a new social function while preserving its historic elements
The design was created through a collaboration between MVRDV
and construction economics consultancy SkaaL
and is expected to be completed at the end of 2027
The church's pews will be repurposed into seating integrated within the glass walls
serving as benches for swimmers on one side and bar-height tables for spectators on the other
The original pulpit will be adapted to serve as the lifeguard's station
Related Article Transforming Sacred Spaces: 17 Adaptive Reuse Projects Revitalizing Churches
the design incorporates compartmentalized glass walls that preserve the surrounding stained glass and interior finishes
The roof will be insulated from the outside to prevent excessive heat loss while maintaining the view of the original brickwork from the inside
the existing roof covering is planned to be reinstated
The wooden ceiling structure will be retained and enhanced with sound-absorbing panels to improve acoustics
will be discreetly integrated into the basement
recognizing projects worldwide that prioritize reuse and repurposing in architecture for the common good
You'll now receive updates based on what you follow
Personalize your stream and start following your favorite authors
If you have done all of this and still can't find the email
Another new example to highlight today is their forthcoming Heerlen Holy Water conversion in the Dutch countryside in collaboration with Zecc Architecten
By inserting a climatised public pool space into the landmarked St
the firm completed a transformation that once again confers a social function onto the space
The design affords a unique kind of configurability thanks to an adjustable pool floor that can be raised to constitute a new space for intimate gatherings
Construction is expected to be completed at some point in 2027
Hard to believe the conversion won't carry
We need to find ways to ritually cleanse ourselves
Are you sure you want to block this user and hide all related comments throughout the site
Your comment will be visible once approved
MVRDV and Zecc Architecten have won the competition to turn St
built over a hundred years ago and offering religious services until 2023
into a public swimming pool for the Dutch city
nicknamed ‘Holy Water,’ is the adjustable pool floor
even to the point of concealing the water entirely
resulting in a multifunctional flat surface for hosting different social and cultural events
It can also be set to hold a shallow layer of water
The lighting over the pool was inspired by the church’s original lamps
These are reinterpreted with four suspended rows of fixtures that also serve as lane markers for swimmers
A main challenge is to guarantee efficient and sustainable climate control without jeopardizing the integrity of the historical elements
glazed partitions will delimit the pool space as well as protect the stained-glass windows and the artworks
The original roof will be insulated from the outside to prevent excessive heat loss
while maintaining the view of the original brickwork from inside
Technical systems will be integrated into the basement
freeing up the main space entirely for public use
Construction work is programmed for completion in 2007
there arent any match using your search terms
About . Contact . Donation
Archaeologists have uncovered the earliest evidence of Roman settlement in Heerlen
with the discovery of a 2,000-year-old burial belonging to a Roman soldier named Flaccus
made during ongoing excavations at the Raadhuisplein (Town Hall Square)
offers new insights into Heerlen’s history as Coriovallum
a Roman settlement strategically located at the crossroads of major Roman roads
One of these plates bore the abbreviation “FLAC,” a nickname for Flaccus
The burial of Flaccus predates other known Roman graves in Heerlen and represents the oldest named individual in the city’s history
such as pottery fragments from the first half of the 1st century CE
as they could have been lost or discarded along the road
Flaccus’ grave provides unequivocal evidence of early Roman presence
including four matching plates and a personalized bowl
were made in Italy and date to around the year 0
These items suggest that Flaccus was a Roman soldier stationed at Coriovallum during the early Roman expansion into the region
Archaeologists highlight the rarity of identifying non-elite individuals by name in ancient contexts
making Flaccus’ burial a significant discovery
The presence of the name on a funerary object indicates the personal and cultural practices of the time
Coriovallum was established at the junction of the Via Belgica and Via Traiana
connecting Cologne (Germany) to Boulogne-sur-Mer (France) and Xanten (Germany) to Trèves (France)
Coriovallum evolved into a flourishing civilian town by the mid-1st century CE
remain the largest visible Roman ruins in the Netherlands
Excavations at the Raadhuisplein will continue into December
The artifacts from Flaccus’ grave will be cleaned
and displayed at the new Roman Museum of Heerlen
Clemens noted: “This find not only teaches us more about our past but also demonstrates the unique story of Roman Heerlen for the Netherlands.”
More information: Municipality of Heerlen
I read in other articles and postings that Flaccus was a Roman soldier or auxiliary in Legio XXX
or hanging down” – often used as a cognomen (a nickname or family name); his contubernium mates (tent mates) would laugh that he of all legionaries should be remembered through all time …
and website in this browser for the next time I comment
Δdocument.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime())
Learn how to describe the purpose of the image (opens in a new tab)
Leave empty if the image is purely decorative
Learn how to describe the purpose of the image (opens in a new tab). Leave empty if the image is purely decorative.
Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.
Experts have for the first time been able to put a name to a Roman grave dating back over 2000 years in the Netherlands
Archaeologists have unearthed a unique grave of a Roman soldier “from year 0” in the Netherlands, shedding light on the ancient civilisation’s presence in the region
The 2,000-year-old grave was discovered in the municipality of Heerlen last month and belonged to a soldier nicknamed “Flaccus” who lived around 0AD
They deduced the name from the word “Flac” carved into a bowl found in the grave.
“Today, evidence was found of Roman habitation in the time of Emperor Augustus. A unique discovery that not only teaches us more about our past, but also shows how unique the story of Roman Heerlen is for the Netherlands,” Jordy Clemens, Heerlen’s council member for culture and heritage, said in a statement.
Analysis of the newly found gravesite led researchers to date Heerlen’s earliest settlement to the Augustan era from 0 to 20AD.
The gravesite was found during excavations at Raadhuisplein, the town square in Heerlen which sat near the historical roads Via Belgica and Via Traiana and was a key location in the middle of the Roman settlement Coriovallum, archaeologists said.
Coriovallum stood out for its elaborate Roman bathhouse, the oldest stone building in the Netherlands built around 40AD. The structure also included a restaurant and a library, suggesting it was a meeting place and served multiple functions in the Roman era.
The latest findings could provide new insights into the residential history of the city, archaeologists said. “Never before have we found a Roman grave from this period with a name.”
Researchers also found a bronze skin scraper and four plates along with the bowl in the grave. They traced the pottery to ancient Italy, confirming that Flaccus was indeed a Roman soldier.
Previous digs in the region, unearthing pottery shreds, could not prove the presence of a settlement as there was a possibility the artefacts could have been discarded during travel.
The Flaccus grave offered convincing evidence of Roman presence in the region, researchers said. “It is a unique find because it is not only the oldest Roman grave in Heerlen but also because no name was known there before,” they explained.
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies
A 37-year-old man from Heerlen was arrested Saturday evening in connection with a stabbing that occurred during a carnival celebration in the city
The suspect is being investigated for attempted manslaughter
The stabbing took place in the early hours of Saturday at Pancratiusplein
was transported to a hospital for treatment
the incident followed a dispute inside a nightlife venue
The suspect fled the scene on foot after the attack
Authorities initially estimated the suspect to be around 35 years old based on witness accounts
They later identified and detained the 37-year-old suspect Saturday evening
Police have asked witnesses and anyone with footage of the altercation to come forward as the investigation continues
LBV Magazine English Edition
during archaeological investigations conducted in Heerlen (Netherlands)
an exceptional discovery was made: the tomb of a Roman soldier named Flaccus
dating to the late 1st century BCE and early 1st century CE
represents one of the most significant pieces of evidence of Roman presence in the area
It is the first time a tomb from this period has been found in the region with a name associated
The team of archaeologists from ADC ArcheoProjecten uncovered a cavity filled with remains related to the earliest Roman occupation of Heerlen at the Raadhuisplein (municipal square)
The shape of the remains and the materials found indicated it was a Roman burial site
Among the unearthed items were ceramic pieces and personal utensils that provided crucial information about the deceased’s identity
One of the most notable finds was a bowl bearing the inscription “FLAC”
an abbreviation identified by specialists as a reference to the name Flaccus
a bronze tool used for scraping skin and four ceramic plates were also recovered
Analysis of the objects revealed that they originated in Italy
corroborating Flaccus’ connection to the Roman army
This combination of elements makes the discovery not only the oldest of its kind in Heerlen but also one of the few that allows for the identification of a specific individual from that era
present-day Heerlen was known as Coriovallum and was strategically located at the crossroads of two major routes
These roads facilitated trade and military movement
making Coriovallum a key location within the Roman Empire
was central to this community and remains a site where over 2,000 years of history converge
The new findings provide valuable insights into how the city’s earliest inhabitants lived and their relationship with the Roman Empire
Flaccus’ tomb not only confirms the presence of Roman soldiers in the region but also shows how these individuals were integrated into local society
The wealth of objects found suggests that Flaccus likely held a privileged status within the community
Archaeological work at the Raadhuisplein is ongoing and will continue for several more days
Each new discovery broadens our understanding of Heerlen’s Roman roots
uncovering details that were once thought lost to time
These efforts not only preserve the city’s historical memory but also connect its current residents with their past
highlighting Coriovallum’s importance as a site of historical and cultural significance
Gemeente Heerlen
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
Archaeologists from universities in the United States and Denmark found, deep within the Actun Uayazba Kab cave in Belize, two small stone tools dated between 250 and 900 AD that…
For centuries in China, men and women gathered to play a game called Cuju. Considered an ancient form of soccer, a pastime, but also a political tool, it played a…
A team of researchers has succeeded in recreating for the first time in a laboratory experiment a phenomenon that until now only existed as a theory in the realm of…
As part of a major construction project, the Cantonal Archaeology of Aargau carried out a rescue excavation between early May 2024 and the end of March 2025. This significantly expanded…
The Egyptian archaeological mission affiliated with the Supreme Council of Antiquities announced the discovery of a group of defensive structures, military barracks, and a system of moats that could indicate…
In the southeastern area of the city of Rome, archaeologists excavating inside the Triton Baths, built in the 2nd century A.D. within the monumental complex of the Villa di Sette…
Why did some animals from ancient eras become fossils, while others simply disappeared without a trace? The answer, at least in part, may lie within their own bodies, according to…
A recent study on the cave paintings of the Altamira Cave in Santillana del Mar, Cantabria (Spain) has concluded that some of the artworks it contains could be much older…
A team of paleontologists from the University of Leicester has managed to decipher one of the many enigmas of the dinosaur era—the exact moment when pterosaurs, the large and unsettling…
Throughout its long history, Rome achieved numerous military victories that allowed it to grow, expand, and dominate nearly the entire known world in Antiquity. But it also suffered defeats, and…
Receive our news and articles in your email for free. You can also support us with a monthly subscription and receive exclusive content.
WACH: Breakthrough in missing Malaysian Airlines flight search with Australian fisherman's discovery
Archaeologists have discovered a unique 2,000-year-old Roman soldier's grave in Heerlen
unearthed last month in the Dutch municipality
represents evidence of Roman habitation in the area during the time of Emperor Augustus
The grave site has provided researchers with crucial insights into the earliest settlement of Heerlen
which they now date to the Augustan era between 0 and 20 AD
The soldier was identified as "Flaccus" through the word "Flac" carved into a bowl discovered in the grave
evidence was found of Roman habitation in the time of Emperor Augustus
A unique discovery that not only teaches us more about our past
but also shows how unique the story of Roman Heerlen is for the Netherlands," said Jordy Clemens
Heerlen's council member for culture and heritage
The grave was discovered during excavations at Raadhuisplein
which held strategic importance in the ancient Roman settlement of Coriovallum
The location sat near two significant Roman roads
Coriovallum was notable for housing the Netherlands' oldest stone building
The bathhouse complex included a restaurant and library
serving as a multifunctional meeting place during the Roman period
Researchers discovered several significant items within the grave
including four plates and a bronze skin scraper
The pottery items were traced back to ancient Italy
providing confirmation of Flaccus's identity as a Roman soldier
This discovery was particularly significant as previous finds of pottery fragments in the region could not definitively prove Roman settlement
as they might have been discarded by travellers
The latest discovery was particularly significant as previous finds of pottery fragments in the region could not definitively prove Roman settlement
The discovery of Flaccus's grave marks a groundbreaking moment in Dutch archaeology
being both the oldest Roman grave in Heerlen and the first to bear a name
"It is a unique find because it is not only the oldest Roman grave in Heerlen but also because no name was known there before," researchers explained
The grave provides definitive evidence of Roman settlement in the region during the time of Emperor Augustus
offering new insights into the area's residential history
Mission Statement: to assist the integration of foreign residents living in Spain
and this is never more accurate than when you establish yourself as a foreign resident in a new country
Being able to quickly familiarise yourself with the culture
and customs can help ease the transition during a challenging time
This is why Euro Weekly News makes it our mission to provide you with a free news resource in English that covers both regional and national Spanish news – anything that we feel you will benefit from knowing as you integrate into your new community and live your best life in Spain
you can forget about translating articles from Spanish into awkward English that probably don’t make much sense
Let us be your convenient and essential guide to all things that will likely affect you as a foreign resident living in Spain
A groundbreaking find in the Netherlands reveals the grave of a Roman soldier from around 0 AD
providing fresh insight into the early Roman presence in the region
Archaeologists have made an extraordinary discovery in the municipality of Heerlen
uncovering a 2,000-year-old grave belonging to a Roman soldier
which dates back to the time of Emperor Augustus
is particularly significant as it is the first Roman burial in the area to be identified by name
dubbed ‘Flaccus,’ was identified from the word ‘Flac’ carved into a bowl found within the grave
This marks an unprecedented moment in the study of Roman settlements in the Netherlands
The grave was unearthed during excavations at Raadhuisplein
which was once a strategic location along the Roman roads Via Belgica and Via Traiana
This area formed part of the Roman settlement of Coriovallum
a key military and cultural hub in the region
This discovery is more than just an archaeological find; it offers new perspectives on the Roman occupation of the area
“Never before have we found a Roman grave from this period with a name,” said archaeologists
highlighting the grave’s historical significance
In addition to confirming Roman presence in Heerlen
the grave provides invaluable insights into the daily lives of soldiers stationed in the region
The findings not only enhance our understanding of Roman settlements but also underscore the importance of Heerlen as a Roman settlement in the Netherlands
The unearthing of Flaccus’s grave represents a major milestone in Roman archaeology
enriching the narrative of ancient Roman life beyond traditional texts and illustrations
Find more news about Netherlands
Subscribe to our Euro Weekly News alerts to get the latest stories into your inbox
Euro Weekly News is the leading English language newspaper in Spain
by delivering news with a social conscience
we are proud to be the voice for the expat communities who now call Spain home
With around half a million print readers a week and over 1.5 million web views per month
EWN has the biggest readership of any English language newspaper in Spain
The paper prints over 150 news stories a week with many hundreds more on the web – no one else even comes close
Our publication has won numerous awards over the last 25 years including Best Free Newspaper of the Year (Premios AEEPP)
Company of the Year (Costa del Sol Business Awards) and Collaboration with Foreigners honours (Mijas Town Hall)
All of this comes at ZERO cost to our readers
All our print and online content always has been and always will be FREE OF CHARGE
Download our media pack in either English or Spanish
Gemeente Heerlen/FacebookArchaeologists excavating the grave of the Roman soldier Flaccus
Archaeologists recently uncovered a 2,000-year-old grave from a Roman settlement in Heerlen
The burial belonged to a soldier named Flaccus
and it is now considered the “most unique evidence of Roman habitation at this location.”
This indeed marks the first time that a Roman grave of a specific
offering fascinating new insights into the ancient history of the Netherlands
Gemeente Heerlen/FacebookVarious ceramic artifacts and grave goods were found
including one that bore the inscription “FLAC” for “Flaccus.”
The discovery was made during ongoing excavations at the Raadhuisplein (Town Hall Square) in late November 2024
The site contains remnants of the ancient Roman settlement of Coriovallum
which was situated at the intersection of two important roads
Archaeologists from ADC Archeo Projecten were assessing the area during a redevelopment project when they came across a bit of earth with discolored soil in a rectangular shape
Gemeente Heerlen/FacebookThe grave showed evidence of cremation
But what they found instead was evidence of a cremation burial
they discovered various artifacts including a bronze strigil (a personal hygiene tool used for cleansing the skin)
One of these plates bore the inscription “FLAC,” a nickname for Flaccus
In a statement
Heerlen council member Jordy Clemens said: “Today
but also shows how unique the story of Roman Heerlen is for the Netherlands.”
there had been no conclusive evidence of a Roman presence in the region during the first century C.E
Flaccus’ burial predates all other known Roman graves in Heerlen
individual burial in the city’s history
and although there have been previous first-century C.E
finds in the region — mostly pottery — none were sufficient to confirm with 100 percent certainty that the Romans were present in the region during this time
Flaccus’ grave presents irrefutable proof that the Roman settlement in Heerlen existed around 0 C.E
the researchers also found a bronze skin scraper and four different plates,” the statement continues
It is a unique find because it is not only the oldest Roman grave in Heerlen but also because no name was known there before.”
Raadhuisplein was once at the center of Coriovallum
an integral Roman settlement during the era of their dominance in the region
It emerged at the crossroads of two significant Roman roads: the Via Belgica
This strategic location led to Coriovallum’s development into a bustling hub of activity
According to Livius, one standout feature of Coriovallum was its elaborate Roman bathhouse, or thermae, constructed around 40 C.E. This bathhouse is recognized as the oldest stone building in the Netherlands, showing just how important the settlement was during the Roman era
The well-preserved remains of these baths are now showcased at Heerlen’s Thermenmuseum
Roman ReconstructionsA photograph from the original excavation of the Heerlen bathhouse in 1941
This bathhouse also contained a restaurant and a library
bathhouses like this were common meeting places and often served multiple functions
at least 46 ancient Roman kilns have been identified within the boundaries of Heerlen
suggesting that the Roman settlement had also been an important production center for pottery
The discovery of Flaccus’ grave is just the latest in a long line of important historical discoveries at Heerlen
and given how important this Roman settlement once was
After reading about the discovery of Flaccus’ grave in the Netherlands, learn all about the brutal Roman military punishment known as decimation. Then, learn about the unhinged Roman emperor Commodus
Click 'OK' then 'Allow' to enable notifications
InstagramXThreadsSnapchatTikTokYouTubeLAD Entertainment
Home> News> World News
Archaeologists have made a huge discovery in finding the remains of a person that is believed to be from 'year zero'
The uncovered grave was one from 2,000 years ago
which belonged to a Roman soldier named 'Flaccus'
They discovered his remains in the Netherlands, which also brought more attention to the civilisation's overwhelming presence in the region, and in fact the world, at that time in history
They worked the soldier's name out after finding the name 'Flac' carved into an unearthed bowl that was in the grave itself
Sharing the discovery on the official Municipality of Heerlen Facebook page
Heerlen’s council member for culture and heritage
released a statement on the team's discovery
but also shows how unique the story of Roman Heerlen is for the Netherlands," Clemens wrote
researchers deduced that Heerlen's first settlement would have been around the Augustan era from around 0 to 20 AD
This gravesite was discovered in the midst of excavations at Raadhuisplein
near a couple of historical roads in Via Belgica and Via Traiana
It was found to be an important location in the middle of a Roman settlement named Coriovallum
Cariovallum was known for its Roman bathhouse
which is also the oldest stone building in the whole country
but the building also had a restaurant and library
which points towards the area being a multi-purpose building and a place of meeting in Roman times
Archaeologists further explained that their findings would give us some new insights into the history of the city
adding: “Never before have we found a Roman grave from this period with a name.”
managing to trace the pottery back to ancient Italy
confirming their suspicions that he was a Roman soldier
In the past, digs in the area have uncovered nothing more than pottery shreds, not proving the presence of a settlement as these items could have been left behind during travel
Flaccus' grave gave researchers eye-opening evidence that there was a Roman presence in the region
as they further explained: “It is a unique find because it is not only the oldest Roman grave in Heerlen but also because no name was known there before.”
Topics: History, World News
he has always been interested in writing about a range of subjects
After graduating from Oxford Brookes University with a BA in Media
he got a job freelance writing for SPORTbible while working in marketing before landing a full-time role at LADbible
he's unhealthily obsessed with Manchester United
which takes its toll on his mental and physical health
A 30-year-old man from Heerlen has died from stab wounds following an incident Thursday night
Emergency services transported the victim to the hospital
where he succumbed to his injuries later that night
A 34-year-old man from Heerlen was arrested immediately after the incident
He remains in custody while police investigate the circumstances surrounding the stabbing
Authorities are working to determine the exact details of the altercation that led to the victim’s death
No further information has been released at this time
Netherlands to welcome sprinting legend on July 24 and 26 respectively for exhibition races
he should be back racing - albeit not competitively - as soon as this week in two of the ‘post-Tour crits’
where he had his own podium ceremony to recognise his legendary career
Cavendish was announced to be starting at the criteriums in Chaam on Wednesday
praising Van de Mortel - the owner of team Parkhotel Valkenburg for helping with fees
“Cavendish won the sprint on July 3 and thus reached a legendary number of 35 Tour victories
But he also won 17 stages in the Giro d'Italia and three in the Tour of Spain
A true cycling great who also competed in Heerlen in 2008.”
He’ll be joined on the start line in Heerlen by Dutch Astana Qazaqstan teammate Cees Bol and breakthrough rider Frank van den Broek
after he netted a famous 1-2 for DSM-Firmenich PostNL on the Tour’s opening stage alongside Romain Bardet.
They serve as more of an exhibition for the public to enjoy than actual races
with jersey winners from the Tour riding in their famous jerseys and often taking the ‘win’ and a nice appearance fee for taking part
Roeselare: 1 Mathieu van der Poel, 2 Biniam Girmay, 3 Gianni Vermeersch
Wateringen: 1 Jasper Philipsen, 2 Frank van den Broek
Herentals: 1 Biniam Girmay, 2 Mark Cavendish
Maarheeze: 1 Mike Teunissen, 2 Cees Bol, 3 Danny van Poppel
Roosendaal: Biniam Girmay, Bauke Mollema, Dylan Groenewegen
during which time he also wrote for Eurosport
Prior to joining the team he reported on races such as Paris-Roubaix and the Giro d’Italia Donne for Eurosport and has interviewed some of the sport’s top riders in Chloé Dygert
he spends the majority of his time watching other sports – rugby
GREEN+ - New data by the European Environmental Agency shows the concentration of particulate matter (PM 2.5) in European cities
Heerlen is the Dutch city with the cleanest air
according to new data from the European Environmental Agency (EEA)
No one of the Dutch cities surveyed belongs to the category of European cities with good air quality.
The EEA recently ranked European cities’ air quality based on the average levels of fine particulate matter (PM2.5) in 2022 and 2023
PM2.5 stands for particulate matter particles 2.5 micrometers and smaller in diameter
they can easily be inhaled and cause health problems
PM2.5 comes from sources like vehicle emissions
Bad air quality is behind 300,000 deaths yearly in the EU.
no Dutch city belongs to the cities with good air quality
The 11 surveyed urban areas all fall under the fair air quality level – 5 to 10 μg/m3 of average concentration – with Eindhoven just making it into this bracket with 9.7μg/m3. In addition to Heerlen
The EEA specifies that the ranking only includes cities that have urban or suburban air quality monitoring stations for PM2.5 and that are included in the database of cities established under the European Commission’s Urban Audit
The EEA categorizes air quality as: Good for levels that don’t exceed the 5 μg/m3 WHO guideline; fair for levels above 5 and not exceeding 10 μg/m3; moderate for levels above 10 and not exceeding 15 μg/m3; poor for levels above 15 and not exceeding 25 μg/m3; very poor for levels above the EU limit value of 25 μg/m3
The presence of the airport, the proximity to major national roads, and many livestock farms around the city are some of the drivers behind Eindhoven’s relatively poor air quality, as per Henry van der Velden
advisor on Healthy Urbanisation at the Municipality of Eindhoven
In order to monitor air quality and then take appropriate measures to reduce air pollution
the city council partnered up with the Dutch Institute for Applied Scientific Research (TNO).
The collaboration resulted in the Air Monitoring Network
which groups detections from the national air quality monitoring network
The monitoring network has already resulted in practical policies
including a redesign of one of the main connecting roads in the city center
as well as more public transport connections to the airport.
Most of the cities complying with the WHO guideline for PM2.5 concentrations are in the North of Europe
except for the Portuguese Faro and Funchal – on the island of Madeira.
most of the cities with poor air quality are in the South and East of Europe
The majority of the reported cities in the Italian Po Valley and in Poland have poor air quality
The Croatian Slavonski Brod is the only surveyed city exceeding the 25 μg/m3 threshold with 26,5 μg/m3
Bucharest is the capital with the worst air quality (15,6 μg/m3)
followed by Ljubljana (15,4 μg/m3) and Warsaw (15 μg/m3).
In April, the European Parliament approved a revised version of the Ambient Air Quality Directive
The law sets more stringent air quality targets to be met by 2030 for some of the most common pollutants
such as nitrogen dioxide and fine particles
Annual limits for PM2.5 will be more than halved
EU countries can ask to postpone the deadline to 2040 if some conditions apply
keeping in mind 2050 as the end target for zero air pollution.
will transform into a booming centre of theatre
installations and all sorts of performances during the Cultura Nova festival
Artists and ensembles from various countries will aim to move the audience at various special locations and stages
Cultura Nova presents 10 full days of passionate and inspiring performances and artworks from a variety of disciplines
The performances at Cultura Nova take place at a wide spectrum of locations around the city of Heerlen
adding a degree of excitement and the opportunity for the visitor to explore the beauty of the region
Open to visitors of all ages, there is also a series of performances geared towards children, making it a fun day out for the whole family
Browse their incredible agenda and have a read-through of what they have to offer in 2024
Cultura Nova stages can be found not only in the city of Heerlen
but throughout Parkstad Limburg - the conurbation that includes Heerlen and the towns of Kerkrade
Check out the event website to see which locations are planning on hosting performances this year
The prime locations for Cultura Nova performances typically include:
The festival also attracts spectators from nearby Maastricht and, of course, visitors from over the German border, therefore, this is also the perfect event for expats in Germany
There are so many performances to choose from in different locations around Limburg, so take a look at the Cultura Nova programme, book your tickets and plan your visit. The programme can be filtered to show you only the events that don't need Dutch to be understood
Metrics details
Studying steel microstructures yields important insights regarding its mechanical characteristics
microstructures transform based on a multitude of factors including chemical composition
Martensite-austenite (MA) islands in bainitic steel appear as blocky structures with abstract shapes that are difficult to identify and differentiate from other types of microstructures
material science may benefit from machine learning models that are able to automatically and accurately detect these structures
the training process of the state-of-the-art machine learning models requires a large amount of high-quality data
we provide 1.705 scanning electron microscopy images along with a set of 8.909 expert-annotated polygons to describe the geometry of the MA islands that appear on the images
We envision that this dataset will be useful for material scientists to explore the relationship between the morphology of bainitic steel and mechanical characteristics
computer vision researchers and practitioners may use this data for training state-of-the-art object segmentation models for abstract geometries such as MA islands
area of martensite-austenite in steel • Polygon
Machine-accessible metadata file describing the reported data: https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.14045789
These properties are depending on chemical composition
and cooling rate as they influence the bainitic microstructure
prior research lacks quantitative measurements with meaningful numbers of MA islands
Often only the average size was used to interpret this sub-structure in bainite
the average size appears insufficient to describe the correlation between microstructure and mechanical properties
the characterization of bainite microstructures on microscopy images poses a challenge
and detecting a clear correlation between microstructure and mechanical properties is extremely difficult
To improve reliability and reproducibility
recent developments in machine learning provide a promising approach to tackle the challenge of microstructure description by computer vision
the architectural developments show promise
training object detection and segmentation models require a significant amount of high-quality annotated data
and expert-annotated image sets are rare to come across
the expected benefit of transfer learning (i.e.
applying the knowledge gained while training to solve a particular problem to a different yet similar problem) is limited
we contribute to both materials science and machine learning fields by providing (a) an image collection of steel microscopy on which blocky-type morphologies in bainite microstructures that are annotated by experts
(b) metadata regarding the morphology of these structures
Materials scientists may use the dataset to conduct bainite-related research
and machine learning practitioners may utilize the data to train and test object detection and segmentation models
In this section, we describe our method for generating the data, and measuring and calculating features. Fig. 1 represents the steps of our research process that includes data collection, annotation, feature calculation, and evaluation.
The steps of the data generation process
The images of various steel samples were acquired via a scanning electron microscope
The MA islands that appear on these images were annotated redundantly by multiple experts as points-of-interest (POI)
The set of POIs was refined into a smaller set based on the agreement of the experts using the spatial proximity of the individual annotations
the experts drew polygons on the boundary of the MA islands that were previously marked by the majority of experts
The agreed-upon POIs were also used to guide the automated contour detection around the MA islands
The generated polygons were benchmarked against the expert-annotated polygons
the morphological characteristics of expert annotated polygons were calculated
retained austenite films reveal another topography effect in this type of microstructure
Large MA islands commonly inherit large martensitic areas
carbon can diffuse and stabilize more austenite in the MA islands during cooling
Bainitic microstructures can consist of constituents with the order of magnitude on the sub-micron or even nanometer scale that cannot be imaged by light optical microscopy due to the limited spatial resolution
Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) provides high resolution images (resolution limit less than 10 nm) of a probed surface suitable for refined and more complex microstructures
emitted electrons from a field emission gun are focused on the sample surface
These primary electrons are scattered on the surface
Inelastic scattering excites electrons located close to the surface
These excited electrons cause emission of secondary electrons
Backscattered electrons and secondary electrons can be detected revealing local chemical (Back-Scattered Electron Detector) or topological (Scanning Electron Detector) gradients
EBSD is a time expensive method which requires also additional time for postprocessing
EBSD (or APT) is not suitable for an analysis on larger surface areas or on a larger set of samples
SEM images were chosen to generate efficiently a high quantity of image data suitable to be used as training input for computer vision models
Only secondary electron detectors were used that yield topographic information to take micrographs of local spots covering an area of nearly 650 µm2
the islands show a topographic effect in the SEM image
This effect originates from the etching response and manifests in a brighter appearance from the outer rim to the centre of the island
etching even reveals refined lath structures in the centre of the islands
The complexity of the given task lies in differentiating the MA islands from occasional carbides (bright points) and film-type austenite
These film-type structures occur as elongated and bright films with a thickness in the range of nanometer
The images were acquired in a Zeiss Sigma field emission gun SEM with secondary electron and Inlens detectors by Oxford
The SEM was operated at 15 kV with a working distance below 10 mm and with 60 µm aperture
We used a web-based 2D image annotation platform for the acquisition of spatial annotations on image sets
the annotation platform consists of two parts: a control panel that shows the task description
and a canvas object that displays a single image from the dataset with a transparent overlay that records the spatial coordinates of annotators’ mouse clicks
Two separate modes of operation are supported by the annotation software that were used in different steps of this study
users are allowed to either mark multiple POIs or draw one polygon through consecutive clicks
2.580 images were annotated separately and redundantly by three domain experts
the annotation task consisted of marking a point that is inside the blocky MA region
The annotators were instructed to provide one and only one POI marker per structure
we make the assumption that every marker put by a particular annotator belongs to exactly one MA structure that is visible on the image
markers that are placed by different annotators may indicate the same MA structure which may mean that the experts agree on the existence of a particular structure
Images were displayed in 1024 × 768 resolution
and the coordinates of annotated POIs were recorded in that resolution scale
the annotators marked all MA structures that they could identify on the images
The distribution of the number of POIs marked on images by the experts A
Example visualization of POIs marked by the expert annotators
and blue colored points are the POIs provided by annotators
Yellow points mark a POI that was agreed by two annotators
Purple colored points denote the agreement of three annotators
The number of POIs resulted by the agreement of all three annotators was 2.913
while the number of POIs agreed by two or three annotators was 8.909
we removed 63 images from the dataset because there were no agreed-upon POIs marked on them
The red dots mark the agreed-upon POIs that were collected in the POI annotation step
Polygon compactness measure ranges between 0 and 1
a perfect circle) and 0 indicates complete lack of compactness
Formulas (1) and (2) show how aspect ratio and polygon compactness were calculated where P denotes a polygon
TIFF files are the original outputs of the SEM and PNG equivalents are created to be displayed on web browsers for annotation purposes
Note that only 1.705 of the images have polygon annotations associated with them
The remaining image files are excluded due to suboptimal image quality or there are no agreed-upon MA-islands indicated on them
These images are provided in a separate folder
The description of the fields in the table are listed below
Type describes the chemical composition of the steel
The specifics of the composition are not included in this dataset
Type property is only provided as a classification feature to indicate compositionally different classes
Temperature is the temperature of phase transformation
Direction indicates the direction on which axis the photograph has been taken
It can be ‘Horizontal’ for left-to-right and ‘Vertical’ for top-to-bottom
Distance is the distance to the edge of the sample cross-section in either horizontal or vertical direction
The maximum distance in horizontal direction can be 24 mm and in vertical direction 13 mm
These distances are a result of the deformation of the sample by compression
Magnification is the magnification level while taking images with the electron microscope
All images in this dataset were recorded under 4000x magnification
Angle describes the tilt-angle (that was created by selecting a specific scanning electron detector) that was used during the photo making procedure
‘tilt’ indicates a tilt angle to create a bigger shadow on the sample
This helps to see the different topographic elevations of structures better
means that the electron ray flows perpendicular to the camera lens which is also called in-lens
the image usually gets brighter than otherwise
POI annotations table shows the entire set of annotations provided by all three experts
Each entry consists of the image name and an X
Y coordinate tuple that represents the offset coordinates of the point that was marked to indicate an MA structure by one of the experts
This table also includes the coordinates of MA structures that were agreed by either two or three experts
A: The list of POI annotations provided by the expert A
B: The list of POI annotations provided by the expert B
C: The list of POI annotations provided by the expert C
doubleAgreement: The list of POI annotations on which at least two experts agreed
tripleAgreement: The list of POI annotations on which three experts agreed
The POI lists are stored as coordinate-tuples
An example list that contains four points is as the following
Each entry in the expert segmentation table represents a polygon that marks the boundary around an MA structure
The POIs that lead to the drawing of a particular polygon annotation is also provided within the data table
Polygons are defined by a series of consecutive point tuples such as the following example
point: The point that marks the MA structure
The point is defined with one tuple of coordinates
polygon: The polygon that marks the boundary of the annotated MA structure
The morphological features data table contains the measured and calculated features of the MA islands that are represented by polygon objects
and polygon fields of the expert segmentation table and enriches them with the morphological features that are described below
The points and polygons are represented in Shapely geometry objects with the purpose of facilitating measurements and calculations
point_shapely: The Shapely representation of the point
This point resides within the polygon of the annotated MA island
poly_shapely: The Shapely representation of the polygon that represents an MA island
polygon_area: The area of polygon that represents an MA island in pixel-units
polygon_area_metric: The area of the polygon that represents an MA island in micrometers
polygon_perimeter: The perimeter of the polygon that represents an MA island in pixel-units
polygon_perimeter_metric: The perimeter of the polygon that represents an MA island in micrometers
height: The height of the rectangle that bounds the polygon in pixel-units
width: The width of the rectangle that bounds the polygon in pixel-units
aspect_ratio: The height of the bounding box of the polygon divided by the width of the bounding box of the polygon
This is an indicator of the shape of an MA island that is represented by the polygon
polygon_compactness: Calculated Polsby-Popper compactness34
This table contains polygons (contours) that are automatically created by the baseline model
The purpose of this table is to provide a benchmarking opportunity for computer vision researchers and practitioners
These polygons were created with a simple contour detection method that uses optimal parameters for the set of images that were used in this study
point: The expert-annotated point that marks the MA structure
polygon: The expert-annotated polygon that marks the boundary of the MA structure
point_shapely: The representation of ‘point’ in Shapely data format
poly_shapely: The representation of ‘polygon’ in Shapely data format
contour_polygon_shapely: The representation of the automatically detected contour in Shapely data format
The evaluation table consists of three additional features on top of the baseline contour detection model; area of the expert-annotated polygons
area of the automatically detected contours
and the Intersection-over-Union (IOU) as a measure of segmentation accuracy
area_contour: The area of the automatically detected contour in pixel-units
area_poly: The area of the expert-annotated polygon in pixel-units
IOU: The area of intersection of the expert-annotated polygon and the automatically detected contour divided by the area of the union of them
This is a measure of segmentation accuracy
We ensured the technical validation of the dataset and our curation approach focusing on three areas; POI annotations
and the usefulness of the dataset for training and evaluating object segmentation models
we were able to identify 8.909 MA islands that were separately annotated by at least two experts
and 2.913 that were agreed-upon by three experts
the quality of polygon annotations was controlled by two activities
we automatically checked if the polygons are valid
The validity of a polygon means that the polygon rings are closed
the outcome polygons were individually displayed on base images and carefully visually inspected by the curators
we used contour detection to segment the already-detected microstructures
the contouring procedure uses POIs to automate the consecutive step
which is to draw the boundaries of the MA islands that contain the POIs indicated by experts
The contouring procedure detects the boundaries based on stark changes in color and intensity
it produces polygons that are much more complex and detailed than expert-annotated polygons
The purpose of applying the contouring procedure in our study is threefold
we aimed at seeing whether there is a pattern that could be captured to train models
We assume that the change of color and intensity comprises useful information regarding the boundaries of MA islands
The comparison of contouring and expert-annotated polygons allows us to evaluate the importance of color and intensity changes in detecting boundaries of MA islands
we aimed at evaluating contouring as a supporting tool for the polygon annotation task
Due to the complexity and abstractness of the MA islands -and potentially many other microstructures that appear in steel-
contour detection methods can assist the annotator by fine-tuning the curvature of the polygon boundary that is indicated by POIs placed by the annotator
An example of a similar usage is the magic wand tool that is available in many image processing software products
contour detection provides a baseline model for segmentation
any machine learning model trained for the segmentation of MA islands must overperform the baseline model in terms of accuracy
we compared the outcome of the baseline contour detection method against the expert-annotated polygons
This may suggest that the change in color and intensity are a part of the decision taken by the experts when drawing the boundaries of MA islands
Even though contour detection may not replace a machine learning segmentation model
it has the potential to ease the polygon annotation task and improve the quality of expert-annotations
Further research is required to improve the annotation procedure as well as to train segmentation models that can detect MA island boundaries accurately
this dataset comprises a rich source for training such machine learning models
The methods to visualize the polygons and points on the images are also provided within the code to allow researchers to visually inspect the geometries on the detected MA islands
two Jupyter Notebooks were provided; one that contains the code that describes the data tables and calculates the morphological feature
and another for contour detection and evaluation of the segmentation model
and a full set of stepwise instructions to replicate the calculations in this study
Carbide-free bainite in medium carbon steel
Structure–properties relationship in TRIP steels containing carbide-free bainite
Bainite in silicon steels: new composition–property approach part 1
The identification of cementite for differentiating between the various types of bainite in modern low-alloyed multi-phase steels; Zementitnachweis zur Unterscheidung von Bainitstufen in modernen
Characterisation and quantification of complex bainitic microstructures in high and ultra-high strength linepipe steels
Mechanical properities of an HSLA bainitic steel subjected to controlled rolling with accelerated cooling
Effect of Molybdenum and Cooling Regime on Microstructural Heterogeneity in Bainitic Steel Wires
Influence of bainite morphology on impact toughness of continuously cooled cementite free bainitic steels
Microstructure of martensite–austenite constituents in heat affected zones of high strength low alloy steel welds in relation to toughness properties
Experimental quantification of carbon gradients in martensite and its multi-scale effects in a DP steel
Quantification of complex-phase steel microstructure by using combined EBSD and EPMA measurements
A Correlative Approach to Capture and Quantify Substructures by Means of Image Registration
Rich Feature Hierarchies for Accurate Object Detection and Semantic Segmentation
In 2014 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition 580–587 (IEEE
In 2016 IEEE Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR) 779–788
Simonyan, K. & Zisserman, A. Very Deep Convolutional Networks for Large-Scale Image Recognition. Preprint at https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.1556 (2015)
Is Faster R-CNN Doing Well for Pedestrian Detection
Search Area Reduction Fast-RCNN for Fast Vehicle Detection in Large Aerial Imagery
In 2018 25th IEEE International Conference on Image Processing (ICIP)
A perspective on the morphology of bainite
Morphology and properties of low-carbon bainite
Influence of carbon concentration and reaction temperature upon bainite morphology in Fe-C-2 Pct Mn alloys
The bainite transformation in a silicon steel
Structural characterization of “carbide-free” bainite in a Fe–0.2 C–1.5 Si–2.5 Mn steel
Preperation of carbide-free bainitic steels for EBSD investigations
Methods to Classify Bainite in Wire Rod Steel
Chemistry and three-dimensional morphology of martensite-austenite constituent in the bainite structure of low-carbon low-alloy steels
The third criterion: Compactness as a procedural safeguard against partisan gerrymandering
Iren, D. et al. Aachen-Heerlen Annotated Steel Microstructure Dataset. figshare https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.c.5185004 (2021)
Butterworth, D. Source code for: Minimum area bounding rectangle. GitHub https://github.com/dbworth/minimum-area-bounding-rectangle (2013)
Advanced Steel Microstructural Classification by Deep Learning Methods
Iren, D. Aachen-Heerlen-Annotated-Steel-Microstructure-Analysis-Code: Nature SciData Release. Zenodo https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.4075550 (2020)
Download references
This research was supported by the Province of Limburg
We acknowledge the support of ArcelorMittal Maizières
for contributing image data of wire rod steel in the framework of the knowledge-building program at ArcelorMittal
we would like to pay our gratitude and our respects to our colleague Dr
Amrapali Zaveri who contributed to the initiation of this research project and passed away in January 2020
Center for Actionable Research of Open Universiteit
Sebastian Wesselmecking & Ulrich Krupp
writing and editing the dataset descriptor
U.K.: Reviewing and editing the manuscript
S.W.: Reviewing and editing the manuscript
The authors declare no competing interests
Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations
The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ applies to the metadata files associated with this article
Reprints and permissions
Download citation
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41597-021-00926-7
Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:
a shareable link is not currently available for this article
Sign up for the Nature Briefing: AI and Robotics newsletter — what matters in AI and robotics research
In the heart of Heerlen, the Netherlands, architectural collective Selvatico transforms a dreary car park rooftop into an urban garden that invites the re-appropriation of the space by local citizens
titled ‘The Countryside’ creates a green recreational area that draws inspiration from the crop patterns that characterize the Dutch countryside
Enhancing local biodiversity and fostering reconnection
small sections of crops and gathering spaces host a curated selection of local plants
creating a green oasis across Heerlen’s roofscape
offering a new perspective on how citizens can contribute to a climate-proof living and working environment
Selvatico transforms car park into urban garden | all images by Giovanni Nardi
Selvatico’s rooftop garden reinterprets an infrastructural necessity into a public amenity that reveals the hidden potential of an urban ecosystem. The Amsterdam-based collective’s design concept brings the crop patterns found in the Dutch countryside into Heerlen’s city center
The 1200 sqm concrete roof is divided into a series of crops
each of which hosts a different type of vegetation
57 varieties of plant species are grown in movable planters made of wooden crates
therein defining a system of social spaces for spontaneous meetings and interactions
‘The Countyside’ also comprises five ‘room’ types — the Wilderness
Edible and Aphrodisiac — each defined by the density
‘We need to create dynamic and resilient landscapes that integrate organised planting patterns with ample space for human and non-human interactions
This transformation will allow us to strengthen and safeguard biodiversity and even more to restore natural habitats
our own roofs offer a great opportunity to take action and start the process of regeneration.’ explain the designers
the intervention is part of SCHUNCK’s Heerlen Rooftop Project to create new urban spaces of connection
the rooftop garden reveals the hidden potential of an urban ecosystem
the composition defines a system of social spaces for spontaneous gathering
57 varieties of plant species are grown in wooden crate planters
Selvatico creates a green oasis across Heerlen’s roofscape
the design concept brings the crop patterns found in the Dutch countryside into Heerlen’s city center
name: The Countryside designer: Selvatico program: Heerlen Rooftop Project
organization: SCHUNCK
designboom has received this project from our ‘DIY submissions’ feature, where we welcome our readers to submit their own work for publication. see more project submissions from our readers here.
AXOR presents three bathroom concepts that are not merely places of function
but destinations in themselves — sanctuaries of style
Metrics details
Hereditary Protein S (PS) deficiency is a rare coagulation disorder associated with an increased risk of venous thrombosis (VT)
The PS Heerlen (PSH) mutation is a rare S501P mutation that was initially considered to be a neutral polymorphism
it has been later shown that PSH has a reduced half-life in vivo which may explain the association of PSH heterozygosity with mildly reduced levels of plasma free PS (FPS)
Whether the risk of VT is increased in PSH carriers remains unknown
We analyzed the association of PSH (rs121918472 A/G) with VT in 4,173 VT patients and 5,970 healthy individuals from four independent case-control studies
Quantitative determination of FPS levels was performed in a subsample of 1257 VT patients
the AG genotype was associated with an increased VT risk of 6.57 [4.06–10.64] (p = 1.73 10−14)
In VT patients in whom PS deficiency was excluded
plasma FPS levels were significantly lower in individuals with PSH when compared to those without [72 + 13 vs 91 + 21 UI/dL; p = 1.86 10−6
mean + SD for PSH carriers (n = 21) or controls (n = 1236) respectively]
We provide strong evidence that the rare PSH variant is associated with VT in unselected individuals
we aimed to systematically determine if there was an association between PS Heerlen and VT by combining four French case-control DNA samples totaling 4,173 patients and 5,970 healthy individuals
Genotype distributions of the rs121918472 variant within the four case-control studies are shown in Table 1
No homozygous carrier of the rare rs121918472-G allele was observed
the AG genotype was more frequent in VT patients than in healthy controls
and was associated with an increased VT risk (Odds Ratio OR) of 6.57 [4.06-10.64] (p = 1.73 10−14)
The association was significantly heterogeneous across studies (p < 10−3) due to strong associations in the EDITH cohort (2.4% vs 0.4%)
the EOVT/MARTHA cohort (2.4% vs 0%) samples
but not in FARIVE study samples (1.1% vs 1.8%)
Note that the observed AG genotype frequency was higher in FARIVE controls with hypertension (2.9%
n = 343) in whom the frequency was similar to the other cohort controls
Excluding the FARIVE study from the combined analysis increased the significance of the association between rs121918472 and VT (OR = 14.58 [7.42–28.65]
We also examined whether the rs121918472-G allele frequency varied in specific VT subgroups
such as in patients with provoked or unprovoked VT
patients with deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism
and patients with F5 or F2 G20210A mutations
We did not observe preferential associations in any specific strata
which is far lower than the gold standard of r2 > 0.8 for imputation quality
and the increased risk associated with the imputed rs121918472-G allele was OR = 1.46 [0.28–7.58]
Because 865 MARTHA/EOVT participants examined in the current study also took part in the INVENT study
we were able to calculate the Spearman correlation between the true rs121918472 genotype as provided by Illumina Exome array results
and the imputed dose-derived from GWAS arrays
The resulting low correlation of ρ = 0.25 illustrated how imputation techniques are not reliable for inferring rare variants such as rs121918472
Free PS plasma levels (IU/dL) in MARTHA cases according to the rs121918472 polymorphism (age and sex adjusted P-value: 1.86 × 10−6)
In the present study we systematically analyzed four French case-control collections totalling 4,173 patients and 5,970 healthy individuals and provide strong evidence that the rare PS Heerlen variant is associated with VT
one might hypothesize that PS Heerlen could affect thrombosis risk by impairing TFPI function
we provide evidence that PS Heerlen is associated with increased VT risk in individuals of the general population
Further investigations are required to better understand the surprisingly high prevalence of PS Heerlen mutation in apparently healthy individuals from the FARIVE study
Functional studies investigating the potential influence of PS Heerlen on VT risk would also be of benefit
These results also raise the question of whether PS Heerlen should always be genotyped irrespective of plasma PS levels in thrombophilia screening
Genetic outlier analysis was performed using IBS statistics and principal component analysis to detect individuals of non-European origin
This led to a selected cohort of 2,630 VT patients and 3,414 controls typed with Illumina exome chips for final association analysis
The overall rs121918472 genotype call rate was 0.98
with 0.97 in the FARIVE and EDITH studies typed with HRM
and 0.99 in individuals typed with the Illumina Human Exome chips
fasting blood was drawn for FPS measurement
Quantitative FPS determination was performed by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) using the Asserachrom FPS assay (Diagnostica Stago)
PS deficiency was defined as FPS plasma antigen levels <55 IU/dL−1 using the specific ELISA assay
FPS data were available in 1,257 MARTHA individuals
Genotype distribution of the rs121918472 was tested for deviation from Hardy-Weinberg (HW) equilibrium via the HW exact test
Association of rs121918472 with VT was analyzed via the Cochran-Armitage trend test and by logistic regression analysis adjusting for age and sex
Association of rs121918472 with FPS was assessed using linear regression analysis
Analyses were first performed separately in each study
and were then performed on all samples combined and further adjusted for the study group
Informed consent was obtained from all participants
and the study met all institutional ethics requirement
The procedures employed were reviewed and approved by the Assistance Publique des Hopitaux de Marseille institutional review committee
Protein S Heerlen mutation heterozygosity is associated with venous thrombosis risk
Publisher's note: Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations
Re-evaluation of the role of the protein S-C4b binding protein complex in activated protein C-catalyzed factor Va-inactivation
C4b-binding protein: a forgotten factor in thrombosis and hemostasis
Protein S stimulates inhibition of the tissue factor pathway by tissue factor pathway inhibitor
Plasma protein S deficiency in familial thrombotic disease
an immunologic polymorphism due to dimorphism of residue 460
In vivo clearance of human protein S in a mouse model: influence of C4b-binding protein and the Heerlen polymorphism
The Ser 460 to Pro substitution of the protein S alpha (PROS1) gene is a frequent mutation associated with free protein S (type IIa) deficiency
Protein S inherited qualitative deficiency: novel mutations and phenotypic influence
Deficient APC-cofactor activity of protein S Heerlen in degradation of factor Va Leiden: a possible mechanism of synergism between thrombophilic risk factors
Meta-analysis of 65,734 individuals identifies TSPAN15 and SLC44A2 as two susceptibility loci for venous thromboembolism
Genome-wide association analysis of self-reported events in 6135 individuals and 252 827 controls identifies 8 loci associated with thrombosis
Heerlen polymorphism associated with type III protein S deficiency and factor V Leiden mutation in a Polish patient with deep vein thrombosis
Protein S levels and the risk of venous thrombosis: results from the MEGA case-control study
The Ser460Pro mutation in recombinant protein S Heerlen does not affect its APC-cofactor and APC-independent anticoagulant activities
TFPI cofactor function of protein S: essential role of the protein S SHBG-like domain
Finding the missing heritability of complex diseases
Rare and low-frequency variants and their association with plasma levels of fibrinogen
Contribution of Rare and Common Genetic Variants to Plasma Lipid Levels and Carotid Stiffness and Geometry: A Substudy of the Paris Prospective Study 3
PLINK: a tool set for whole-genome association and population-based linkage analyses
Download references
We are grateful to Rachel Peat for English editing and grammatical corrections
This research was partially supported by the GENMED Laboratory of Excellence on Medical Genomics (ANR-10-LABX-0013)
the French Clinical Research Infrastructure Network on Venous Thrombo-Embolism (F-CRIN INNOVTE) and the ICAN Institute for Cardiometabolism and Nutrition (ANR-10-IAHU-05)
three research programs managed by the National Research Agency (ANR) as part of the French Investment for the Future initiative
Trégouët: These authors contributed equally to this work
Institut National pour la Santé et la Recherche Médicale (INSERM)
Unité Mixte de Recherche en Santé(UMR_S) 1062
Team Genomics & Pathophysiology of Cardiovascular Diseases
ICAN Institute for Cardiometabolism and Nutrition
were in charge of statistical data analysis
designed the participating studies and the overall project
drafted the manuscript that was further revised by A.D.
The authors declare no competing financial interests
Download citation
Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.
Sign up for the Nature Briefing newsletter — what matters in science, free to your inbox daily.
Volume 11 - 2023 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2023.1242151
This article is part of the Research TopicLiving Labs and Open Innovation approaches to scale impact for human wellbeingView all 12 articles
Cities are championing urban experiments in order to address societal challenges and increased urban complexity
urban experiments are used as a method in a broader trend in public policy to align urban planning with citizen needs by viewing cities as platforms for societal transformation that require
we demonstrate the impacts of placemaking and Urban Living Labs not only for healthy environments but also in facilitating transdisciplinary learning
we elaborate on the Aurora transformation process in the neighborhood GMS in Heerlen-North as being one of the 16 Dutch neighborhoods that need extra attention to its socio-urban challenges due to the historical context and consequent local development
providing two main results for ULLs as infrastructure for innovation for community wellbeing
as an alternative spatial planning approach for urban contexts with extreme social-urban conditions that draw on the multitude of local values to generate and accelerate urban transformations going beyond the traditional impacts of urban transformations including public health equity
and addressing social-economic determinants of community wellbeing
as an infrastructure for education innovation encompassing and operationalising social learning theory
it addresses societal issues in these neighborhoods
or democratic decision-making more appropriately and enhances student
learning through transdisciplinary collaboration among those involved and by connecting education
We conclude the article by emphasizing its novelty
Contemporary cities are going through an intense transformation phase driven by increasing urban complexity and grand societal challenges. Hence, there is a growing trend in public policy to align urban developments to citizens' needs by viewing cities as platforms for societal transformation toward addressing issues such as inclusion, equity, and human development opportunities [see, e.g., (1, 2)]
we will focus on the articulation of the innovation and added value of both placemaking and the ULL set-up to demonstrate the impacts of such approaches not only for vital
and inclusive environments but also in facilitating a transdisciplinary learning environment for students
and other urban stakeholders with a focus on social learning theory
there are diverse concentrations and clusters of multiple urban challenges
One of them is the Aurora apartment building
a social housing unit of over 200 dwellings housing a community from over 60 nationalities
The housing block has been renovated recently and painted with the largest artistic mural in Europe
This development aligns with national targets for housing associations to upgrade their housing stock energy efficiency wise as well as the present development perspective of the municipality to enhance the quality of the urban environment by emphasizing culture and arts
while in parallel enhancing its local identity in link to its distinctive local qualities and historical context
amidst the challenges faced by neighborhoods like GMS
understand and examine the interplay between
urban development approaches and strategies and
public health equity and community wellbeing to improve both the quality of the built environment and the social-health fabric of these neighborhoods
we asked ourselves the following research question:
“How can Urban Living Labs as an (urban) innovation and learning infrastructure contribute to vital
healthy and inclusive neighborhoods by physical and socio-spatial interventions in neighborhoods like GMS in Heerlen-North?”
For illustration purposes, Figures 1–3 show the location and its context
Aurora apartment building before painting and renovation (Source: Boa Mistura)
Aurora apartment building after painting and renovation (Source: Boa Mistura)
Aurora apartment building and GMS neighborhood incl
the Maankwartier station area (Source: Boa Mistura)
Recently, Horstman and Knibbe (9) have shown that the healthy city concept is about public space
“The living environment of people with low incomes often contains more health threats than the public space of high income groups' [p. (21); own translation]
or fewer social encounter opportunities to support their claim
three perspectives on the built environment and the healthy city arise:
1. Public space for social interactions in the built environment. Here, the concept of “public familiarity” (21) is important as it emphasizes that social interactions increase feelings of safety and familiarity consequently leading to less social isolation in cities (22)
3. Social mixing in the built environment. Here, it is proposed that mixing certain socio-economic inhabitant groups automatically leads to more physical quality of the living environment, more social cohesion and increased social capital. However, research has shown the opposite of homogenous neighborhoods (25) and that social mixing assumptions pay too little attention to the historical context of places and the aspirations of community members (26)
not only reshapes the physical environment but also reimagines the social fabric of these neighborhoods
ULLs advance place understanding and placemaking through a process of collaboration and interactive learning among local stakeholders
research in the public health domain has repeatedly shown the importance of
social interactions and community engagement to address health disparities rooted in the (re-)production of the built environment
examining how ULLs can function as innovation infrastructure by providing a social learning arena is essential in the pursuit of community wellbeing impacts in neighborhoods
Against this background on the need for innovation actions on a local scale
while having sustainability challenges on a higher scale
it is important (if not a necessity) to develop the needed and appropriate knowledge
and expertise to achieve the required innovation actions to govern those changes and achievements
The social learning theory encompasses four elements arguing that engagement with social issues is fundamental to how learning takes place and how people become who they are (38)
Drawing on these four elements enhances student learning impacts as it intertwines personal and professional development with locally relevant societal issues
It also provides possibilities for transversal (students from different years in one discipline) and multi-level (vocational
and master) collaboration and learning in addition to multidisciplinary perspectives
Learning as belonging: Students are part of the ULL community; they learn within and with the local stakeholders and community actors
engagement in and understanding of actual societal challenges can lead to the development of relevant knowledge
Learning as becoming: Students collaborate with the ULL community to develop their own work identity relative to other disciplines
professionals develop a broader understanding and knowledge base of the complexity and interconnectedness of actual urban questions
Learning as experience: Students learn by working on real-life societal issues in a local context
makes learning and working meaningful for students
This will help to bridge the gap between abstract concepts and context-specific questions and needs
Learning as doing: Students learn to take initiative and responsibility regarding societal issues and the ULL community to gain knowledge and skills and reflect on their own as well as other disciplines
and monitoring of certain interventions on the local scale bridges the gap between diverse scales that students work on
From neighborhood to building or product scale
resulting in more interrelated hands-on knowledge development
The Aurora apartment building area has gone through a process of transformation since the coal mine closure that left a strong stigma on the building and the inhabitants
being a residence and area for mainly underprivileged communities and a place for drugs and prostitution
Many efforts and projects have been implemented in the past 10 years to transform the place and bring better life quality and imago by the housing association Wonen Limburg
Within this context of ongoing transformation
it was an important step to work on the development of the courtyard of the Aurora apartment building to enhance the sense of community and the creation of a social place that is safe
The Aurora apartment building courtyard is a parking lot for the tenants of the social housing association
the parking lot is only rented out for two-thirds of its capacity and the residents experience the courtyard as a site for illegal activities (ranging from illegal parking to drug usage)
and as a non-inviting stressing environment (i.e
not climate resilient and physically closed)
Wonen Limburg and the research center Smart Urban Redesign (SURD) developed a co-creation process to identify residential needs and wishes for the Aurora apartment building courtyard to transform it into a climate-resilient
and community place that supports the residents in their daily life activities; a place where sense of community and collective identity can flourish
urban vitality and social cohesion as impacts
In this process, both learning together and making together as part of co-creation (17) are outlined in the Aurora Days and Aurora Challenge, respectively. Both worked toward the Spektakeldag festival on 4 June 2022 in which the housing association opened the largest mural of Europe festively (postponed earlier due to COVID19 measurements). In Figure 4
Aurora apartment building intervention co-creation process (Source: SURD)
The Aurora Days included an informal pizza session
These served (1) to get to know the inhabitants and for them to get familiar with the SURD students and staff
(2) to gain insights into eight different locations around the area that concerns
the community and that were emphasized by the community members in conversations during the pizza session
and (3) to enhance place understanding of the direct context around Aurora with urban experiences from the community members
In the photo group discussions and Walk and Talk sessions
in-between result posters were hung up at all four the entrances of Aurora apartment building to allow for adjustments
The Aurora Days were coordinated by a Built Environment and an Occupational Therapy intern duo at SURD and were supported and facilitated by researchers
The Aurora Challenge was a multidisciplinary
and multi-level design challenge held in the Aurora apartment building
The Aurora Challenge took place in the week of 25 April 2022 to 29 April 2022
Four international and interdisciplinary student groups worked for 1 week non-stop on the design challenge to translate the collected insights from the Aurora Days into an urban design intervention
The students ranged from first-year BSc students to second-year MSc students and came from the Netherlands
The Aurora Challenge led to a winning design
and local stakeholders that was showcased at the Spektakeldag festival on June 4th in 2022
the involved stakeholders have been working toward the implementation of the winning design scenario
an active experimentation of the winning design elements on
and based on the monitoring impacts after the Spektakeldag festival
the actual intervention implementation in the Aurora courtyard
The Spektakeldag active experimentation June 2022 (Source: SURD)
the impacts and use of the circular products have been monitored by a MSc
Architecture intern at SURD who lives in the Aurora apartment building
and type of activity that took place around the circular furniture as well as if citizens used the circular furniture in “unexpected ways.” To illustrate
it was observed that some children were climbing on the circular furniture that was otherwise assumed not being outside at all
and social activities and interactions between children and their parents
The Aurora apartment building courtyard in March 2022 (Source: SURD)
The intervention implementation result April 2023 (Source: SURD)
The intervention implementation impacts April 2023 (Source: SURD)
As explained earlier, the social learning theory encompasses four elements arguing that engagement with social issues is fundamental to how learning takes place and how people become who they are (38)
It should be noted that in practice the four elements are intertwined and reinforce each other
the four elements are exemplified with a couple of examples from our experiences
Learning as belonging: students are part of the ULL community; they learn within and with the local stakeholders and community actors
As the Aurora apartment building process has been ongoing for almost 2 years now
and citizens are taking ownership of the ULL
third-year students who engaged themselves in the Aurora Challenge are actively asking partners like the housing association for internship positions or the SURD for graduation research positions in the current 4th year of their study
citizens who co-hosted our photo group discussions during the Aurora Days are now actively supporting teachers in student assignment presentations to elaborate upon the historical context of the area
the intern who lives in the Aurora apartment building is an actual part of the community and therefore a continuous presence both from the University of Applied Science—formal and personal—informal perspective
a specific example of a spatial planning student is mentioned worthy to explain
The student participated in the Aurora Challenge while being on internship at a private project developer
While working on the Aurora Challenge and currently doing her graduation research at SURD
she developed herself as an architectural activist against hostile architectural practices by the municipality that forbid certain activities for citizens in public spaces
Her experiences in the ULL community made her aware of what she stands for and wants to stand for as a professional in the built environment discipline relative to other disciplines like health or nature; not as a private developer focusing on financial profit
but as a local activist ambitioning community wellbeing for citizens in their own living environment
the actual change achieved exemplifies this element
Students reported that they experience the ULL community and its focus and activities as extremely motivating and valuable due to the fact that they see the concrete change and improvement from their efforts for the local community and their wellbeing
In contrast to traditional classroom teaching
the student learning curve is enhanced by working across various disciplines
transversal educational institutes as well as actors covering the quadruple helix model and multiple development phases
The process also allows students to change roles with other students
When students are engaged long enough in the process
they gain experience that allows them to be coach and guide other newly involved students in group assignments
the interplay between student and coach roles is an important professionalization experience
Similar impacts are observed among other stakeholders
Social Learning in practice (Source: SURD)
we want to highlight the novelty of our study in two ways
which seems so necessary and promising for today's sustainability transitions and challenges on local and global scales
the ULL functions as an alternative spatial planning and urban innovation approach to governing local neighborhood development in and for collective learning about a context of extreme urban and social conditions
ULLs do so due to their potential and ability to bridge a multitude of perspectives and disciplines as well as go beyond particular and traditional development phases only by the creation of a flexible process that is open for continuous evaluation
It has proven to function as a kind of platform that is able to respond to short-term urgent needs
providing design scenarios and imaginative references for long-term development prospects
it functions as an instrument to outline and accelerate placemaking processes and urban interventions that go beyond the design phases of urban development and explicitly experiment in practice by drawing upon local urban complexities for value creation
community wellbeing as aspired by the local community
The co-creation process and the urban intervention have positively impacted the community wellbeing
and others have been actively engaged in the transformation process leading to a stronger sense of community
we observe and notice increased levels of trust between stakeholders and ownership toward local issues and challenges
we argue that the explicit combination of placemaking and ULLs puts the potentials of placemaking
into practice and beyond project-based operations
driving the pursuit of public health equity and community wellbeing impacts in neighborhoods
We elaborate upon two main points for our discussion
we notice that literature in itself from Placemaking
ULLs and the Healthy City often refers to outcome indicators to focus on rather than process indicators that are important to create those wished-for outcomes
we question whether the impacts of placemaking practices and ULLs from a public health domain perspective can rather be assessed and evaluated by outcomes or process indicators
especially when drawing upon the local community and unique local values as a main driver of the activities and knowledge generation
instead of political or policy motivations
in practice and from social learning theory and our experiences so far
it remains unclear on an operational level how to organize and facilitate this meta-learning
we emphasize in an enumerative manner the implications for theory
Our experiences show three implications for theory:
and adjusted more intensively in practice to help stakeholders on a local scale
Our experiences show two implications for policy:
6] argues that “a university living lab governance framework is needed to generate a culture of collaboration across research
without stifling emergence and innovation.” While the authors provide recommendations like flexible coordination or relationship building between silos within the university that we acknowledge as well based on our experiences
we also add to this that there is a need to redefine the role of knowledge institutes in today's society
the funding system of education (and research) in the Netherlands is currently based on quantitative measures
we do argue that qualitative measurements that are aligned with societal challenges and needs are required in order to guarantee quality education and research to address societal challenges and educate location-aware global citizens
Our experiences show four concrete implications for practice:
Community engagement: Practitioners in urban planning should prioritize community engagement and co-creation processes
Placemaking and ULLs demonstrate that involving local residents
and implementation of urban interventions can lead to more holistic and sustainable outcomes
Transdisciplinary collaboration: Practitioners should foster transdisciplinary collaboration among students
and community members as this enables a more comprehensive place understanding of complex urban and societal challenges with responsive solutions
Experiential learning: Educational institutions and practitioners should promote the inclusion of Social Learning dimensions
and researchers to actively participate in addressing local experienced societal issues within their contexts and domains
it helps to bridge the gap between scientific and theoretical knowledge with practical application
Tailored solutions: Urban planning practitioners should tailor solutions to the specific needs and characteristics of the place that they will intervene in
Recognizing the uniqueness of places and their communities and involving them in the decision-making process can lead to more aspired and effective interventions
Our experiences call for further research along the following lines:
1. First, and process-wise, more experiences and insights are needed into the diverse roles that stakeholders can or must play based on the activity and phase in the ULL. In particular, when engaging multiple disciplines and education. For example, Vinke-de Kruijf et al. (48) provide a robust review of research roles in transdisciplinary projects
we observe and experience fluid roles during the process of urban interventions in ULLs that should be better understood to enhance effectiveness
and comprehensive monitoring and evaluation activities in ULLs
Our experiences made clear that impacts go beyond what individuals and stakeholders imagined and expected
We argue it is important to understand the full impacts of ULLs to better understand their innovation potentials
we not only call ULL practitioners to focus on development activities but also more on impact monitoring and evaluation activities; both formally and informally as well as on the short term and the long term
Examples may be learning aspects or the maturity level of ULLs for impact creation
we call for more research in the urban planning and health domains to their interconnectedness
especially toward institutional causalities of public health equity in various geographical areas
While our experiences show and emphasize the importance of ULLs to the quality of the built environment in relation to health impacts (and other domains) on the local scale
it focuses on addressing observed societal issues; not the causalities of the societal issues in the first place
we argue that understanding the institutional arrangement through which health as a discipline on the one hand and urban planning as a discipline on the other influence each other mutually
It is crucial to understand these legal institutional causalities if ULLs as innovation infrastructures indeed want to scale up impacts for community wellbeing beyond the local scale and beyond the solution-focussed perspective
The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be made available by the authors
Written informed consent was obtained from the individual(s) for the publication of any potentially identifiable images or data included in this article
SB contributed to the theoretical and practical conception and design of the study
NA and HS contributed to the theoretical and practical conception and design of the study
All authors contributed to the article and approved the submitted version
This research is based on diverse research projects and funds; the ELSA Lab Poverty and Debt funded by the Dutch Ministry of Internal Affairs and Kingdom Relations
and the City Deal Kennis Maken programme funded by the Dutch Ministry of Science
The authors would like to acknowledge that this article is based on the work of several years in Heerlen and with the team of Smart Urban Redesign Research Center
and Anne van Dun and all the students who participated in the activities
this paper is based on two previous versions presented at the Open Living Lab Days 2022 Conference Proceedings (section on top contributions) and the Repurposing Places for Social and Environmental Resilience 2023 Conference Proceedings (section on Educational Projects)
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations
Any product that may be evaluated in this article
or claim that may be made by its manufacturer
is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher
Actor roles in an urban living lab: What can we learn from Suurpelto
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
City labs as vehicles for innovation in urban planning processes
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Transformative thinking and urban living labs in planning practice: a critical review and ongoing case studies in Europe
Google Scholar
The Ecology of Human Development: Experiments by Nature and Design
Google Scholar
Policies and Strategies to Promote Social Equity in Health
Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office for Europe (2006)
Google Scholar
An ecological approach to creating active living communities
doi: 10.1146/annurev.publhealth.27.021405.102100
8. Dutch Ministry of Internal Affairs and Kingdom Relations. Overzicht 16 Stedelijke Vernieuwingsgebieden. (2020). Available online at: https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/documenten/publicaties/2020/03/31/overzicht-16-stedelijke-vernieuwingsgebieden (accessed March 31
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
10. Stadszaken. Ron Meyer Over Heerlen Noord: ‘We zijn een Nationaal Programma Zonder Nationaal Budget. (2022). Available online at: https://stadszaken.nl/artikel/4602/ron-meyer-over-heerlen-noord-we-zijn-een-nationaal-programma-zonder-nationaal-budget (accessed September 21
Google Scholar
11. Haker F,., Hosper K, van Loenen T. Gezondheidsverschillen Duurzaam Aanpakken. (2019). Available online at: https://www.pharos.nl/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Gezondheidsverschillen-duurzaam-aanpakken_Pharos_mei-2019.pdf (accessed September 5
Google Scholar
Planning from failure: Transforming a waterfront through experimentation in a placemaking living lab
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
13. Wyckoff A. Definition of place making: four different types. Plann Zoning News. (2014) 32:1. Available online at: https://www.canr.msu.edu/uploads/375/65824/4typesplacemaking_pzn_wyckoff_january2014.pdf
Google Scholar
Toward a theoretical understanding of placemaking
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
The everyday political economy of “making place.” Planning Theor Prac
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Living Lab: user driven innovation for sustainability
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Urban experimentation and institutional arrangements
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
“The Urban Living Lab as tool for introducing circularity in the everyday life of vulnerable neighbourhoods: case study Kerkrade-West
the Netherlands,” in Digital Living Lab Days Conference
European Network of Living Labs (ENoLL) (2021)
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
21. Blokland T. Het belang van publieke familiariteit in de openbare ruimte. Beleid en Maatschappij. (2019) 36:183–91. Available online at: https://research.tudelft.nl/en/publications/het-belang-van-publieke-familiariteit-in-de-openbare-ruimte
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
and the uneven development of urban public space
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Revisiting the end of public space: assembling the public in an urban park
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
social mix and urban policies in the Netherlands
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Evidence suggests a need to rethink social capital and social capital interventions
Challenges in the acceleration of sustainability transitions
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Urban living labs: governing urban sustainability transitions
Infrastructure for sustainable development
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Urban living labs and transformative changes: a qualitative study of the triadic relationship between financing
and the outcomes of urban living labs in terms of impact creation in the city of Groningen
Urban Living Labs: Experimenting With City Futures
Google Scholar
Towards a learning system for university campuses as living labs for sustainability
Univ Living Labs Sust Dev Support Implem Goals
A closer look at living labs and higher education using a scoping review
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
transgressive social learning: rethinking higher education pedagogy in times of systemic global dysfunction
Universities as the engine of transformational sustainability toward delivering the sustainable development goals
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Beyond the third mission: exploring the emerging university function of co-creation for sustainability
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Google Scholar
39. West C, Böttger B, Tang WS. Experiment. In: Philipp T, Schmohl T, , editors. Handbook Transdisciplinary Learning (2023). p. 133–143. Available online at: https://www.transcript-verlag.de/978-3-8376-6347-1/handbook-transdisciplinary-learning/?number=978-3-8376-6347-1
Google Scholar
40. Barth P, Pfister J. Critical thinking. In: Philipp T, Schmohl T, , editors. Handbook Transdisciplinary Learning (2023). p. 63–71. Available online at: https://www.transcript-verlag.de/978-3-8376-6347-1/handbook-transdisciplinary-learning/?number=978-3-8376-6347-1
Google Scholar
Public Space Site-Specific Assessment: Guidelines to achieve Quality Public Spaces at Neighbourhood Level
Public Space Site-Specific Assessment: Guidelines to Achieve Quality Public Spaces at Neighbourhood Level
Google Scholar
Enhancing the contribution of urban living labs to sustainability transformations: towards a meta-lab approach
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Bridging the Gap Between Open and User Innovation?: Exploring the Value of Living Labs as a Means to Structure User Contribution and Manage Distributed Innovation (Doctoral dissertation)
Google Scholar
Co-creation in urban governance: from inclusion to innovation
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Urban experimentation as a politics of niches
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Governing University Living Labs for Sustainable Development: Lessons from International Case Studies
Google Scholar
Knowledge co-production and researcher roles in transdisciplinary environmental management projects
Abujidi N and Sap H (2024) Urban living labs as innovation infrastructure for local urban intervention acceleration and student social learning: the impacts on community wellbeing in Heerlen
Received: 18 June 2023; Accepted: 27 November 2023; Published: 05 January 2024
Copyright © 2024 Blezer, Abujidi and Sap. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY)
distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted
provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited
in accordance with accepted academic practice
distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms
*Correspondence: Stefano Blezer, U3RlZmFuby5ibGV6ZXJAenV5ZC5ubA==
Disclaimer: All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations
Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher
94% of researchers rate our articles as excellent or goodLearn more about the work of our research integrity team to safeguard the quality of each article we publish