In a combined summons document issued by the Bloemfontein High Court
Sagra chief executive Ismael Tshiame and chairperson Tebeho Mongoato say two articles by Food For Mzansi contained allegations which are “wrongful and defamatory” and “malicious and/or slanderous”
Sagra’s top executive refused to be drawn into public spats with “ill-disciplined members.” These members were allegedly soliciting public sympathy in an effort to discredit them in public
oblivious to the modus operandi of these members
It notes the defamatory utterances… levelled against the CEO and the chairperson of Sagra in their personal capacities,” Mongoato said
When asked by Food For Mzansi about the validity of the allegations that Mongoato and Tshiame benefitted financially from Sagra funds
Mongoato said that they were remunerated according to Sagra’s approved framework
Lephatoa told Food For Mzansi that despite the summons
they do not intend issuing an apology to Mongoato and Tshiame
they should do this within ten days after receiving the court documents
failing which further legal action will be taken
Sign up for Mzansi Today: Your daily take on the news and happenings from the agriculture value chain
This week's agricultural events include Food For Mzansi's Nampo Bothaville lunchtime conversations
Deloitte's conversation with agricultural experts
With 21 global awards in the first six years of its existence
Food For Mzansi is much more than an agriculture publication
unashamedly saluting the unsung heroes of South African agriculture
We believe in the power of agriculture to promote nation building and social cohesion by telling stories that are often overlooked by broader society
Contact usOffice: +27 21 879 1824News: info@foodformzansi.co.zaAdvertising: sales@foodformzansi.co.za
Frustrated members of the South African Grain Farmers’ Association (Sagra) have brought a motion of no confidence against its national chief executive
The members – specifically representing Sagra in the Free State and Eastern Cape – say they have had enough of Mongoato and Tshiame’s “ineffective and unaccountable leadership”
They demand that Sagra’s top dogs step down with immediate effect
During a media briefing held yesterday in Johannesburg
one of the Sagra district chairpersons in the Free State
claimed Tshiame and Mongoato made a number of crucial organisational decisions without consulting Sagra members
This included a recent decision taken to walk away from the African Farmers’ Association of South Africa (Afasa) following a fallout at its annual congress
ALSO READ: Afasa reels after mass exodus of black farmers According to Matsole
alleged mismanagement by Sagra’s national executive committee has negatively impacted the association’s members
he sighted a project which lead to great unhappiness
“The sunflower project was not well managed
Inputs to farmers arrived late and in a very disorderly fashion
One would get fertilisers and chemicals but not seeds and fertiliser
[that] does not mean anything,” Matsole told Food For Mzansi
Sunflower farming is one of Sagra’s 12 key commodity focus areas
some members maintain that the intended beneficiaries did not receive the sunflower support they were approved for
farmers are left in debt and their ability to invest in the 2022/2023 planting season has suffered a big blow… The decision by the national leaders have left farmers in the Free State
Eastern Cape and other provinces in debt due to non-payment of soil preparation
Sagra’s district chairpersons have been served with letters of demand in their personal capacities
This follows an earlier report by Food For Mzansi in which Mongoato and Tshiame confirmed that they would be seeking legal counsel in light of a series of corruption and other allegations levelled against them
ALSO READ: Sagra may drag ‘ill-disciplined’ farmers to court
The allegations included that they were milking private and public resources to enrich themselves and that they were allegedly involved in illegal bank accounts
dodgy input procurements for grain farmers
and unable to present financial statements
Sagra’s Free State leaders insist they are acting on the mandate of frustrated members
the province has resolved to bring a motion of no confidence against Mongoato and Tshiame
Food For Mzansi understands that Eastern Cape members of the grain association also backed the motion of no confidence
representatives from this province could not physically attend yesterday’s media briefing
the two provinces are calling on government to stop transferring funds that are intended to support grain farmers to this leadership
remove Sagra national as an implementing agency but work directly with provinces,” Matsole said
Mongoato justified their decision to walk away from Afasa
Sagra’s constitution empowered the NEC to act and exercise final authority on all matters affecting the association
Members in the Free State have since also instructed attorneys “to deal” with the two Sagra leaders
They call on other provinces to support the motion of no confidence and to also demand the immediate resignation of Mongoato and Tshiame
Sagra’s Free State and Eastern Cape leaders are calling on relevant law enforcement agencies and government departments to investigate whether funds disbursed to Sagra were administered to achieve the intended objectives
ALSO READ: Black farmer rift deepens: Sagra boss lambasted
Sign up for Mzansi Today: Your daily take on the news and happenings from the agriculture value chain
A bitter dispute between Sagra’s Free State district chairpersons and its national executive may end up in court
Sagra represents the interests of commercial black farmers in South Africa
Free State farmers who claimed that the top brass of the South African Grain Farmers’ Association (Sagra) were involved in corruption may soon be dragged to court
are both seeking legal advice over “defamatory and spurious allegations.” The bitter dispute ensued after Tshiame and Mongoato’s announcement that it had joined five other black farmers’ organisations in walking away from the African Farmers’ Association of South Africa (Afasa)
Sagra’s district chairpersons in the Free State – Petrus Maloka
Johannes Lephatsoa and Frans Matsholo – distanced themselves from the national executive’s decision
and also made a number of allegations against Tshiame and Mongoato
This included that they were milking private and public resources to enrich themselves and that they were allegedly involved in illegal bank accounts
It further has complaints and dispute resolution processes in place that are available to all its members
office bearers and officials.” According to Mongoato
and in front of its members and funders. “Sagra is not
Sagra’s Free State district chairpersons called on private and public funders to stop funding the NEC with immediate effect
They believe law enforcement agencies should probe Sagra – a move Mongoato experiences as harmful to the grain organisation
it is accorded the necessary attention it deserves.” According to Mongoato
all Sagra members have subscribed to abide by the processes of the organisation
and therefore Sagra will not hesitate to deal with ill-discipline among its members
the conduct intended to bring the organisation into disrepute have unfolded and afforded befitting impetus,” Mongoato said. He furthermore told Food For Mzansi that both him and Tshiame were remunerated according to Sagra’s approved framework. Members of the public
Sagra’s members and business partners should not to be alarmed
they should rather to contact the relevant authorities within the official structures of Sagra for any queries in this regard
ALSO READ: Afasa reels after mass exodus of black farmers
Recent foot-and-mouth disease cases in Newcastle and Bergville have prompted renewed warnings from agricultural authorities
These outbreaks highlight the importance..