Man Utd goalkeeper conundrum a 'huge problem' - Murphy It was the last thing Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim needed After taking goalkeeper Andre Onana out of the firing line for Sunday's trip to Newcastle, the Portuguese watched forlorn as replacement Altay Bayindir conceded four goals in a chastening defeat at St James' Park the Turkey international was to blame for Newcastle's fourth after a poor pass "We did a lot of mistakes that made it harder to win a game - that's all," said Amorim "It's a little bit of everything it's hard to point to one thing." With a crucial Europa League quarter-final second leg to follow against Lyon on Thursday United are keen to put defeat in the north-east quickly behind them But Amorim now faces a potentially season-defining decision of whether to recall Onana or stick with Bayindir Altay Bayindir made his Premier League debut against Newcastle Whether Onana was rested or simply dropped for the visit to Newcastle the fact he wasn't even named on the bench was a brave decision from the United boss former Manchester United captain Roy Keane said Amorim's patience with the Cameroon international had worn out "I think he (Onana) has done OK in the Premier League because United defensively actually haven't been too bad," Keane told Sky Sports "The keeper has made some big mistakes and he's been punished for it so it's a big call for the manager." Onana came under fire again following two costly errors in the 2-2 first-leg draw in Lyon last Thursday the 29-year-old has made eight errors leading to goals in all competitions the most of any keeper playing for a Premier League club "The situation has been coming," former England goalkeeper Paul Robinson told 5 Live "A lot of Manchester United fans have been getting frustrated with him and there is a time where you do need to take the goalkeeper out of the firing line because the pressure does become too much "When you're in front of the opposition fans you're reminded of your poor form every time you touch the ball and sometimes you do need a rest "It's good man-management to put your arm round him and say 'look you're still my number one goalkeeper but at the moment you're not playing to the levels I want you to play at - I'm going to take you out Newcastle beat Man Utd to boost Champions League hopes How does Onana compare to other Man Utd keepers after Matic criticism Ruben Amorim’s Manchester United goalkeeping dilemma Amorim may have been keen to stress Onana's omission was a one-game decision but you don't drop your first-choice keeper at this stage of the season and do so lightly has waited patiently for his first start in the Premier League But the 26-year-old failed to grasp his opportunity against Newcastle conceding four of Newcastle's six shots on target and flapping at a number of crosses but completed just 27 of those - an unimpressive rate of 47.4% The most costly of those passes came 13 minutes from time when Bayindir attempted a chipped pass into midfield that was cut out by Joelinton allowing Bruno Guimaraes to add a fourth goal Newcastle were already on their way to victory by then Amorim has tended to keep faith with the former Inter Milan stopper was keen to move on from the defeat by Newcastle and stressed several times in his post-match interview how the focus was now firmly on the visit of Lyon It's the biggest match of his United reign so far keeping hopes alive of a trophy and place in next season's Champions League but the Portuguese was giving nothing away when asked if he would recall Onana we are going to start the next week," said Amorim "I'm going to choose the best starting XI for the next match." thinks Onana's spell on the sidelines will continue "I don't think he's going to play [against Lyon]," said the former Tottenham goalkeeper "You don't take him out for just one game put him in a few days later and expect him to be on top of his game I don't expect to see him play on Thursday." Get Man Utd news notifications Top storiesTrailblazer Zhao set to take snooker to 'another level' in China Alexander-Arnold leaves as modern Liverpool great - but fans will feel hurt Alpine poised to replace Doohan with Colapinto The final series of Man Like Mobeen has arrived John Simm stars in the provocative 90s drama Warm-hearted comedy with Ben Miller and Sally Phillips Follow two ambitious river restoration projects Trailblazer Zhao set to take snooker to 'another level' in China Zhao beats Williams in historic final - highlights VideoZhao beats Williams in historic final - highlights 'Scheffler and DeChambeau wins further raise US PGA excitement levels' Match-fixing scandal to Crucible champion - fall and rise of Zhao 'We need to take a look at ourselves' - Arsenal stalling at wrong time Palmer's brilliance could be key moment in Chelsea's Champions League quest Europa League 'papering over cracks' for Man Utd - Rooney VideoEuropa League 'papering over cracks' for Man Utd - Rooney Ask Me Anything the new BBC Sport service designed to serve you Bayern's 'James Bond' - how Kane clinched his first trophy Nine bolters with a shot of making the Lions squad How 'absolutely outstanding' Palmer 'destroyed' Liverpool VideoHow 'absolutely outstanding' Palmer 'destroyed' Liverpool Still number one & 'sparring' with Draper - return of Sinner Saints 'punch' favourites Leinster in game for the ages VideoVardy the best £1m ever spent - Shearer Poppy's tears Elton John & Happy Gilmore - McIlroy on Jimmy Fallon show Two opposing views on football's transgender ban Copyright © 2025 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read about our approach to external linking. Altay Bayindir has been slammed as "pathetic" after being at fault for one of Newcastle United's goals in their 4-1 win over Manchester United. with much of the pre-match discussion centred around the absence of goalkeeper André Onana Onana faced further criticism on Thursday following two errors in their 2-2 draw with Lyon in the first leg of their quarter-final clash The game came just a day after former Manchester United midfielder Nemanja Matic slated Onana labelling him “one of the worst goalkeepers” in the club’s history According to BBC Sport, the 29 year-old has been left out of the squad to face Newcastle by Ruben Amorim to let the Cameroonian “rest and disconnect” Onana’s absence opens up a rare opportunity for Turkish goalkeeper Altay Bayindir, who is set to make his Premier League debut and just his sixth appearance of the season for the club Bayindir has had limited game time in his debut season for the Red Devils since joining from Fenerbache in the summer of 2023 his last appearance was certainly a performance to remember The Turkish international saved two penalties as a 10-men Manchester United side knocked out Arsenal of the FA Cup at the Emirates Stadium Bayindir denied Arsenal captain Martin Ødegaard from the spot during regulation time keeping the match alive and sending it into extra time The match went to a penalty shootout and Bayindir was the hero thwarting Kai Havertz and securing victory for the Red Devils against the odds sending the travelling United fans into raptures Following the game, Bayindir couldn’t hide his excitement, he told the BBC: “I want to make everyone happy for this great club if you are a Man Utd player you have to be ready always.” Bayindir’s FA Cup heroics earned him praise from Red Devils captain Bruno Fernandes as well as manager Ruben Amorim Fernandes lauded the Turkish international’s performance whilst commending his character the first penalty and another save here and we are really happy for him whenever he gets his chance he’s top class for us he’s always available for everyone and he truly deserves this moment.” Amorim echoed the Portuguese international’s sentiment and said: “Today he was our hero playWhat is Ruben Amorim hoping to achieve with Man United criticism (2:50)Rob Dawson reacts to Ruben Amorim's comments about his Man United team potentially being the worst in the club's history The keeper wasn't the only United player at fault during a miserable 3-1 defeat by Brighton with this current United incarnation failing to respect the legacy of Red Devils great Dennis Law - who passed away on Friday - with a display entirely lacking the vigour dash and courage of Law's European Cup winners of 1968 United were already 2-1 down and seeking an equaliser when Onana's error in the 76th minute condemned them to a sixth defeat in the 11 PL matches since Amorim arrived as head coach as a replacement for also-struggling Erik ten Hag Attempting to smother a cross from Yasin Asari on the right flank, Onana took the ball to the turf, appearing to have everything under control, only for it to squeeze out of his grasp and into the path of substitute Georginio Rutter It was a gilt-edged opportunity for the Franco-Malagasy forward who seized on the chance and fired a powerful effort beyond the sprawling stopper "An awful mistake from Onana," ex-United striker Dion Dublin said on BBC as Minteh's swinging cross evaded the hosts' backline Brighton only registered three shots on target during the course of the contest a damning indictment of Onana's contribution and while Minteh made the most of the space he enjoyed on the right there was to be no heroic cameo from wonderkid Amad Diallo to save United on this occasion Far from emerging as one of the solutions to United's problems Onana has become yet another concern in the long list of issues for Amorim to address during what is shaping up to be a particularly testing year for the Portuguese head coach The manager resisted criticising the goalkeeper directly when asked about his blunder after the match but privately the 39-year-old must surely be questioning whether it's time to take Onana out of the firing line Unlike a week or two ago, Amorim now has a viable option to at least explore beyond the Cameroon keeper, with Altay Bayindir excelling in the FA Cup Third Round victory over Arsenal notably emerging as United's saviour during the penalty shootout That showing transformed the 26-year-old Turk from untrusted squad player to a credible alternative between the sticks for United with some portions of the fanbase already appearing to believe that Amorim should have replaced Onana as his No Expect those calls to intensify in light of Onana's latest setback with Amorim surely needing to revaluate the goalkeeper who cost the club £47.2 million when he was signed by Ten Hag in 2023 play1:59What does Ruben Amorim need to change at Manchester United?Gab Marcotti and Julien Laurens discuss why Ruben Amorim is struggling to deliver results at Man United after his side's 2-0 defeat to Brighton at Old Trafford The former Ajax man was meant to set the tone for the Dutchman's tactical approach excellent vision and impressive passing ability to instigate attacking moves and ensure the Red Devils were quickly back on the front foot This version of Onana has been spied increasingly rarely in recent months with the stopper's passing occasionally wayward and the confidence he once enjoyed in possession replaced by hesitancy and a tendency to move the ball around without purposeful direction Onana's one key strength appears to have disappeared while neither he nor United's defenders appear able to transmit confidence to the other during these tense and tumultuous times More broadly, United's decision to allow club servant David de Gea to depart on a free transfer in 2023 before parting with such an eye-watering fee for Onana is increasingly looking like a costly misstep from Ten Hag The lapse against Brighton was the fourth time this season that Onana has made an error which has led directly to a goal. For context, only Arijanet Muric of Ipswich Town has been guilty of directly contributing to the opposition scoring more often than the Cameroonian By contrast, De Gea, playing now for Fiorentina in Serie A is yet to make an error that has led to a goal this season The Spaniard's save rate of 72.5 percent is also superior to Onana (63.7) with the Viola man also registering more saves per match than his successor at Old Trafford While Onana is conceding an average of over 1.4 goals per match this season De Gea is letting in just 1.16 goals per match should still have several strong years ahead of him in Europe's big leagues and the midweek Europa League 'Battle of Britain' against Glasgow Rangers will represent a stern test of his faith in Onana who starts between the sticks for the Red Devils on Thursday Stay in the know with The National Interest newsletter © Copyright 2025 Center for the National Interest. All Rights Reserved. We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised ads or content, and analyse our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies. We use cookies to help you navigate efficiently and perform certain functions. You will find detailed information about all cookies under each consent category below. The cookies that are categorised as "Necessary" are stored on your browser as they are essential for enabling the basic functionalities of the site. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyse how you use this website, store your preferences, and provide the content and advertisements that are relevant to you. These cookies will only be stored in your browser with your prior consent. You can choose to enable or disable some or all of these cookies but disabling some of them may affect your browsing experience. Necessary cookies are required to enable the basic features of this site, such as providing secure log-in or adjusting your consent preferences. These cookies do not store any personally identifiable data. Functional cookies help perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collecting feedback, and other third-party features. Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics such as the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyse the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with customised advertisements based on the pages you visited previously and to analyse the effectiveness of the ad campaigns. Altay Bayindir sent out a message to Manchester United fans after a nightmare Premier League debut against Newcastle United. Bayındır made six saves during the 120 minutes of play — including a stopped penalty against Arsenal captain Martin Odegaard — and then stood tall in the shootout as the Red Devils advanced to the next round of the competition despite overwhelming pressure from the Gunners. It was a performance that earned Bayındır man of the match honours, with Man United captain Bruno Fernandes hailing the 26-year-old's ability to step up to the challenge despite being the backup to regular starter André Onana. "It's a big moment for him, the first penalty and another save here and we are really happy for him," Fernandes told BBC One. "It's tough to be second goalkeeper, he came here to play, whenever he gets his chance he's top class for us, he's top class in training, he's always available for everyone and he truly deserves this moment." Fernandes also quelled any talk of celebration by the Red Devils, stating that the team still needs to find consistency in order to get where it wants to be. "I know we want to celebrate and everything but our focus is now Southampton [on Thursday], that is when we have to back it up," he said. "The big games against Liverpool, Arsenal, everyone steps up because it's a big game. You want to be in these kinds of games, you want to be involved, you want to be the best but we have to do it in Old Trafford with these fans again. We have to give it back for the club. We need to do it every week, every game." Ruben Amorim made the bold decision to drop Andre Onana from the squad to face Newcastle United after watching his two mistakes against Lyon in the Europa League That opened up a gap for Altay Bayindir to make his Premier League debut at St James’ Park, but United were hammered 4-1 by Newcastle to extend their winless streak to four matches United fans were ‘furious’ at Bayindir after he conceded four times on Tyneside and now Amorim has a big decision to make for the second leg against Lyon on Thursday evening Onana’s future at Old Trafford is uncertain following his underwhelming performances this season, but Altay Bayindir has not put himself in a strong enough position to capitalise and become the new No.1. After the full-time whistle at Newcastle, Bayindir took to social media to send a message to United fans. View this post on Instagram A post shared by Altay Bayındır (@altaybayindir) “Honored to make my PL debut for this club “We’ll be back stronger — keep believing.” Harry Amass also sent a message after he was handed his first Premier League start at St James’ Park After Onana made two terrible mistakes against Lyon to set up an unnecessarily nervous second leg at Old Trafford United now have two goalkeepers low on confidence with Bayindir struggling at St James’ Park United tried to pass out from the back against Newcastle but their pressing caused issues all match Bayindir often looked panicked in possession and his stats prove that he was nowhere near good enough It has been reported that Amorim wants new goalkeepers at United made just two saves and also made one error that led to Newcastle scoring 2024 shows staff members work on the competition venue for the FWT (Freeride World Tour) qualifier at the Jikepulin International Ski Resort in Altay Prefecture northwest China's Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region (XINHUA)  A new ski-themed museum has opened to the public in northwest China's Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region recently which boasts modern ski resorts and an ancient rock painting depicting skiing hunters.  Altay's historical legacy and favorable skiing conditions and China's rapid growth in winter sports since the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics have accelerated the development of the region's snow-and-ice economy.  Altay welcomed about 4.89 million tourist visits with tourism revenue totaling 5.1 billion yuan (about $711.3 million) It drove about half of the growth in both visits and revenue of Xinjiang's total.  Ancient history and modern resources  About 40 kilometers away from the site of the museum an archaeological find showing the history of skiing was discovered in 2005: a rock painting in Handgait township depicting early humans skiing on fur-covered wooden skis while hunting believed to be between 10,000 and 30,000 years old is considered the earliest evidence of human skiing activity.  Situated at 45 to 47 degrees north latitude Altay enjoys 170 to 180 days of snowfall annually with snow depths reaching 1 meter on average and 2 meters in mountainous areas The terrain is ideal for skiing due to vertical drops of over 1,000 meters.  "Skiing conditions here are absolutely world-class with breathtaking landscapes and rich cultural heritage," said Justin Downes a Canadian with over 30 years of experience in the ski industry who has worked for major North American ski resorts and participated in snow-related projects at the Beijing Winter Olympics.  Due to the winter sports fever brought by the Olympics the region has invested 7 billion yuan in constructing six alpine ski resorts has also been upgraded to meet international standards.  Altay now plays a significant role in China's plans to boost its ice-and-snow economy as a new growth sector The country targets an economic scale of 1.2 trillion yuan by 2027 and 1.5 trillion yuan by 2030 according to guidelines issued by the General Office of the State Council in November 2024.  Boasting a latitude akin to other world-class ski regions such as the Alps and the Rocky Mountains Altay has drawn professionals and enthusiasts worldwide.  a prestigious international backcountry skiing competition held a qualifying event at the Jikepulin resort in Altay More than 50 athletes from various countries participated.  safety measures and emergency response capabilities including a helicopter for medical evacuations Altay has also launched regional initiatives such as Winter Games Around the Altai Mountains The just-concluded second edition of this event featured over 170 athletes and coaches from China snowboarding and cross-country skiing.  attended her first competition in China during the event and the facilities are excellent," she said adding that the experience helped her connect with athletes from different countries while also enjoying local culture and cuisine.  Altay is forming partnerships with global ski-industry insiders to accelerate its development French ski coach David Guigaz has been working with local ski instructors at the Jiangjunshan ski resort sharing advanced techniques and preparing for the peak season.  "Altay has great potential to expand as a global ski destination," said Guigaz now in his second season working in the region.  three major Altay ski resorts have already established partnerships with training institutions in France Global brands such as Burton and Descente have opened flagship stores in the area signaling the growing commercial interest in Altay's burgeoning ski market.  The region's unique conditions also make it an ideal training ground for professional athletes This has attracted not only domestic teams but also international ones including ski squads from the Republic of Korea.   Photo: Courtesy of the Altay Museum of the Origin of Human Skiing The ratings of popular miniseries To the Wonder The inaugural Altay Mountains Winter Sports Games commenced on Monday night in Altay Northwest China's Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous .. The Altay team from the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region stood out at the 26th Harbin International Snow Sculpture .. The Altay battle tank, designed and produced in Turkey, will enter service in the Turkish army in 2025 after having started the phase of mass production as announced yesterday by the President of the Presidency of Defence Industries (SSB) during a visit to the facilities of the Turkish defence firm BMC in Ankara we will deliver our first mass-produced battle tanks to our heroic armed forces Our current plans are to open our facilities in August and to begin and continue the production process for all our armoured vehicles,’ said Görgün explaining that production will take place at a plant in the Kahramankazan district a total of 85 Altay battle tanks will be delivered in the first phase the delivery of 165 tanks of the T2 variant For the moment no date has been announced for the production of the T3 model Görgün also emphasised the growing importance of Turkey as an exporter of military land vehicles pointing out that more than 4,500 vehicles of this type have been exported to about fifty countries The SSB president made these statements precisely coinciding with the signing yesterday of a contract with the Turkish defence firm FNSS to begin delivering the new Turkish next-generation armoured vehicles PARS ALPHA 8×8 and PARS ALPHA 6×6 to the Turkish Armed Forces, according to news agencies The first prototype of the Altay battle tank was presented more than a decade ago as part of the investments in defence of Turkey; it is a vehicle that stands out for incorporating technologies and capabilities based on the Turkish army’s experience in real combat increasing its accuracy and speed against enemy targets As a history lover, Pablo Gómez was captivated by Turkey from the first day he visited it in 2006: he got married there has a house there… and has since become an expert on Turkey’s current affairs he has been at the helm of hispanatolia.com since 2011 but he’ll find plenty to like from his 10-man Manchester United’s third-round FA Cup win at Arsenal on Sunday The Red Devils led through Bruno Fernandes when Diogo Dalot took a silly second yellow card to doom the visitors to 10 men [ RECAP, HIGHLIGHTS — Arsenal 1-1 (3-5 pens) Man Utd ] Arsenal quickly leveled the score and then looked set to go ahead when Kai Havertz managed to win a penalty with an acrobatic act around Harry Maguire But Turkish goalkeeper Altay Bayindir saved Martin Odegaard’s penalty and was terrific in the second half as United took the favored Gunner to extra time On Man Utd’s fight: “Thankfully the players were there Sometimes what we talk about before the match is not tactical or technical no matter what the situation we competed today Arsenal didn’t deserve to lose but we deserved to win the way we fought was really tough since the beginning We didn’t have the ball too much but we had control without the ball.” “We were facing a great team and it was not just 90 minutes it was more than that — you feel like the players are really tired But we deserved to pass through this round because we suffered all together and we showed character and that’s a very important thing.” Bayindir’s big day: “Really important not just for him but for all the players Your life as a footballer has cycles and moments and sometimes in one week you life can change everyone was pointing the finger against Altay Joshua a few weeks ago had a small problem with our fans and today every time he goes on the field you feel the support from the fans Life is like that and you have continue humble he works a lot and life has beautiful things A few weeks ago we were suffering through a difficult moment but now he’s like a hero for us All the players in this team who have the opportunity and they are lucky because they are playing for Manchester United It doesn’t matter if you play one game or 90 games — It’s always a joy to play for this club.” I’ve already spoken about how I make the choices so it is what it is "Today he was our hero" 🙌Ruben Amorim praised Altay Bayındır's performance as Manchester United knocked Arsenal out of the FA Cup on penalties 👇 pic.twitter.com/MuLQA3Rth7 I want to make everyone happy for this great club if you are a Man United player you have to be ready always.” "[Amorim] is talking with us everyday and he wants to help us We love him and he’s always trying to do his best He has a very good relationship with the players and we are trusting him A Division of NBCUniversal DISCLAIMER: This site and the products offered are for entertainment purposes only and there is no gambling offered on this site This service is intended for adult audiences No guarantees are made for any specific outcome If you or someone you know has a gambling problem Watch as Fernandes rescues Man Utd with stoppage-time winner Highlights: Fernandes late winner breaks Rangers hearts after frantic finish that is hard' - Mainoo gifted unique FA Cup winners bucket hat AdvertisementHow was your experience today Manchester United goalkeepers Altay Bayindir and Tom Heaton are not expected to play in the team's FA Cup game against Leicester City this Friday Tom is also not for this game but he can play the other ones (in the future) The important thing is we are ready to face the game," Ruben told Manchester United TV on Thursday The Red Devils will play Ruud van Nistelrooy's Foxes in the FA Cup fourth round at Old Trafford at 2000GMT on Friday played a crucial role in Man U's advancement by saving two penalties in their match against Arsenal in the third round The Turkish goalie has appeared in six games for Manchester United showcasing his ability to perform under pressure The SSB announced the completion of the modernisation of Turkish M60Ts to the M60TM standard under the Fırat project in July 2020 A Pulat countermeasure module can be seen on the front left of the MBT During his presentation earlier on 12 November Erdem said that Akkor is being installed on Türkiye's Leopard 2A4 MBT as part of an upgrade Akkor consists of a high-speed hard-kill launcher which has been installed on an entire battalion of M60T MBTs as part of an upgrade and is operational Gain unlimited access to Janes news and more.. Delivering trusted intelligence to warfighters to protect national interests Providing mission users with faster access to quality data to pre-empt threats and protect national security Assured interconnected OSINT to deliver informed Solutions Insights About Contact Request a demo Customer Login Store Receive the latest developments in defence and security as well as keep informed on Janes news and events. Janes Intelligence SummaryA fortnightly update featuring the latest analysis,  intelligence briefings, podcasts and news.  Struggling goalkeeper Andre Onana should be recalled for Manchester United’s must-win clash with Lyon I would like to be emailed about offers, events and updates from The Independent. Read our Privacy notice Andre Onana after the most turbulent few weeks on and off the pitch had to be taken out of the firing line at Newcastle It was understood that from moment Ruben Amorim informed Onana of his decision to leave him out of the squad entirely for Manchester United’s trip to the north east, the struggling goalkeeper would be back for his team’s do-or-die Europa League clash with Lyon on Thursday That did not stop the growing number of Onana doubters getting their hopes up Altay Bayindir has impressed when given the opportunity in cup games for United most notably in his stunning athletic display in victory at Arsenal Had he had a blinder on par with the Turkey international’s Emirates heroics at St James’ Park on Sunday Amorim would certainly have a decision to make as to who would be the safest pair of hands for his most crucial fixture yet A stunning first-half save to deny Alexander Isak in front of the Gallowgate would have caused Onana By the time the final whistle went as United shipped four goals for the first time in the league this season the fourth of which was a glaring error from Bayindir Onana can start to focus on getting his A-game back together Not only will winning a trophy provide a major lift for a club stuck in a dizzying death spiral they are labouring to get out of but the riches brought by getting into next season’s Champions League are absolutely essential for this summer’s crucial squad overall Amorim has talked a good game since walking through the Carrington doors, but the results have remained so embarrassing – United are assured their worst-ever Premier League points return already, likely by some margin – the room for error is minimal, to put it mildly. All of which heaps pressure on Thursday’s encounter, meaning Amorim cannot take even the remotest of risks. Especially in goal. Onana has made more errors leading to a goal than any other Premier League goalkeeper in all competitions since the start of last season, but given what is at stake against Lyon, Bayindir still needed that exceptional performance to convince Amorim to make a bold call. Where Bayindir really failed the audition was with the ball at his feet. Onana has not reached anything like the ball-playing finesse levels he managed at Inter Milan, but the Cameroonian never looked as jittery as Bayindir did for 90 minutes at St James’ Park. On numerous occasions, the United number two took the easy option that put his defenders in trouble, while almost getting caught in possession all too often. The mistake for Newcastle’s fourth goal was the final nail in Bayindir’s forlorn attempts to get the nod for Thursday. What pass he was aiming for is unclear, but Joelinton did not have to move a great deal to cut it out before setting up Bruno Guimaraes for the simplest of finishes. “We are going to analyse the game, but we need to focus on the next one, we cannot change this one,” Amorim said. “The next one is massive for us, so let’s focus on the next one on Thursday to play better and to win the game. “You guys have to wait (to see his selection), we are going to start the next week tomorrow and I’m going to choose the best starting XI for the next one.” One call in particular seems to have been made for Amorim. Onana is not in a great place, but the risks involved in going with Bayindir are too great at this point of no return for a coach desperate to get the chance to properly bring about real change at Old Trafford. Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies Andre Onana left Manchester United fans deeply frustrated after the former Ajax and Inter Milan star’s horror showing against Lyon in the Europa League quarter-finals The 29-year-old Cameroonian committed two major howlers that allowed Lyon to snatch a draw against United in the first-leg tie at the Parc Olympique Lyonnais Onana’s form at United has taken a turn for the worse in the 2024-25 campaign despite appearing to turn over a new leaf at the beginning of the season 🔥What a finish from the Manchester United winger 😤 https://t.co/IdquW6uJyT The Cameroon international has remained the Red Devils’ No 1 under Ruben Amorim after the former Sporting CP manager replaced Erik ten Hag at United in 2024 But United manager Ruben Amorim made the big call to drop Onana from the Red Devils squad for the trip to St James’ Park to face Newcastle in the Premier League Altay Bayindir has played second fiddle to Onana and the 26-year-old Turkish shot-stopper had only made six appearances ahead of the Newcastle encounter The Turkey international’s last match for United was back in January and Amorim handed Bayindir his Premier League debut after Onana was left out of the squad READ MORE: What Andre Onana was spotted doing before Lyon match came back to haunt him after his Man Utd horror show display Manchester United fans on social media platform X insisted that Altay Bayindir’s “audition” ended in complete disaster against Newcastle Absolutely pathetic performance,” one X user said Another United fan added: “Bayindir has failed his audition woefully Signing a GK in the summer is now a top priority for Ineos.” “Audition over for Bayindir,” someone else commented Altay Bayındır's ball is intercepted by Joelinton and Bruno Guimarães is there to finish it off 🎯 pic.twitter.com/FpKEAI75uR A fourth Red Devils supporter wrote: “Bayindir failed the audition While a fifth tweeted: “Bayindir failing the audition Looks like our Europa [Leauge] race may end on Thursday to cap off a horrific season.” And an eighth United fan simply claimed: “[That] Bayindir howler possibly just making a way for Onana to start against Lyon this upcoming midweek.” READ MORE: Mike Phelan warns Ruben Amorim that he must now make his ‘biggest decision’ as Man Utd manager after Lyon draw Newcastle opened the scoring in the first half at St James’ Park after Sandro Tonali broke the deadlock for Eddie Howe’s men in the 24th minute on Sunday Manuel Ugarte lost the ball before Kieran Trippier later found Alexander Isak in the middle and the Newcastle striker flicked the ball over the top to Sandro Tonali Tonali then smashed a superb first-time volley past a helpless Bayindir but United managed to climb back into the Premier League match before half-time Amorim’s men found an important equaliser in the 37th minute after Manuel Ugarte won possession in the United half and unleashed Diogo Dalot on the counter-attack Diogo Dalot superbly charged into the Newcastle half before he slotted the ball into the path of Alejandro Garnacho who fired a superb low shot past Nick Pope HARVEY BARNES!He's done it again!! 🔥 pic.twitter.com/f7QZt9Vpuy Newcastle restored their lead over United only four minutes into the second half after Harvey Barnes fired an easy tap-in past a helpless Bayindir at St James’ Park Harvey Barnes put Newcastle 3-1 up and completed his brace after he dispossessed Noussair Mazraoui before scoring a stunning solo effort in the 64th minute Bayindir’s Premier League debut took a turn for the worse after he carelessly passed the ball straight out to Joelinton Bruno Guimaraes then fired his strike past a helpless Bayindir and Newcastle extended their thumping lead over United to 4-1 at St James’ Park United will now resume their Europa League campaign on Thursday evening with their crucial second-leg quarter-final tie against Ligue 1 side Lyon at Old Trafford The Red Devils and Lyon will kick off their return-leg clash at 8pm UK time with a place in the Europa League semi-finals hanging in the balance Bayindir joined United in September 2023 from Fenerbahce His appearances have been limited to cup competitions as he has been unable to displace Andre Onana despite the Cameroonian’s error-prone ways between the sticks Bayindir has yet to get a taste of Premier League football since arriving at Old Trafford He has played six games this season across the Europa League Ahead of the 2026 World Cup, it was suggested that Bayindir could look to leave United in search of regular first-team minutes elsewhere Now, Stretty News reveal that the Red Devils are willing to sanction his sale for a fee in the region of £6-7 million It’s understood that Bayindir is not short of suitors he also has admirers in La Liga and Serie A “Bayindir’s lack of playing time did little to repel these suitors as they still believe he has what it takes to replicate the superb displays he produced during his years at Fenerbahce something he didn’t have the chance to do at Man Utd.” our sources can confirm that INEOS have pinpointed Burnley’s James Trafford as the ideal profile to replace Bayindir.” Last month, a report covered by The Peoples Person relayed that United held talks about signing Trafford who is on the brink of promotion to the Premier League with Burnley United are back in action on Thursday when they go away to Lyon in the first leg of their Europa League quarter-final tie will certainly be hoping to be handed a start by Ruben Amorim as he looks to prove he has what it takes to become the club’s first-choice goalkeeper Derick Kinoti is a football writer at The Peoples Person who has covered Manchester United and the game extensively for many years He is a keen analyst with expertise in SEO and journalism standards Derick is convinced Wayne Rooney is the true GOAT and won't hear otherwise Bilge Altay assistant professor in the Department of Packaging and Graphic Media Science co-presented their research at RIT’s 2024 Undergraduate Research Symposium “Plant-Based PFAS-Free Alternatives for Food Packaging” explores eco-friendly non-toxic solutions for food packaging to reduce environmental impact Graduate milks his education and creates device to help dairy farms RIT honors two faculty members with Russell C Packaging science students organize Packaging Jamboree national conference Three new games by Ares are arriving at your friendly local retailer: 45+ min) is a new game by acclaimed designers Ole Steiness and Paolo Mori and area expansion elements come together to create an easy-to-play The game will transport you to a fantasy world at the dawn of time In a secluded region within a vast continent four mysterious societies have cultivated distinct cultures over countless years They now face a new challenge: an influx of human settlers with advanced crafts and weapons As the leader of one of Altay’s Elder Peoples you will decide how to react to this challenge 45+ min) is a unique three-dimensional tile placement game a new chapter in Sylvan Dale’s history began The Elders have called on you and your fellow architects to design a new woodland realm – a haven perched in the high embrace of the Great Trees Guide the builders of Sylvan Dale as they construct dwellings 60+ min) is a board game with simple rules and fast Each squad of snails is led by a unique leader who grants their soldiers special abilities and enhances their chances to win by eliminating opponents with an assortment of funny weapons Each combat takes place on a dozen islands which get destroyed as the game progresses Your snail may end up in the water in no time and by excavating more island levels you may encounter new gear but also lethal traps The last squad standing on the board wins the game Snails is published by Galakta Games and distributed in North America by Ares Games One of the longest running independent gaming news Since his arrival at United in September 2023 Bayindir has mostly deputised n.o 1 Andre Onana with most of his appearances coming in cup competitions he made just one appearance – an FA Cup meeting against Newport County while Onana was away with Cameroon for the Africa Cup of Nations Ruben Amorim has utilised Bayindir slightly more with the Turkey international playing six games so far this term across the Carabao Cup He has yet to get a taste of Premier League action Bayindir took the acclaim in January as a 10-man United side beat Arsenal at the Emirates Stadium to advance to the fifth round of the FA Cup He denied Martin Odegaard from the penalty spot in the 72nd minute and also kept out a low effort from Kai Havertz in the penalty shootout The 26-year-old has not featured in United’s matchday squads for the past few weeks due to injury There have been suggestions that Bayindir could leave United this summer in search of regular first-team minutes elsewhere. A recent report covered by The Peoples Person claimed that the shot-stopper could seek a transfer to boost his chances of playing in the 2026 World Cup Now, Turkish-Football report that Bayindir is indeed attracting interest from Premier League and Super Lig clubs but his priority is still staying at Old Trafford “Altay Bayindir has reiterated his commitment to the club expressing his desire to secure more playing time following his recovery from injury sources revealed to Turkish-Football.” “Bayindir acknowledges the inherent competition within a club like Manchester United and asserts he is prepared to face the challenge.” “Speculation regarding potential transfers to other Premier League clubs has circulated He understands that rumors are part of the game but his priority is to find success at Manchester United He expressed gratitude for the opportunity to play for such a prominent club and is committed to demonstrating his worth.” Turkish-football further note that Bayindir is working hard to recover from his injury and become available for selection once again Amidst Onana’s poor form and mistake-strewn performances there is a real chance for Bayindir to finally break into the team and make the starting goalkeeper spot his own It’s up to him to take the opportunity when it inevitably arrives United are back in action on Thursday when they go away to Spain to face Real Sociedad in the round of 16 of the Europa League Featured image Julian Finney via Getty Images United battled hard for an hour with 10 men after Diogo Dalot’s red card to take the clash to penalties and eventually overcome their hosts Bayindir saved Martin Odegaard’s penalty in normal time and also denied Kai Havertz from the spot kick in the ensuing penalty shootout the Turkish goalkeeper came up with several other crucial stops that kept United in the game It was Zirkzee who stepped up to convert the winning penalty in United’s 5-3 shootout triumph at the Emirates It was a massive turnaround for the two players who have had very difficult spells at United for different reasons Bayindir has struggled to get regular playing time and has had to be content with playing the role of Andre Onana’s understudy Bayindir was at fault for at least two of the four goals conceded as the Red Devils were dumped out of the Carabao Cup by Tottenham Hotspur Zirkzee was booed off the pitch by his own fans after being substituted in the 33rd minute of the 2-0 home defeat to Newcastle Speaking in his post-match press conference after beating Arsenal Amorim told reporters about the two players “It’s really important not just for them but for all the players Your life as a footballer has cycles and moments and sometimes in one week your life can change.” everyone was pointing the finger for Altay and I understand that “[The penalty save] was really important because it gave us more strength and with less one player it’s really hard to press A team like Arsenal with 11 players – imagine with ten players And if you are in disadvantage it’s really hard they were already controlling the ball in a lot of moments so it was vital to draw the game.” he had a small problem with our fans and today every time he goes on the pitch you feel the support from the fans and then he has the last penalty It’s not just important for them but for their teammates.” “Especially in the first half we played better than in the first game “The sending-off was really hard on us There were some opportunities from Arsenal But I felt since the first minute today was our day And I felt a connection with our fans.” “When we score first it helps us to suffer It’s more strength to suffer.” We are understanding more the way we play – sometimes not playing well but you can control the game in certain moments It’s clear we’re improving with the way we suffer It’s a good thing for a team.” United are back in action on Thursday when they face Southampton at Old Trafford