ZEELAND — Zeeland's longtime plan to improve Hoogland Park will soon accept bids
Hoogland Park is located near the cemetery at the corner of Rich Street and Peck Street
The plan includes the use of adjacent property at 370 E
Councilmembers approved a bid to demolish a home on the property in 2020
The city was unsuccessful in securing a Passport Grant through the Michigan Department of Natural Resources
but a portion of funds was allocated in June to cover the cost of revamping Hoogland Park
During a meeting of Zeeland City Council on Monday, Nov. 4, $109,526 was approved for a construction administration contract with MCSA Group, which will convert the schematic design into construction documents to be put up for bid
The city plans to select a bid by March and complete construction by next fall
“The plan looks great,” said Mayor Kevin Klynstra
“It will be nice to get the property at 370 E
staff will continue to work with the Zeeland Cemetery and Parks Commission to nail down details
— Cassidey Kavathas is the politics and court reporter at The Holland Sentinel
Contact her at ckavathas@hollandsentinel.com
Prepare to be in stitches as Dual Piano returns to the Hoogland Center for the Arts August 8th-10th
The Hoogland Center for the Arts is excited to welcome Dual Piano back for another great summer concert
Damien and Mark will work their magic on the music as only they can do
a couple of grand pianos and a couple of hours of delight - that's Dual Piano
Comedy runs amuck throughout their programs
and no one knows what is going to happen next – including Mark and Damien
The ghosts of such past entertainers as Victor Borge
Liberace and Ferrante & Teicher can be felt rampaging through the hall when Mark and Damien are at the keyboards
gain access to exclusive promotions and contests
and discover even more reasons to #EnjoyIllinois
The Official Website of the Illinois Office of Tourism
Randy Eccles: This is Community Voices on 91.9 UIS
I'm really looking forward to the concert in Springfield
Randy Eccles: You've been here in Springfield before
it was “The Lincolns of Springfield.” This wonderful show that Terry Cranert and his wife
produced and wrote about the life of our illustrious president
The people of Springfield are so warm and loving and embraced us
Randy Eccles: I'm hopeful that anybody who saw that understands that you're going to be here again and have a chance to see you
Michal Connor Dawson: I'm going to be singing music
I've spent the bulk of my life arranging these songs
You'd get the melody because they were all done a cappella
Because the workers were out in the fields
but I've woven in different hymn tunes or popular songs of the time or musical things that make your ears prick up and say
Randy Eccles: This performance is called Echoes of the Spirit
These songs were definitely born of the spirit and the heart
It was a difficult time in the life of our country
Straight from the mouth of someone who'd actually been there
but she was sowing these seeds in my brain and in my heart so that one day when I was a much older man
I could sing these songs to a wider audience
These are in their crude way because my ancestors were illiterate
Because it was illegal to teach a Black person at the time to read or write
imprisoned if you taught a Black person to read or write
and ultimately leaving behind these beautiful songs that I'm proud to sing now
as you were saying with your great grandmother
there was so much lost because people weren't able to write it down
If it hadn't been for enterprising white people in the end of the 1700s
they would go along and collect these songs and preserve them
Lucy McKim Garrison." It's a wonderful book
This is hailed as one of the very first original collections of African American spirituals
No other race has a group of songs called spirituals
Randy Eccles: Earlier you were saying an emancipated slave
or an emancipated person might write back to their plantation
Why would they write back to somebody who had enslaved them
Michal Connor Dawson: Do you mind if I share one of these letters with you
Michal Connor Dawson: Talk about catharsis
They would write because they were all family together
even though they were mistreated and abused
This letter is from Hannah Grover to her son Cato
I pray you to come and see your dear old mother or send me $20 and I will come and see you in Philadelphia
And if you can't come to see your old mother
My master will free me if anybody will pay enough for me
"If you'd only treated me like a human being
All I asked for was a little bit of kindness." It's really heart breaking to hear
but there were the majority who didn't get free
Randy Eccles: The tragedy of family separation is well illustrated by that letter and I'm sure by so many others
The thing that brings me back time and time again
thinking about these people who have my blood
is they were able to make lemonade out of lemons in the best way possible
that's what draws me to them — their timelessness
Randy Eccles: What would the public recognize from any of these spirituals
but they know their neighbor will hit them
Randy Eccles: Is that something they'll be able to hear at the Hoogland
I'm thrilled to be in this town that I love
I sense the place is thick with beautiful spirits wandering the streets
The place has not been changed in a long time and there's these old buildings
it's called Bind Up the Nation's Wounds in The Lincolns of Springfield
I told my friends this and they laughed at me
so they could hear what one of their own was doing
It's a song about opening our hearts and binding up the wounds that have plagued this nation from the beginning
The divisions of racial separation and hatred
and it's just thrilling for me to have these songs inculcated in my soul
Randy Eccles: If somebody would like to hear your music before the event
Michal Connor Dawson: it's on Spotify. It's on Apple music. It's on my website, which is MichalDawsonConnor. com. And I have a fair number of pieces on there
One of my favorite songs is Nobody Knows the Trouble I've Seen
(sings acapella) "Nobody knows the trouble I've seen
Randy Eccles: It's impressive to hear you sing it
Michal Connor Dawson: I know you didn't ask me to sing
Randy Eccles: Anybody else who has the opportunity to hear you and get to see you in person on Friday
Michal Connor Dawson: One of the greatest spirituals that exists is He's Got the Whole World in his Hands
and I will ask the audience to sing it with me
Please come out and support this incredible theater complex
Gus Gordon has done a remarkable job bringing live theater and music to the world
Randy Eccles: A little bit more on your background
it looks like you spent some time everywhere
and I just got through a very difficult event
Michal Connor Dawson: They singed the back part of my house
but there's great guilt with my house surviving when so many didn't
and I did some solo concerts all over small towns in Germany
I've had four trips there with the Roger Wagner Chorale
Randy Eccles: You've performed on Broadway several times too
That's one of the songs that's near and dear to my heart
Randy Eccles: We look forward to seeing you back in Springfield
Thanks for spending some time with us today on Community Voices
We'll look forward to seeing you on Friday
We have the address for the funeral home & the family on file
If you're not happy with your card we'll send a replacement or refund your money
Hoogland created this Life Tributes page to make it easy to share your memories
© 2025 Langeland-Sterenberg Yntema Funeral Homes
Made with love by funeralOne
Please select what you would like included for printing:
Copy the text below and then paste that into your favorite email application
at Royale Meadows Care Center in Sioux Center
the daughter of Richard and Sarah (DeVries) Hulstein
She graduated from Plato #5 country school
1946 she married Alfred at her family’s farm in Carmel
She had been a resident of Royale Meadows Care Center of Sioux Center
Ethel and Alfred were looking forward to their 70th wedding anniversary in June
She was involved in Trash for Cash and Ladies Bible Study with the church
Survivors include: her husband of nearly 70 years
IA,Grandchildren;Leonard's Children: Tanya (Matt) Eaton of N
Kayla (Matt) Blessinger and their children Mitchell and Lila of CO
Roger's Children: Jason (Shelly) Luckel and their children Alexis
Bradley (Stephanie) Hoogland and their daughter Paisley of CO
Stan's Children: Darren (Deb) Hoogland of IA
KayLynn (Elmer) Rolfes and their son Carson of IA
Morgan Hoogland of Iowa.She was also survived by many nieces and nephews
She was preceded by: her parents; one brother
two grandchildren; Shelly and Nathan Hoogland
In lieu of flowers the Hoogland family requests to direct memorial donations to Hospers First Christian Reformed Church or Royale Meadows Care Center
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply
Service map data © OpenStreetMap contributors
and support for a vital cause is coming to downtown Springfield
The Children’s Advocacy Center of Illinois (CACI) is proud to present “That’s What She Said”
a live storytelling event happening at the Hoogland Center for the Arts
known for spotlighting the voices of local women through powerful
will take the stage with a lineup of inspiring speakers from the community
But this event is about more than just stories — it’s about purpose
and advocacy for children who have experienced abuse throughout the state
guests are helping ensure that young survivors across Illinois continue to receive the compassionate care they deserve
“This event gives women a platform to share their truth — and allows the audience to connect in a really human
often emotional way,” said Liz Brown-Reeves
and it supports a mission that touches so many lives.”
“That’s What She Said” is part of a growing national movement that amplifies real women's voices in local communities
and deeply personal — from humor to heartbreak and everything in between
The event will be held at the Hoogland Center for the Arts in Springfield
bringing together community members for a night that is as meaningful as it is memorable
visit www.childrensadvocacycentersofillinois.com or www.hcfta.org
HOLLAND — Zeeland’s longest serving mayor
He was a councilman for eight years prior to being elected mayor
Mayor Kevin Klynstra said what stood out most about Hoogland was his passion for the city
“He loved this city more than anyone I’ve ever met,” Klynstra said
“He dedicated his life to serving our community.”
Hoogland led growth and development with policy changes and local incentives that aided in the recruitment and retention of some of Zeeland’s largest industrial businesses
He also worked toward the preservation of downtown
and helped launch the campaign "Feel the Zeel" in 2007
said he was ready to continue his service to the city
I enjoy the job and I think I work well with (City Manager) Tim (Klunder),” Hoogland said
“There are some things yet I’d still like to complete
More: After nearly eight decades, Zeeland mayor not slowing down
Hoogland was known for his fundraising expertise
which resulted in the creation of the Howard Miller Library and Community Center
He helped raise funds for the Zeeland Historical Society
Netherlands American Foundation and Zeeland Community Hospital
Subscribe: Get all your breaking news and unlimited access to our local coverage
Klynstra has ordered city flags be flown at half-staff from Monday
Hoogland will be laid to rest with military honors at the Zeeland Cemetery on Lincoln Avenue on Aug
The city’s police and fire departments will honor Hoogland with a casket watch and will lead the procession from the memorial service to the cemetery
For more information, visit langelandsterenberg.com/obituaries
— Contact reporter Austin Metz at ametz@hollandsentinel.com
Enter your phone number above to have directions sent via text
ZEELAND — A sizable reconstruction at Hoogland Park is slated to begin in May
after Zeeland City Council approved a bid of $1.185 million during a meeting Monday
“It will be nice to see that when it’s done,” said Councilmember Jim Broersma
The completed project will include a new restroom building
According to a rendering previously shared with council
a bocce ball court and a natural playscape
The bid was significantly lower than the estimated project cost of $1.7 million
The project budget is $1.413 million in total
More: Hoogland Park will see long-awaited $1.7M facelift in 2025
Similarly, the city has been working on refreshing Heritage Square for renaming, with a proposed title of Hoogland Plaza in memory of Former Mayor Les Hoogland, who died in 2024
estimated around $20,000 for landscaping and plaque placement
Harrie Lavreysen and Jeffrey Hoogland cross the finish line and set the new world record during the men’s team sprint event
Harrie Lavreysen of Netherlands celebrates after setting the new world record in the men’s team sprint event
Conor Leahy and Kelland O’Brien compete on their way to set the world record
Oliver Wood of Britain prepares to compete in the men’s team pursuit event
Thomas Denis of France and Valentin Tabellion of France compete during the men’s team pursuit event
Chloe Moran and Maeve Plouffe compete during the women’s team pursuit event
Charlie Tanfield and Ethan Vernon compete during the men’s team pursuit event
congratulate each other after competing in the men’s team pursuit event
Tsuyaka Uchino of Japan adjusts her helmet before competing in the women’s team pursuit event
Matthew Glaetzer of Australia competes during the men’s team sprint event
Chloe Dygert and Kristen Faulkner compete during the women’s team pursuit event
Anna Morris and Jessica Roberts compete during the women’s team pursuit event
Qi Liu of China competes during the men’s team sprint event
Lisa Klein and Mieke Kroeger start the women’s team pursuit event
France (AP) — Harrie Lavreysen figured that on a searing fast track in the velodrome outside of Paris
and going against the erstwhile sprinting kings from Britain
that his trio from the Netherlands would have to set a world record to defend their Olympic gold medal
“Of course we were going for the gold medal
The Dutch had a big lead in the three-lap race when Van den Berg swung off the front after Lap 1
Hoogland was left to sprint to the finish with no pressure at all
The time of 40.949 seconds beat Britain by nearly a full second
and the mark of 41.191 they set in their heat against Canada
“and then going under 41 seconds is amazing.”
The Netherlands knocked off its own Olympic record in qualifying Monday night
then lowered the world mark it set during its triumph at the Tokyo Olympics in the heats
Lavreysen and Hoogland into the finals against their longtime nemesis Britain
pitting the two nations that have combined to win the last five gold medals
It was never much of a contest for the gold medal this time
The Dutch have dominated the team sprint since winning their first world title in 2018
and the latest Olympic gold sets up what could be a memorable Paris Games
Lavreysen and Hoogland also are among the favorites in the sprint and the keirin
They are three great individuals,” Carlin said
which trailed the French team through two laps of their head-to-head race before anchor Matthew Glaetzer pulled back more than a tenth of a second on rival Rayan Helal to land on the podium
“I think we should be proud,” Glaetzer said
“To bring it home and win the bronze final is special.”
The Australians covered 4,000 meters in 3:40.730
more than a second faster than Italy’s winning time at the Tokyo Games
but I don’t think we realized we were going that quick out there,” Welsford said
“I think we just really gelled really well
who had their streak of three straight Olympic pursuit titles snapped three years ago
subbed Charlie Tanfield into the lineup along with Ethan Hayter
Oliver Wood and Ethan Vernon to face Denmark
The quartet trailed by more than a second at one point before rallying to win in 4:42.151 and advance to the gold-medal race Wednesday night
New Zealand nearly broke the world record with a stunning time of 4:04.679 in qualifying
which was fifth-fastest in qualifying and can do no better than bronze when the heat races and medal rounds take place Wednesday night
“One thing I learned from the Olympics last time I was here (in Tokyo) is you never know what to expect,” New Zealand’s Bryony Botha said
“We are trying to be realistic and just follow our own process
« Back
Jeffrey Hoogland roared to a new kilometre time trial world record
Tom Davidson spoke to the Dutchman and his team to find out what it took
It might come as a surprise, but Jeffrey Hoogland needed to be persuaded to have a punt at the kilometre time trial world record
“He took a lot more convincing than I thought,” his coach
‘Do you fancy a trip to Mexico where it can be all about you
and the upshot is that you become the world record holder
I want to be world champion first.’ And that kind of threw me
‘I’m pretty certain you’re going to be world champion on your worst day.’”
and this February became the first person to go under 58 seconds at sea level
was that plans were already in place,” the coach reveals
without him really knowing too much.”
shaving 0.87 seconds off a benchmark that lasted for almost a decade
“Every time I think about it I get this amazing feeling,” Hoogland says
speaking to Cycling Weekly from a beach resort on the Caribbean Sea
“I didn’t just want to set a new world record
I wanted to set it so it’s pretty hard to ever beat again.”
Hoogland’s team came across a road block in planning
They had originally hoped to run the sprinter’s kilo effort as a race
with a rider on the opposite side of the track offering a drag advantage
the UCI has suspended the Mexican Federation
meaning Hoogland would have to stage an official world record event
Kordi, however, had a trick up his sleeve. To generate airflow, he planned to send a motorcyclist onto the boards in the minutes before the effort. “He was whizzing around at 70km/h, and as soon as we gave the signal, he was off in five seconds,” the former British Cycling sprint coach says
They practiced the motorbike’s track exit in the days before the effort
was the sudden drop in atmospheric conditions
“[Hoogland] did the effort on the worst day he could have done it on,” says Kordi
The velodrome in Aguascalientes relies on warm air pumped in from outside to heat up
Hoogland did very little training on the track
“I was there 10 years ago and I expected it to maybe have gotten worse over time
but it was exactly how I remembered it,” Hoogland says
they turn rapidly and you get smashed in pretty hard.”
his peak torque coming in the standing start
It had been tested in a wind tunnel using a mannequin of Wout van Aert
the most comparable one to Hoogland that they had lying around
The suit contained fabrics used in speed skating
so when the sprinter neared 80km/h on his second lap
“The biggest mistake was the last turn when I went into the red
but at that point I couldn’t focus or see anymore
Hoogland twisted his face in pain as he lay beside the track
showed him gasping into a humidifier face mask
wearing the grimace of a man immobilised by the lactic acid in his legs
considering the circumstances at high altitude
Everything was more intense than ever before.”
It would end up taking Hoogland more than half an hour to compose himself after his effort
pulling on a pair with the number 55 - his new time benchmark - and cartoon images of the Hulk
the comic book character who lends the sprinter his nickname
Lap times (seconds): 1 (standing start) - 17.52 - 12.03 - 12.44 - 13.3
Average speed: 64.943km/hTop speed: 79km/hMax power (estimated): 3,000w
Hoogland's double leg press PB: 760kg (equivalent to a 1990s Mini Cooper)
the cost of the project was estimated to be in the region of €65,000 (£56,500)
financial consultant AP Support and Japanese giant Yamaha
but it ended up costing “significantly more”
the Dutchman is beginning to think more and more about his legacy in the sport
“I’m a bit of an older athlete at the moment and I don’t know how long my career will go on,” the 30-year-old says frankly
your legacy starts to become more important
actually everything I’ve wanted in my life already with track cycling.”
Hoogland holds three out of the four men’s sprint world records: the kilometre time trial
the team sprint (set at the 2020 World Championships) and the flying 500m
which he achieved in the middle two laps of his kilo
Hoogland returned to the track to try to complete the set with the flying 200m
“I was actually surprised by how close I came,” he says
The sprinter landed three hundredths of a second short of the 9.1 second record
where he shared “some beers” and “some laughs” with his team
“Maybe I’ll go for the 200m next time
“Everything I add now is even better and more fun
I love that people will remember me as one of the greatest in track cycling and I worked really hard for that
I will hopefully not be forgotten in track cycling
When it comes to designing a kilo-record-setting bike
“stiffness is more or less the main goal,” says Tim de Boer
“Especially with a rider like Jeffrey
we mainly look for stiffness and aerodynamics
Weight is a little bit less important.”
Hoogland’s Koga track bike weighed 7.7kg and
is worth around €21,000 in its constituent parts
The sprinter used a 70-tooth carbon Digirit chainring - the biggest he has ever ridden - with a 15-tooth rear cog
“I think the kilo is maybe the hardest event regarding gearing
because everything is in it,” the mechanic says
We felt that the gear was pretty perfect.”
running a Mavic Comete front disc and a rear Campagnolo Ghibli disc
His Dugast tubular tyres - 20mm in width at the front
“Most teams do it like that,” De Boer says
explaining that higher pressures offer less rolling resistance and greater control in the corners
Although Hoogland’s Speedbar TT extensions were brand new
his PRO Missile base bar was over a decade old
reliable model for fear that he might snap a different one
were developed specially to withstand Hoogland’s power
Thank you for reading 20 articles this month* Join now for unlimited access
Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription
Try first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
An enthusiastic cyclist himself, Tom likes it most when the road goes uphill, and actively seeks out double-figure gradients on his rides. His best result is 28th in a hill-climb competition, albeit out of 40 entrants.
Strengthening Rehabilitation in Health Systems
Volume 5 - 2024 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fresc.2024.1371553
Objectives: The purpose of this systematic review is to provide an overview of published follow-up care programs of primary and secondary health conditions (SHCs) in spinal cord injury/disorder (SCI/D) and spina bifida and describe recommendations on content
setting of follow-up care programs for persons with SCI/D and spina bifida
Methods: According to the sequence of procedures of the AWMF (Association of the Scientific Medical Societies in Germany) a systematic literature search was performed (in PubMed
Cochrane Library and nine additional databases for guidelines) between 5 September 2019 and 22 September 2019
2018) and guidelines (up to 2018) published in English or German and describing an evidence-based follow-up care program for persons with SCI/D or spina bifida were included
Results: The systematic literature search found 1973 publications in PubMed and Cochrane Library
resulting in 19 papers for SCI/D and 6 for Spina bifida
we included 34 guidelines developed by reputable committees or medical associations
were rated and classified according to the guidance of AWMF
level of evidence of follow-up care programs was mostly based on informal procedures and expert opinion or formally consent based expert opinion
or publications described an evidence based comprehensive clinical practice guideline (CPG) for follow-up care for people with SCI/D or spina bifida
Conclusion: Based on the comprehensive and extensive literature research conducted
regular (annual) follow-up care appointments at specialized SCI clinics are recommended
There is a notable absence of a comprehensive CPG covering all relevant health conditions for long-term follow-up in SCI/D or spina bifida
In order to provide persons with SCI/D with up-to-date and best possible medical and rehabilitative care
a CPG for follow-up care is urgently needed
the German-speaking Medical Society of Paraplegia (DMGP) has commissioned its members to establish a guideline for follow-up care for individuals with SCI/D
The current review serves as an evidence-based framework for the development of this guideline
Urinary tract infections can be particularly troublesome due to the disruption of normal bladder function and impaired immune responses
making individuals with SCI/D more susceptible to these infections
Pressure injuries result from prolonged immobility and the loss of sensation in affected areas
leading to tissue breakdown and the formation of open wounds
Respiratory infections often arise due to weakened respiratory muscles and compromised cough reflexes
making individuals with SCI/D vulnerable to pneumonia and other respiratory ailments
This statistic emphasizes the critical role that specialized SCI clinics play in not only managing SHCs but also in preserving the overall health
and life expectancy of individuals with SCI
However, despite the clear benefits of regular check-ups up to now, limited evidence regarding content and frequency of follow-up care programs for persons with SCI/D exist (13)
de Witte & Post performed a literature study regarding follow-up care in SCI and described the effects of different follow-up care programs regarding secondary impairments
hardly any evidence existed regarding content and frequency of follow-up care in persons with SCI/D
the content of these descriptions was often focusing on one secondary health condition
The researchers pointed out the urgent need for the development and publication of comprehensive follow-up care programs tailored specifically for individuals with SCI/D
The current systematic review was undertaken to explore and describe current evidence on long-term follow-up care of SHCs in SCI/D or spina bifida and to serve as a basis for the development of a clinical practice guideline (CPG) for follow-up care as commissioned by the German-speaking medical SCI Society (DMGP)
Although we are aware that follow-up care in SCI and spina bifida is much broader than follow-up of HCs
the current review was limited to this topic
The objective of this systematic review therefore is to provide an overview of current evidence and recommendation regarding follow-up care for SHCs in SCI/D and spina bifida with following specific aim: To describe current existing recommendations on content
setting of follow-up care programs focusing on SHCs for persons with SCI/D and spina bifida
We conducted a systematic review of clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) and publications using the JBI Manual for Evidence Synthesis (14)
The search was conducted in all databases between 5 September 2019 and 22 September 2019 and included publications from January 2008 until December 2018
This leads to underrepresentation of relevant aspects for this population
we added a separate search for spina bifida in our search strategy to ensure that aspects
relevant for persons with spina bifida are also covered in the review
Inclusion criteria according to PICO format
Medical content of guidelines and publications
Eligibility criteria for publications and guidelines were defined according to the extended PICO-(patient, intervention, comparison, outcome, study design) format (Table 1)
We included an article if it described recommendations for medical follow-up care for persons with SCI/D or spina bifida (living in the community)
If an article focused solely on recommendations for acute phase
we excluded publications considering mainly pediatric aspects
an experienced SCI/D physician & LM
a health scientist) assessed the retrieved records by title and abstract against the inclusion criteria
After an initial selection of the literature
the full articles were read and evaluated independently by the two reviewers (IEH & LM)
they decided whether the study met the established criteria
discrepancies were solved through discussion or involving a member (all senior physicians) of the core group of the development of the clinical practice guideline for long term follow-up care n SCI as a third reviewer (XJ
Two trained authors (IEH and LM) participated in the data extraction and methodological assessment process using a standardized data extraction form in MS Excel
We retrieved the following information (1) title
For guidelines we extracted additional information about recommendations including assessment recommendations
Of all included manuscripts we extracted aim
Opinion papers and qualitative studies were not specifically rated
but we described their content using the above-mentioned categories
The synthesis includes all medical aspects covered in the papers and guidelines (Supplementary Table S1). As a reference framework the ICF-Core Set for long-term care (56) was used to identify and quantify the underlying medical conditions. Following the standardized ICF linking rules (57)
two authors (IE and LM) linked the ICF categories of the ICF-Core Set for long-term care to the inherent health condition
The search for publications related to follow-up care for people with SCI/D was carried out on 5th September 2019 and resulted in 1973 articles and for people with spina bifida in 19 articles. The decision tree for the selection of manuscripts is presented in Figure 1
We finally included 19 articles on SCI/D and 6 articles on spina bifida
The search results are available on request
The search results for guidelines is explained in chapter 3.5
PRISMA flowchart for search strategy and results
(a) PubMed search with no specific filters for publication methods
(b) PubMed search with limitation on Guidelines
() publications for people with spinal cord injury/disorder
()* publications specifically for people with spina bifida
Most articles were excluded due to missing and no clear conclusion on follow-up care (7)
along with some articles focused only on therapeutic and nursing (2) aspects
Others described solely the patient perspective (with focus on quality of life) (3)
focusing on consumer needs and highlighted issues of communication
we excluded articles discussing education and vocational rehabilitation (2)
as well as one publication focusing on rehabilitation access (1)
These articles provide insights into the effectiveness of telephone or video-based follow-up or care planning in various medical contexts
The authors recommend that regular visits to an outpatient clinic should occur every 18–24 months
A total of 34 guidelines were found including the topic of follow-up care for SCI/D (see Figure 1)
In total 31 guidelines are focusing on people with SCI/D
three guidelines solely on people with spina bifida
and another three guidelines address both people with spina bifida and SCI/D
The Guideline for Care of People with spina bifida from the American Spina Bifida Association is very comprehensive, covering a wide range of topics related to health problems and self-management (44)
The sources provide information on the causes
The guideline is informed by current self-management research for people with spina bifida and offers recommendations to promote self-management and independence across the lifespan
The guideline covers 25 areas of physical health
and general well-being for people with spina bifida
Most of the included guidelines were developed and published in the United States of America (14)
while others were published in the United Kingdom (5) or Canada (2)
The remaining guidelines were developed within global or European committees (3)
A total of 34 guidelines were included in the study. All guidelines were methodologically assessed by the DELBI tool (54) and the results are summarized in Supplementary Table S5
Most guidelines perform very well in terms of formulating clear objectives regarding scope and purpose
most guidelines demonstrate editorial independence
guidelines tend to perform poorly in terms of integrating and involving interest groups
as well as in methodological accuracy during the development process
guidelines tend to receive a poor rating in terms of applicability in the German healthcare system
This remark refers specifically to the German healthcare system and cannot be generalized globally
Three systematic reviews (59, 69, 75) were identified in the search results and their quality were assessed with the R-AMSTAR tool (53). The overall quality of the studies was assessed as low quality. Not fully addressed were especially quality items related to the methodological reporting. The results of the quality assessment of all included systematic reviews are summarized in Supplementary Table S6
Total quality scores ranged from 9 (73) to 19 points (62). None of the 13 observational studies full field all quality standards set by STROBE (52). In particular, the quality criteria were not met in the methods and results sections (e.g., no effort to address potential sources of bias). The results of the quality assessment of all included observational studies are summarized in Supplementary Table S7
The current retrieved publications cover though a broad range of different health conditions, including urological problems, pain, pressure injuries and osteoporosis (48, 58–62)
Although clinical opinion is to perform comprehensive follow-up care in SCI/D and spina bifida
we found hardly any publications or guidelines describing this comprehensive approach and covering all relevant health conditions for persons with SCI/D or spina bifida
with the ICF generic core set and the ICF Core set for spinal cord injury in the long-term context
an ideal framework for the development of an evidence based comprehensive clinical practice guideline for follow-up care would exist and the current findings of this review could serve as an evidence-based basis for a comprehensive clinical practice guideline as commissioned by the DMGP
Innovative approaches such as telemedicine and local visits by nurses might help to ensure specialized care in those vulnerable population
This approach could also help to reduce healthcare costs by preventing unnecessary referrals to specialists
The search results for persons with spina bifida highlight the importance of understanding their health needs
particularly as they transition into adulthood
The articles provide valuable insights into the management of spina bifida
The findings can inform the development of evidence-based practices in healthcare to improve outcomes for individuals with spina bifida
Considering the methodological quality of included publications
we can conclude that high quality recommendations for follow-up care for people with SCI/D and spina bifida are largely missing
With the application of the STROBE tool for observational studies
the AMSTAR checklist for systematic reviews
and the JBI-tool for randomized Trials we provide a valuable baseline to inform the development of an evidence-based practice guideline in follow-up car for people with SCI/D
As there were also publications with methodological limitations included
there might be a risk of bias considering the reliability of specific recommendations for follow-up care for individuals with SCI/D and spina bifida
The results of this systematic review may be limited by the following factors: The search was performed in 2019 as a first step of the development of the guideline on follow-up care of secondary health conditions in spinal cord injury and spina bifida” and thus included literature from January 2008 until December 2018
relevant articles and guidelines might have been published
which we have not included in the current review
A revision of the guideline for follow-up care
including an update of the review is planned and due on 1.1.2027 and will include all new literature and guidelines published
We conducted our systematic search in PubMed
Cochrane library and in several Guideline databases
nevertheless there is a residual probability that a publication on this topic has not been included
where only German and English were considered
12 out of the 19 publications (in PubMed) were conducted in Canada
Three were conducted in Switzerland and two in Germany
The other publications were from Bangladesh
The high number of English-speaking countries might be due to the lack of translation of publications in other languages
Most publications come from the USA which can partly be explained due to the reasonably shorter initial rehabilitation period for people with SCI and therefore
There is an underrepresentation of evidence on long-term follow-up care in low and middle income countries
The idea of a LHS assumes that a health system can learn when it can rely on cyclic processes where data for the health system serve as a basis for the generation of new evidence
establishment of an LHS is helpful to ensure evidence to be integrated in clinical practice and experience from clinical practice to be integrated in new research
follow-up care of persons with SCI encompasses much more as prevention and early treatment of SHCs
Besides the assessment and evaluation of body structures and body functions
regular evaluation and assessment of activities
and quality of life should be performed during each follow-up visit
The ICF and its core sets build a framework for the evaluation of all relevant aspects of functioning with SCI
it was beyond the scope of the current guideline to describe all aspects of follow-up care in persons with SCI
we recommend regular (annual) follow-up care appointments at specialized SCI clinics
While several specific health concerns (SHCs) were addressed in follow-up care programs
there is a notable absence of a comprehensive clinical practice guideline (CPG) covering all health conditions relevant for the long-term follow-up of individuals with SCI/D or spina bifida
the DMGP has commissioned its members to establish a guideline for follow-up care for individuals with SCI/D
The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/Supplementary Material
further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author
XJ: Writing – review & editing
MB: Writing – review & editing
BH: Writing – review & editing
FM: Writing – review & editing
The author(s) declare that no financial support was received for the research
Martin Schubert (delegate of University clinic Balgrist
Hildegard Oswald (librarian Swiss Paraplegic Centre)
Austrian and Swiss SCI Patient association: Daniel Joggi
Hannes Wiesinger and Marcel Studer delegate of the Swiss Spina Bifida and hydrocephalus (SBH) patient association as well as delegates of the interest groups: Dr
Karl Kothbauer (†) (Neurosurgery Cantonal Hospital Lucerne
Raoul Heilbronner (Neurosurgery Swiss Paraplegic Centre)
MsC (Neuro-urology Swiss Paraplegic Centre)
The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations
Any product that may be evaluated in this article
or claim that may be made by its manufacturer
is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher
The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fresc.2024.1371553/full#supplementary-material
Arbeitsgemeinschaft wissenschaftlicher medizinischer Fachgesellschaften/Association of the Scientific Medical Societies in Germany; CPG
Deutsches Leitlinienbewertungsinstrument/German instrument for
deutschsprachige medizinische Gesellschaft für Paraplegiologie; ICF
International Classification of functioning
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence; PICO
Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses; R-AMSTAR
Revised—A MeaSurement Tool to Assess Systematic Reviews; SCI/D
Strengthening The Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology
and life expectancy after spinal cord injury
Frequency and age effects of secondary health conditions in individuals with spinal cord injury: a scoping review
Perception of secondary conditions in adults with spina bifida and impact on daily life
Health conditions in people with spinal cord injury: contemporary evidence from a population-based community survey in Switzerland
Secondary health conditions in individuals aging with SCI: terminology
Secondary health conditions in persons with a spinal cord injury for at least 10 years: design of a comprehensive long-term cross-sectional study
and self-reported fitness after spinal cord injury: a cross-sequential analysis of age
Utilization of health services following spinal cord injury: a 6-year follow-up study
The person with a spinal cord injury: an evolving prototype for life care planning
Primary care of people with spinal cord injury: scoping review
PubMed Abstract | Google Scholar
Factors influencing specialized health care utilization by individuals with spinal cord injury: a cross-sectional survey
Attrition from specialised rehabilitation associated with an elevated mortality risk: results from a vital status tracing study in Swiss spinal cord injured patients
Follow-up care for persons with spinal cord injury living in the community: a systematic review of interventions and their evaluation
14. Aromataris E, Munn Z, editors. JBI Manual for evidence synthesis. JBI. (2020). Available online at: https://synthesismanual.jbi.global (Accessed February 05
Google Scholar
pathophysiology and emerging cellular therapies
Global maps of non-traumatic spinal cord injury epidemiology: towards a living data repository
17. Kurze I, Schmidt M, Bertschy S, Lange U, Kues S, Fiebag K. Schwangerschaft, geburt und wochenbett bei frauen mit querschnittlähmung (Langfassung). S2k-Leitlinie (2018). Available online at: https://register.awmf.org/de/start (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
18. Steffen F, Schulz B, Wang H, Gottschalk S, Grüter F, Friedrich J, et al. Leitlinie schmerzen bei querschnittlähmung. S2k (2018). Available online at: https://register.awmf.org/de/start (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
19. Biglari B, Dissemond J, Donhauser M, Föcks I, Fürstenberg CH, Gstaltner K, et al. Querschnittspezifische dekubitusbehandlung und -prävention (2017). Available online at: https://register.awmf.org/de/start (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
20. Scheel-Sailer A, Bartholet C, Bersch-Porada I, Curt A, Gisler A, Huber B, et al. Rehabilitation der unteren exremität, der steh- und gehfunktion bei menschen mit querschnittlähmung (2018). Available online at: https://register.awmf.org/de/start (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
Querschnittlähmungsassoziierte Osteoporose
Google Scholar
22. Geng V, Böthing R, Kurze I, Hildesheim A, Leder Eckhart D. S2k-leitlinie neurogene darmfunktionsstörung bei querschnittlähmung (2019). Available online at: https://register.awmf.org/de/start (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
23. Drzin-Schilling B, Eisenhuth J, Janker P, Neikes M, Prang P, Stolle A. S1-leitlinie der deutschsprachigen medizinischen gesellschaft für paraplegie (DMPGP). Depression bei menschen mit querschnittlähmung. Besonderheiten in der Diagnostik und Behandlung (2016). Available online at: https://register.awmf.org/de/start (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
24. Stein R, Assion C, Bredel Geissler A, Beetz R, Bürst M, Cremer R, et al. Diagnostik und therapie der neurogenen blasenfunktionsstörungen bei kindern und jugendlichen mit spinaler dysraphie. S2k Leitlinie (2013). p. 043–7. Available online at: https://register.awmf.org/de/start (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
25. Böthig R, Domurath B, Bremer J, Vance W, Kaufmann A. Neuro-urologische versorgung querschnittgelähmter patienten (2016). Available online at: https://register.awmf.org/de/start (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
26. SCIRE Professional. Rehabilitation Evidence (2010). Available online at: https://scireproject.com/evidence/rehabilitation-evidence/ (Accessed September 11
Google Scholar
27. NICE, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Urinary incontinence in neurological disease: assessment and management (2012). Available online at: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/conditions-and-diseases (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
28. NICE, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Faecal incontinence in adults: management. (2007). Available online at: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/conditions-and-diseases (Accessed September 10
Google Scholar
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence
Pressure Ulcers: Prevention and Management
Google Scholar
British Society of Rehabilitation Medicine
BSRM Standards for Rehabilitation Services Mapped on to the National Service Framework for Long-Term Neurological Conditions
Google Scholar
Prevention of Venous Thromboembolism in Individuals with Spinal Cord Injury: Clinical Practice Guideline for Health Care Providers
Washington: Paralyzed Veterans of America (2016)
Google Scholar
Sexuality and Reproductive Health in Adults with Spinal Cord Injury: A Clinical Practice Guideline for Health-Care Providers
Washington: Paralyzed Veterans of America (2010)
Google Scholar
Bladder Management for Adults with Spinal Cord Injury: A Clinical Practice Guideline for Health-Care Providers
Washington: Paralyzed Veterans of America (2006)
Google Scholar
Preservation of upper limb function following spinal cord injury: a clinical practice guideline for health-care professionals
Respiratory Management Following Spinal Cord Injury: A Clinical Practice Guideline for Health-Care Providers
Washington: Paralyzed Veterans of America (2005)
Google Scholar
Pressure Ulcer Prevention and Treatment Following Spinal Cord Injury: A Clinial Pracitce Guideline for Health-Care Professionals
Google Scholar
Consortium Guidelines for Spinal Cord Medicine
Outcomes Following Traumatic Spinal Cord Injury: Clinical Practice Guidelines for Health-Care Professionals
Washington: Paralyzed Veterans of America (1999)
Google Scholar
Depression Following Spinal Cord Injury: A Clinical Practice Guideline for Primary Care Physicians
Washington: Paralyzed Veterans of America (1998)
Google Scholar
Clinical practice guidelines: neurogenic bowel management in adults with spinal cord injury
Identification and management of cardiometabolic risk after spinal cord injury: clinical practice guideline for health care providers
Management of faecal incontinence and constipation in adults with central neurological diseases
Organisation of health services for preventing and treating pressure ulcers
Automated telephone communication systems for preventive healthcare and management of long-term conditions
44. Spina Bifida Association. Guidelines for the Care of People with Spina Bifida (2018) Available online at: https://www.spinabifidaassociation.org/guidelines/ (Accessed September 11
Google Scholar
Management of pain in individuals with spinal cord injury: guideline of the German-speaking medical society for spinal cord injury
Urodynamics in patients with spinal cord injury: a clinical review and best practice paper by a working group of the international continence society urodynamics committee
Neurogenic bowel dysfunction: clinical management recommendations of the neurologic incontinence committee of the fifth international consultation on incontinence 2013
The CanPain SCI clinical practice guideline for rehabilitation management of neuropathic pain after spinal cord: recommendations for model systems of care
Professional standards of practice for psychologists
Physical and rehabilitation medicine (PRM) care pathways: “spinal cord injury”
Spina bifida health-care guidelines for men’s health
PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
The strengthening the reporting of observational studies in epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational studies
AMSTAR 2: a critical appraisal tool for systematic reviews that include randomised or non-randomised studies of healthcare interventions
DELBI – German instrument for methodological Guideline Appraisal - Development of a AGREE - based checklist adapted for use in Germany (2005)
Google Scholar
The revised JBI critical appraisal tool for the assessment of risk of bias for randomized controlled trials
ICF Core sets for individuals with spinal cord injury in the long-term context
Refinements of the ICF linking rules to strengthen their potential for establishing comparability of health information
Neuro-urological diagnosis and therapy of lower urinary tract dysfunction in patients with spinal cord injury: s2k guideline of the German-speaking medical society of paraplegia (DMGP)
Recommendations for urological follow-up of patients with neurogenic bladder secondary to spinal cord injury
VA-based survey of osteoporosis management in spinal cord injury
Preventing recurrent pressure ulcers in veterans with spinal cord injury: impact of a structured education and follow-up intervention
Spinal cord injury/disorder teleconsultation outcome study
PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Health care utilization in persons with spinal cord injury: part 1—outpatient services
Patterns of health care use of injured adults: a population-based matched cohort study
Perceptions of person-centered care following spinal cord injury
Secondary health conditions and spinal cord injury: an uphill battle in the journey of care
Long-term follow-up of patients with spinal cord injury with a new ICF-based tool
Rehabilitation nach querschnittlähmung
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Promoting long-term health among people with spinal cord injury: what’s new
Long-term follow-up in patients with spinal cord injury - prevention and comprehensive care
The delivery of specialist spinal cord injury services in Queensland and the potential for telehealth
A pilot randomised trial of community-based care following discharge from hospital with a recent spinal cord injury in Bangladesh
Development of interprofessional care plans for spinal cord injury clients through videoconferencing
Functional and clinical outcomes of telemedicine in patients with spinal cord injury
Rehabilitation and medical management of the adult with spina bifida
Current opinions regarding care of the mature pediatric urology patient
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Medical and psychosocial problems in middle-aged spina bifida patients: survey among members of the Dutch patients’ association
Impact of a person-centred community rehabilitation service on outcomes for individuals with a neurological condition
Effectiveness of the interdisciplinary ambulatory rehabilitation program in persons with spina Bifida
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Myelomeningocele: need for long-time complex follow-up-an observational study
A telerehabilitation model for victims of polytrauma
Vollständig überarbeitete Empfehlungen zur Prävention für Menschen mit Querschnittlähmung
Google Scholar
83. Spina Bifida Association. Guidelines for the Care of People with Spina Bifida (2020) Available online at: https://www.spinabifidaassociation.org/guidelines/ (Accessed September 11
Google Scholar
Non-adherence to follow-up care in persons with spinal cord injury within 10 years after initial rehabilitation
Swiss Learning health system: a national initiative to establish learning cycles for continuous health system improvement
Thietje R and Müller L (2024) Recommendations for long-term follow-up care of secondary health conditions in spinal cord injury/disorder: a systematic review
Received: 16 January 2024; Accepted: 26 September 2024;Published: 11 October 2024
Copyright: © 2024 Eriks-Hoogland, Jordan, Baumberger, Seijas, Huber, Michel, Thietje and Müller. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY)
distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted
provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited
in accordance with accepted academic practice
distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms
*Correspondence: Inge Eriks-Hoogland, aW5nZS5lcmlrc0BwYXJhcGxlZ2llLmNo
Disclaimer: All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations
Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher
94% of researchers rate our articles as excellent or goodLearn more about the work of our research integrity team to safeguard the quality of each article we publish
Chad Pregracke is the founder and president of Living Lands and Waters
a nonprofit organization dedicated to cleaning up America's rivers
He is set to speak at an Earth Day celebration at the Hoogland Center for the Arts on April 18
He spoke to Community Voices about growing up on the Mississippi River and how he became a leader in environmental cleanup
He also explained how he and his team have mobilized volunteers to remove more than 14 million pounds of garbage from 25 rivers across the U.S
The free April 18 event at the Hoogland Center for the Arts will feature a social hour from 5:30 - 7 p.m
cash bar and art exhibit by Sangamon Watercolor Society
and a presentation by Chad Pregracke from 7 - 8:30 p.m.
For more information visit: https://www.facebook.com/share/1GLjDGSDhZ/
Ashley Brown originated the role of Mary Poppins on Broadway
14 as the headliner for the Hoogland Center for the Arts Gala
Brown spoke to the Beyond the Mouse podcast about her upcoming performance
Jeffrey Hoogland misses bronze medal after judges reject team's protest in men's sprint final
but he did so to a mix of cheers from the Union Jack-waving British fans and boos from the orange-clad Dutch supporters of his rival in the final
Carlin had faced a warning in his quarterfinal match when he defeated Japan's Ota Kaiya in the third head-to-head
and the memory of the incident was fresh in the mind of the Dutch coach
when Carlin faced Hoogland for the bronze medal
Carlin slid up-track and ran into Hoogland
very nearly crashing the both of them in the process.
and Kordi said he thought that meant the officials would relegate Carlin and the bronze medal would belong to Hoogland
But the jury decided instead to issue another warning to Carlin
but Kordi said Carlin came out of the sprinters' lane
which is against the rules if the rider has taken the lane
He came out of sprinters lane," Kordi said
the crash and the collision that did influence the race in my opinion
Kordi said the officials made it clear on the morning of the final round that they would be more stringent
"The jury made it clear to me this morning
with all the incidents that had happened with Carlin included
with all the fighting - basically rugby on wheels - that if you come out the sprinter's lane when it's engaged
"It was two pedal strokes not just that his front wheel flicked in and out
There's two pedal strokes in that corner there [turn 3]
It was a close race and it affected the outcome because it was in the corner and he goes uphill and kills the speed
So I was confused because they said it didn't influence the race
"I was saying he altered the course by going out of it - [Hoogland] could have had a sharper corner and probably come over him
and the other guy [Carlin] would have probably lost the speed as well
But they didn't seem to think that affected the race
because I thought we were saying that if you come in the sprint is lane
Although Kordi said he wasn't angry with Carlin for how he raced
he added he didn't think the jury would be so forgiving if it was another sprinter
"I think what it's encouraging is people pushing boundaries
There's a saying in sports that you swallow your whistle in the highest sort of pressurized moments
meaning they're not going to give the call because it's such a grand occasion
but I still am confused with all the warnings and head butting and coming out the line he was doing yesterday and today
that it didn't actually come of anything."
The boos and the protests didn't hurt Carlin as much as the entire sprint tournament
where he had to defeat riders like Nicholas Paul (Trinidad & Tobago) and Ota all while just getting over a fractured ankle that he suffered in April
"I won't lie when I say the last two days have probably been the most mentally challenging in my career," Carlin said
you just saunter in if you're one of the top qualifiers
and then you walk away and you recompose yourself for the harder races
The jeers of the Dutch fans were just another day in the life of a match sprinter
"Tokyo was the same - that's part of the Olympics
and you put yourself in the light to be challenged on that
she coordinates coverage for North American events and global news
As former elite-level road racer who dabbled in cyclo-cross and track
Laura has a passion for all three disciplines
When not working she likes to go camping and explore lesser traveled roads
UCI governance and performing data analysis
More than half of the respondents to a State Journal-Register poll said the best place for a New Year's Eve date in Springfield is at First Night at the Hoogland Center for the Arts
That outdistanced "staying at home/on the couch" in the SJ-R poll
the family-friendly celebration of the arts put on by the Springfield Area Arts Council
More: Here's why two UIS Performing Arts Center venues will temporarily close in 2025
Among the performers at the Hoogland Center area the Lincoln Ring of Magicians
Lotus Fire Belly Dancers and Capital City Improv
with the Illinois Capitol Building as the backdrop
Tickets are $25 (youth 15 and under attend free) and available at the SAAC website or the Hoogland box office.
Contact Steven Spearie: 217-622-1788; sspearie@sj-r.com; X, twitter.com/@StevenSpearie.
Volume 5 - 2024 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fresc.2024.1371556
Introduction: While it is well-established that follow-up care programs play a crucial role in preventing and early detecting secondary health conditions (SHCs) in persons with spinal cord injury [SCI
the availability of evidence-based follow-up care programs remains limited
Under the leadership of the German-speaking Medical Society for Paraplegiology (DMGP)
we have developed an evidence based clinical practice guideline for follow-up care of SHCs in persons with SCI and identify research gaps
Methods: This guideline was developed in accordance with the regulations of the Association of the Scientific Medical Societies in Germany (AWMF e.V.)
we utilized the International Classification of Functioning
Disability and Health (ICF) generic core set and ICF Core Set for individuals with SCI in long-term context as our foundational framework
We conducted a comprehensive literature review to identify existing recommendations for follow-up care and graded the level of evidence according to relevant instruments
we formulated recommendations and achieved consensus through a structured nominal group process involving defined steps and neutral moderation
while adhering to the criteria outlined in the German guideline development instrument (DELBI)
Results: Although there is a fair number of literatures describing prevalence and severity of SHCs after SCI
the amount of literature including recommendations was low (19 for SCI and 6 for SB)
Based on the current evidence on prevalence and severity of SHCs and available recommendations
a clinical practice guideline on follow-up care of most relevant SHCs was defined
The recommendations for follow-up care are described in the following chapters: (1) Nervous system; (2) (Neuropathic) pain; (3) Cardiovascular diseases; (4) Respiratory System; (5) Immunological system
vaccination and allergies; (6) Gastrointestinal tract and function; (7) Endocrinological system and nutrition; (8) Urogenital system; (9) Contraception
birth and postpartum care; (10) Musculoskeletal system; (11) Pressure injuries; (12) Psychological health; (13) Medication and polypharmacy
Conclusion: We could successfully establish an evidence based clinical practice guideline for follow-up care of SHCs in individuals with SCI
There is however a notable lack of high-quality recommendations for SCI follow-up care
The management of SCI therefore goes beyond the initial injury and acute care phase
necessitating a comprehensive approach to long-term follow-up care
A critical aspect of follow-up care involves the prevention or early diagnosis of new health conditions (HCs)
Despite the established benefits of follow-up care programs throughout the lifespan, including improved health, prevention of SHCs, current follow-up care programs are scarce, limited in availability, predominantly rely on expert opinions, and exhibit considerable variation in terms of content, frequency, and setting (23)
To provide individuals with SCI with up-to-date and optimal medical and rehabilitative care
as well as to establish a first step building an evidence-based framework for a (learning) health system (LHS) in SCI
the development of an evidence-based clinical practice guideline for follow-up care in persons with SCI is imperative
The German-speaking Medical Society for Paraplegiology (DMGP) has
tasked its members with the development of a clinical practice guideline for the follow-up care of SHCs in individuals with SCI
This guideline aims to provide the most comprehensive
and current recommendations for the long-term care of persons with SCI
Its purpose is to serve as a foundation for a dynamic LHS
ensuring continuous enhancement through structured data assessment along the continuum of care and so building a framework for research and adaptation
The guideline addresses critical clinical questions
Content of follow-up care programs: What should be the core components of follow-up care programs focusing on prevention and early adaptation of SHCs
including clinical and additional evaluations
Assessments tailored to specific SCI groups: Are there specific assessments that should be uniquely tailored to distinct SCI groups
Frequency of follow-up care appointments: How often should individuals undergo follow-up care appointments
Setting for follow-up care appointments: In what clinical settings should these follow-up care appointments take place
By addressing these clinically relevant key questions
the guideline seeks to provide a structured and evidence-based approach to optimize the long-term care of individuals with SCI
ultimately aiming to enhance their overall well-being and quality of life
The development of the present guideline was spearheaded by the DMGP e.V
The core working group comprised six medical doctors/physicians (IEH
XJ) all with over 15 years of experience in the field of SCI
The extended working group existed of medical doctors/physicians hailing from diverse backgrounds including physical medicine and rehabilitation
RB) as well as members from patient associations for individuals living with SCI or SB
The development process also engaged representatives (mandates holders) of professional societies within the Association of the Scientific Medical Societies (AWMF) for external reviews
all DMGP members were provided the opportunity to review the guideline
The content of the clinical practice guideline was structured using the International Classification of Functioning and Health (ICF) Generic Core Set and ICF Core Sets for individuals with spinal cord injury in the long-term context as frameworks (Table 1) (26, 27). Additional ICF categories were incorporated by expert opinion recommendation of the core group (see Supplementary Material)
Grey literature sources were also examined from the Spinal cord injury research evidence (SCIRE) project and existing guidelines
Comparison and Outcomes (PICO) tool was used to identify all relevant literature
Included were all studies which included persons with SCI and SB (P)
frequency and setting of follow-up care of SHC in SCI (I) and describing outcome measures (O)
A reviewer (IEH) evaluated the identified “titles and abstracts” according to the inclusion criteria (IEH)
After an initial selection of literature from PubMed (spinal cord injury n = 1,973/SB n = 19)
the full texts from the databases were then retrieved (n = 34/n = 6) and evaluated by two reviewers (IEH & LM)
the reviewers then decided again whether the study met the established criteria
two additional members of the guideline group were consulted to reach a decision
19/6 articles were ultimately assessed as suitable for addressing the key questions and thus serve as the basis of evidence
The information from the relevant literature was extracted by one person (IEH) and documented in a specially developed template
which was later used for processing in the consensus process
The information includes title and authors of the study
Since all identified texts were written in English
the summary of the information was also conducted in English
Additional findings from guidelines and textbooks were consecutively included in the template
The approach to evidence assessment is based on the process of a systematic literature review. Critical Appraisal Tools are used to evaluate the quality of the relevant literature. Since various types of literature and studies were identified through the literature search, different tools were also utilized to represent the quality. Level of evidence was classified according to the AWMF Regulations in four Grade categories: high, moderate, low and very low (30)
In a next step the Grade of recommendation A (must/must not), B (should/should not) and 0 (could/could not) was then defined, based on the level of evidence and according to the regulations of the AWMF (30)
The analysis of this literature search served as the foundation for this guideline
grading of evidence and grade of recommendation
Based on the ICF Generic Core Set (27) and ICF Core Sets for individuals with spinal cord injury in the long-term context (26) and expert opinion of the working groups a content of the guideline was defined (see Supplementary Table S1)
The included ICF categories were clustered in 13 chapters: (1) Nervous system
sleep and autonomic function; (2) Pain; (3) Cardiovascular diseases including cardiometabolic syndrome and thrombosis; (4) Respiratory System
infections and sleep-associated breathing disorders; (5) Immunological system including vaccination and allergies; (6) Gastrointestinal tract and function including obstipation and incontinence
screening recommendations for colon carcinoma and dysphagia; (7) Endocrinological system and nutrition including osteoporosis and malnutrition; (8) Urogenital system
renal function and urinary tract infections
preventive medicine and screening for women
and pregnancy in women with spinal bifida; (9) Pregnancy
birth and postpartum care; (10) Musculoskeletal system including upper extremities
and scoliosis; (11) Pressure injuries; (12) Psychological health; (13) Medication and polypharmacy
guidelines and textbooks was allocated to the referring chapters and authors summarized the relevance and recommendations for follow-up care
The AWMF-guideline “Follow-up care in persons with SCI” (32) recommends following: The primary objectives of these appointments are to prevent the onset of SHCs
and optimize the person's rehabilitation status
1. Content of follow-up care: Follow-up care appointments should encompass a broad range of health aspects, as defined by the current guideline (see Supplementary Table S1) and not be limited to SCI-specific issues
They should also evaluate typical aging-related concerns
such as degenerative changes and cardiovascular health
2. Assessment: Ideally, follow-up care appointments should adopt an interdisciplinary and/or interprofessional approach, involving healthcare professionals from various backgrounds. This collaborative approach ensures comprehensive assessment and management of the person's health. In Supplementary Table S1 specific recommendations on assessments
Frequency of follow-up care appointments: Regular monitoring for all individuals with SCI: It is strongly recommended that every person with SCI undergoes regular follow-up care appointments
It is advisable to schedule follow-up appointments at specific intervals
persons should attend follow-up appointments at 3
annual appointments at specialized SCI clinics are recommended
Setting of follow-up appointments: Follow-up care appointments ideally are scheduled at a specific SCI clinic to ensure a holistic health evaluation
Specific health issues might need inclusion of other medical specialists
an important role in healthcare management of persons with SCI is reserved for the general practitioner of the person
5. Assessments tailored to specific SCI groups: Specific recommendations for different age groups, persons with tetraplegia, those with complete lesions, persons able to walk, women, and persons with spina bifida are made where applicable and included in Supplementary Table S1
The supplement provides a detailed overview of recommendation of all above mentioned 13 chapters, but now clustered in five key-components (neurological status, general internal status, neuro-urological & urogenital status, musculoskeletal status and rehabilitation status). For each chapter a short description of the problem (frequency/severity) is given, followed by the recommendations including level of evidence and grade of recommendation. In Supplementary Table S1
we provide a “quick-read” overview of the content of follow-up care appointments
as well as clinical examination and additional examinations
It also includes an overview of assessments that are recommended
The key components of follow-up care appointments are listed below
They mirror the comprehensive approach which is needed to ensure that all relevant aspects of health and functioning are covered in follow-up appointments
1. SCI specific neurological assessment: Each follow-up care appointment should include a thorough assessment of SCI-specific neurological aspects (33)
This evaluation should encompass the individual's neurological status
as well as any changes or developments in their SCI
special attention should be given to cognitive status and shunt function
Any neurological concerns or developments should be identified and addressed
Assessment of internal medicine status: The follow-up care process should involve a comprehensive assessment of the individual's internal medicine status
This includes evaluating their overall health (including for example cardiac
preventive care and screening status and medication management
Any changes or issues related to internal medicine should be addressed and managed as appropriate
(Neuro-) musculoskeletal assessment: An integral part of follow-up care is the assessment of (neuro-) musculoskeletal health
This evaluation examines the individual's musculoskeletal system
Any musculoskeletal concerns or developments should be identified and addressed
Neuro-urological and urogenital assessment: Follow-up care appointments should incorporate a neuro-urological and urogenital assessment
This includes evaluating urinary and genital function
identifying any issues related to bladder or sexual health
Rehabilitation status: The individual's rehabilitation status should be continuously monitored and assessed during follow-up care appointments
and the need for adjustments or modifications to the rehabilitation plan
individuals with SCI can receive comprehensive and proactive care that aims to optimize their overall well-being
and address potential health issues associated with aging
This approach ensures that follow-up care is tailored to the unique needs of each person with SCI
promoting a higher quality of life and long-term health
The current clinical practice guideline for follow-up care in individuals with SCI represents a significant milestone as it stands as the first comprehensive
evidence-based guideline for follow-up care across the lifespan for individuals with SCI and SB
This guideline emerged through a collaborative effort of experts
including healthcare specialists and individuals with lived experience
The incorporation of the ICF generic core set and the ICF core set for SCI underscores the guideline's robust evidence-based foundation
With the implementation of the current follow-up care guideline
a framework for assessment of SHCs in persons with SCI has now been established
making outcomes of follow-up carte appointments measurable and therefore comparable
It also sets the standard for follow-up care recommending on content
frequency of follow-up care appointments and specific considerations for subgroups
The idea of a LHS assumes that a health system can learn when it can rely on cyclic processes where reliable and regular assessed data for the health system serve as a basis for the generation of new evidence
The evidence is transferred into practice for implementation
and structured data generated from practice as well as experience from implementation are fed back into the cycle
By including structured assessments and outcomes
a comparison over time and between health care settings is possible
In recognition of the dynamic nature of SCI and the ever-evolving healthcare landscape
the guideline adopts a learning health system approach
This approach serves as a bridge between research evidence and practical application
allowing real-world data to generate new research questions and inform ongoing improvements in care delivery
the guideline remains adaptable and aligned with the dynamic nature of SCI and healthcare
It is imperative to emphasize that guidelines are most effective when integrated into everyday clinical practice. The implementation of the guidelines in our health care setting is a step-wise approach based on recommendations of Beachemin et al. (34) using a repeating-process model
While the guideline provides a valuable framework for follow-up clinical care
it is essential to underscore that individualized care should always consider the unique circumstances of each health care setting and each person
Guidelines are not legally binding documents and should be applied judiciously in light of individual needs
and the regional/national health care system
The guideline is anticipated to undergo periodic updates in accordance with AWMF guidelines
These updates will prioritize the enhancement of guideline development methodology
including the evaluation of systematic reviews and meta-analyses in line with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis (PRISMA) statement and the application of the GRADE approach to assess the quality of available evidence and the strength of recommendations
The guideline recommends specialist in SCI care (ideally a PMR specialist) to be the coordinator of follow-up care
in close collaboration with all included health care specialist
The guideline therefore is not only a tool for SCI specialists
but also informs general practitioners and persons with SCI on the recommendations for follow-up care
The DMGP successfully established a clinical practice guideline for follow-up care of SHCs in individuals with SCI
Although we found a fair number of literatures describing prevalence and severity of SHCs after SCI
for some health conditions this was completely missing (for example breast and cervical cancer prevalence in women with SCI and the amount of literature specifying recommendations for follow-up care appointments was low (19 for SCI and 6 for SB) and mostly of low-moderate quality
CB: Writing – review & editing
HE: Writing – review & editing
MV-A: Writing – review & editing
RB: Writing – review & editing
KF: Writing – review & editing
RT: Writing – review & editing
Switzerland) which participated in the start of the guideline development
We also like to thank Hildegard Oswald (librarian at Swiss Paraplegic Centre) for her help with the literature searches and moderating the process
Further thanks we are obliged the persons with “lived experience”
Austrian and Swiss SCI Patient associations: Daniel Joggi
delegate of the Swiss Spina Bifida and hydrocephalus (SBH) patient association
we thank the delegates of all involved interest groups: German society of neurorehabilitation (DGNR)
Austrian society of neurorehabilitation (ÖGNR)
German society for gynecology and birth (DGGG)
We also like to express our thanks to the guideline committee of the German speaking association of paraplegiology (DMGP) and its members for providing us with valuable feedback
The Supplementary Material for this article can be found online at: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fresc.2024.1371556/full#supplementary-material
Deutsches Leitlinienbewertungsinstrument/German instrument for methodological guideline appraisal; DMGP
Deutschsprachige Medizinische Gesellschaft für Paraplegiologie (German Medical Association for Paraplegia); e.V
eingetragener Verein (registered association); GRADE
international classification of functioning
physical medicine and rehabilitation; PRISMA
preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses; SB
Recent trends in mortality and causes of death among persons with spinal cord injury
Survival after non-traumatic spinal cord injury: evidence from a population-based rehabilitation cohort in Switzerland
All-cause and cause-specific mortality following non-traumatic spinal cord injury: evidence from a population-based cohort study in Switzerland
Differential survival after traumatic spinal cord injury: evidence from a multi-center longitudinal cohort study in Switzerland
Mortality and longevity after a spinal cord injury: systematic review and meta-analysis
Google Scholar
secondary health conditions and quality of life in people with spinal cord injury
Lifetime prevalence of chronic health conditions among persons with spinal cord injury
Survival and cause of death after traumatic spinal cord injury
A long-term epidemiological survey from Denmark
Long-term survival in spinal cord injury: a fifty year investigation
Long-term morbidity and mortality after spinal cord injury: 50 years of follow-up
A prospective assessment of mortality in chronic spinal cord injury
and psychosocial outcomes of persons spinal cord injured more than 20 years ago
Expectations of life and health among spinal cord injured adults
and economic risk factors for mortality after spinal cord injury
severity of injury and period of latency: a descriptive study on 135 patients with spinal cord injury and bladder cancer
Factors affecting mortality and morbidity in adult spina bifida
PubMed Abstract | Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Spina bifida outcome: a 25-year prospective
International spinal cord injury data sets
Developing core sets for persons with spinal cord injuries based on the international classification of functioning
disability and health as a way to specify functioning
ICF core sets for individuals with spinal cord injury in the long-term context
Towards a minimal generic set of domains of functioning and health
MD: Wolters Kluwer Health/Lippincott Williams & Wilkins (2011)
Google Scholar
ISCOS—textbook on comprehensive management of spinal cord injuries
Crossref Full Text | Google Scholar
Arbeitsgemeinschaft der Wissenschaftlichen Medizinischen Fachgesellschaften
Google Scholar
S2k-Leitlinie Lebenslange Nachsorge für Menschen mit Querschnittlähmung
Google Scholar
International standards for neurological classification of spinal cord injury (revised 2011)
Implementation of clinical practice guidelines in the health care setting: a concept analysis
Health care utilization in persons with spinal cord injury: part 2-determinants
geographic variation and comparison with the general population
Thietje R and Jordan X (2024) Evidence based clinical practice guideline for follow-up care in persons with spinal cord injury
Received: 16 January 2024; Accepted: 9 August 2024;Published: 9 September 2024
Copyright: © 2024 Eriks-Hoogland, Müller, Baumberger, Huber, Michel, Belfrage, Elmerghini, Veseli-Abazi, Böthig, Fiebag, Thietje and Jordan. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY)
Disclaimer: All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
94% of researchers rate our articles as excellent or goodLearn more about the work of our research integrity team to safeguard the quality of each article we publish.
Volume 8 - 2023 | https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2023.1293754
This article is part of the Research TopicBest Practices in Numeracy Education for the 21st CenturyView all 5 articles
A correction has been applied to this article in:
Corrigendum: The changing nature of basic skills in numeracy
Conducting large calculations manually with pen and paper following prescribed procedures or algorithms has been diminishing in significance for some time
individuals employ digital instruments for such computational tasks
and the application of digital instruments for computation
that numeracy education for adults prioritizes these competencies to achieve efficacy
This lack impedes their autonomous and effective participation in our technologically advanced
leading to potential occupational exclusions and daily life challenges
While adult numeracy educational practices should mirror these broad
multifaceted competencies for effectiveness
a significant portion of such practices remains anchored in manual calculations with abstract numbers
Although there's a discernible shift toward materials and strategies that align with the aforementioned broad competencies
the traditional computational approach remains deeply entrenched
Subsequent sections will elucidate the primary cause for this enduring incongruence
with a deeper exploration of the evolution of basic numeracy skills
Figure 1. Common European Numeracy Framework: aspects of the quality of numerate behavior. Adapted from (Hoogland et al., 2021)
To grasp the evolving essence of numeracy as a basic skill
it's crucial to differentiate between two distinct yet related phenomena
shaped by our interactions with a world abundant in numerical concepts and artifacts
The depth and breadth of this toolkit can vary among individuals
Regular engagement in diverse numeracy situations can enhance and solidify this toolkit
and math anxiety can influence its effective utilization
The second phenomenon is the capacity to finds answers to more complex and larger calculations
using written down procedures and algorithms
These complex mathematical operations go beyond the direct scope of the mental toolkit
Examples include more complex calculations starting from 123 × 939
cultures developed specific written algorithms
or even clay tablets were employed to break down these calculations into smaller
manageable steps that could be tackled using the mental toolkit
The mental toolkit was used in these procedures over and over again in a specific—detached from reality—way
The distinction between the mathematical mental toolkit and procedural calculations offers a lens to comprehend the evolution of basic numeracy skills
The first phenomenon is rather universal and encompasses also the higher-order skills necessary to cope with a plethora of numeracy situations
the second one is time-bound and started loosing its relevance at the end of last century after being prominent for centuries
We will discuss in broad strokes three periods in recent times and how the phenomena described above played a role
We distinguish between roughly three periods
brought about significant changes in the way society perceived and imparted basic skills
As industries grew and urbanized areas expanded
the need for a more universally applicable set of skills became evident
It became clear that this system of apprenticeships was insufficient to meet the demands of a rapidly changing workforce
The mid-19th century, particularly the Victorian era, saw an emphasis on the so-called 3 R's of Reading, 'Riting, and 'Ritmetic. These skills were deemed essential for individuals to navigate the complexities of an industrialized society (Thomas, 1987)
there was a global push toward mass education
Schools became the primary institutions for imparting a standardized set of skills
Subjects like language and mathematics were at the forefront
considered indispensable for personal and professional growth
there was a noticeable shift in pedagogical approaches
While the emphasis on mastering basic facts remained
the procedural content became more abstract and decontextualized
The practical application of these skills in daily life was often overlooked in favor of rote learning and procedural mastery
This abstract approach to mathematics trickled down to adult education as well
There was a prevailing belief that mastering abstract mathematical procedures was a prerequisite to harnessing one's mental toolkit in real-life situations
with adults learning skills that they found little to no application for in their daily lives
witnessed a seismic shift in the substantiation of basic skills
revolutionizing the landscape of arithmetic
were capable of executing a vast array of calculations
from basic arithmetic to advanced scientific computations
This technological leap posed a challenge to the traditional goals in education as the necessity to manually perform calculations diminished
This meant also that the “natural” environment to keep using and exercising the mental toolkit in carrying out procedures came under pressure because the need to master it to solve calculational problems dwindled rapidly
A discernible gap emerged between real-world practice and school curricula
While calculators and digital computation tools became ubiquitous in daily life
their use was often restricted in educational settings
In primary and most secondary education this discrepancy was kept at arms length by simply not allowing calculators or other digital calculation software in the mathematics lessons
For adult numeracy education the need to tackle this discrepancy is urgent
It simply doesn't make sense to teach adults again procedures that are not used anymore
while an abundance of challenging numeracy problems comes across in their daily life
a stark contrast is evident when we turn our gaze to the prevalent practices in adult numeracy education
The current pedagogical landscape is dominated by traditional
often emphasizing decontextualized number crunching and rigid procedural algorithms
while rooted in historical educational paradigms
seems misaligned with the dynamic demands of the contemporary world
Labeling the prevailing calculational approach as “catastrophic teaching of skills” is not an overstatement
It epitomizes an educational scenario where a skill
is incessantly drilled into learners without any tangible demonstration of its applicability outside the classroom
Such an approach not only diminishes the perceived value of the skill but also causes a disconnect between learning and real-world relevance
To foster a versatile mathematical mindset in adults
a paradigm shift in educational practices in adult numeracy education is imperative
The focus should pivot from rote calculations to the cultivation of higher-order skills that resonate with the complexities of a mathematized society
By anchoring lesson tasks in real-world scenarios and emphasizing ánd exercising higher order skills that hold tangible relevance
we can bridge the chasm between adult classrooms and practical use
ensuring that adults are well-equipped to navigate the intricacies of the modern world
The author declares that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Citation: Hoogland K (2023) The changing nature of basic skills in numeracy
Received: 13 September 2023; Accepted: 02 October 2023; Published: 20 October 2023
Copyright © 2023 Hoogland. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY)
*Correspondence: Kees Hoogland, a2Vlcy5ob29nbGFuZEBodS5ubA==
Brad has spent over 20 years in marketing and strategy helping the CEOs of the world’s largest global companies to improve their business performance and impact
He joined BCG’s Atlanta office in 2001 and left in 2004 to help start (r)evolution partners
a growth and innovation strategy firm that was acquired by Prophet in 2012
Brad returned to BCG in 2016 to servee as the Chief Operating Officer of BCG BrightHouse to help grow and scale the firm globally
Brad moved to Berlin to start and build the BCG BrightHouse business in Europe and the Middle East
He served as President and Managing Director of Europe and Middle East for BCG BrightHouse until 2021.His worked principally focused on helping BCG’s global clients to improve their business performance and impact
He has deep experience in industrial goods
Brad currently serves as the Chief Strategy & Financial Officer at Decisely
a private-equity backed insurtech company that is reinventing the ecosystem of small business employee healthcare benefits
Brad was born and raised outside Washington
He earned an MBA from the Booth School of Business at the University of Chicago and a BS in Chemical Engineering from Case Western Reserve University
Brad has served on the executive committee of the Product Development and Management Association board and has been awarded the American Marketing Association’s Marketer of the Year
Brad and his wife are the proud parents of three daughters who attend the University of Wisconsin
"13" the musical opens at the Hoogland this weekend. For tickets, go to hcfta.orgg
Silver medallist Jeffrey Hoogland (left) and gold medallist Harrie Lavreysen celebrate Dutch 1-2 after the men's Sprint race
Denmark's Julie Leth reacts after winning the women's Point race
Denmark's Tobias Aagaard Hansen on his way to gold in the men's Elimination race
Tim Torn Teutenberg and Roger Kluge of Germany win men's Madison
Tobias Aagaard Hansen wins third medal of week in rowdy men's Elimination race
Mina Sato makes it a Keirin sweep for Japan
On the fifth and final day of the 2024 UCI Track World Championships
five world titles were decided at Ballerup Super Arena outside Copenhagen
were the top two countries at Track Worlds
Great Britain added four to their talley on the final day in the women’s Points and Keirin races as well as the men’s Elimination and Madison races
Host nation Denmark took two gold medals on the fifth and final day of competition at the Ballerup Super Arena outside Copenhagen to match Great Britain and the Netherlands with four gold medals
Denmark also had two silver and a bronze to give them seven total
Belgium and Italy each earned four total medals
Harrie Lavreysen outdueled Jeffrey Hoogland in a Dutch showdown for the men's Sprint title at the 2024 UCI Track World Championships
It was Lavreysen's third gold medal of the week at the Ballerup Super Arena
and a sixth consecutive Sprint world championship
For the second time he went up against his compatriot Hoogland
who won the gold in the men's Team Sprint.
The 27-year-old Lavreysen swept both races against Hoogland
adding a 16th career gold to his world championships domination
as well as holding five Olympic gold medals
And I knew that record [of 14 world titles] could be broken one day
The Track World Championships have been held for over 100 years and have many great records and rankings
That I can top one of those lists is very special," Lavreysen told Nos.nl after the race
"I knew I had to go for the kilometre time trial at some point
Kaiya Ota (Japan) defeated last year's silver medallist Nicholas Paul (Trinidad & Tobago) and earned the bronze medal
third in the Sprint at the Tokyo Olympic Games
also was part of Japan's bronze medal finish this week in the men's Team Sprint.
Lavreysen defeated Ota in back-to-back races
while Hoogland needed a decider to move to the gold medal round ahead of Paul
It was the second round that Hoogland needed a decider round to continue
as he split races on Saturday's quarterfinals against Mikhail Yakovlev (Israel) and moved on with the decider victory by a slim 0:00:0.018 margin.
Sprint for goldPos.Rider (Country)1Harrie Lavreysen (Netherlands)2Jeffrey Hoogland (Netherlands)Swipe to scroll horizontallySprint for bronzePos.Rider name (Country)3Kaiya Ota (Japan)4Nicholas Paul (Trinidad & Tobago) Women's Points Race
Julie Leth (Denmark) won the gold medal in the women's Points race
going three points better than defending champion Lotte Kopecky (Belgium)
and finished just ahead of New Zealand's Ally Wollaston
Kopecky experienced a mechanical issue with her chain before the final sprint
which kept her from winning a third world title in the Points race (having previously won in 2021 and 2023)
The Belgian all-rounder also won the silver in the Elimination race this week
"This silver is a bit harder to accept than the one from the elimination
it is still a World Championship and it is still a medal
It was not meant to be," Kopecky said to Sporza
"It was still difficult to get 4 points back on Leth
Without the chain problem I would probably have been stranded on one point
so that would not have changed the final result."
Jennifer Valente (United States of America)
Mizuki Ikeda (Japan) and Alexandra Manly (Australia) took a lap and 20 points early in the race
Then Leth launched a lethal attack and moved into the lead with lap bonus.
Kopecky pushed the pace and could only be followed by Leth
Marit Raaijmakers (Netherlands) and Neah Evans (Great Britain)
Evans was one of the riders brought down in a crash in the final bend while Kopecky could not counter the final sprint of Leth
The 32-year-old Leth celebrated her second gold of the week
and had a special celebration with the crowd as she heads to retirement.
Denmark's Tobias Aagaard Hansen took the rainbow jersey as he outpaced two-time world champion Elia Viviani (Italy) in the men's Elimination race on Sunday
But it was far from a straightforward event
as the race saw a number of crashes as well as relegations of three riders for causing disruptions in the frenzied competition
Jules Hesters (Belgium) was removed and posted a result of 18th for "dangerous riding" in a close pass with Edibaldo Maldonado Rayas (Mexico)
Three laps later Blake Agnoletto (Australia) was relegated for causing a crash
The loudest controversy struck when Jan-Willem van Schip (Netherlands) was relegated from the final four riders and then disqualified for "improper conduct"
After Diogo Narciso (Portugal) was dismissed by Van Schip to fifth place
On the next pass with Bibic the trailing rider in fourth
the race jury ruled Van Schip as the dropped rider for "dangerous riding" when he interfered with Narciso on the previous lap
demonstrating his displeasure by cursing and directing an obscene gesture toward the UCI officials in front of the spectators
improper conduct directed at any other person"
While Van Schip's behaviour could have spoiled the event
the Danish crowd went on to celebrate Hansen's success
having been part of the gold medal Team Pursuit effort alongside Carl-Frederik Bevort
and Frederik Rodenberg Madsen and taking a silver in the Scratch race
(Image credit: Tissot Timing for UCI)Mina Sato ensured that Japan could lay claim to both Keirin world titles at this year’s Track Worlds following Kento Yamasaki’s victory in the men’s race earlier this week
Sato took the gold when she came out from the wheel of sprint champion Emma Finucane
the British rider leading the way into the final lap of the race
Sato sped around the outside as she launched her bid for glory
She edged around the outside of the final corner to nip into the lead with perfect timing to take home the rainbow jersey by a bike length
Hetty van de Wouw (Netherlands) also managed to make her way past Finucane
just getting past metres ahead of the finish line for the silver.
Katy Marchant (Great Britain) was another late mover
also nudging past Finucane in a photo finish to claim bronze
Sato’s win is her first at the Track Worlds following silver medals in 2021 and 2022
This year she has won the UCI Nations Cup and Japan Track Cup
meaning the world title rounds out an incredibly successful season
The wins from Yamasaki and Sato mark the first Keirin world titles for Japan since 1987
when Harumi Honda won the men’s title in Vienna
Germany scored victory in the men’s Madison as Tim Torn Teutenberg and Roger Kluge took home rainbow jerseys ahead of Belgium and Denmark in the final event of the Track World Championships on Sunday
The Germans finished with 76 points to Belgium’s 60
Denmark narrowly missed out on the silver medal with 59 points
while Portugal finished in fourth on 53 points
and 22-year-old Teutenberg were among the early leaders in the event along with Portuguese brothers Ivo and Rui Oliveira
Belgian pair Lindsay De Vylder and Fabio Van den Bossche and the Danish duo Niklas Larsen and Michael Mørkøv were forced into catch-up mode
winning sprints along the way in order to try and close the points gap
The podium squads were up front in the hunt for points at the midway stage
with Dutch pairing Yoeri Havik and Vincent Hoppezak and Portugal also in the mix
extending their lead and avoiding pressure from other teams to ensure they enjoyed a good lead heading into the final phase
The battle that remained was over silver and bronze and it came down to the death as Belgium surged ahead at the last sprint
picking up four points to Denmark’s two and nabbing second place
I always dreamed of becoming world champion and now it’s real,” Teutenberg said after the race before Kluge spoke about their age difference
and bouncing back from the disappointment of coming fifth at the Paris Olympics
age doesn’t matter,” Kluge said
“He’s young but he’s been a working professional for years already
We had two days of preparation at home to get clear about our tactics
even if I didn’t have the signs on Friday that it could go this well
“Madison is a special race and I’m happy I could show off that I still have the legs to go for it
In Paris we were very unlucky and I’m happy that we could finish off the season here.”
a sports marketing and public relations agency
which managed projects for Tour de Georgia
a Georgia non-profit to promote safe cycling
She is proud to have worked in professional baseball for six years - from selling advertising to pulling the tarp for several minor league teams
She has climbed l'Alpe d'Huez three times (not fast)
Her favorite road and gravel rides are around horse farms in north Georgia (USA) and around lavender fields in Provence (France)
Get ready for a scorching Summer of Sport as TNT Sports brings fans well over 3,000 hours of live action this May
June and July from across the nation’s favourite sporting events
tournaments and championships to fans across the UK and Ireland
marked Earth Month by spotlighting some of the key initiatives that form part of its 2025 Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) strategy
Discovery Sports Europe will oversee promotion and distribution for the Golden Trail World Series circuit as part of a multi-year partnership
A record-breaking 41 permanent teams are set for action when the 2025 FIM Endurance World Championship fires up in France next week
The French equipment brand signs five-year deal as the Official Bicycle Shoe Supplier and also becomes the official partner for its home UCI World Cup round of Les Gets
Iconic Japanese bicycle components manufacturer signs four-year deal as the Official Drivetrain & Electric Drive Unit Components partner
New AI technology platform transforms storytelling capabilities for WHOOP UCI Mountain Bike World Series coverage
enhancing the viewer experience through data-driven insights
Discovery (WBD) Sports Europe agrees new partnership with the International Federation of Sport Climbing (IFSC) to broadcast all IFSC World Cup and World Championship events until 2028
outdoor and lifestyle brands make their collective TV and multi-platform sponsorship debut
The Union Cycliste Internationale (UCI) and its partner Warner Bros
Discovery (WBD) Sports confirm that the UCI Track Champions League was held for the last time in 2024
the UCI Track Nations Cup will be revitalised from 2026
UK - Tom Daley: 1.6 Seconds tells the incredible life story of five-time Olympic medallist Tom Daley OBE in a new collaboration between Warner Bros
Set to premiere on discovery+ in the UK and Ireland early June
broadcast on Really and TNT Sports later that month
the feature documentary film explores the remarkable journey of one of Great Britain’s most iconic athletes
| Privacy Notice
| Cookies & Tracking Technologies Notice
via the web service Clipsource ("Service")
a tool for visitors and registered users ("User") to use the videos
texts and other information ("Materials") from the Service for publication or personal consumption
This agreement regulates the conditions around the User's use of the Service and Materials from the Service
The Service includes search and monitoring and playback
embedding and downloading of Materials from businesses
organizations and others ("Sources") via clipsource.se or clipsource.com
Via the Service Sources can choose to publish Material to integrated external sites like Press rooms
Usage of Material from these sites are regulated by each sites terms and conditions
The User undertakes to use the Material for editorial purposes only
The User agrees to fully comply with the Sources restrictions to use the Material
The User undertakes not to reveal login information for the Service to any third party
Clipsource AB may at any time terminate the User's account on the Service
Clipsource AB is not responsible for direct or indirect damages or other problems related to errors in the Material
non-delivery or late delivery of the Material
Clipsource AB is not responsible for any Material provided by a Source
All Sources have signed agreements with Clipsource in which they declare that they are responsible for the content
The Service is usually in operation 24 hours per day
Clipsource AB does not warrant that the Service is free of errors or disturbances
The User hereby acknowledges and consents that Clipsource AB may store and use his or her personal data to manage the Users account and to provide logs of the use to the Sources. The data can also be used to alert the user of new Material. For further information please see our Privacy Policy
These Terms shall be construed in accordance with Swedish law
becoming the first team to ride 750m in less than 41 seconds
it's close to the Netherlands,” said Hoogland
and then going under 41 seconds is amazing."
Van den Berg got off to a flying start over the first 250m
nearly leaving his team-mates outside his draft
setting up an ideal second lap for the Dutch trio
gradually increasing his speed and building a larger gap for Hoogland to utilise in the final lap
Hoogland took over from Lavreysen at the 500m mark
speeding away to a world record and Olympic gold medal
"When I crossed the line after two laps
He added: “I was already smiling on my bike before he finished
Team GB couldn’t match the sheer speed of the Netherlands
riding to the finish line in a time of 41.814 to claim the silver medal
they were more than pleased to finish with the silver medal
We had that in the tank if we executed well," said Carlin
"It's not easy to come to your first Olympic Games
Australia won a tight battle against hosts France in the bronze-medal match to claim the final spot on the podium with a time of 41.597
"It was a really hard one, and a challenging one," said Richardson. "I could not even be prouder of the team that I am riding with and it shows the heart that we put into that final ride, switching it up last minute without any preparations."
The crowd saluted the effort of the French riders, who raced to fourth in a time of 41.993 seconds.
🥇","event":null,"destination_url":"","entry_point_tag":"base","entry_point_type":"instory_campaign"}" data-tracking="click" href="https://www.olympics.com/en/sign-in?entry_point_type=instory_campaign&entry_point_tag=base&template=base&origin=https%3A%2F%2Folympics.com%2Fen%2Folympic-channel" target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer">Olympic Membership - Free Live Stream Sports & Original Series - join now
Say a little prayer for audiences at “Late Nite Catechism” at the Hoogland Center for the Arts this Sunday afternoon
This long-running comedy play and participatory theater takes audience members back
The Sister teaches a catechism class to a roomful of students
The show was written in 1993 and popular Chicago actress Mary Zentmyer has played the role for 26 years
This will be the third time HCFTA has brought Zentmyer as Sister to the arts center
“We presented ‘Late Nite Catechism’ in 2016 and the sequel
Both productions were huge hits for the Hoogland
The shows have toured around the country with different performers
but Mary really struck a nerve with our local audiences
She is so quick-witted and funny as Sister
“There is a large Catholic community in central Illinois,” Gordon continued
“and this show reminds them all of their days in Catholic school
The nuns and priests we've had in the audience frequently laugh the loudest
But that doesn't mean this is a show that only Catholics will find funny
People of all denominations find this show hilarious.”
Sister goes from being a compassionate instructor rewarding the “students” for correct answers with items like glow-in-the-dark rosaries and laminated saint cards to an authoritative instructor
These abrupt swings may strike a resonant chord among those who survived the ups and downs of going to school with an all-knowing authoritarian at the head of the class
appealed to her with the comic approach to religion
and the show was funny but not disrespectful
“Having been raised Catholic with a great aunt who was a Sister of Providence and a great uncle who was a Passionist Father
I grew up with an Irish-Catholic mother and am the baby of six children
so this acting role fulfilled that dream with no lesson plans to do
classes as an elementary school kid and being taught by the school sisters of St
Francis at Alvernia High School on the Northwest Side of Chicago have all prepared me for this role.”
Zentmyer appreciates the Sister’s no-nonsense approach to everything
but strict and tough — all qualities necessary when you have more than 50 students to teach in one classroom
There were no teacher's assistants — just one nun.”
You do not have to be Catholic to "get it," Zentmyer said
You will find it even funnier if you attended Catholic School and remember the good Sisters.” In this scripted yet somewhat improvisational play
the audience becomes part of the cast called upon to answer pop quiz questions and share stories if they wish
and you will hear other stories of your fellow 'classmates’ nun memories or ruler-whacking stories
Some of the funniest moments are the true stories that the audience members share
“There's a reason why people keep coming back to Sister's Class,” Zentmyer added
and listen to stories about these hard-working
and throw a few bucks into the basket after class
and it will go directly to real retired nuns
who took a Vow of Poverty and kept you in line all those years ago.”
More information: Visit www.hcfta.org or call 217-523-2787
You don't have permission to access the page you requested.
What is this page?The website you are visiting is protected.For security reasons this page cannot be displayed.
Method: Regional and cellular dystrophin distribution was evaluated in both human and rat hippocampi and in rat cerebellar tissue by immunofluorescent colocalization with neuronal (NeuN and calbindin) and glial (GFAP) markers. In addition, hippocampal dystrophin levels were estimated by Western blot analysis in biopsies from TLE patients, post-mortem controls, amygdala kindled (AK)-, and control rats.
Conclusion: Dystrophin is ubiquitously expressed by astrocytes in the human and rat hippocampus and in the rat cerebellum. Hippocampal full-length dystrophin (Dp427) levels are upregulated in human TLE, but not in AK rats, possibly indicating a compensatory mechanism in the chronic epileptic human brain.
Volume 10 - 2016 | https://doi.org/10.3389/fncel.2016.00174
Objective: Dystrophin is part of a protein complex that connects the cytoskeleton to the extracellular matrix
it functions as an anchoring protein within the central nervous system such as in hippocampus and cerebellum
Its presence in the latter regions is illustrated by the cognitive problems seen in Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy (DMD)
Since epilepsy is also supposed to constitute a comorbidity of DMD
it is hypothesized that dystrophin plays a role in neuronal excitability
we aimed to study brain dystrophin distribution and expression in both
human and experimental temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE)
Method: Regional and cellular dystrophin distribution was evaluated in both human and rat hippocampi and in rat cerebellar tissue by immunofluorescent colocalization with neuronal (NeuN and calbindin) and glial (GFAP) markers
hippocampal dystrophin levels were estimated by Western blot analysis in biopsies from TLE patients
Results: Dystrophin was expressed in all hippocampal pyramidal subfields and in the molecular-
suggesting expression in astrocytes such as Bergmann glia (BG) and velate protoplasmic astrocytes
In rat hippocampus and cerebellum there were neither differences in dystrophin positive cell types
nor in the regional dystrophin distribution between AK and control animals
hippocampal full-length dystrophin (Dp427) levels were about 60% higher in human TLE patients than in post-mortem controls (p < 0.05)
whereas the level of the shorter Dp71 isoform did not differ
AK animals showed similar dystrophin levels as controls
Conclusion: Dystrophin is ubiquitously expressed by astrocytes in the human and rat hippocampus and in the rat cerebellum
Hippocampal full-length dystrophin (Dp427) levels are upregulated in human TLE
possibly indicating a compensatory mechanism in the chronic epileptic human brain
its potential theoretical relation with epileptogenesis is hard to speculate upon and hence this isoform will not be further discussed in this paper
to evaluate regional and cellular dystrophin distribution in the aforementioned two anatomical brain regions by means of immunofluorescence and
to assess whether there were quantitative differences in dystrophin expression between epileptic and control individuals by means of Western blot analysis
All procedures performed in studies involving human participants were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institutional and/or national research committee and with the 1964 Helsinki declaration and its later amendments or comparable ethical standards
Written informed consent was obtained from all individual participants included in the study
and/or institutional guidelines for the care and use of animals were followed
All procedures performed in studies involving animals were in accordance with the ethical standards of the institution or practice at which the studies were conducted
Netherlands) were kept under controlled conditions (21 ± 2°C ambient temperature
background noise provided by radio and food and water available ad libitum)
The animals were habituated 1 week to the experimenter and the housing before the start of the experiment
All experimental procedures were approved by the local animal ethics committee of Maastricht University and complied with national and international governmental legislation
Also one stainless screw was implanted over the nasal sinus
The connector was fixed on the skull using dental acrylic cement
Amygdala kindling started 10 days after the electrode implantation and was performed as described previously (Aalbers et al., 2009, 2014; Rijkers et al., 2010)
stimulation was performed twice daily (first stimulus between 8 and 10 AM
second stimulus between 2 and 4 PM; an interstimulus-interval > 6 h) with the following parameters: 2 s
A stimulus intensity of 400 μA was chosen to assure that the intensity was above the after discharge threshold for all rats
Stimuli were delivered through a WPI Accupulser A310 connected to a WPI Stimulus Isolation Unit A360 (World Precision Instruments
All rats were videotaped (Olympus FE-330) during delivery of the kindling stimulus and for as long as the behavioral seizure lasted. Seizure severity was evaluated offline from video-recordings by two blinded observers and classified according to the Racine scale (Racine et al., 1972)
defined as five consecutive stage five seizures
rats received one AK-stimulation per day for two more weeks
Sham rats (N = 8) received an amygdala electrode that was not stimulated
are further described in the respective sections
Clinical characteristics of subjects used for Western blotting analysis
Immediately after surgical resection, the hippocampi were cooled for 1 min at 4°C 0.9% saline and then dissected into two parts perpendicular to the longitudinal axis. One part was fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde overnight at 4°C, embedded in paraffin, and used for routine histopathological evaluation. The other part was immediately frozen on dry ice and stored at -80°C until further analysis (Aalbers et al., 2014)
rats were sacrificed and processed for immunofluorescence as described previously
Rats received an overdose of pentobarbital (Nembutal
0.1 mg/kg body weight) and were then trans-cardially perfused with 0.5 M ice cold phosphate buffered saline (PBS) followed by 4% paraformaldehyde in 0.5 M PBS
Brains were dissected and post-fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde/0.5 M PBS for 90 min
brains were cryoprotected by immersion in 20% sucrose/0.5 M PBS for 24 h
the brains were frozen by immersion in -40°C isopentane for 3 min and stored at -80°C until further analysis by immunofluorescence
50 μm sagital sections of the right cerebellum (50 μm
free floating) and coronal sections of the left hippocampus (30 μm
free floating) were serially cut using a cryostat
Free-floating sections were successively incubated at room temperature for 30 min in 1 M tris-buffered saline (TBS)
and 10% normal donkey serum (NDS) for 60 min
sections were incubated overnight at 4°C in TBS containing 0.5% Triton X-100 and 10% NDS - for NeuN (neuronal nuclei) in hippocampus - or PBS - for GFAP (glial fibrillary acidic protein) and calbindin in cerebellum and GFAP in hippocampus -
and rabbit polyclonal anti-dystrophin (Abcam
followed by donkey anti-rabbit secondary antibody conjugated to Alexa 488 (Invitrogen
sections were incubated overnight with monoclonal mouse anti-calbindin D-28k (SWANT
diluted 1:25,000) as a marker for PC or with monoclonal mouse anti-GFAP (Sigma-Aldrich
Hippocampal tissue was also stained with monoclonal mouse anti-GFAP (Sigma-Aldrich
diluted 1:500) and additionally with monoclonal mouse NeuN (Millipore
diluted 1:50) as a marker for neuronal nuclei
Primary antibodies were detected by donkey anti-mouse secondary antibody conjugated with Alexa 594 (Invitrogen
USA) staining (1:500) was performed at room temperature and after washing
the sections were coverslipped with 80% glycerol
Negative controls were incubated with non-immune serum
Rat biceps femoris muscle sections were used as a positive control for dystrophin immunofluorescence
Additionally we performed triple staining - due to the unclear subcellular localisation of the dystrophin protein in the cerebellar sections - with the following primary anti-bodies: rabbit anti-dystrophin (Abcam
monoclonal mouse anti-calbindin D-28k (SWANT
diluted 1:2,500) and polyclonal goat anti- GFAP (Santa Cruz Biotechnology
All primary antibodies were diluted in 1% NDS in 0.5% PBS-T and simultaneously incubated at 4°C for 16 h after blocking for 1 h with 10% NDS
Secondary antibodies used were: Donkey anti-mouse secondary antibody conjugated to Alexa 647 (Abcam
donkey anti-rabbit secondary antibody conjugated to Alexa 488 (Abcam
donkey anti-goat secondary antibody conjugated to Alexa 594 (Invitrogen
All secondary antibodies were diluted in 1% NDS in 0.5% PBS-T and simultaneously incubated at room temperature for 2 h
Paraffin-embedded human hippocampal sections of 4 μm were cut in a coronal plane and directly mounted on glass
followed by antigen-retrieval (0.01 M citric acid in a water bath of 95°C for 20 min
Sections were immunohistochemically stained as described above using the following antibody concentrations: rabbit anti-dystrophin (1:100)
Photomicrographic images were made using a BX51-microscope (Olympus
Japan) connected to an Olympus XC10 camera (Olympus
Images were taken with different exposure times for the different fluorophores
Exposure times were kept constant among all sections
thereby only being filter-specific (DAPI/Hoechst 1 ms
confocal 1 μm space stacks were made of neuronal and glial cells in hippocampal sections (600 times magnification)
PC in cerebellar sections (1000 times magnification
not shown) and the cerebellar triple staining (400 times magnification) by means of a confocal disk spinning unit microscope (Olympus
Japan) financed by The Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (grant number 911-06-003)
all pictures were taken from the GCL of the DG
right-side hippocampi were isolated by dissection and frozen at -80°C until further analysis
The right side was chosen since this is contralateral to the stimulation site
hence preventing potential confounding by the effects of direct electrical stimulation
rat and human) was separately homogenized in lysis buffer (1 g tissue per 9 ml lysis buffer) containing 0.01 M PBS
1 mM EGTA (ethylene glycol tetraacetic acid)
1 mM EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid)
and protease inhibitor (Roche Custom Biotech
For the limited amount of rat cerebellar tissue available (sham control and AK acute group; both N = 4)
proteins were extracted from paraformaldehyde fixed sections using an extraction buffer kit according to the manufacturer’s instructions (Qiagen
Optical density values were normalized to glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH)
detected by mouse monoclonal anti-GAPDH primary (Fitzgerald Industries International
diluted 1:2,000,000) and donkey anti-mouse IRDye 680RD (LI-COR
Quantified blot intensities were averaged of at least two independent experiments (and thus two or more samples per animal) within groups and were expressed as the mean + SEM
These values were then used to calculate group averages
In order to evaluate the effect of kindling on dystrophin expression
we compared levels of sham and kindled animals by a Mann-Whitney U test
To compare the acute effect with the long-lasting effect of a seizure on dystrophin expression in the hippocampus
we compared rats that were sacrificed 2 and 24 h after a seizure by
we corrected the alpha of 0.05 by Bonferroni to 0.025
we compared dystrophin levels in epileptic and non-epileptic tissue
In order to assess the influence of neuronal cell loss and gliosis
we also evaluated the difference in dystrophin expression between epileptic patients with and without HS
Dystrophin distribution was studied in rat hippocampus and rat cerebellum. A general overview of these examined anatomical regions is depicted in Figure 1 by means of low-power images
Immunofluorescent overview staining of rat hippocampus (A) and rat cerebellum (B) in order to evaluate dystrophin expression in an animal model for TLE
consisting of the GCL is stained purple due to colocalization between NeuN (red) and Hoechst (blue) and is surrounded by dystrophin (green) positive astrocytes and blood vessels through all different hippocampal layers
(B) The three cerebellar layers can be clearly distinguished: from right to left note the completely red MCL as a consequence of densely packed PC processes
the PCL as visualized by the calbindin (red) antibody
and finally the GCL which mainly consists of dystrophin (green) positive cells and blood vessels
The regional and cellular distribution of dystrophin did not differ between sham control and AK rats
H&E-staining of (dorsal) hippocampus of a sham rat (A) and AK rat (B)
granular cell dispersion or pyramidal cell loss) could be noted
Immunofluorescent staining of dystrophin distribution in rat hippocampus
Double staining for dystrophin (green) and GFAP (red) (magnification 400 times) reveals colocalization (yellow signal) of GFAP and dystrophin in rat hippocampal sections of a control rat (A) and a similar colocalization pattern of GFAP and dystrophin is present in the hippocampus of AK rats (acute condition) (B)
No colocalization is present in the double-labeled immunofluorescent staining for dystrophin (green) and NeuN (red) (magnification 200 times) in and around the pyramidal cell layer of the CA3 region in sham rat tissue (C) nor in AK (acute) rat (D)
There is also no colocalization between dystrophin (green) and NeuN (red) (magnification 400 times) in the hilus between the DG and CA3 in control rat hippocampus (E) or AK (acute) rat hippocampus (F)
(G,H) (sub)cellular distribution of dystrophin in rat hippocampus (DG) as visualized by confocal microscopy (magnification 600 times)
(G) One micrometer spacing stack through the hippocampus of a sham rat stained for dystrophin (green) and GFAP (red)
white arrowheads indicate dystrophin positive
(H) One micrometer spacing stack through the hippocampus of a sham rat stained for dystrophin (green) and NeuN (red)
black arrowheads indicate dystrophin positive (perivascular) astrocyte-like cells
Asterisks indicate dystrophin positive blood vessels
AK = Amygdala Kindled rat (here: acute AK rat; i.e.
Dystrophin distribution in rat cerebellum (sagital sections)
(A) Sham rat section stained for dystrophin (green) and GFAP (red)
(B) AK (acute) rat section stained for dystrophin and GFAP
Note the colocalization between GFAP and dystrophin (in both A,B)
which are extending from the molecular layer and surround the PC
There is also co-expression in the GCL between GFAP and dystrophin
thereby possibly reflecting dystrophin positive velate protoplasmic astrocytes (white arrowheads)
(C) Dystrophin (green) and calbindin (red) expression in sham rat cerebellum
(D) Dystrophin and calbindin expression in the cerebellum of an (acute) AK rat
There is no clear co-expression of dystrophin with calbindin positive PC in (C,D)
(E) Triple staining in sham/control rat tissue with dystrophin (red)
and calbindin (gray) visualized by means of confocal microscopy
solely performed in order to assess which cell types here express dystrophin
Dystrophin is visible in blood vessels and in BG (indicated by white arrowheads)
both around the PC - where the soma of the BG is located - but also in the processes within the MCL
Calbindin is depicted in gray and stains the PC as such
Note the presence of multiple blood vessels in all three layers of all images
AK = Amygdala Kindled animal (here: acute AK rat; i.e.
It should be noted that the dystrophin distribution pattern was similar for sclerotic and non-sclerotic patients
therefore no visual distinction could be made and hence only the images of an epileptic
Immunofluorescence of dystrophin distribution in human hippocampus of a post-mortem control patient (A,C,E) and a TLE patient without sclerosis (B,D,F)
(A) NeuN (red) in the GCL of the DG without dystrophin (green) positive astroglial-like cells in post mortem control tissue
none of these NeuN positive cells are stained yellow and are therefore dystrophin negative
(B) NeuN staining revealing NeuN (red) in the GCL of the DG and many dystrophin (green) positive astroglial-like cells in the hippocampus (DG) of a TLE patient
(C) GFAP (red) but not dystrophin (green) positive astrocytes (indicated by means of black arrowheads) around the DG in the hippocampus of a post-mortem control patient
(D) Dystrophin positive astrocytes around the DG of an epileptic hippocampus
double stained for dystrophin (green) and GFAP (red)
(E) 400 times magnified close-up of the DG of a post-mortem control patient
The white arrowhead indicates a glial cell that reveals some colocalization between GFAP (red) and dystrophin (green)
whilst the black arrowheads indicate none colocalizing astrocytes
(F) 400 times magnified close-up of an area within the DG of a TLE patient
glial cells that show (yellow) colocalization between GFAP (red) and dystrophin (green)
Western blotting demonstrated that the full-length isoform (Dp427), Dp140, and Dp71 are expressed in the hippocampus and cerebellum of AK rats (see Figures 6C,F and 7C for a typical example)
Mean values of relative dystrophin expression in hippocampus and cerebellum of sham and AK rats (SEM’s are indicated with whiskers)
(A) Dp427 expression in sham rats (N = 8) versus acute AK (N = 7) and chronic AK rats (N = 8)
(B) Dp71 expression in again sham rats (N = 8) versus acute AK (N = 8) and chronic AK (N = 8) rats
(C) An example of the performed Western blot technique for dystrophin (in green) in rat hippocampus
The different isoform bands as well as the GAPDH bands (red) are indicated
(D) Dp427 expression in the cerebellum of sham rats (N = 4) versus (acute) AK rats (N = 4)
(E) Dp71 expression in again sham rats (N = 4) and (acute) AK rats (N = 4)
(F) Typical example of Western blot performed in cerebellum
A = acute AK rat (sacrificed 2 h after last seizure)
C = chronic AK rat (sacrificed 24 h after last seizure)
Mean values of relative dystrophin expression in the hippocampus of patients operated for therapy-resistant TLE by means of neurosurgical removal of the hippocampus
compared to post-mortem controls (SEM’s are indicated with whiskers)
(A) Dp427 expression in post-mortem controls (N = 8) versus epilepsy patients
both with severe sclerosis and without sclerosis (total N = 15)
∗Significant at alpha < 0.025
(B) Dp71 expression in again hippocampus from post-mortem control patients (N = 9) and in hippocampus from all patients included with TLE (i.e.
with and without severe sclerosis; N = 15)
(C) Example of Western blot performed in human hippocampus tissue; it is interesting to note the aspecific dystrophin (green) bands
Abbreviations in panel C: W = without/no sclerosis
p = 0.343 for Dp427 and p = 0.686 for Dp71)
the post-mortem delay time was minimized (average time ± SEM = 1112 ± 175 min)
dystrophin expression intensity did not correlate with post-mortem delay (Pearson’s R = 0.28
p = 0.47); hence the post-mortem delay did not influence the analysis
Dp427 expression was on average 59.8% higher (SEM post-mortem control group: 10.7%; SEM pooled epilepsy group: 26.9%) in TLE patients (N = 15; p = 0.023), whereas Dp71 expression was not significantly increased in epileptic patients (+8.4%; p = 0.682; Figure 7)
there was no statistically significant difference in dystrophin expression between severely sclerotic and non-sclerotic hippocampi from TLE patients (data not shown
p-values of 0.689 and 0.955 for Dp427 and Dp71
we evaluated the hippocampal and cerebellar distribution of dystrophin in TLE patients and in an animal model of TLE (I) qualitatively by means of immunofluorescence in order to assess both the regional and cellular distribution pattern
and (II) quantitatively by means of Western blot analysis
We have shown that dystrophin is expressed in different types of glial cells in multiple layers of both the hippocampus and the cerebellum
no expression of dystrophin in neuronal cells – like granular cells in the hippocampus or PC in the cerebellum – was found
the dystrophin distribution pattern did not seem to differ between sham control and AK conditions
the amount of dystrophin expression was not different between control and kindled animals
In human hippocampi from TLE patients there was
a significant increase in the amount of Dp427 when pooling all TLE samples
we checked for auto-fluorescence by microscopic evaluation of unstained sections
The contradicting effect of up- and downregulation within the same structure might have led to a net difference of approximately zero
which may explain the results in our study in which a homogenate of the full hippocampus was evaluated
we could not detect any major regional differences by visual inspection of the immunofluorescent stained rat hippocampus sections
The dystrophin increase (here: only Dp427) in epileptic hippocampi could theoretically be explained as a compensatory upregulatory mechanism. Dp427 and Dp71 have powerful effects on excitation by clustering of postsynaptic GABAA-receptors (Brünig et al., 2002) and astrocytic AQP-4 and Kir4.1 channels (Connors et al., 2004; Perronnet and Vaillend, 2010), respectively, (Hendriksen et al., 2015)
thereby illustrating another relation with (hyper) excitation and consequently TLE
mutation dependent; a more distal mutation affects more brain isoforms and would thus give rise to multiple deficient counteracting mechanisms (i.e.
hence increasing the probability of hyperexcitable brain (networks) and thereby epilepsy
The discrepancy between human and experimental TLE data regarding dystrophin expression is interesting. Possibly, this can be explained by the presence of neuronal cell loss and gliosis in human TLE, which is absent in AK since this model is not characterized by neurodegeneration (Brandt et al., 2004). Indeed, Heuser et al. (2012) demonstrated a difference in dystrophin immunoreactivity in epilepsy patients with and without hippocampal sclerosis
in this study we did not find such a difference in dystrophin expression between these two groups
Another possible explanation is that in humans
the tissue from which the seizure originated was evaluated
while in rats the contralateral hippocampus was used in order to exclude the influence of direct electrical stimulation
all human patients suffered from chronic and intractable epilepsy that has been tried to manage for years before epilepsy surgery was performed
The compensatory mechanisms hypothesized above may only develop over years in-vivo
and not after the relatively short period (i.e.
the full-length isoform was based on immunofluorescence neither visualized in cerebellum nor in hippocampus
for ethical reasons we were not able to include human cerebellar tissue in this study
cerebellar rat tissue was treated differently in the Western blot procedure since it was paraformaldehyde fixed
As the material from the experimental AK group has been treated in the same way
this should not have affected the relative difference between the two groups
the two groups included in the analysis of the cerebellum are small
the average age of the post-mortem control patients was – logically – substantially higher than the average age of the epilepsy patients
which could have influenced the quantitative expression of neuronal proteins
Future research should focus on studying dystrophin expression in different brain areas in order to better understand the possible association between hyperexcitation and dystrophin alterations
since this relation has only been marginally addressed in literature
Conversely the role of dystrophin in (hyper)excitation should be further evaluated using animal models in which different dystrophin isoforms are absent
ideally by making use of electrical kindling techniques
such as in this study applied and which has not been studied before
future studies should disentangle the possible contribution of the different dystrophin isoforms to epileptogenesis in order to assess possibilities for new anti-epileptic therapies
Dystrophin is ubiquitously expressed in the hippocampus and cerebellum of AK rats and in human hippocampal tissue from epilepsy patients with and without HS as proven by Western blot and immunofluorescent analysis in this study
which principal function in the brain it is to anchor GABAA receptors in the post-synaptic membrane
is increased in human epileptic hippocampi
possibly as a compensatory mechanism in order to restore the inhibitory balance in hyperexcitable brains
This is the first study that reports on a (full-length) dystrophin upregulation in epilepsy
which justifies more research in order to further investigate this newly emerging relationship between hyperexcitation and dystrophin
Future studies should address how the different brain dystrophin isoforms are related to hyperexcitation
in what direction this relationship may be established and
whether dystrophin may represent a novel target for seizure treatment
All authors agree to be accountable for the content of the work
RH and MA performed the statistical analysis
MA obtained the animal tissue used in this study
OS and JD obtained the human tissue used in this study
MA and GH supervised the laboratory experiments
after which all authors substantially contributed to obtain the final version
JV initiated this research project and furthermore supervised and guided the collective research process
The authors would like to thank Dr. F. van Leeuwen for the calbindin antibodies, H. E. Steinbusch for the microscopy and staining assistance, E. Yeung for optimizing the double staining protocol and I. D. Reis for the assistance with the triple staining. Finally, the authors would like to refer to the following conference paper: Aalbers et al. (2014)
fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography; GABAA
The influence of neuropathology on brain inflammation in human and experimental temporal lobe epilepsy
Horner’s syndrome: a complication of experimental carotid artery surgery in rats
Subcellular localization of Dp71 dystrophin isoforms in cultured hippocampal neurons and forebrain astrocytes
Google Scholar
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Brain function in Duchenne muscular dystrophy
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
“Duchenne muscular dystrophy and brain function,” in Muscular Dystrophy
Google Scholar
Dystrophin quantification: biological and translational research implications
Expression and synthesis of alternatively spliced variants of Dp71 in adult human brain
Interference filter microfluorometry of neuromelanin and lipofuscin in human brain
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Loss of Dp140 regulatory sequences is associated with cognitive impairment in dystrophinopathies
Different dystrophin-like complexes are expressed in neurons and glia
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
The neurobiology of Duchenne muscular dystrophy: learning lessons from muscle
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Recurrent seizures and hippocampal sclerosis following intrahippocampal kainate injection in adult mice: electroencephalography
histopathology and synaptic reorganization similar to mesial temporal lobe epilepsy
Epilepsy induced by extended amygdala-kindling in rats: lack of clear association between development of spontaneous seizures and neuronal damage
GABAergic terminals are required for postsynaptic clustering of dystrophin but not of GABAA receptors and gephyrin
Google Scholar
Expression of the murine Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene in muscle and brain
CrossRef Full Text
The potassium channel Kir4.1 associates with the dystrophin-glycoprotein complex via α-syntrophin in glia
Single section Western blot: improving the molecular diagnosis of the muscular dystrophies
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Intelligence and Duchenne muscular dystrophy: full-scale
Role of mental retardation-associated dystrophin-gene product dp71 in excitatory synapse organization
synaptic plasticity and behavioural functions
Hippocampal tissue of patients with refractory temporal lobe epilepsy is associated with astrocyte activation
and altered expression of channels and receptors
Loss of perivascular aquaporin 4 may underlie deficient water and K+ homeostasis in the human epileptogenic hippocampus
Google Scholar
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Epilepsy in boys with Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy
Google Scholar
Epilepsy in Duchenne and Becker muscular dystrophies
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Kainate-evoked changes in dystrophin messenger RNA levels in the rat hippocampus
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
GABAergic miniature spontaneous activity is increased in the CA1 hippocampal region of dystrophic mdx mice
Are males with Duchenne muscular dystrophy at risk for reading disabilities
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Neuropsychiatric disorders in males with duchenne muscular dystrophy: frequency rate of attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)
A possible role of dystrophin in neuronal excitability: a review of the current literature
Loss of perivascular Kir4.1 potassium channels in the sclerotic hippocampus of patients with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy
Recent developments in the understanding of astrocyte function in the cerebellum in vivo
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Localization of dystrophin in the Purkinje cells of normal mice
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Astroglial loss and edema formation in the rat piriform cortex and hippocampus following pilocarpine-induced status epilepticus
Alterations in dystrophin and utrophin expression parallel the reorganization of GABAergic synapses in a mouse model of temporal lobe eplilepsy
Definition of drug resistant epilepsy: consensus proposal by the ad hoc Task Force of the ILAE Commission on Therapeutic Strategies
A 71-kilodalton protein is a major product of the Duchenne muscular dystrophy gene in brain and other nonmuscle tissues
Aquaporin-4 is increased in the sclerotic hippocampus in human temporal lobe epilepsy
The distribution of dystrophin in the murine central nervous system: an immunocytochemical study
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Dp140: a novel 140 kDa CNS transcript from the dystrophin locus
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Dystroglycan contributes to the formation of multiple dystrophin-like complexes in brain
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and cognitive function in Duchenne muscular dystrophy: phenotype-genotype correlation
Google Scholar
and associated scaffolding complexes: role in mammalian brain and implications for therapeutic strategies
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Epileptiform activity and neural plasticity in limbic structures
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
and behavioural problems in Duchenne muscular dystrophy in relation to underlying dystrophin gene mutations
Acute seizure-suppressing effect of vagus nerve stimulation in the amygdala kindled rat
Reduction of lipofuscin-like autofluorescence in fluorescently labeled tissue
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
The functional organization of the hippocampal dentate gyrus and its relevance to the pathogenesis of temporal lobe epilepsy
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Neuropsychological and neurobehavioral functioning in Duchenne muscular dystrophy: a review
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Increased density of dystrophin protein in the lateral versus the vermal mouse cerebellum
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Connexin43 and bergmann glial gap junctions in cerebellar function
Defined methodology for reliable quantification of Western blot data
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Increasing complexity of the dystrophin-associated protein complex
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
[Central nervous system neuromodulation for the treatment of epilepsy]
The dystrophin-glycoprotein complex in brain development and disease
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Aalbers MW and Vles JSH (2016) Dystrophin Distribution and Expression in Human and Experimental Temporal Lobe Epilepsy
Copyright © 2016 Hendriksen, Schipper, Hoogland, Schijns, Dings, Aalbers and Vles. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY)
provided the original author(s) or licensor are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited
*Correspondence: Ruben G. F. Hendriksen, aGVuZHJpa3Nlbi5ydWJlbkBnbWFpbC5jb20=
†These authors have contributed equally to this work.
A two-phase research framework was adopted to address this inquiry. A comprehensive literature review was conducted to discern the prevalent challenges regarding numeracy awareness. Subsequently, two illustrative case studies were undertaken in Slovenia and Spain to contrast and deliberate upon the insights derived from the literature review. Qualitative research methods were employed to engage in a nuanced exploration of the gathered data.
This empirical analysis deduced guidelines aimed at enhancing awareness and ameliorating some of these challenges.
We conclude that making visible the awareness that adults already have about numeracy in aspects of their lives, such as finance, health, or the use and critical interpretation of data, can give policymakers and curriculum developers clues to design effective numeracy programs to address the multifaceted challenges confronting contemporary society, both in the immediate and foreseeable future.
Volume 8 - 2023 | https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2023.1295781
Introduction: The contemporary scientific literature indicates that numeracy is a multifaceted concept
The ongoing societal and technological transformations underscore the imperative to re-evaluate the attributes characterizing a numerate individual and the strategic initiatives that policymakers should devise and implement to ensure that individuals are not marginalized from participation in public and private domains due to their lack of numeracy proficiency
Numerous empirical investigations on numeracy consistently affirm its pivotal role in enabling individuals to engage autonomously across diverse contexts within their daily lives
numeracy’s fundamental role has often been neglected in our societies
The present study scrutinizes the overarching challenges associated with numeracy
particularly emphasizing the challenges regarding healthcare
and the critical utilization and interpretation of data awareness
Methods: A two-phase research framework was adopted to address this inquiry
A comprehensive literature review was conducted to discern the prevalent challenges regarding numeracy awareness
two illustrative case studies were undertaken in Slovenia and Spain to contrast and deliberate upon the insights derived from the literature review
Qualitative research methods were employed to engage in a nuanced exploration of the gathered data
Results: This empirical analysis deduced guidelines aimed at enhancing awareness and ameliorating some of these challenges
Discussion and Conclusion: We conclude that making visible the awareness that adults already have about numeracy in aspects of their lives
or the use and critical interpretation of data
can give policymakers and curriculum developers clues to design effective numeracy programs to address the multifaceted challenges confronting contemporary society
both in the immediate and foreseeable future
where numeracy was only identified with knowing how to perform a series of arithmetic operations using the existing algorithms correctly and appropriately
numeracy has been integrated with cultural
we argue that it has become a multifaceted concept
This article is the product of two case studies that have been carried out in Spain and Slovenia
two of the countries that participate in the Erasmus+ project Numeracy in Practice (NiP)
which is currently running for the period 2022–2024
we indicate the research work that we present here and the methods that have been used to collect evidence and discuss it
organized according to the main areas that have been used in the NiP project concerning numeracy awareness: general
health and critical use and interpretation of media
current challenges regarding numeracy awareness are identified
We finalize this paper with a reflection on the impact of this sort of work on future lines of action
Several authors have endeavored to offer a concrete definition of numeracy. After more than 70 years of discussion, a widespread agreement is that numeracy is not just mathematics, it is more (Arney, 2002; O’Donoghue, 2003; Barwell, 2004; Callingham and Beswick, 2015). In Table 1
some relevant quotes are included endorsing this idea:
for example proposed the following definition of numeracy:
To be numerate means to be competent, confident, and comfortable with one’s judgments on whether to use mathematics in a particular situation and if so, what mathematics to use, how to do it, what degree of accuracy would be appropriate, and what the answer means in relation to the context (Coben, 2000b, p. 35; emphasis in the original; Coben et al., 2003
The article published by Coben (1992) (What do we need to know
Issues in numeracy research) was a turning point that laid the foundations for establishing a new field of research: the learning of mathematics by adults
The international forum Adults Learning Mathematics (ALM) was then created
and an effort to investigate the relationship between adults and mathematics from education was begun in a more rigorous and systematized manner
The OECD endorsed this effort by establishing a research agenda: the international surveys (the first one was the International Adult Literacy Survey—IALS—in 1996)
which are still carried out today through the Program for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies
Despite the difficulties in defining its limits (even because there are languages with no comparable word to translate it)
numeracy continues to be the international term used when referring to how adults use mathematics in their lives
In recent years, the international scientific community has reached a certain consensus around the idea that numeracy must be understood as a social practice rather than a set of quantitative contents (numbers, symbols, etc.) or procedures (addition /subtraction structures, multiplication/division structures, proportional reasoning, etc.). Now, “numeracy” focuses on the social use given to these contents and processes (Figure 1)
Figure 1. Numeracy conceptual development (Hoogland et al., 2019)
the Erasmus+ Project Numeracy in Practice that frames the study being presented in this article
the concept of numeracy is defined as a multifaceted concept
which cannot be understood only as a competence
as a set of knowledge or as a social practice alone
It is considered to be all these different aspects together
The concept of numeracy and numerate behavior encompasses more than just substantive mathematical knowledge and skills
It is about managing all kinds of situations that require mathematical insight
as described in the PIAAC definition—competencies which enable individuals to take adequate actions in situations which need further elaboration
and the situation in which mathematical activities occur play an essential role
The use of mathematical knowledge and skills (content) in daily life is always situation-specific (in context)
The quality of the mathematical action depends on how the person relates himself to his or her mathematical knowledge and skills (dispositions) and the extent to which he/she can oversee and control a situation (higher-order skills)
On the other hand, being numerically competent involves using a series of higher-order skills. Many of those that appear in Figure 2 have already been mentioned in various frameworks on numeracy [Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), 2021]
There is also an overlap with the so-called 21st Century Skills
Every individual—whatever his/her cognitive abilities and experiences—uses higher-order skills
These skills include managing and analyzing situations
but also critical thinking and problem-solving and obviously
they can also be improved by many individuals
Figure 2. Common European Numeracy Framework (CENF; Hoogland et al., 2021a)
Content knowledge and skills matter to improve numerate behavior
The first four subcategories—quantity and number
and chance—can be found in most frameworks regarding mathematics or numeracy outside the formal school system
They can be considered the contemporary replacements of the Algebra-and-Geometry division
which dominated the 19th and 20th centuries
The use of (digital) tools and applications is another set of subcategories relevant today to cope with situations in our digitalized society
Finally, another facet of the framework that we use here is dispositions (Hoogland and Díez-Palomar, 2022)
Adult numeracy dispositions develop throughout life
starting from childhood and compulsory school
They depend on people’s capabilities
beliefs and feelings concerning mathematics
they are also influenced by external positive and negative experiences: how and what mathematics was learned in schools and experiences in lived-in situations
Students who perform better in school mathematics may have good math and numeracy provisions: feeling confident with numbers
and recognizing the usefulness of mathematics
students with negative experiences may develop negative feelings for numbers
The disappointment when receiving low marks for mathematics may have an enormous influence on the numeracy capacities of the future adult
our main objective is to make numeracy visible
Why is it important to run campaigns to draw attention to numeracy
and contexts in our daily lives is numeracy present
and what challenges does this entail from the point of view of making it visible
What opportunities for future action can we find by making numeracy visible to everyone
most of the existing scientific literature on numeracy has always been dedicated either to defining the concept or to developing tools (frameworks) to be able to measure it in quantitative or qualitative studies
we do something that has only been partially done in the field of adult education or studies of a socio-cultural nature (studies of the “mathematics” present in the cultural practices of human groups): we want to identify the numeracy that appears in the different contexts of daily life and make it visible
and critical use and interpretation of media
The objective is to make numeracy visible in these four areas
The research questions of the study reported here are: what are the challenges regarding numeracy awareness today
And what prospects for future initiatives can be discerned by rendering numeracy apparent to all
The study we report here was organized in two phases to answer this question
A systematic review of scientific literature was carried out in the first phase. The objective of this phase was to find the recent contributions made so far on numeracy when trying to make it visible. To do this, we first review what numeracy means since this concept has been defined differently over time (Hoogland et al., 2019, 2021a)
The study reported in this paper focuses on numeracy as a multifaceted construct defined within the Common European Numeracy Framework (CENF) and Numeracy in Practice (NiP) projects
To guide the systematic review of the scientific literature
we used the four thematic axes of numeracy defined in the NiP project: general
Drawing on identifying the principal contributions within the current body of research on numeracy across the aforementioned four domains
we proceeded to the second phase of our study
contrasting the findings extracted from our systematic literature review with the perspectives and insights of adults
given that these two countries are members of the consortium of partners involved in the Numeracy in Practice (NiP) project
which serves as the overarching framework for our investigation
We used a “focus group” as a research instrument in both case studies
which is grounded in the ontological principle positing that a comprehensive understanding of reality is constructed by engaging all the actors involved
Details about the data collection tools and the subsequent analytical procedures are elaborated upon in the following sections
First, we conducted a systematic literature review. Following Egger et al. (2008), we defined the following inclusion and exclusion criteria (see Table 2)
We decided not to use the PRISMA method (Moher et al., 2010) to perform the literature review
The reason for our decision is that PRISMA is based on a targeted search with standard words and combinations of words (keywords) in databases without considering prior knowledge on the subject
so this method has the serious flaw of including irrelevant or little-known studies in the literature review
it omits other studies that all of us who work in numeracy studies know are essential references but that the algorithm does not recognize (due to
the use of everyday expressions or non-normative ones in the title of the paper
or because the word “numeracy” does not appear in it
and therefore are excluded from the search results
this search has been complemented with the use of search engines such as Google Scholar
and the EU Cordis research projects search engine to complement the literature review as we are aware that in addition to expert knowledge on the subject
the use of these other sources is relevant to find
identify and include other less known studies that also respond to the objective of our study
Secondly, we carried out two focus groups (one in Spain and the other in Slovenia). Focus groups are commonly used in educational research (Denzin and Ryan, 2007)
Focus groups stand apart from other forms of group interviews by the researcher’s use of a predetermined set of directed inquiries tailored to evoke group perspectives on a particular subject
Participants in the focus groups (both in Spain and Slovenia) included: adult learners (with basic academic skills up to ISCED level 2) and teachers in adult education
The objective of these two focus groups conducted in Spain and Slovenia was to collect the voices of the participants (mathematics teachers in adult education
and other stakeholders) to validate the contributions identified through the review of scientific literature
It is essential to say that a representative sample has yet to be made and that the results presented below cannot be generalized
The intention has been to identify relevant topics that future research would need to contrast with surveys carried out with representative samples
Our objective here has only been to identify items that could raise awareness and make numeracy visible in the four areas defined above: general
The systematic literature review was employed to methodically consolidate the principal contributions of the international scientific community on our subject of inquiry
This review served the two-fold purpose of refining the scope of our investigation and identifying the key insights substantiated by prior research
we formulated an instrument tailored to probe the extent of these contributions within two distinct groups—adult learners and teachers of adult learners—drawn from Spain and Slovenia
These countries are members of the NiP project consortium
and our selection criterion focused on individuals engaged in adult education
with participants falling into the categories of adult education students (lacking higher education) and adult education teachers
Our choice of employing focus groups was deliberate
given that the conversational dynamics among participants engender spontaneous discussions that often yield unanticipated
This conversational spontaneity enriches the original question script of the instrument
an instrument featuring a predefined set of questions to steer focus group conversations ensures reproducibility across diverse contexts
facilitates the combination of data for comparative analysis
as detailed in the limitations section toward the conclusion of this paper
the focus group methodology is inherently circumscribed in its capacity for generalization
extending only to the participants within the two case studies
While focus groups permit in-depth exploration of the subject of study by affording interviewers the flexibility to pursue unscripted inquiries
these findings must subsequently be corroborated through studies employing representative samples
thereby allowing for broader applicability to the entire study population
we present the results that have been obtained
both stemming from the revision of the scientific literature as from the contributions drawn from the two focus groups conducted in the two countries participating in this study
The findings are organized into topics to facilitate their presentation
The first challenge we have encountered is the difficulty in identifying numeracy aspects, contents, or behaviors from daily life that are currently considered components of numerate behavior (Hoogland et al., 2021b; Tout et al., 2021)
In the framework from where we depart as a reference in this study (the Common European Numeracy Framework)
numeracy is a multifaceted concept that refers to mathematical knowledge and skills (including quantity and number
that are used in different contexts (everyday life
and that puts in place a series of higher order skills measured also by the dispositions of the person
which broadly coincide with what we have found two decades later
both in the case of the participants in the focus group in Slovenia and in the one we carried out in Spain
When asked about examples to identify numeracy
the most common one is usually either “doing the shopping,” “adapting a recipe for four people to a larger number of diners,” or “doing chores.” The following quote illustrates the type of comments made by people who participated in this study:
it was just what I had in my purse (Adult learner
According to Coben (2000b)
mathematics is associated with common sense when it is invisible
She illustrates it with the following quote:
You measure, put up shelves, distance, sire, and the brackets, where they go – that all involve general maths. To me, though, that’s just common sense. […] You do not think of [it] as being math (Coben, 2000b
Our data aligns with Coben’s assertion concerning the invisibility nature of numeracy
Although we use numeracy quite a lot on a daily basis
This person acknowledges the ubiquity of numeracy within everyday life scenarios
it is noteworthy that people need to maintain a conscious awareness of this omnipresence
While numeracy practices are not visible, they are part of a numerical behavior, a way of acting and resolving the different situations that we encounter in daily life, in the workplace, when we exercise our citizenship, or in any of the other situations that Hoogland et al. (2021b) highlight as “contexts.”
However, when one asks about instances of employing numerical concepts in any of the contexts emphasized by Hoogland et al. (2021b)
the notion of “common sense” appears to yield to a recognition that the activities in question are intricately connected to the domain of mathematics
How much does each thing you have in the trolley cost
To know more or less what you are going to pay (Adult learner
As these mathematical aspects cease to remain concealed
they undergo a transformation into explicit mathematics within the discourse of the individuals involved in the two focus groups
The subsequent quotation from the Slovenian case study exemplifies this assertion:
Numeracy is associated closely to mathematics
so people think they are the same thing (Adult learner
It is of paramount importance to underscore that the participants in this study consciously avoid the use of the term “numeracy” in their discourse
primarily because neither the Spanish nor Slovenian languages possess a direct equivalent for this concept
When explicitly discussing their engagement with numerical concepts
they employ the term “mathematics.”
another critical aspect to highlight in the discourse of the people who participated in this study is that they seem to establish a distinction between “daily life mathematics” and “school mathematics.” The teachers who work in adult education centers who participated in the Spanish focus group say that the difficulties occur in the second case when we are talking about “school mathematics.”
In the fact that they do not know how to do subtraction
or that they do know how to subtract in their life
but they do not know how to do it in their notebook
They do not know how to do it in the notebook because
and if you have to “carry,” they no longer know… the concept of… how do I explain it to them: units
And here I find that I do not know how to do it
Think that sometimes it’s because some people do not even know how to hold a pencil and have never been to school (Teacher
The review of the scientific literature is consistent with this distinction (Civil, 2002). Díez-Palomar (2020) states that women who go to adult schools to study the basic level of education usually use different mental strategies to count and solve problems
sometimes totally different from “pencil and paper” school strategies
the case of subtraction by inverse addition is a widespread mental strategy when shopping and differs entirely from subtraction “by positional value.” An older woman
was trying to understand the meaning of “borrowing one” to apply the subtraction algorithm when the minuend unit is smaller than the subtrahend unit
and it is necessary to “borrow a unit from the tens” (for example
when you want to subtract 25 minus 19; to subtract nine from five
you have to ask a 10 from 20 to have 15 and then be able to subtract the 9)
Nobody does that kind of subtraction when they go shopping
Thanks to the egalitarian dialog established in that case
that lady could overcome a negative disposition toward the place value algorithm of subtraction (since she had developed a negative self-confidence
saying that she was incapable of subtracting)
Talking with the facilitator made it evident to her that she knew how to subtract because she “added” from 19 to 25 to obtain the result (the difference)
consistent with the comments that came out in the focus groups of our study
shows another key finding: that there is a tension between “invisible” numerical behavior (those strategies that we use as if it were common sense
and visible mathematics in school through algorithms
organizing and communicate the schedules to take medicines
While some studies talk about the competencies that people have in this type of practice
the focus is on the effects of changing the numerical representation (for example
going from using a graph to a table of values)
In the case of the people who have participated in the case studies of this study
a clear example is that which refers to diets and the calculation of the number of calories and the amount of food to eat
Diet is a topic that is of interest to some of the people who participated in the study
and they use its numeracy to calculate the calorie content of foods
and make decisions about what to eat and what not to eat
based on the results of those calculations
one of the key issues that arises here is the estimation and precision of the calculations
the decision is based on an estimate (which
implies assuming tolerance margins rather than considering the precise calculation)
Another recurring example is calculating dosages; in this case
the task consists of taking half of a pill (which shape is a cercle)
How exactly to cut a pill which is a cercle
This situation is common and involves geometric thinking
the person ends up using a “visual” approach to break the pill “more or less” by what looks like “half.”
They call you from the hospital and tell you: look
I’m from the hospital and we’ll change your appointment
Sometimes you do not even know how to take the date they tell you… But you have made me think about medication: look
the other day we did this in the classroom: the teacher told us: imagine that you must take a pill
You must take half of the pill; But how much is “half”
How do you make sure you cut “half” exactly
a teacher working with adult people in Slovenia stated that:
Interpreting data like dosage and frequency of medicine intake can be challenging for low-educated individuals
I come across examples of needing help understanding these things when taking medicine (Teacher
or the possession of limited numeracy skills
exerts a profound and far-reaching influence on individuals’ health status and their capacity to oversee their own well-being or the well-being of those reliant upon them
Being able to interpret numerical data can mean a difference between positive and negative health outcomes (Teacher
According to the EU, only 45% of the European population understand simple and compound interest, and 20% understand the link between interest rates and bond prices; 35% need to understand what inflation is, and 34% do not understand that an investment with a higher return is likely to be riskier (Eurobarometer, 2023)
people remember the case of the futures market
when the global financial crisis occurred due to the real estate market bubble
many people were recruited by banks to invest in the futures market
buying shares in products that did not exist
with the confidence that they would later become produce and investors were going to earn large amounts of money through interest
Something similar has happened (or is happening) with cryptocurrencies
Financial literacy (financial numeracy) is a crucial aspect
the mathematical algorithms embedded in finance are so complicated that not even the experts themselves can know for sure what is in those stock packages
The results of previous research are also consistent with what people participating in case studies say
Regarding the mathematical knowledge and skills facet of the CENF framework
people tend to have more difficulties with calculations involving percentages (quantity and number) or the calculation of probabilities (data and chance)
The literature highlights the world of finance as the one that usually presents the most significant difficulties because it involves very complex and non-transparent algorithms
which are difficult to understand even for people with expert financial literacy
But the literature also mentions other contexts
such as domestic finances (calculating bills
Among the people who participated in this study
the examples that are repeated the most are understanding the receipt of electricity
Another example is understanding the purchase receipt:
… and we see the purchase receipt of Mercadona [grocery store]
to see where the decimals are placed … (Adult learner
There is also a person who talks about the retirement pension
These are examples that illustrate different contexts in which one (or several) of the mathematical knowledge and skills defined in the CENF framework appear
the problems: addition problems… I bought a fish that cost me 3,50
there are things that are difficult to understand
and she did not know how to add or subtract or anything
when she charged for a coffee when she charged…because mentally [she knew how to calculate] … but later when it came to… [in school] … well
those are the elements they must live with (Adult learner
Possessing a high level of financial literacy exerts a significant influence on individuals’ prospects. Additionally, numeracy also provides a “critical sense” that bears substantial consequence in the lives of individuals, enabling them to make enlightened and responsible choices. This “critical disposition” holds the capacity to shield individuals from potential risks and uncertainties, as expounded by Beck (1992)
The subsequent quotation from the Slovenian case study serves as an illustrative embodiment of this revelation:
Financial literacy does not only give the individuals the ability to understand amounts
It also provides the basis for improvements in attitude toward finances and a more reasonable and responsible use of resources that benefits not only the individual but also the people and the environment around them (Adult learner
such as reading about voting trends or electoral results
Any electoral debate between candidates is another relevant example of the biased use of statistical data
Evans and his colleagues report several sources to this effect
For people who took part in the focus groups
the fact that media use mathematics content is obvious: they are very aware that mathematics appears in the media
The main challenges that are derived thereof include checking the source of the data
if the form of representation is correct (i.e.
the intervals in which the data are grouped are equal)
if the measures of central tendency or dispersion are used correctly
and it is part of the do’s and don’ts of the critical reader of information in the media
The following quote from one of the adult learners in the Spanish case illustrates this “critical spirit” in the reading of information provided by the media:
… the evolution of the mortgages in the last years
graphs can provide us with biased information
but they represent it in a tendentious way so that the interpretation that we can do is not correct (Adult learner
Diminished numeracy skills can likewise constrain individuals’ aptitude for interpreting data and comprehending the information disseminated by the media
consequently impeding their capacity to respond effectively and initiate appropriate actions
The subsequent quotation from the Slovenian case study serves as an exemplification of this phenomenon:
People need to pay more attention to numerical skills for critical interpretation of important information
1-degree rise in global temperature may seem like a small thing
People can underestimate the importance of such change because they do not know what it means in the context of climate and not act to counter global warming decisively enough
because of lack of critical interpretation skills
they can vote for policies that make global warming even worse (Adult learner
one of the things that follows from the study that we report here is that although the people who have participated in the focus groups know that the media use numerical information and that they share the need to read the information of the media critically
it is also true that this way of acting implies an active attitude
playing agency in reading the information offered by the media is related to people’s disposition
Carrying out a passive reading of the media without paying attention to what is read can have the effect of being exposed to biased information
whether involuntarily or in a tendentious way
But neither in the review of the literature nor in the data from the focus groups have we managed to find more information on this topic
The fact that numeracy is often presented to us in an invisible way (implicit
embedded) represents a challenge for adult teachers who design the lessons
study programs and evaluation and assessment instruments (and for the authorities who design adult education standards)
It is also a challenge for adults themselves since the “invisibility” of mathematics in certain situations is related to action dispositions such as “using intuition,” “beliefs,” and “emotional decisions” instead of using mathematical reasoning to solve problems and/or make decisions (like when I buy a lottery ticket because it coincides with my date of birth
without thinking that any ticket has the same probability of winning)
The objects that appear in the “mathematics knowledge and skills” facet in the CENF framework can be visible or invisible (embedded in the human practices of our societies). But in all cases, they are equally mathematical. Just because some practices are “common sense” does not mean they are any less mathematical. Bernstein's (2000) concept of horizontal discourse has sometimes been used to refer to numeracy
both regulated by rules of discourse that are structured in restricted and elaborate codes
what he is saying is that people who do not know how to use the elaborate code of the vertical discourse (academic mathematics) have a lower level than those who use the restricted code of the horizontal discourse
The evidence that we have collected in the fieldwork shows that the numeracy that adult learners use in their daily lives also presents elements of the “mathematics knowledge and skills” facet
as well as what we call “academic mathematics” (or “pencil and paper”)
Another general challenge that emerges from our work is that we must break with the idea that familiarity is associated with “common sense,” and when situations are unfamiliar
then the contents are perceived as “mathematics” (in the academic sense of the term)
consider the case of someone thinking that if twice as many people come to dinner
what they will have to do is calculate twice as much food so that everyone can have dinner is “common sense”; and then consider this other case of someone thinking that if the prospect of medicine gives the indications for the case of an 80 kg adult
he have to administer that medicine to his son
and he has to apply a conversion rule that is not linear (but considering the volumetric difference)
This is considered “doing math.” The challenge is to consider that we are talking about numerical awareness in both cases
Gramsci (1971) already gave us elements in his philosophical reflections to dismantle this obstacle: for him, “common sense” is immediate knowledge, which serves to solve problems, and which is the result of a deep knowledge of all the variables present in the situation or problem to be solved. In our field of mathematics teaching, the Gramscian concept of common sense is very close to the concept of intuition of Poincaré (1908)
Mathematical intuition cannot appear without a deep base of knowledge
It is a spontaneous form of knowledge but deeply rooted
It is also part of the task to make numeracy more visible
we have organized the analysis in four areas (general
and critical use and interpretation of media)
it is relevant to indicate that numeracy is a social practice in all areas and contexts of our lives
Many of the challenges already discussed above are common to all four areas
the mathematical knowledge and skills facet is also related to dispositions
In cases such as financial mathematics (bank products
mathematics is evident (often in a very complex way)
But as the testimonies of the people who participated in this study show
finances do not only appear in the professional context; We also see them in everyday life (at home
when calculating the tip at the restaurant
it happens that sometimes we prefer to make a decision based on a belief (disposition)
not as a result of a rational calculation of different options (for example
I invest in shares of a company because everyone invests and I think I will be able to benefit; but if suddenly confidence is lost
as happened during the Crash of ‘29
The fact that we rely on a series of beliefs without numerical basis to act (and that this leaves us in a situation of profound vulnerability) is also another of the challenges that we have been able to detect
considering that several of the arguments we have used so far also apply to the field of critical use and interpretation of media
one of those that most clearly emerges is the case of agency
Many previous studies have drawn attention to the deceptions arising from using mathematics (statistics
we do not pay attention (we see the data provided to us with a passive attitude)
one of the main challenges regarding numeracy awareness in this area is to find a way for everyone to have an active attitude (agency) to read the information about the world around us critically
this applies not only to cases in which media misinforms
but also when media use numbers to report truth
thus people also need to be numerate to interpret correctly
As one of the participants in this study stated in the focus group:
Critical thinking can be improved and supported by strong numeracy skills as it often Relies on estimates and predictions of trends that can be expressed through numbers
and other mathematical ways (Adult learner
the identification of prevailing numeracy awareness challenges may constitute a means to enhance individuals’ capacity for critical thinking and their preparedness to confront the exigencies of our contemporary society
we wanted to identify some of the challenges regarding numeracy awareness in the four areas defined in the Erasmus+ project Numeracy in Practice
We do not intend to generalize these challenges
They have emerged from the analysis of previous studies (literature review) and from the testimonies of people who have participated in two case studies carried out through focus groups in Slovenia and Spain
limited to the fact of identifying the challenges
Future studies must verify whether these challenges are specific or can be generalized to most “adults.” To do this
it will be necessary to conduct quantitative studies with representative samples
The raw data supporting the conclusions of this article will be made available by the authors
The author(s) declare financial support was received for the research
This paper has been produced with the support of the research project “Numeracy in Practice,” funded by the European Commission under the grant: 2021-1-NL01-KA220-ADU-000 026 292
Rethinking health numeracy: a multidisciplinary literature review
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Mathematics and democracy: the case for quantitative literacy
Google Scholar
“Fostering early numeracy in preschool and kindergarten” in Encyclopedia of language and literacy development
ON: Canadian Language and Literacy Research Network)
Google Scholar
“The development of young children’s early number and operation sense and its implications for early childhood education” in Handbook of research on the education of young children
Google Scholar
The construction of large number representations in adults
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
literacy and numeracy support in vocational education and training
Centre for Research in learning and change
New South Wales: Faculty of Arts and Social Science
Google Scholar
A social critique of the judgement of taste
Google Scholar
Distinction: A social critique of the judgement of taste
Google Scholar
Utilizing and adapting the Delphi method for use in qualitative research
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
An initial exploration of teachers’ numeracy in the context of professional capital
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
and school mathematics: can we bring them together
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Google Scholar
mathematics and adult learning” in Adult numeracy development: Theory
Google Scholar
Researching ‘invisible’ mathematics through adults’ mathematics life histories” in Perspectives on adults learning mathematics: Research and practice
Google Scholar
(2003) Adult numeracy: Review of research and related literature
National Research and Development Centre for Adult Literacy and Numeracy
Google Scholar
Perspectives on adults learning mathematics: Research and practice (New York
Google Scholar
Meeting the mathematical demands of the safety-critical workplace: medication dosage calculation problem-solving for nursing
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
London: Her Majesty’s Stationery Office
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
A framework for adult numeracy standards: The mathematical skills and abilities adults need to be equipped for the future
The Adult Numeracy Practitioners Network System Reform Planning Project
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
“Qualitative methodology (including focus groups)” in The SAGE handbook of social science methodology
Google Scholar
Díez-Palomar
Dialogic mathematics gatherings: encouraging the other women’s critical thinking on numeracy
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Systematic reviews in health care: meta-analysis in context
Google Scholar
“The philosophy of mathematics education: an overview” in The philosophy of mathematics education today
Google Scholar
Eurobarometer (2023). Monitoring the level of financial literacy in the EU. Available at: https://europa.eu/eurobarometer/surveys/detail/2953
Google Scholar
Building bridges: reflections on the problem of transfer of learning in mathematics
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Data in society: Challenging statistics in an age of globalisation
Google Scholar
Numeracy skills and the numerate environment: affordances and demands
Google Scholar
What counts as mathematics in adult and vocational education
In: Proceedings of 8th international conference of adults learning Maths – A research forum (ALM) (pp
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Frankenstein
“Reading the world with Maths: goals for a critical mathematical literacy curriculum” in Proceedings of the first international mathematics education and society conference (180–189)
Gates (Centre for the Study of Mathematics Education: Nottingham University)
Google Scholar
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Google Scholar
PA: National Center on Adult Literacy Publications
Google Scholar
Comparison of PIAAC and PISA frameworks for numeracy and mathematical literacy
Google Scholar
Path model of mathematics achievement in senior high school
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
An introduction to discourse analysis: Theory and method
Google Scholar
“Mathematical literacy and common sense in mathematics education” in Sociocultural research on mathematics education
Google Scholar
Discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research
Google Scholar
A definition and operational framework for health numeracy
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Gómez
Beyond action research: the communicative methodology of research
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Google Scholar
The Mathematisation of society: rethinking basic skills for adults
In: Twelfth congress of the European Society for Research in mathematics education (CERME12)
Google Scholar
Programme for the international assessment of adult competencies
Boundaries and bridges: Adults learning mathematics in a fractured world
In: Proceedings of the 25th international conference of adults learning Maths – A research forum (ALM) (pp
Google Scholar
Hoogland, K., Díez-Palomar, J., and O’Meara, N. (2021a). Common European numeracy framework—A multifaceted perspective on numeracy. In: Paper presented at the 14th international congress on mathematics education (ICME14), Shanghai, China. Available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/368921986
Google Scholar
Literature overview and review EU Commission
Google Scholar
Hoogland, K., and Stoker, M. (2021). The Mathematisation of society. Available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?reload=9&v=8HisrNPI65E
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Proportional reasoning in nursing practice
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Google Scholar
report of a pilot study to compare outcomes of two practical simulation tools–an online medication dosage assessment and practical assessment in the style of objective structured clinical examination
“Mathematical literacy” in Second International Handbook of Mathematics Education
Google Scholar
Concerns about numeracy skills of nursing students
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Adults learning mathematics–inside and outside the classroom
In: Proceedings of 10th international conference of adults learning Maths – A research forum (ALM) (pp
Google Scholar
“Defining adult and numeracy: An academic and political investigation” in Contemporary Research in Adult and Lifelong Learning of Mathematics: International Perspectives
Google Scholar
mathematics and work: From research into practice
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Numbers in the news: A mathematics audit of a daily newspaper
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
O’Donoghue
Mathematics or numeracy: does it really matter
Google Scholar
First year undergraduate nursing students’ perceptions of the effectiveness of blended learning approaches for nursing numeracy
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)
The assessment frameworks for cycle 2 of the Programme for the international assessment of adult competencies
Google Scholar
Guidelines for the development of adult numeracy materials
Adults learning mathematics 4—proceedings of 4th international conference of adults learning Maths—A research forum (ALM) (pp
Google Scholar
Innumeracy: Mathematical illiteracy and its consequences
Google Scholar
Google Scholar
Plaza, P. (2021). Las matemáticas en la educación de personas adultas. Video document, Available at: https://serveiseducatius.xtec.cat/cesire/recurs-eco2/las-matematicas-en-la-educacion-de-personas-adultas/
Google Scholar
Poincaré
Google Scholar
Pólya
Google Scholar
Safford-Ramus
Adults learning mathematics-A research forum 1993–2018
Google Scholar
Safford-Ramus
Google Scholar
Sanmamed, F. F., Ruiz Eugenio, L., and Vrecer, N. (2013). La alfabetización en salud y el empoderamiento de las comunidades. Scripta Nova 17. Available at: https://ddd.uab.cat/pub/artpub/2013/218029/scrnov_a2013v17n427p5iSPA.pdf
Google Scholar
Mathematical knowledge developed at work: the contribution of practice versus the contribution of schooling
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
“Learning to think mathematically: problem solving
and sense making in mathematics” in Handbook of research on mathematics teaching and learning
VA: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics)
Google Scholar
Schütz
Google Scholar
Use of mathematics by adults in daily life
Leicester: Advisory Council for Adult Continuing Education (ACACE)
Google Scholar
Strässer
Mathematics for work—a didactical perspective
Google Scholar
“Grounded theory methodology: an overview” in Handbook of qualitative research
Google Scholar
“Some reflections on adult numeracy” in Adults learning mathematics
Proceedings of 3rd international conference of adults learning Maths – A research forum (ALM)
Google Scholar
Review of the PIAAC numeracy assessment framework
Google Scholar
“PIAAC cycle 2 assessment framework: numeracy” in The assessment frameworks for cycle 2 of the Programme for the international assessment of adult competencies (Paris: OECD Skills Studies
In: Proceedings of 5th International Conference of Adults Learning Maths – A Research Forum (ALM) (pp
Google Scholar
van Groenestijn
Numeracy assessment for the international life skills survey
In: Proceedings of 4th International Conference of Adults Learning Maths – A Research Forum (ALM) (pp
Google Scholar
Improving the numeracy skills of nurse prescribers
PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
To know or not to know – mathematics
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Literacy on the agenda: the origins of the adult literacy campaign in the United Kingdom
CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar
Numeracy as social practice: Global and local perspectives
Google Scholar
Simonič M and Hoogland K (2023) Challenges for numeracy awareness in the 21st century: making visible the invisible
Received: 17 September 2023; Accepted: 10 November 2023; Published: 29 November 2023
Copyright © 2023 Díez-Palomar, Ramis-Salas, Močnik, Simonič and Hoogland. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY)
*Correspondence: Javier Díez-Palomar, amRpZXpwYWxvbWFyQHViLmVkdQ==
Please note that this is an automated translation and it will not be perfect
All articles have been written in English and if anything appears to not make sense
“In the era of science-ing the sh%t out of it
-Mehdi Kordi on Hoogland's wear-and-tear of gear
A $5 million commitment from alumni Susan and Keith Hoogland names the university’s new trans-institutional minor for business study the Hoogland Undergraduate Business Program
The gift continues a tradition of Vanderbilt philanthropy for the Hooglands
both 1982 graduates of the College of Arts and Science
couple has supported the Managerial Studies program and also served as Reunion chairs for their 25th Reunion in 2007 and as class fundraising chairs for their 30th Reunion in 2012
three of their six children are Vanderbilt graduates
“This generous gift from the Hooglands—one of the first at Vanderbilt to name an academic program—provides all of our undergraduates the opportunity to pursue business education,” Provost and Vice Chancellor for Academic Affairs Susan R. Wente said
“[rquote]Adding an undergraduate business minor to our curriculum signals the thirst for business education from our students—and the appetite for innovation and leadership on campus.[/rquote] We look forward to introducing this uniquely Vanderbilt program that is open to any of our undergraduates.”
Wente added that the new minor complements the strong liberal arts foundation at the heart of Vanderbilt undergraduate programs. She also noted that the minor meshes with key themes in the Academic Strategic Plan through its unique teaching model that draws on the trans-institutional strength of faculty and provides immersive experiences for students
The new cross-campus undergraduate business program consists of a business core—undergraduate-only classes taught by faculty members from the Owen Graduate School of Management—that introduces students to five fundamental business disciplines: financial reporting
Students may choose electives from the four undergraduate schools to build “business pathways” according to their specific areas of interest
The courses are designed to actively engage students in solving business problems—whether those occur at a start-up business
Those hands-on opportunities are important to Keith Hoogland, who joined his father’s business after college. He is now president of Highland Ventures and Family Video
I felt behind because I hadn’t taken classes like accounting or business,” he said
“This new minor will make Vanderbilt’s liberal arts students even better prepared when they graduate.” Hoogland
who majored in economics and psychology at Vanderbilt
says the new minor will make Vanderbilt’s undergraduate education more complete and its graduates more competitive in the job market
Susan Hoogland said that her wake-up moment was when she learned a friend’s son wasn’t even considering Vanderbilt because the university does not offer a bachelor’s in business
“Vanderbilt was missing out on these incredibly talented students,” she said
students can get what they need to be successful entrepreneurs without subtracting from the wonderful liberal arts education
I credit Vanderbilt for being willing to think out of the box with this program.”
She seconds her husband’s belief in the value of a liberal arts education
there won’t be as many opportunities to take history and art classes,” she said
“Those classes are just as important as the business courses.”
the couple’s ties to Vanderbilt remain strong
and both still enjoy a circle of close friends from their college days
“We both had such a great time at Vanderbilt,” Keith Hoogland says
“[lquote]Vanderbilt has had a huge impact on both of our lives
We’re excited to be a part of this great new program.”[/lquote]
A wide selection of courses and experiential opportunities in the new minor will enable students to design a flexible program specific to their academic and professional interests
while increased faculty and administrative resources will offer comprehensive support for students navigating the program
This program’s goal is to enrich the undergraduate educational experience
helping to prepare graduates who can lead in business and beyond
“Integrating the study of business with liberal arts will provide our students with a rich foundation for long-term career success,” said Katharine Brooks, the Evans Family Executive Director of the Career Center
“The program will encourage experiential learning
helping students combine their liberal arts and business knowledge to creatively solve real-world problems.”
more than 200 sophomores and juniors are enrolled in classes for the minor
Seniors who have declared one of the existing business-related minors (Human and Organizational Development
and/or Financial Economics) will complete those programs
Nashville, Tennessee 37240
615-322-7311 • Contact Us
Vanderbilt University’s Online Privacy Notice
Esther Mae Hoogland passed away at age 94. Esther was born March 23, 1925 in Vriesland, MI to William and Elizabeth Meengs. She married John Hoogland (who preceded her in death in 2017) in 1948 and after 71 years together (married for 69 years)... View Obituary & Service Information
The family of Esther Mae Hoogland created this Life Tributes page to make it easy to share your memories
Clara Hoogland age 94 of Sioux Center
at Crown Point Estates Care Center in Sioux Center
A funeral service will be 10:30 AM Wednesday, October 19, 2022, at the Bethel Christian Reformed Church in Sioux Center. The funeral service will be live-streamed on the Bethel Christian Reformed Church youtube: Clara Hoogland Service
Burial will follow at Memory Gardens Cemetery in Sioux Center
Public visitation with family present will be Tuesday
October 18th from 5:00 to 7:00 PM at the Bethel Christian Reformed Church
Memorials may be directed to the Bethel Christian Reformed Church Christian Education Fund
Clara Hoogland was born on November 23
the daughter of John and Helen (Kooiker) Kroese
She grew up on a farm near Hull and attended Country school and Hull Christian through the eighth grade
they farmed southwest of Sioux Center and in 1962 they moved to a farm east of Sioux Center
Clara was a member of the Bethel Christian Reformed Church
Left to cherish her memory are her five children
and one great-great-grandchild; three siblings
She was preceded in death by her parents
and Helen Kroese; husband Alfred of 39 years; one sister