are meant not to be only representative of their moment
but to be cooked from for years to come — and to be
So the choice not to include how they shut down for a few days and then offered takeout meals
and then shutting down completely for one winter month before re-opening for outdoor dining was deliberate
Perhaps when someone opens Bavel a few years from now
the confluence of the pandemic and a war will be a distant memory
I’ve written about my fair share of Israeli cookbooks since 2012
the year that Yotam Ottolenghi and Sami Tamimi’s “Jerusalem” came out
The better known among them include those by Michael Solomonov
Einat Admony and Adeena Sussman; the lesser known but still worth knowing about by Honey & Co
I sometimes even wonder how many more we need of the genre
the mark of a great chef is to take a dish that we already have multiple recipes for – take hummus for example – and make you excited to try their version
because it’s a dish that’s so overdone by now
but Menashe’s spins with avocado tahini and pepita chile oil
or celery leaf chermoula definitely stood out
This cookbook reminded me that while the last thing I need is another hummus recipe
what I can always use is new and inspired ways to serve the beloved staple
That his za’atar blends include both rose and mushroom versions
is a good representation of Menashe’s culinary point of view
It’s also worth mentioning that crème fraiche seems to be a favorite ingredient of his
“Creme fraiche is just a lighter version of yogurt and I feel some things need that lightness,” Menashe explained in an email
“Yogurt and labne are more noticeable and you can taste that it’s there
With creme fraiche it’s more subtle and it’s easy to add something without overpowering a certain ingredient
There are actually a lot of modern Israeli restaurants using creme fraiche.”
Menashe and Gergis are the married couple behind Bavel
They met cute in an Italian restaurant they both worked in
before opening their first restaurant together
Bavel was a much more personal project; Gergis also has Middle Eastern roots
Gergis was pregnant when the idea to open an Israeli restaurant occurred to them
While they knew opening a second place with a totally different concept than the first was kind of an insane thing to do
The name Bavel is the Hebrew word for Babel
and it’s a metaphor for the various peoples and cultures making up the Middle East
before all the conflicts that came to define it in the last two centuries
It’s a restaurant that is both very Israeli and very L.A.
Menashe points out that the climate of both is similar
as is the superior produce that can be found in both places
Menashe had to teach himself how to make the food he grew up with
Luckily he comes from a family with a strong pedigree
and was the kind of person who would treat his son to a skewer of foie gras after his soccer games
Morocco and Turkey — all countries known for their superb cuisine – family dinner was never a boring affair in his household
in which his parents write the headnotes to some of their favorite recipes: examples include a beef-cheek tagine from Menashe’s Moroccan mother
and where we get a good idea of her culinary point of view
Some of the best known Middle Eastern desserts like baklava can be overly sweet to some
and Gergis writes that a dessert need not be “sugary” to be satisfying; there are so many other ways to end a meal
a pastry with strawberries tossed in sumac paired with a ricotta yogurt filling
all topped with pistachio ice cream is a great example
there are now a lot of great Israeli cookbooks out there already
But there are many dishes in “Bavel” that make me want to get back into the kitchen
Alix Wallis a freelance writer in Oakland
I’d like to ask you to please support the Forward
American Jews need independent news they can trust
At a time when other newsrooms are closing or cutting back
the Forward has removed its paywall and invested additional resources to report on the ground from Israel and around the U.S
rising antisemitism and polarized discourse
This is a great time to support independent Jewish journalism you rely on
See our full guidelines for more information, and this guide for detail about canonical URLs
subject line “republish,” with any questions or to let us know what stories you’re picking up
Copyright © 2025 The Forward Association
Iker Casillas backs Ancelotti after Real Madrid's Champions League shock
Real Madrid legend Iker Casillas responds to ex-porn star Claudia Bavel’s accusations
Legendary Spanish goalkeeper Iker Casillas has been spotted with former adult actress and OnlyFans model Claudia Bavel in Barcelona, fueling speculation about his love life. The pair were reportedly seen together at a hotel, with Spanish magazine Diez Minutos publishing exclusive images from last Tuesday.
Since splitting from Sara Carbonero in 2021 after five years of marriage, Casillas has been linked to several high-profile women. The 28-year-old Bavel, who began her career in adult films as a teenager, now earns around £17,000 per month through her OnlyFans platform.
Bavel boasts nearly 250,000 Instagram followers, where she regularly shares bold fashion choices, and an additional 16,000 followers on a separate account featuring more daring selfies and a link to her OnlyFans page.
Asked about the pictures on Telecinco’s ‘TardeAR’, Bavel admitted: "I can't deny what appears in the photos." When pressed on whether she had spoken to Casillas since the images surfaced, she confirmed that she had and that neither of them was worried about the attention.
Casillas, widely regarded as one of the greatest goalkeepers in history, spent 16 years at Real Madrid, making over 500 appearances before moving to Porto in 2015. He retired in August 2020 after suffering a heart attack. Over his illustrious career, he won three Champions League titles, five La Liga titles, and led Spain to one World Cup and two European Championship victories.
Nogomania.com is a premier destination for football enthusiasts, delivering fresh and in-depth content from the heart of the Ex-Yu region's football scene.
Show Search Search Query Submit Search Don't Miss
2018 Hummus is definitely having a moment
It seems you can’t scroll through a menu without at least one offering
And with all of the varieties available — I’ve seen variations flavored with everything from edamame to chipotle
roasted butternut squash to English pea with watercress — it’s become the muse of many a chef
You might even argue hummus is the next avocado toast
“It’s like risotto,” says chef Sean Lowenthal
“You just need an ingredient to become a theme to bind the dish.”
has served at least 15 varieties of hummus since the restaurant opened five years ago
he’s offering a black-eyed pea hummus topped with a Hoppin’ John-inspired salsa as part of a Southern-themed pop-up at the restaurant through the summer
“I was trying to figure out why we love black-eyed peas in the South but nobody else eats them,” he says
He wanted to find a vehicle for the ingredient that would be more approachable to guests
the dish is more about tradition and technique
Perhaps the most lauded hummus at the moment can be found at downtown L.A.’s Bevel
chef/owner Ori Menashe’s latest venture with partner Genevieve Gergis
waxed poetic about Menashe’s hummus offerings
it’s more vulnerable when you can’t cover it with different flavors.”
Menashe went through hundreds of tests to come up with the right technique for his hummus
The airy hummus simply can’t be replicated using home equipment
but the rustic hummus masabacha can be made simply by whipping a handful of ingredients — parsley
tahini and water — together using a mortar and pestle
Menashe stresses using the best ingredients
and he uses an imported tahini paste used by many chefs in Israel
chef and owner of the Fat Dog in Fairfax and North Hollywood
uses the idea of traditional hummus — garbanzo beans
lemon juice and garlic — as a starting point
The restaurant had just taken a beet salad off the menu
“Beets present all these opportunities,” he notes
Beets work with a variety of crumbled fresh cheese
along with a crunchy topping such as seeds or nuts
parsley — and “it makes the dish more of a salad hummus as opposed to just puréed garbanzos with beets.”
At the modern Mediterranean restaurant Momed (with locations in Atwater Village and Beverly Hills)
owner Alex Sarkissian says the avocado hummus is one of the classic dishes that remains from when the first restaurant opened almost 10 years ago
“Most people keep the garbanzo as the base ingredient while switching up other flavors,” Sarkissian says
he was concerned the dish might taste too much like guacamole without the garbanzo beans
“But think of the tahini as the key ingredient.” And it’s worked
Sarkissian calls the hummus one of the “superstars” on the menu
that avocado hummus also tastes really good on toast
cover the garbanzo beans with 3 cups of water and 1 ½ teaspoons baking soda
combine the garbanzos with the remaining 1 ½ teaspoons baking soda
Toast the garbanzos over low heat until the skins start to fall off
Add the remaining 5 cups water and bring to a boil
skim the foam and skins that rise to the surface
Leave the garbanzos in the liquid for 10 minute before straining
This makes approximately 3 cups cooked garbanzos
The garbanzos can be made up to a few days in advance; cover and refrigerate to store
Add the lemon juice and set aside for two minutes
Noelle Carter is the former Los Angeles Times Test Kitchen director
I was struck — and totally won over — by the beauty
who led the Studio UNLTD team on the project
started working on the design together in 2016 — a few years after their successful design collaboration on perennial LA hotspot Bestia
“My side is more directive on atmosphere and the feeling we wanted
And Greg takes it to his team and makes it come to fruition,” says Gergis
Bleier finds those restrictions creatively freeing
“I find it more refreshing than someone giving you a blank canvas
and Genevieve and Ori are great at making problems,” he quips
it meant transforming a former clothing warehouse into an a breezy yet opulent showpiece
Bleier and architectural designer Osvaldo Maiozzi added a skylight
Leaving the concrete floors of the patio unglossed helped maintain a sense of history and age
Kitchen designer Alec Bauer kept the open kitchen totally modern
Bleier and Studio UNTLD senior interior designer Ania Bown pulled blues from the photos Gergis would send from her travels to Morocco and Israel — the water in particular — while the yellows were a necessary counterbalance
Bleier also wanted to be smart about incorporating the visual touchstones of the region: The curves of the back bar nod to the iconic arches of Islamic architecture; instead of recreating Moroccan inlay floor details
oversized fish-scale pattern with custom California-made tiles; instead of relying on chandeliers to cast familiar geometric patterns on the walls
the plants (“our own hanging garden of Babylon,” Beier jokes) achieve the same effect
The various white tiles that comprise the bar area express different textures
A mix of brass and rose gold throughout the space keeps things feeling both luxe and lived in
The brick walls inside the restaurant were treated by a scenic painter who added layers of texture after white-washing to evoke a sense of history
And the entire scheme embraces where the restaurant actually is — not on a Mediterranean coast
but in the heart of Los Angeles’s burgeoning Arts District
a design as expansive and well executed as Bavel’s is worth celebrating
The freshest news from the food world every day